Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send my child to private school at age 4?

233 replies

confusedaboutworkingandparenting · 08/02/2023 10:23

Wise Mumsnetters, please talk to me about private school in the UK. Or public school? What is the difference? As you have probably gathered already, DH and I went to comprehensive schools and have no experience of education options in London or the independent school system in the UK. Other children is unlikely to be a factor here so we could probably afford to pay for one to go, although of course it would involve some sacrifices. We have some good private schools nearby to us and none of the "local" state primary schools are actually that convenient, so all options involve a bit of a trek. So talk to me about private school? Is it worth it? Is it really that different to state school? When is the best time to send them? If you could afford it, would you do it? And why? And will I inadvertently turn my beloved child into a posh tw*t?! Also the holidays are so long! What do you do with them then! Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences and wisdom.

OP posts:
Pasadenadreaming · 08/02/2023 13:43

Totally depends on the quality of schools in your area and what your child is like. We didn't get a place in the local state primary that we thought would have been ok, and weren't impressed with the one we did get - plus it was also really awkward to get to, lacked the wrap around care we needed, and would have been a nightmare with work at that point. She'd have had no friends going there and the kids tended to come from a different type of background to us as it was a rougher area. I would say there's a similar amount of ethnic diversity in both the schools. We're in a city so bound to be more diverse than some places anyway.

My DD is very shy but academically advanced and needs to be challenged. She also loves music and so these were factors that pushed us into private. We looked round schools with an open mind but she actually preferred the private one herself too - I think she was won over by the visit to the music department.

Four years in and we're really happy with our decision. Class sizes are small, she's benefited from specialist music, language, IT, sports etc teachers. She's been able to learn two instruments in school time and made a lovely group of friends. She is still quiet but her confidence has definitely increased and the additional opportunities have been amazing for her. Because her school is from 5-18, the kids also benefit from being able to use the senior school facilities for things like science experiments. Discipline is great and so the teachers are able to use all their time for actual teaching! I'm really impressed with everything she's learnt and the standard of her work.

IntotheEther · 08/02/2023 13:41

Our DC goes to a small private pre-prep school. Since the school is small, the benefits are more in terms of a very structured environment on a lovely site, smaller class sizes, lots of individual attention and a decent range of extracurricular activities, rather than fantastic facilities/lunches etc. Our DC is making excellent progress and loves going to school and we're happy that he's getting such a good grounding in the basics early on. That said, our decision to send him there was influenced by our state school option. There are many fantastic state primaries in our area, but the one we were offered is not one of them and, when I visited, I was put off by the uninspiring teaching and somewhat chaotic environment. It seemed very easy for children to get 'lost' there.

ComeTheSpringLobelia · 08/02/2023 13:40

Just to say that our private school has 20% SEN children. Mine is one of them. The SEN provision is excellent.

If you are going to be craping by to send them then I would think about it carefully. Ours costs about £18 k per child per year but that is the base rate- everything costs on top of it and the school uniform is extortionate (although we have a thriving second hand shop).

For us the pros are small classes (never had more than 16 in the class and the DCs are now Yr 8 and Yr 6 and have been there since aged 4) - excellent SEN provision- terrific pastoral care- truly exceptional- dedicated ambitious teachers- global outlook- loads of extra curricular stuff (although my SEN child cannot access that as it is too much for him on top of school).

But that is our school. If we had a state school that did what we need thwn we would be state. The sheer cost of it is an issue for us, but we can (currently) manage. If the propsoed VAT on school fees goes ahead then god knows what we will do. No-one is mega rich at our school- in my friendhsip circle of parents one works for the NHS in CAMHS; one is a store manager at Costa (although her daughter in on a part-funded bursary); one is a plumber and alot are forces families.

user567543 · 08/02/2023 13:30

Went from state to private - it really depends on your local options. We got smaller classes and miles better pastoral care. Mine hate team sports and clubs so probably don't get the traditional benefits

Devoutspoken · 08/02/2023 13:29

State schools are not as ethnically diverse? what now?

FeinCuroxiVooz · 08/02/2023 13:27

not all state schools are awful.
not all private schools are brilliant.

in general, learning outcomes at KS1 are a lot more strongly dependent on how engaged parents are with education, how much reading practice the kids do at home with parents, and how much books are central to family life. without these, a kid in a brilliant school won't thrive nearly as much as a kid who has these advantages but is at a terrible school. so for years R-2 save your money unless the private school is really convenient for other reasons.

the gaps do widen and start being less acceptable from around y4-5. "State till Eight" is as commonplace a motto as "on your knees to avoid the fees" (ie use religious criteria to get a faith-based state place). But we stuck with state till y7.

visit all possible schools both state and private and go with the ones that feel like the right fit.

whether it's "worth it" depends what you are giving up to afford it. For a family who are taking themselves close to the breadline to scrape together fees and are foregoing all luxuries and comforts, then maybe not. If it means just 2 weeks of skiing rather than 3 and having to fly economy rather than business class occasionally but otherwise being generally able to have everything you want, then yes it's totally worth it for a good school.

