Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send my child to private school at age 4?

233 replies

confusedaboutworkingandparenting · 08/02/2023 10:23

Wise Mumsnetters, please talk to me about private school in the UK. Or public school? What is the difference? As you have probably gathered already, DH and I went to comprehensive schools and have no experience of education options in London or the independent school system in the UK. Other children is unlikely to be a factor here so we could probably afford to pay for one to go, although of course it would involve some sacrifices. We have some good private schools nearby to us and none of the "local" state primary schools are actually that convenient, so all options involve a bit of a trek. So talk to me about private school? Is it worth it? Is it really that different to state school? When is the best time to send them? If you could afford it, would you do it? And why? And will I inadvertently turn my beloved child into a posh tw*t?! Also the holidays are so long! What do you do with them then! Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences and wisdom.

OP posts:
user567543 · 10/02/2023 15:31

Mine were the opposite of thriving in state, so I abandoned my admittedly flaky principles because I do not require them to fix this society's problems through being miserable and we were all having an awful time. Funnily enough, I know a teacher who quit because it was having an awful effect on her own child due to her hours.

Schools need reform, the SEN situation is diabolical amongst many other things.

ScrollingLeaves · 10/02/2023 15:30

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · Today 14:15

they are furthering the wealth of the wealthy business owners who run the private schools - who are in the back pocket of our inept government+

What about schools like the GDST schools and other city centre equivalents. These are not run by business owners in the back pocket if our inept government.

I mention those because I happen to know more about them, but there are
many similar where the fees are kept as low as possible and all ploughed back into the school, and buildings and facilities and bursaries.

Futurethoughts · 10/02/2023 15:24

It isn’t an extreme example, it’s exactly what people are demanding those who privately educate their children do. Put them somewhere they’d be worse off in order to benefit the greater good. Most people - saint like as they may proclaim to be - don’t do that. It’s only when deciding what other people should do with their money that they are this generous!

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/02/2023 15:16

Futurethoughts · 10/02/2023 15:02

It’s not being ignored at all, but it isn’t the same thing as what is being discussed. Someone doing something in the line of paid work for someone else is not the same as making an active choice to disadvantage their child in the name of a tenuous benefit to unknown children.

If someone actually tells me they could live in a detached house in Leafy Suburb and actively choose to live on Council Rise because Council Rise has anti social behaviour and their family are good for the demographics, fair enough. But I suspect no one does!

Quite.

The parlous state of state education in this country is a tragedy and it makes me angry. But I have never followed the logic that says I have actively disadvantaged other children by removing my child from state education.

I have chosen to spend money on increasing the odds that my child will get a good education, partly because my child found her state primary overwhelming and difficult and also because the state secondaries in my area are generally not of great quality and I'm not prepared to gamble on them if I don't need to. I'm not sure what purpose is served by my sending an anxious child into a difficult and resource-stretched educational environment when I can afford not to out of some misplaced sense of solidarity. I am not removing resources from other children by sending my child private.

I understand the broader principle that in a truly equitable society all children should get access to a high-quality education. But it is not an equitable society and the reality is that if private schools were abolished overnight wealthy and affluent parents would simply find other ways to try to tilt the playing field in their kids' favour.

Your child only has a certain number of years in education. Using that time to focus on ideological gestures which will have no impact at all either on government policy or on other children and could have a detrimental effect on your child is cutting off your nose to spite your face.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 15:13

I appreciate that you’re having to find increasingly extreme examples to make your point.

I agree that it is hard to draw a hard line when someone’s paid work - as a teacher, a paediatric nurse, a children’s social worker - involves children. By definition, they will often be putting other people’s children first, and it is hard to say when that is genuinely job related and when above and beyond.

Perhaps the initial statement that only mad people don’t put their own children first might need a little modification, rather than deciding how others interpret that bald statement is ‘wrong’?

Futurethoughts · 10/02/2023 15:02

It’s not being ignored at all, but it isn’t the same thing as what is being discussed. Someone doing something in the line of paid work for someone else is not the same as making an active choice to disadvantage their child in the name of a tenuous benefit to unknown children.

If someone actually tells me they could live in a detached house in Leafy Suburb and actively choose to live on Council Rise because Council Rise has anti social behaviour and their family are good for the demographics, fair enough. But I suspect no one does!

Scooby5kids · 10/02/2023 14:55

Some of the posters moaning about the special needs kids in the classes. Wow! Clearly speaking from a place of snobbery and privilege that you were blessed with kids without SEN. Where do you all expect for these kids to go then? You do realise that going to a special school is not an option for all SEN kids right? Not all kids are granted EHCP. Some kids with autism and ADHD are actually academically on par with their piers and going to a special school wouldn't be withholding them from the education that they deserve. Instead of looking at it that SEN kids are inconvenience, maybe be mad with the government for lack of funding for more teaching assistants in the class room!

