Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send my child to private school at age 4?

233 replies

confusedaboutworkingandparenting · 08/02/2023 10:23

Wise Mumsnetters, please talk to me about private school in the UK. Or public school? What is the difference? As you have probably gathered already, DH and I went to comprehensive schools and have no experience of education options in London or the independent school system in the UK. Other children is unlikely to be a factor here so we could probably afford to pay for one to go, although of course it would involve some sacrifices. We have some good private schools nearby to us and none of the "local" state primary schools are actually that convenient, so all options involve a bit of a trek. So talk to me about private school? Is it worth it? Is it really that different to state school? When is the best time to send them? If you could afford it, would you do it? And why? And will I inadvertently turn my beloved child into a posh tw*t?! Also the holidays are so long! What do you do with them then! Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences and wisdom.

OP posts:
ACynicalDad · 10/02/2023 13:55

My kids are flourishing in state, but if I had the money they'd be in private school in seconds. The only downside is some privately educated kids have no idea about the other 90% of society and they need to break out of the private school bubble, but do it if you can.

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 13:50

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:49

You might find your own self serving values fine and be happy to install the same values into your children.

Large parts of society think that this is incredibly selfish behaviour.

Okay 🤷🏻‍♀️

Have you finished now?

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:49

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 13:32

i don’t feel sad about not thinking that private school parents have some nebulous moral duty to support state schools even if it meant putting their own children at a disadvantage, no.

Perfectly comfortable with both this and my core values. The issues with them seem to be yours.

You might find your own self serving values fine and be happy to install the same values into your children.

Large parts of society think that this is incredibly selfish behaviour.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:47

Libelula21 · 10/02/2023 13:41

Just to be super pedantic, you are increasingly getting a choice of Gaelic medium school too. Both Edinburgh and Glasgow have Gaelic medium high schools, for example.

Yes, this is true - but again, you would go to your local Gaelic school, and they are non selective. And often, they are attached to the local non denominational school anyway.

We considered Gaelic medium for my daughter from nursery level, but ultimately I wasn’t happy by her going in a mini bus herself aged 3, due to the car seat situation. Unfortunate as there are many benefits!

morechocolateneededtoday · 10/02/2023 13:46

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:23

The fact you don’t feel sad about all children not getting a fair crack at a good education speaks volumes about your core values.

I think you are directing your anger at the wrong person here.
The average class in a state school has 30 children - so 30 sets of parents. Are they all unable to speak up for themselves? PP has pointed out they have encountered lots of children from influential families in state schools whose parents believe that state is the way to educate. Why are they not being attacked for their lack of support towards fellow parents?

Most of all, the fault lies at the government's door. If state schools were appropriately funded, far fewer would feel the need to consider private education. This is where the ultimate problem lies. Pitting private school parents as nasty is just another way of them achieving the divide and conquer whilst deflecting the attention from their spectacular failures

Libelula21 · 10/02/2023 13:41

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 09/02/2023 19:10

They do just go to their local school. Catholic schools here are just regular schools. You get a choice of two - a catholic school and a non denominational school. There is no applications, no second choices - you get into whatever school you choose, out of the two you are zoned for.

Just to be super pedantic, you are increasingly getting a choice of Gaelic medium school too. Both Edinburgh and Glasgow have Gaelic medium high schools, for example.

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 13:32

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:23

The fact you don’t feel sad about all children not getting a fair crack at a good education speaks volumes about your core values.

i don’t feel sad about not thinking that private school parents have some nebulous moral duty to support state schools even if it meant putting their own children at a disadvantage, no.

Perfectly comfortable with both this and my core values. The issues with them seem to be yours.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:23

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 13:14

I don’t feel sad about it at all, but if you want to then feel free I guess.

No, it’s not the responsibility of private school parents to prioritize supporting state schools over the educational opportunities of their own children.

The fact you don’t feel sad about all children not getting a fair crack at a good education speaks volumes about your core values.

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 13:14

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:11

It’s quite sad that you think that way. It’s everyone’s responsibility to speak up for those who can’t speak up for themselves.

I don’t feel sad about it at all, but if you want to then feel free I guess.