Dixiechickonhols · 08/02/2023 13:25

If you have another child with additional needs then the all in aspect of private might suit versus state and ferrying to activities every night.

Leirvassbu · 08/02/2023 13:19

I think you should go to open days for state and private and get a feel for the differences yourself.
Not every state school is the same and not every private school is the same.
I taught in both sectors. If you have a good or very good state primary school near you then I really don't think there is much difference other than small class sizes and fewer disruptive pupils (they'll usually be asked to leave a private school). People talk about the extra-curricular activities at private schools, but to be honest, many state schools also offer clubs and if your child is interested in music or sport you can pay for lessons/clubs outside of school, same for drama, art, language whatever.
It can be worth it at secondary level depending on where you live and what the state schools are like.
If you are going to put them in at 4 you need to be really sure you can fund it all the way up - it's not great for the child if they have to move to a state school at a critical point in their schooling because your money has run out.
Save the money now, look for a good state primary, if it turns out your child has difficulties or isn't being challenged, you can look at private schools in a couple of years time, otherwise revisit the issue at 11.

Dixiechickonhols · 08/02/2023 13:18

I’d compare the local states you can get a place at v privates locally. Try and visit as many as you can.

Compare class sizes
Facilities
Extra curricular
Wrap around/holiday care
Destinations at 11

Mine went to a small private primary. Class of 15. It was in a deprived northern town so cost same as nursery at time . Pros all parents were supportive. Virtually all children had 2 working patents so it was set up for that it was very working parent friendly. Mix of ethnic backgrounds unlike local state and there were many children with additional needs (it very much catered for the need a bit of extra help but won’t qualify for ehcp market)
It was quite old fashioned focus on basics and manners. Behaviour standards were high - they stood out at events with other local schools in a good way. Extras like public speaking encouraged. Lots of sport.
Mine got off to a flying start and she speaks fondly of her time there and the head.
She went into state grammar at 11.

SunlightThroughTrees · 08/02/2023 13:08

“Private schools are less racist” 🙄

I would love to see the evidence behind this statement.

whumpthereitis · 08/02/2023 13:05

I went to private school (albeit secondary) and had a great experience. Smaller class sizes which allowed for more one-on-one attention when necessary, fantastic resources, and more opportunities in terms of subjects and extra curricular activities. Obviously it depends on the school, but undoubtedly you’ll do your research beforehand.

If affordable to you I would absolutely recommend it.

TheaBrandt · 08/02/2023 13:02

As others say you can’t extrapolate a judgement from your own experience. We have been happy with state as we carefully moved to an area with strong single sex secondaries. Both dds thriving. Second one socialises with the private school crowd (not actually sure this is a good thing). Agree the sport provision does seem better at private we have to seek that out.

ZombiePara · 08/02/2023 12:41

As a child who started in state primary and got moved to private (I had no idea why at the time, but found out whilst clearing a house it was due to the state school not being able to challenge/teach me enough), I would advocate for private.

I got the education I needed, the push, the challenge and the support. I was by no means from a rich family, but I wasn't alone in that either.

I also went to a state school for secondary, and felt well set up for it, and capable of what was needed.

I haven't got my own kids, yet, and not sure whether I'll be in a position to give them what I had growing up, but I'd like to, as I feel it benefitted me very well.

NerrSnerr · 08/02/2023 12:33

@2Bornot that sounds like your experience of one state school and one private school.

Some will be universal but 100% my kids state school is more ethnically diverse than the local private. Surely it depends on the area?

