Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If your dc was described as 'spacey' 'away with the fairies' 'daydreamer' and it wasn't ASD then what was it?

144 replies

PaulHeymanHairline · 08/02/2023 09:08

Basically I'm looking at the most recent criteria for ASD diagnosis and I'm not sure my dd fits anymore. I'm not too bothered as she seems to have caught up in school more or less but I'm still concerned as her teachers say she's very much 'not present' during the majority of her lessons.
ASD was first raised when she was 2 and I suppose I've always thought of her in this context, she didn't have a diagnosis but her nursery made special care plans around her sensory needs and anxiety. I didn't mention to them that the health visitors had mentioned it but they independently raised it with me.
The school have been great but even they disagree amongst themselves whether it is ASD or ADD or some other sensory processing thing.
I just wondered if it could be personality. Has anyone else had a similar type of child who hasn't received a diagnosis? And if so then did they grow out of it and become more present or do they continue to live in a sort of half day dreamy state of semi reality.
I have a lot of empathy for my DD as I also spend my time with a sort of internal story playing in my head. I am very creative and think sort of visual images and narratives for things rather than rational plans. I genuinely thought everyone's mind was like this until recently. I am not ASD and I can focus if I need to, it takes a lot of concentration. If I have to do something with numbers or dates I have to work up to it and break it up and I will get 50% of the numbers wrong. Luckily I don't have to di this in my job!

OP posts:
weaselwords · 09/02/2023 08:43

Low end of normal dyspraxic dyslexia, so could cope with mainstream school but was unhappy and picked at by teachers as was slow producing work and daydreamy. I also suspect some autistic traits but not full ASD and is now a very happy and successful adult who earns more than me in tech.

Craftycorvid · 09/02/2023 08:36

Me also. I think I might have felt sceptical about ‘labels’ some years back, and the wrong label can be highly damaging. It’s worth stating that undiagnosed ASD and ADHD will most likely accrue the person a crop of delightful ‘labels’ through their lifespan - lazy, difficult, manipulative etc. If you have a happy child who is imaginative but also has no particular problems with learning or sensory processing, who has friends and seems confident, then seeking diagnosis is perhaps not necessary. If, however, you have a journey like mine: lived in my head, labelled as ‘in a world of my own’, found other kids bewildering creatures, was badly bullied, am most likely dyscalculic and bombed out of school with no qualifications and a label of being antisocial and unemployable - possibly some additional help and some curiosity about those difficulties would have helped. That knowledge wasn’t available when I was a child and I’m extremely glad it is there for youngsters now, so that hopefully fewer children have my journey in future. If it means a lot more ‘labels’ and terminology, as long as that also means understanding and support, that’s a good thing. I am not diagnosed with anything; my understanding of my problems has been informed by the growing amount of information available nowadays, and through working with women who are autistic and having multiple ‘aha’ moments.

Zaliea · 09/02/2023 08:35

I don't have any diagnosis. I just felt happier inside my own head. I enjoy my own thoughts and daydreams. I don't think that has to be cause for something being "wrong" or "abnormal". Not everyone is the same. I tend to feel a bit sorry for people who don't have an active inner world.

Greenfairydust · 09/02/2023 08:31

What is the school like? could it be that some of the teaching is really poor and/or that there are a lot of issues with classroom discipline so your child is withdrawing because of that and could be bored because of the lack of stimulation?

If it is a good school as other have said autism might be something to look into.

But some people simply learn differently and might have other talents (such as being creative) than the traditional academic type.

I was very much like that as a child and teen. Very quiet but with really good imagination and creativity. Many schools are really quite rigid and not geared towards people who simply have different personalities.

Maybe see what activities outside school she could thrive in and that might give you a clue of what is going on.

JFDIYOLO · 09/02/2023 08:20

That was me. Always in my own world, nose in a book, fantasy and SF more real to me than the real world. At 11 I went to secondary school - and it was discovered I'm extremely short sighted. Fine without glasses close up but a blur four feet away.

PS - I'm an (unknown) actor. Just saying, being a bit away with the fairies can be an actual job.

Fireingrate · 09/02/2023 08:19

FourTeaFallOut · 08/02/2023 09:29

This is me. I can't tell you how often I walk on autopilot and feel surprised when I hit my destination, the walking was entirely secondary to whatever I was daydreaming about. I daydream any time that I don't feel compelled to engage completely with whatever is going on.

There are upsides. I never get bored, as in -never. There is no wait so long, journey so far or task so monotonous that cannot be negated by daydreaming.

This is me!