No, it’s not the responsibility of private school parents to prioritize supporting state schools over the educational opportunities of their own children.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:11

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 13:09

Sure, but that doesn’t mean that private school parents have a duty to do it for them.

It’s quite sad that you think that way. It’s everyone’s responsibility to speak up for those who can’t speak up for themselves.

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 13:09

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:05

Well obviously. But often, those who can’t afford to send kids to private school are those who are less able to campaign for change. Which is what my original point was.

Sure, but that doesn’t mean that private school parents have a duty to do it for them.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:05

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 13:02

That the focus should be on ‘let’s improve for the students we do have’, rather than ‘this is the fault of parents who don’t state educate, they’re letting us down’.

Well obviously. But often, those who can’t afford to send kids to private school are those who are less able to campaign for change. Which is what my original point was.

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 13:02

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:00

I’m not actually sure what you are trying to say in the last paragraph?

That the focus should be on ‘let’s improve for the students we do have’, rather than ‘this is the fault of parents who don’t state educate, they’re letting us down’.

FourFour · 10/02/2023 13:02

@whumpthereitis agree with this. My academic and sensitive child will absolutely not thrive as he is, if he was in a state school. As you say we are ensuring certain things for our ds. I'm horrified when I read threads on here about bullying. I'm not saying this doesn't happen in private at all, there's just a lot more intervention and repercussions immediately. The biggest load of nonsense is that a bright child will flourish anywhere.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 13:00

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 12:58

That seems to be working on the assumption that private school parents have a duty to support state schools over their duty to their own children (from their perspective).

State schools shouldn’t be supported already for the pupils that are there, not reliant on the hypothetical support of the parents of pupils that aren’t.

I’m not actually sure what you are trying to say in the last paragraph?

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 12:58

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 12:55

Of course it depends on many factors. And yes, it’s simplistic, but it is also generally true. And those parents who are best placed to demand change withdrawing their kids from state schools means things will never improve in state schools.

I’ve yet to come across a school which doesn’t focus on academic achievement, by the way. Not saying it doesn’t exist; but I’ve never seen it. Academic achievement doesn’t just mean how many kids get the top grades though.

That seems to be working on the assumption that private school parents have a duty to support state schools over their duty to their own children (from their perspective).

State schools shouldn’t be supported already for the pupils that are there, not reliant on the hypothetical support of the parents of pupils that aren’t.

FourFour · 10/02/2023 12:56

We do, ds is also very shy and sensitive but quite academic. It has suited him to be in this type of schooling. The individual attention he receives is so worth it. The headteacher makes it a point to teach a class for a term to get to know each and every child. His teachers are always available, always. I don't want ds having to deal with difficult or disruptive children and our school has zero tolerance on bullying. We are also in the NW 'hot house' type of school which gets a bad rep but the pastoral care is exceptional. My experience is of 2 independent schools and many friends who's kids are in both private and state schooling.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 12:55

I’m at the far end of the process with my own children - I see them at higher education institutions of internationally -renowned quality and their choice, courtesy of a total of 4 state schools between them.

When I was at the other end, yes, of course I fretted. I saw peers and relatives making very different school choices, and worried that ours were, by comparison, ‘failing’ our DC.

I can completely understand why parents choose private schools ‘just in case’; ‘for security’; ‘because that’s what people like us do’; ‘because I can only see average results, not the results for my type of child’. In the current climate of school funding snd teacher flight, we also might have made different choices.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 12:55

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 12:48

Depends on other factors though, doesn’t it? ‘Bright kids will do well anywhere’ is a simplistic trope. Environment absolutely can impact outcomes, and one that isn’t focused on academic achievement, and/or one where children are bullied if they work hard, or the attention of teachers is taken up by ‘problem’ students, will have consequences for pupils.

Thankfully, parents with the means are free to decide ‘to throw money at it’ if they deem that to be in the best interests of their own children, despite the fact that you disagree.

Of course it depends on many factors. And yes, it’s simplistic, but it is also generally true. And those parents who are best placed to demand change withdrawing their kids from state schools means things will never improve in state schools.