Wakeywake · 08/02/2023 12:29

I moved my kids to a decent private school from a really good state school half way through primary. I really couldn't fault the state school and we would have happily stayed there if we hadn't moved. However, the private school still offered some advantages. Smaller class sizes, fewer disruptive children, earlier streaming, additional tutoring support, many, many school clubs (free), ability to learn an instrument (paid extra), a focus on developing confidence and interpersonal skills, sports, really good school trips, great facilities. For us, it was worth it.

gogohmm · 08/02/2023 12:25

Pressed too soon

Researched the school really well, not all private schools are good or right for your child. Be wary of schools with high staff turnover especially heads

gogohmm · 08/02/2023 12:24

Just make sure you research the sch

NRCOA · 08/02/2023 12:11

I have been a nanny in London for over 20 years.
I have cared for many kids in both private and state schools.
If I could afford it, I would absolutely send my child (if I had one!) to a private school.
People are correct; there are some lovely state schools but in all honesty, the private schools that my charges have been to have been incredible and you can't beat the facilities and experiences that they give. The majority of my privately educated kids have been miles ahead than the kids of the same age at state school. Yes, private school children are worked hard with long days. But that's why they have longer holidays.
If you can afford it, start private school at aged 4 because.
In regards to the long holidays, if you can afford private school, then there are lots of holiday childcare options, including some very good sports camps that are reasonably priced.

TheSnowyOwl · 08/02/2023 12:02

A good private school that is suitable for the particular child (ie focuses on their strengths whether that is sport, music, art, academic etc) is nearly always going to be better than a state school.

I hear people say they save for private secondary but I think the foundations achieved from a good primary education are far more essential.

The only negative, in my experience, can be that the class sizes can be very small at some schools which doesn’t leave such a wide opportunity for a range of friends and it can feel a little claustrophobic. In lots of other ways this is outweighed.

If you can afford it, taking into account fee increases throughout the year and all the extra curricular activities, and covering the longer school holidays, then I absolutely would.

confusedaboutworkingandparenting · 08/02/2023 12:01

Thanks for the helpful replies. My child is a sensitive and clever little one. Way ahead of their peers in certain areas (speech). Struggles a bit in others respects (emotional side). Like all children! Strengths and weaknesses. For what it's worth, I know all about SEND as I have another child with complex additional needs who attends a specialist school. Sorry for the drip feed, I didn't expect it to be relevant but it clearly is to some of the posters here.

OP posts:
Suedomin · 08/02/2023 11:56

2Bornot
You are describing one state school and one private school. You can't base a meaningful conclusion from that!
There are some excellent state schools where none of what you describe exists and some terrible private schools where bullying is rife, results matter more than the child, and teachers are unqualified.
OP you have to look at the schools and decide what will suit your child. Also you need to think about the cost and is the benefit of private school to your child more than the benefit of holidays, treats days out together etc.
Personally at age 4 unless your child has particular needs I would think it's too soon to tell.

BigotSpigot · 08/02/2023 11:43

2Bornot I take issue with nearly everything you have stated as fact, aside from class sizes and costs. You really can't make such sweeping judgements. I have had a child in a private school with deeply entrenched bullying problems and I have experienced state primaries with fantastic diversity where the children were absolutely encouraged to be individuals. 30% SEN across the board is absolutely ridiculous too. Regarding class sizes, the ratio of adults (including TA's) to child is actually not very different between the schools my DC go to.

cestlavielife · 08/02/2023 11:43

2Bornot · 08/02/2023 11:36

I sent my DC to state school and moved to private school at age 9. I strongly wish that we had never gone to the state school and had done private from the beginning.

The main differences are:

  • State school is now about 30% special needs, who take up all of the teacher’s time, disrupt the class for the other children, and make it hard to learn. If your child is lucky enough to be in a year with no SEN, the head will move someone disruptive down from the year above.
  • Bright kids are ignored by the teacher at state school as ‘meets target, no further action needed.’
  • Class size. At state school your 4 yr old will be in a class of 30. At private the class size will be 4-16 (depending on school: ask the policy).
  • Bullies. At state school these are hard to get rid of, at private school they’ll be swiftly told to leave.
  • Money. Private school costs. 😬
  • Racism. State primaries can be shockingly racist. Private schools are usually more ethnically diverse and less racist: social dynamics are not about skin they’re about manners/money/sportiness/intellect/parents’ behaviour.
  • Sports. At state school your child will do almost no exercise, and will quickly lose fitness. At private school you can expect 3-4 sessions of proper exercise every week.
  • Fitting in. If your child is an introvert from a wealthy background and interested in eg classical music, they won’t fit in socially at state school. It isn’t a big deal at age 4 but by age 9 is very difficult for the child.
  • Facilities and cleaning is much better at private but this wasn’t a big deal for us. That said our school was able to stay open during much of the pandemic when others were ordered to close because our school had the facilities and staff to arrange tiny ‘bubbles’, and our school seems much healthier than our old state primary, perhaps because of the better cleaning standards.
  • Unless your child is supremely confident, state school will ‘squash’ them with adults constantly saying “shhh” instead of listening to and encouraging the child’s opinions.