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 14:52

Futurethoughts · 10/02/2023 14:43

Yes, you do nice things for the benefit of others. So do I. So do most people.

But that is very different to doing things that would put your own child at a disadvantage, or make them less happy than they could be.

Three teachers here have said that they actively do things for other children that make their own children less happy, through having much less of their time and attention than they should have. I think you are choosing to ignore this, partly because it has no ‘monetary value’ .

Mumsanetta · 10/02/2023 14:48

I think pp have already covered most things but I would say that sending your child at 4 vs older if you can afford it has its advantages - the 4+ is a lot less pressurised than 7+ or 11+!

Scooby5kids · 10/02/2023 14:46

If I had the money I definitely would. Unfortunately not an option for us but I can completely understand why people do

Futurethoughts · 10/02/2023 14:43

Yes, you do nice things for the benefit of others. So do I. So do most people.

But that is very different to doing things that would put your own child at a disadvantage, or make them less happy than they could be.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 14:43

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 14:29

Presumably they’re doing those things because they want to continue getting paid in order to support said children. Same as many are striking for better pay.

Either way, I’m not sure placing your own child as a lesser priority is unquestionably something that should be aspired to.

In Scotland, a teacher is employed for 35 hours per week and nobody can stop paying you for doing any less than that. Yet here we are, doing significantly more than that, to benefit the children in our classes, at the detriment of our own children.

prescribingmum · 10/02/2023 14:41

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 14:15

That previous poster was actually me.

And the influential parents who send their kids to state schools ARE the ones speaking up for other children. They are the ones who join the PTA, who are involved in fundraisers, who contact the local papers to raise local issues, and so on.

And obviously it’s the governments faults. But by opting out of the state system, they are letting the government get away with it, and also by paying into private schools, they are furthering the wealth of the wealthy business owners who run the private schools - who are in the back pocket of our inept government.

No, by opting out of the state system, I am simply giving my children the education they need. I still support state schools, write to my MP regarding the shocking conditions and support teachers striking. But I will not do things to the detriment of my children's education.

Contrary to MN opinion, all private schools are not super wealthy schools where children gain contacts that make them a MP/CEO. The overwhelming majority are simply there to provide a good education and these are the ones that are affordable to the professionals rather than ultra rich. My children attend a small, local prep school that has a focus on holistic care. The fees are a tiny fraction of the likes of Harrow/Eton/Westminster/Winchester. There are no huge funds going into a wealthy business owner (just about manage to keep the school running) and fellow parents tend to be educated professionals such as doctors, lawyers, accountants, owners of small local businesses.

Levelling up is the government's responsibility. I most certainly support it and believe all children should be given a good chance but its a bit much to expect parents not to put their own children first.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 14:40

Futurethoughts · 10/02/2023 13:56

@CherLloydbyCherLloyd , are you telling me that you give a significant share of your income - enough that you actually have to go without things that you don’t need, but would make life easier - to children’s charities? Are you working full time, perhaps even an extra job, regardless of what is best for your family or your health, in order to donate to these charities?

Because whilst altruism is a good thing to do, there also comes a point where it is a bit stupid. Not sending my child to the best school for them would have a marginal, if any, positive impact on the other children there. It would have the biggest impact on my own child and I won’t ever apologise for putting them first. Any parent who doesn’t put their own child before others is barking mad, to be honest.

I’m a teacher working up to double the hours I am paid for in order to give my pupils (in a state school) the best access to education I possibly can; meaning my own daughter often misses out, yes. I also volunteer in a charity for disadvantaged children for one evening a week, plus several days during school holidays.

Id rather be barking mad than selfish but I guess we can all have our own values - one of mine is equity.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 14:38

I would agree that neglecting your own children / family because of the needs of others - probably common across caring professions such as nurses in addition to teachers - is not unquestionably a good thing.

What do you think should be done about it, while the demands are there and the working conditions and decimation of other services mean there are few options?

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 14:34

Presumably they’re doing those things because they want to continue getting paid in order to support said children.

No. Worrying about the safety of a child in your class overnight, spending hours seeking out resources to support a child with SEN, multiple meetings with parents and agencies to try to resolve issues - none of these are ‘the core job’ of the teacher, but are done because teachers as a group care about the children they teach.

The 96 books are, but they would be done at slightly less unsocial hours if all of those ‘above and beyond’ factors weren’t involved.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 14:30

The original point made was that only mad people didn’t always put their own children first (no condition made about ‘in terms of how money is spent).

Teachers don’t always put the needs of their own children first.

whumpthereitis · 10/02/2023 14:29

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 14:18

Future, it’s interesting that all of your examples are around money.

