Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send my child to private school at age 4?

233 replies

confusedaboutworkingandparenting · 08/02/2023 10:23

Wise Mumsnetters, please talk to me about private school in the UK. Or public school? What is the difference? As you have probably gathered already, DH and I went to comprehensive schools and have no experience of education options in London or the independent school system in the UK. Other children is unlikely to be a factor here so we could probably afford to pay for one to go, although of course it would involve some sacrifices. We have some good private schools nearby to us and none of the "local" state primary schools are actually that convenient, so all options involve a bit of a trek. So talk to me about private school? Is it worth it? Is it really that different to state school? When is the best time to send them? If you could afford it, would you do it? And why? And will I inadvertently turn my beloved child into a posh tw*t?! Also the holidays are so long! What do you do with them then! Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences and wisdom.

OP posts:
Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 22:33

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 09/02/2023 22:20

I can see your point but let's face it, when it comes to one's own children we as parents tend to do what we think is best for them.....sometimes that means private school.

Private schools do also relieve the burden on the state system.

They absolutely do not relieve burden - schools funding is per capita. Plus, affluent parents can often assist with revenue streams into schools (for example, more able to participate in fundraising, which benefits all pupils)

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 09/02/2023 22:20

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 16:46

I personally disagree with the whole concept of private education. All it does is widens the gap between rich and poor. The wealthy parents who can afford private school are generally the ones best placed to force the government to improve the non private schools. Instead, the poor are left in failing schools while the rich buy their way out of the problem.

I can see your point but let's face it, when it comes to one's own children we as parents tend to do what we think is best for them.....sometimes that means private school.

Private schools do also relieve the burden on the state system.

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 19:24

Dixiechickonhols · 09/02/2023 19:10

Religious near me (I’m
in England) means selective.
Out of interest I checked free school meal stats. C of E 8% free meals, Academy 31% on free meals - Both schools in same postcode!
C of E needs child christened & weekly attendance at church yr 4 & 5.
Results are majority of C of E get 5 pass GCSE’s v 20% at the Academy. It’s that stark.

You don’t live somewhere with very sectarian roots. Religious segregation in schools in Scotland is a really contentious issue. But no, most certainly not selective.

My (large) town has two non denominational schools and two catholic schools. All are run by the local council. There are two catchments in the school - one catholic and one non denominational school is in each catchment.

It’s far more simple and more fair, IMO, than the English system, because there are less layers.

surreygirl1987 · 09/02/2023 19:21

OP, I'm sending my 4 year old to private school (and his little brother next year too). The main reasons are good wraparound care (most kids stay) and half the class size of the local state school. However, I wouldn't have even considered it if I didn't work in a private (senior) school - we get a 50% staff discount if we send them to this particular private prep school. We can afford it but it will mean some sacrifices.

456pickupsticks · 09/02/2023 19:14

Dixiechickonhols · 08/02/2023 13:18

I’d compare the local states you can get a place at v privates locally. Try and visit as many as you can.

Compare class sizes
Facilities
Extra curricular
Wrap around/holiday care
Destinations at 11

Mine went to a small private primary. Class of 15. It was in a deprived northern town so cost same as nursery at time . Pros all parents were supportive. Virtually all children had 2 working patents so it was set up for that it was very working parent friendly. Mix of ethnic backgrounds unlike local state and there were many children with additional needs (it very much catered for the need a bit of extra help but won’t qualify for ehcp market)
It was quite old fashioned focus on basics and manners. Behaviour standards were high - they stood out at events with other local schools in a good way. Extras like public speaking encouraged. Lots of sport.
Mine got off to a flying start and she speaks fondly of her time there and the head.
She went into state grammar at 11.

Another thing for OP to consider is:

COST THE SAME AS NURSERY AT THE TIME.
If you're going to have to pay for before and after school care, but the private school offers this for free (alongside afterschool sports, choirs, drama, music, clubs etc), this could be a major consideration.

I went to a private school for sixth form with an attached nursery and primary school, and several of the parents in nursery or infants sent their children their because it was cheaper for more hours than other private nurseries or childcare options (open 7:30 am- 5;30pm with no more cost than if girls just attended core school hours of 8:40-3;30ish).

Newnamenewname109870 · 09/02/2023 19:13

Private school can be truly wonderful.

However, I coped at state for a bit. (Well I coped at one but not another).