I’ve yet to come across a school which doesn’t focus on academic achievement, by the way. Not saying it doesn’t exist; but I’ve never seen it. Academic achievement doesn’t just mean how many kids get the top grades though.

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 12:48

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 10/02/2023 12:29

I honestly think these people are throwing money at a problem which doesn’t need to be a problem.

Statistics show that, even in the same school, those from more affluent areas perform better than those from less affluent areas. Poverty isn’t contagious - and nor are bad exam grades. I reckon many of those kids who achieve 5 highers (the equivalent of what you need to get into medical school etc - top A level grades I think) would do so at a private school or a state school - and all sending them to a private school does is make the state school look worse.

Depends on other factors though, doesn’t it? ‘Bright kids will do well anywhere’ is a simplistic trope. Environment absolutely can impact outcomes, and one that isn’t focused on academic achievement, and/or one where children are bullied if they work hard, or the attention of teachers is taken up by ‘problem’ students, will have consequences for pupils.

Thankfully, parents with the means are free to decide ‘to throw money at it’ if they deem that to be in the best interests of their own children, despite the fact that you disagree.

Bleese · 10/02/2023 12:44

2Bornot · 08/02/2023 11:36

I sent my DC to state school and moved to private school at age 9. I strongly wish that we had never gone to the state school and had done private from the beginning.

The main differences are:

  • State school is now about 30% special needs, who take up all of the teacher’s time, disrupt the class for the other children, and make it hard to learn. If your child is lucky enough to be in a year with no SEN, the head will move someone disruptive down from the year above.
  • Bright kids are ignored by the teacher at state school as ‘meets target, no further action needed.’
  • Class size. At state school your 4 yr old will be in a class of 30. At private the class size will be 4-16 (depending on school: ask the policy).
  • Bullies. At state school these are hard to get rid of, at private school they’ll be swiftly told to leave.
  • Money. Private school costs. 😬
  • Racism. State primaries can be shockingly racist. Private schools are usually more ethnically diverse and less racist: social dynamics are not about skin they’re about manners/money/sportiness/intellect/parents’ behaviour.
  • Sports. At state school your child will do almost no exercise, and will quickly lose fitness. At private school you can expect 3-4 sessions of proper exercise every week.
  • Fitting in. If your child is an introvert from a wealthy background and interested in eg classical music, they won’t fit in socially at state school. It isn’t a big deal at age 4 but by age 9 is very difficult for the child.
  • Facilities and cleaning is much better at private but this wasn’t a big deal for us. That said our school was able to stay open during much of the pandemic when others were ordered to close because our school had the facilities and staff to arrange tiny ‘bubbles’, and our school seems much healthier than our old state primary, perhaps because of the better cleaning standards.
  • Unless your child is supremely confident, state school will ‘squash’ them with adults constantly saying “shhh” instead of listening to and encouraging the child’s opinions.

A private (aka independent) school is anything where the parents fund it instead of the state.

A public school is one of the oldest private schools, very traditional and probably a bit wanky.

Will it turn your child into a posh wanker? Some will! But it won’t if you pick the school with care. Do open days and tours and look at the parents / other children. Would YOU fit in? Probably, about half our school is ‘normal’ parents, many from working class backgrounds, who’ve chosen a small house and fewer holidays because they’ve prioritised education.

If you look at schools and don’t fit in, look for a cheaper or more bohemian school. Some private schools still wear top hats and straw boaters 🤣 others have no uniform and call the teachers by first names. You can find one that suits your family perfectly if you search.

Is it worth it? If you have a badly behaved noisy child who doesn’t care about sports or learning, there’s no point spending money on private school where they’d get asked to leave in a few years. If you have a well behaved bright child, or a sensitive child, it is a wise investment.

You read some right rubbish on MN but this is up there with the best.

Cant be bothered to address it all but a few highlights:

SEND nationally isn't 30%. Most of the kids in my state class on the SEND register get no more support from me than others but toddle off to do something like speech therapy with a TA a few times a week. They are not disruptive, far from it. Apart from a bit too much chatting, I've not dealt with a single instance of poor behaviour since September.

My class has 16 children. The other classes around 20. This was the same at the last school I taught at and we don't anticipate it changing soon. Our budget is fine for this.