Joshitai · 09/02/2023 08:18

To add on while I have ASD and ADHD + mild dyslexia,

My elder DD has ASD and severe dyslexia- she wasn’t seen as academically gifted because of her struggle to learn to read, and then of course by year 3 you are reading to learn. So she was below average until I got fed up waiting for the school to admit she had dyslexia (hers isn’t “classic” either), and went private which came with a list of accommodations the school had to do that actually worked for her. She went from below average to going to one of the top 10 Unis in the World, and #1 Uni in the U.K.

So you don’t know whether your DD is gifted or not. You won’t until you tangle whether she has SEN holding her back. Then you’ll have to fight the schools every year to keep her accommodations.

alldaysleeper · 09/02/2023 08:16

Both DH and myself, but more DH as he was diagnosed earlier were described as this as children/teens and we both have epilepsy.

louise5754 · 09/02/2023 08:12

Those with Dyspraxia / kids with it. I'm diagnosed with it together with other things and I can't tell what's what. What are the things you struggle with? I know a lot overlap autism too though. Thank you.

Joshitai · 09/02/2023 08:11

PaulHeymanHairline · 09/02/2023 05:38

Just to clarify, she is not gifted academically (sorry DD) and struggles to focus even long enough to work out the answer for most maths questions. She can read but only bright, loud fonts, even if the subject of the book is one she enjoys or is passionate about, she can barely make it through one page. In writing she is so eager to get what she wants to write down that there are loads of mistakes, but not, her teacher says, the classic ones which would signify dyslexia.

I would still get her assessed for dyslexia as it is a spectrum all of its own with different presentations. The only similarity is the learning disability to encode from thought to writing and decode from writing to thought. Don’t take a teachers word as gospel, have a professional assess her.

louise5754 · 09/02/2023 08:09

Dd had Autism / ADHD assessments.

She was just diagnosed with dyslexia. She used to see "people" dancing around the board / screen when the teacher was talking.

I'm Autistic Dyslexic and Dyspraxic

Stompythedinosaur · 09/02/2023 08:06

ADHD or trauma.

Rabblemum · 09/02/2023 07:47

Could be ADHD or is there any trama?

I have ADHD and I had a lot of trama as a child. I spaced out because I wanted good grades but unless I found a lesson really interesting and connected with the teacher I checked out.

In high school I got rebellious and simply walked out of class.

I developed a "loud" personality because of my impulse brain but as a small child I was away with the faries.

I recommend a test. While uou wait try fresh air and exercise. If I get some energy out it's easier to concentrate and sleep. Being still is often uncomfortable for me.Help you child get organised but follow her lead, ADHD people do things their own way, be patient and show love.

You seem to concentrate on grades but also look at her social skills. Girls can be mean to anyone different. Chat about friendships ans teach basic social skills without trying to change her.

Also get therapy, a stressful environment makes things worse and you are a lot of her environment.

I really regret not getting meds until my 40s, I could have had a lot more in life.

On the bright side your daughter is probably sensitive and creative.

Donotgogentle · 09/02/2023 07:28

MadEyeWheezy · 08/02/2023 09:52

As long as she is coping well she doesn't need a diagnosis but as you get older the cracks will show and then a diagnosis, a label, is invaluable for several reasons:

  1. Medication (if it is ADHD. For most people this is the first line of treatment and probably the only really effective one)
  2. Accommodations in school
  3. Knowing that your issues are not a moral failing and Understanding yourself: I thought my whole life I was lazy, stupid and crazy (as did everyone else too). I was diagnosed in my thirties with ADHD but it has led to a lifetime of low self esteem. I still can't shake the feeling that I'm just lazy, crazy and stupid.
  4. Once you know what you are dealing with you can find tricks and strategies to help you out in daily life. People with ADHD do better under certain circumstances. Once you know it's ADHD you are more likely to accept that you need to create these circumstances rather than just trying harder and failing.
  5. If I had known I had ADHD as a child and that the symptoms are something I can't will myself out or overcome by trying harder I would have picked a different job, something that doesn't rely solely on self motivation.

I realise this is a very ADHD centric reply but that is what I have experience of. I don't know if it is different for other disorders but yes, a label can be invaluable!!

This is a really helpful explanation.

Vanillazebra · 09/02/2023 05:56

I have a child like this who has adhd dysgraphia and is also gifted. I wouldn’t have known about the giftedness without a diagnosis

PaulHeymanHairline · 09/02/2023 05:38

She is 8.

OP posts:
PaulHeymanHairline · 09/02/2023 05:38

Just to clarify, she is not gifted academically (sorry DD) and struggles to focus even long enough to work out the answer for most maths questions. She can read but only bright, loud fonts, even if the subject of the book is one she enjoys or is passionate about, she can barely make it through one page. In writing she is so eager to get what she wants to write down that there are loads of mistakes, but not, her teacher says, the classic ones which would signify dyslexia.