It depends on the school exactly. Also it really, really does have to be fair between children and I’d rather start at state then move to private later on. The other way round isn’t great!

you need to do all the open days.

Dixiechickonhols · 09/02/2023 19:10

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 19:05

We have Catholic state schools which are non selective, you don’t even need to be Catholic.

We have non denominational schools which have Christian input - these are generally seen as “Protestant” schools, but that’s not actually true.

Generally speaking, the catchments for the catholic school are the exact same as for the non denominational school. Strictly speaking anyone can go to either of them though.

We also have faith based private schools for whatever faiths are prevalent in a particular area.

Religious near me (I’m
in England) means selective.
Out of interest I checked free school meal stats. C of E 8% free meals, Academy 31% on free meals - Both schools in same postcode!
C of E needs child christened & weekly attendance at church yr 4 & 5.
Results are majority of C of E get 5 pass GCSE’s v 20% at the Academy. It’s that stark.

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 19:10

Dixiechickonhols · 09/02/2023 18:41

The poster was so adamant all Scottish children just went to their local school that I thought I’d missed something all these years!
So they don’t all go to same local school as I thought.

They do just go to their local school. Catholic schools here are just regular schools. You get a choice of two - a catholic school and a non denominational school. There is no applications, no second choices - you get into whatever school you choose, out of the two you are zoned for.

cantkeepawayforever · 09/02/2023 19:05

Why would a school accept a child who was already identifiable at age 4 as “(be)low average” if it meant that child could get into the highly competitive senior school without doing exams? What is in it for the school?

The schools with attached primary / prep depts are not, in any real sense other than in publicity, ‘selective’ for anything other than wealth and non-SEN. (The parents don’t understand this at 4, and by the time they realise it, are already within the system, and are unlikely to leave it.) The schools involved are the most expensive and socially ‘posh’.

The school which is genuinely selective doesn’t have linked preps - I agree there is nothing in it for it to become all through or facilitate secondary transfer.

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 19:05

Dixiechickonhols · 09/02/2023 18:30

You don’t have any religious secondary schools in Scotland?

We have Catholic state schools which are non selective, you don’t even need to be Catholic.

We have non denominational schools which have Christian input - these are generally seen as “Protestant” schools, but that’s not actually true.

Generally speaking, the catchments for the catholic school are the exact same as for the non denominational school. Strictly speaking anyone can go to either of them though.

We also have faith based private schools for whatever faiths are prevalent in a particular area.

bakewellbride · 09/02/2023 19:01

Having seen some London private schools I would never send a child there even if you paid me. Some of the things I saw:

  • kids afraid of the water in a swimming lesson being forced into the water and screaming
  • reception art work being 90% done by staff so it 'looks good for the parents'
  • a nursery teacher who thinks 'play is a waste of time' and has the children (age 3 and 4) stand in lines chanting shit that means absolutely nothing to them like the continents of the world. To the parents / on the surface kids from this class appear smarter than state kids because wow they're only 3 and they can name the continents of the world! But scratch beneath the surface and they have no concept of what a continent is because they're too young and in fact they've not been learning in a way that's meaningful to them so it's all smoke and mirrors.
  • same teacher as above "girls tend to be nurses and men tend to be doctors" (yes, really)
I could go on and that's not really having spent that much time covering private. The vast amount of experience I had was in state primary schools but I'd seen enough to feel really uncomfortable. State all the way for my kids.
ScrollingLeaves · 09/02/2023 19:00

Futurethoughts · Today 18:11
No one is saying all affluent families will choose to educate privately, @Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris , any more than they do now.

But if private schools were scrapped tomorrow, affluent families wouldn’t meekly accept Crap St Academy.

Isn’t easy to change a school your child is at. The minute you aren’t meek you are ‘that parent’ and you worry it will affect your child.

Lots of parents might decide to make groups with private tutors if there were no choice.

cantkeepawayforever · 09/02/2023 18:59

The thing that makes comparison really challenging is that the private schools’ budget for advertising etc is infinitely greater than that for state schools. It’s really hard to glean detailed enough information to make sensible and fair comparisons across sectors, especially at primary.

I would certainly ask about the qualifications of every member of staff (including so called associates/ tutors / assistants, often used to allow claims that ‘all teachers are highly qualified’, while obscuring the fact that the teacher teaches the parallel class, while the ‘associate’ teaches yours) in the private schools you are interested in, as well as enquiring about the numbers and destination of children leaving ‘along the way - many private primary schools actively manage out children with SEN to local state primaries to boost their exit stats.