I've dealt with children being mean to others. I've genuinely never dealt with an actual case of bullying nor racism. Parent View questionnaires consistently show that parents don't think either bullying or racism is an issue.

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 10/02/2023 12:34

ScrollingLeaves · 10/02/2023 12:29

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · Today 09:02
Not really. Education budgets are set by local authorities, but that is divided up between schools based on how many pupils go there. Decreasing pupil numbers actually means larger classes, less teachers, less resources (because collectively buying resources is cheaper in larger quantities, and resources eg textbooks, non consumable stationery can be shared between multiple classes)

So if a school got £2k per pupil and had 1500 pupils, they would have a budget of 3 million, but if 300 of them went to the private school, they would only have £2.4 million. They might need to cut two teachers out, meaning class sizes increase, and each department has £1000 cut off their budget, so no textbooks, no new pens, no technology.

Decreasing school roles is a big, big issue for schools - whether that is due to a decrease in birth rate, out migration, or people not sending their kids to their local school.

Yes, I can see more children attending a school means a bigger budget for that school.

But the bigger school budget following from taking in the ex-private school pupils,
would be paid for by the state and therefore would be a bigger burden on the state (even given what you are saying about it not just working in a per capita way).

It isn’t as though the ex-private school pupils would be donating their now unused fees to the state school they attend instead.

If what you say is true, what is wrong imo
is the state/council not ploughing that money they save (by pupils going to private instead of state schools) back into the state schools.

It wouldn’t though - a pupil from a more affluent background costs the school less than a pupil from a less affluent background, because the school is required to provide less for them - for example, they wouldn’t get FSM, they would be less likely (statistically speaking) to require intensive input from pupil support/supported study, they would come to school better resourced (eg having their own pens and pencils, they would have access to a laptop so the school wouldn’t need to provide them, they would be able to use Google classroom for homework rather than being given printed resources)

It would be great if the money was ploughed in but realistically, that isn’t going to happen.

ScrollingLeaves · 10/02/2023 12:29

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · Today 09:02
Not really. Education budgets are set by local authorities, but that is divided up between schools based on how many pupils go there. Decreasing pupil numbers actually means larger classes, less teachers, less resources (because collectively buying resources is cheaper in larger quantities, and resources eg textbooks, non consumable stationery can be shared between multiple classes)

So if a school got £2k per pupil and had 1500 pupils, they would have a budget of 3 million, but if 300 of them went to the private school, they would only have £2.4 million. They might need to cut two teachers out, meaning class sizes increase, and each department has £1000 cut off their budget, so no textbooks, no new pens, no technology.

Decreasing school roles is a big, big issue for schools - whether that is due to a decrease in birth rate, out migration, or people not sending their kids to their local school.

Yes, I can see more children attending a school means a bigger budget for that school.

But the bigger school budget following from taking in the ex-private school pupils,
would be paid for by the state and therefore would be a bigger burden on the state (even given what you are saying about it not just working in a per capita way).

It isn’t as though the ex-private school pupils would be donating their now unused fees to the state school they attend instead.

If what you say is true, what is wrong imo
is the state/council not ploughing that money they save (by pupils going to private instead of state schools) back into the state schools.

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 10/02/2023 12:29

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 12:17

I remember a tool like that for England - haven’t seen it for a while. I’ll have a dig to see if it’s still around. Thanks for the reminder! The court of public opinion may not be swayed so easily, however…..

I honestly think these people are throwing money at a problem which doesn’t need to be a problem.

Statistics show that, even in the same school, those from more affluent areas perform better than those from less affluent areas. Poverty isn’t contagious - and nor are bad exam grades. I reckon many of those kids who achieve 5 highers (the equivalent of what you need to get into medical school etc - top A level grades I think) would do so at a private school or a state school - and all sending them to a private school does is make the state school look worse.

KiwiMum2023 · 10/02/2023 12:20

Some ridiculous comments here about state school. There are many poorly performing private schools out there. Choose wisely. I recently saw an ad on FB for a private prep. On closer examination the school has a grand total of 30 pupils. Not where I would send any DC.