OP posts:
PomPomChatton · 09/02/2023 05:33

Very bright girls can present with traits similar to ASD. Could it be that she isn't distracted, rather she is focused on something that is more interesting to her, such as her own thoughts/ideas?

DahliaRose3 · 09/02/2023 05:21

That’s pretty rude. It’s because constantly daydreaming is not conducive to getting things done as you need to concentrate in class. It may well be normal though…but it may well not be.

I was diagnosed with inattentive ADHD as an adult and didn’t have huge issues at school. Looking back I can see why I struggled with exams even though I was getting high grades on assignments (retention issues). Daydreaming, constant chatting, makes silly mistakes - all adhd related. As a mature Uni student, it was a slap in the face - taking 5x longer than my peers to get assignments done and more….

As an adult it really affected me in my relationships, my ability to regulate my emotions, manage anxiety (even realising I had it), and understanding myself.

In my first corporate role (I needed additional support - a checklist if you can believe it as I was struggling to do my job due to retention issues). I nearly lost my job, once I had a checklist I excelled.

So yes, to you it may be just a label etc but to someone else it can mean accommodations, and having self awareness to help manage stress, emotions, and navigate life.

Joshitai · 09/02/2023 05:09

PaulHeymanHairline · 08/02/2023 09:08

Basically I'm looking at the most recent criteria for ASD diagnosis and I'm not sure my dd fits anymore. I'm not too bothered as she seems to have caught up in school more or less but I'm still concerned as her teachers say she's very much 'not present' during the majority of her lessons.
ASD was first raised when she was 2 and I suppose I've always thought of her in this context, she didn't have a diagnosis but her nursery made special care plans around her sensory needs and anxiety. I didn't mention to them that the health visitors had mentioned it but they independently raised it with me.
The school have been great but even they disagree amongst themselves whether it is ASD or ADD or some other sensory processing thing.
I just wondered if it could be personality. Has anyone else had a similar type of child who hasn't received a diagnosis? And if so then did they grow out of it and become more present or do they continue to live in a sort of half day dreamy state of semi reality.
I have a lot of empathy for my DD as I also spend my time with a sort of internal story playing in my head. I am very creative and think sort of visual images and narratives for things rather than rational plans. I genuinely thought everyone's mind was like this until recently. I am not ASD and I can focus if I need to, it takes a lot of concentration. If I have to do something with numbers or dates I have to work up to it and break it up and I will get 50% of the numbers wrong. Luckily I don't have to di this in my job!

I have ASD and ADHD and that was most of my childhood. I never “grew” out of it, the nature of my distractions changed.

Lemme · 09/02/2023 05:01

It’s not a label, it’s a diagnosis. Why are people so rude? Diagnosis can make a massive difference to treatment, access to benefits, obligations that schools have to deliver a learning style that helps the child to learn, inform parenting strategies, quite apart from helping one cope with one’s own self through a better understanding of why one struggles in certain areas.

OP - I also think inattentive ADHD. Perhaps autism or deafness. Speak to her teachers, get her on the CAHMS waiting list, wait times for assessment can unfortunately take 24 months.

Itisbetter · 09/02/2023 04:42

High IQ

greenspaces4peace · 09/02/2023 04:29

@MyopicBunny
only 14% of children with ADHD have ASD.
however 70% of children with ASD also have ADHD.
so it’s not that uncommon to only have ADHD.

TitaniaTheBold · 09/02/2023 04:25

Sounds like ADHD to me (both my dc have it although they are both autistic too). At a guess I would say you also have ADHD, look up hyperfocus re, ADHD, means you can focus when you need to but at a cost (ie you will be exhausted afterwards).

@MyopicBunny - I know they are co-morbid conditions but I don't think that your statement is true It's quite unusual to have ADHD and not also be on the spectrum - maybe you meant have some autistic traits - which is a completely different thing?

I would say the reverse is possibly more of the reality, that many people with ASC have ADHD. I think it is very common to have ADHD and not be autistic (which is what being on ' the spectrum' means). Possibly the most damaging word ever associated with a condition, it implies you can be a little bit autistic or VERY autistic which is bollocks, you are either autistic or you are not. How it affects the individual and their ability to cope with every day life obviously varies enormously. BTW - none of that is a dig at you personally MyopicBunny just the view of a worn down parent of 'high functioning' - bloody awful term - dc who people see are 'hardly' autistic - because dc mask well enough in public to cover up the sensory struggles, meltdowns, enormous levels of anxiety etc that come out when they feel 'safe' to let the mask drop.

Valhalla17 · 09/02/2023 03:40

I would just assume she's probably a dreamy pisces like me 😊