A private (aka independent) school is anything where the parents fund it instead of the state.

A public school is one of the oldest private schools, very traditional and probably a bit wanky.

Will it turn your child into a posh wanker? Some will! But it won’t if you pick the school with care. Do open days and tours and look at the parents / other children. Would YOU fit in? Probably, about half our school is ‘normal’ parents, many from working class backgrounds, who’ve chosen a small house and fewer holidays because they’ve prioritised education.

If you look at schools and don’t fit in, look for a cheaper or more bohemian school. Some private schools still wear top hats and straw boaters 🤣 others have no uniform and call the teachers by first names. You can find one that suits your family perfectly if you search.

Is it worth it? If you have a badly behaved noisy child who doesn’t care about sports or learning, there’s no point spending money on private school where they’d get asked to leave in a few years. If you have a well behaved bright child, or a sensitive child, it is a wise investment.

Thats experience of One state and One private
You cannot extrapolate
There are good state schools yes acvomodating SEN too!!
There are poor private ones
Op do your homewoirk and visit them
If you like the private one and can afford it might be right fir you

2Bornot · 08/02/2023 11:36

I sent my DC to state school and moved to private school at age 9. I strongly wish that we had never gone to the state school and had done private from the beginning.

The main differences are:

  • State school is now about 30% special needs, who take up all of the teacher’s time, disrupt the class for the other children, and make it hard to learn. If your child is lucky enough to be in a year with no SEN, the head will move someone disruptive down from the year above.
  • Bright kids are ignored by the teacher at state school as ‘meets target, no further action needed.’
  • Class size. At state school your 4 yr old will be in a class of 30. At private the class size will be 4-16 (depending on school: ask the policy).
  • Bullies. At state school these are hard to get rid of, at private school they’ll be swiftly told to leave.
  • Money. Private school costs. 😬
  • Racism. State primaries can be shockingly racist. Private schools are usually more ethnically diverse and less racist: social dynamics are not about skin they’re about manners/money/sportiness/intellect/parents’ behaviour.
  • Sports. At state school your child will do almost no exercise, and will quickly lose fitness. At private school you can expect 3-4 sessions of proper exercise every week.
  • Fitting in. If your child is an introvert from a wealthy background and interested in eg classical music, they won’t fit in socially at state school. It isn’t a big deal at age 4 but by age 9 is very difficult for the child.
  • Facilities and cleaning is much better at private but this wasn’t a big deal for us. That said our school was able to stay open during much of the pandemic when others were ordered to close because our school had the facilities and staff to arrange tiny ‘bubbles’, and our school seems much healthier than our old state primary, perhaps because of the better cleaning standards.
  • Unless your child is supremely confident, state school will ‘squash’ them with adults constantly saying “shhh” instead of listening to and encouraging the child’s opinions.

A private (aka independent) school is anything where the parents fund it instead of the state.

A public school is one of the oldest private schools, very traditional and probably a bit wanky.

Will it turn your child into a posh wanker? Some will! But it won’t if you pick the school with care. Do open days and tours and look at the parents / other children. Would YOU fit in? Probably, about half our school is ‘normal’ parents, many from working class backgrounds, who’ve chosen a small house and fewer holidays because they’ve prioritised education.

If you look at schools and don’t fit in, look for a cheaper or more bohemian school. Some private schools still wear top hats and straw boaters 🤣 others have no uniform and call the teachers by first names. You can find one that suits your family perfectly if you search.

Is it worth it? If you have a badly behaved noisy child who doesn’t care about sports or learning, there’s no point spending money on private school where they’d get asked to leave in a few years. If you have a well behaved bright child, or a sensitive child, it is a wise investment.

Nevermind31 · 08/02/2023 11:34

We started in private as it was the only option that worked logistically for us (school, nursery, work). now in state school as moved.
there are some pros and cons to both.
with private school, you pay for everything. Often in addition to fees, so I would check that. Lunch, trips, language specialist, dyslexia referral… uniform is more expensive too. If you are thinking of a selective school, then your child will need to go for an interview. Tuition fees will go up every year. Holidays are tricky to cover if you don’t have a SAHP or nanny, as clubs don’t cover all the holidays. Students will come from a wider area, so less local friends.
you most likely will get smaller class sizes, language tuition earlier on, more/ better clubs, better extras.
if money is not an issue then I would look at the schools around you and choose the one that fits your child.m, be it private or state.
Mine go to an excellent state school now that has small class sizes, excellent facilities, free trips and lunch - and we are very very grateful for the money we are No longer paying.