Where teachers put the needs of their pupils above those of their own children is time and brain space and attention - no, I can’t play, I’m planning for child X; no, I’m not really ‘present’, I’m worrying about child Y; no, I’ve got to be late home tonight / will miss your concert/ will put you in childcare until late because I’m trying to meet the needs of my class and I have meetings with parents and specialists; no, we’re not going to place A, we’re going to place B because I need to do the pre-visit for a school trip; no, I can’t read with you because I have 96 books to mark for tomorrow….

Presumably they’re doing those things because they want to continue getting paid in order to support said children. Same as many are striking for better pay.

Either way, I’m not sure placing your own child as a lesser priority is unquestionably something that should be aspired to.

Futurethoughts · 10/02/2023 14:27

it’s interesting that all of your examples are around money.

Because private schools are about money, or more specifically, what money can buy. People who have a dogmatic view that is against private schools, regardless of individual circumstance or need, are against them because the argument generally amounts to not wanting money to be able to buy advantages in life over and above those who do not have it.

A teacher telling their own child ‘not now, I am marking’ doesn’t really have anything to do with that particular argument.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 14:18

Future, it’s interesting that all of your examples are around money.

Where teachers put the needs of their pupils above those of their own children is time and brain space and attention - no, I can’t play, I’m planning for child X; no, I’m not really ‘present’, I’m worrying about child Y; no, I’ve got to be late home tonight / will miss your concert/ will put you in childcare until late because I’m trying to meet the needs of my class and I have meetings with parents and specialists; no, we’re not going to place A, we’re going to place B because I need to do the pre-visit for a school trip; no, I can’t read with you because I have 96 books to mark for tomorrow….

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/02/2023 14:15

morechocolateneededtoday · 10/02/2023 13:46

I think you are directing your anger at the wrong person here.
The average class in a state school has 30 children - so 30 sets of parents. Are they all unable to speak up for themselves? PP has pointed out they have encountered lots of children from influential families in state schools whose parents believe that state is the way to educate. Why are they not being attacked for their lack of support towards fellow parents?

Most of all, the fault lies at the government's door. If state schools were appropriately funded, far fewer would feel the need to consider private education. This is where the ultimate problem lies. Pitting private school parents as nasty is just another way of them achieving the divide and conquer whilst deflecting the attention from their spectacular failures

That previous poster was actually me.

And the influential parents who send their kids to state schools ARE the ones speaking up for other children. They are the ones who join the PTA, who are involved in fundraisers, who contact the local papers to raise local issues, and so on.

And obviously it’s the governments faults. But by opting out of the state system, they are letting the government get away with it, and also by paying into private schools, they are furthering the wealth of the wealthy business owners who run the private schools - who are in the back pocket of our inept government.

Futurethoughts · 10/02/2023 14:07

So they never take their own children on days out or have family holidays? That money is given to the school or charity?

They live in the cheapest house possible, with the money they’ve saved donated elsewhere?

Christmas and birthdays are shunned in favour of charitable giving?

I’m obviously being a bit facetious there but a lot of this ‘well, of course I would sacrifice this and that for my children to enable all children to access a good education’ doesn’t stack up.

cantkeepawayforever · 10/02/2023 14:03

Any parent who doesn’t put their own child before others is barking mad, to be honest.

I find this quite ironic in the context of the current teachers’ strikes - I know no teacher who doesn’t often put the needs of the children in their school above the needs of their own children.

Futurethoughts · 10/02/2023 13:56

@CherLloydbyCherLloyd , are you telling me that you give a significant share of your income - enough that you actually have to go without things that you don’t need, but would make life easier - to children’s charities? Are you working full time, perhaps even an extra job, regardless of what is best for your family or your health, in order to donate to these charities?

Because whilst altruism is a good thing to do, there also comes a point where it is a bit stupid. Not sending my child to the best school for them would have a marginal, if any, positive impact on the other children there. It would have the biggest impact on my own child and I won’t ever apologise for putting them first. Any parent who doesn’t put their own child before others is barking mad, to be honest.

ScrollingLeaves · 10/02/2023 13:55

*CherLloydbyCherLloyd · Today 13:23
The fact you don’t feel sad about all children not getting a fair crack at a good education speaks volumes about your core values

All children should have a fair crack at a good education.

If you closed down private schools tomorrow it wouldn’t mean more children would have a fair crack though would it?

It would just mean more children get a not very good education.

But the richer parents would get a lot of tutoring in anyway.

The idea is that the formerly privately educating parents would scream at the government to change schools for the better and find them, but in practice that takes generations to work.

Disadvantaged children should be getting top quality free private style nearly one to one education and good nutrition from age 2 too as a start. When is this ever mentioned?

Then there are the ideologies to contend with ( nothing to do with money) such as using a fountain pen and hand writing is elitist; learning Shakespeare is not de-colonising enough etc