Catnary · 09/02/2023 18:57

It is possibly worth paying for 1 of the others at a push if your have a child who is low average and you want them to go to private secondary, as they dodge the secondary entrance exams.

Why would a school accept a child who was already identifiable at age 4 as “(be)low average” if it meant that child could get into the highly competitive senior school without doing exams? What is in it for the school?

There are lots of reasons to try to avoid entrance exams even if your child is bright, and plenty of bright kids applying for 4+ places at straight through schools. What you say makes no sense.

ancientgran · 09/02/2023 18:55

ancientgran · 09/02/2023 18:51

Mine didn't go to school until they were 8, tested when they started school and I was told the test only went up to 14 so they couldn't give me an age.

Sorry Devoutspoken, I was agree kids from all sorts of backgrounds and education types can be above the reading age just like yours and mine did. When I read it back I wasn't sure that was how it came across.

ancientgran · 09/02/2023 18:51

Devoutspoken · 08/02/2023 22:27

My kids were above their reading age in state school

Mine didn't go to school until they were 8, tested when they started school and I was told the test only went up to 14 so they couldn't give me an age.

cantkeepawayforever · 09/02/2023 18:51

You have to do the comparison between
specific schools, not at a sector level.

In a town I am familiar with (5 large private primaries / preps and 1 small; 4 private secondaries; 5 state secondaries; 10+ state primaries):

It is worth paying for 1 of the private primaries for a bright child, and a further 1 if you live in the catchments of 3 of the primaries. It is possibly worth paying for 1 of the others at a push if your have a child who is low average and you want them to go to private secondary, as they dodge the secondary entrance exams.

It is not worth paying for any of the private primaries if your child has SEN.

It is worth paying for 1 of the secondaries, especially if you are not in the catchment for the best 2 state schools.

It is possibly worth paying for another of the secondaries if you are in the catchment of 1 of the secondaries, depending on your views on extensive sport vs excellent value add but a challenging cohort.

The rest of the private provision? No, not really worth it. Several of the state options have better results.

Catnary · 09/02/2023 18:46

Untitledsquatboulder · 09/02/2023 18:46

According to that poster the reason is that they are less ethnically diverse (so I guess have less people to be racist to) or something about nice manners - they weren't entirely clear coherent Hmm

No, she said they were MORE ethnically diverse.

Untitledsquatboulder · 09/02/2023 18:46

SunlightThroughTrees · 08/02/2023 13:08

“Private schools are less racist” 🙄

I would love to see the evidence behind this statement.

According to that poster the reason is that they are less ethnically diverse (so I guess have less people to be racist to) or something about nice manners - they weren't entirely clear coherent Hmm

Catnary · 09/02/2023 18:46

Dixiechickonhols · 09/02/2023 18:41

The poster was so adamant all Scottish children just went to their local school that I thought I’d missed something all these years!
So they don’t all go to same local school as I thought.

To be fair there are probably fewer Catholic schools north of the Central belt, perhaps she lives in Inverness or something and forgot.

Dixiechickonhols · 09/02/2023 18:41

Catnary · 09/02/2023 18:34

Just in case that was a serious question- most towns have a Catholic school and all the Catholic children go to it.

The poster was so adamant all Scottish children just went to their local school that I thought I’d missed something all these years!
So they don’t all go to same local school as I thought.

Catnary · 09/02/2023 18:34

Catnary · 09/02/2023 18:34

Just in case that was a serious question- most towns have a Catholic school and all the Catholic children go to it.

Thus perpetuating the rampant sectarianism across all levels of Scottish society.

Catnary · 09/02/2023 18:34

Dixiechickonhols · 09/02/2023 18:30

You don’t have any religious secondary schools in Scotland?

Just in case that was a serious question- most towns have a Catholic school and all the Catholic children go to it.

Catnary · 09/02/2023 18:33

Dixiechickonhols · 09/02/2023 18:30

You don’t have any religious secondary schools in Scotland?

Ha ha ha ha ha. Quite.

user567543 · 09/02/2023 18:30

@Thepeopleversuswork one of my dds v similar and really struggled in co ed state primary. There isn't enough choice in state schools in Scotland and I certainly can think of several with incredibly well heeled catchments.