Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of my grandmother and all her money

409 replies

TetherEndOfMy · 08/02/2023 08:42

Went to see my grandmother last night. She's in her mid 80s and constantly talks about how much money she has. I am a lone parent struggling to pay my bills and childcare. Every time I see her she asks 'how are you coping with paying bills?' and talks about how awful the cost of living crisis is for people like me. I never raise the topic of money. Last night she then continued on to talk about the two houses she needs to sell which will hopefully see £600k into her savings, and was talking about 200k she had 'lying around' and needed to put into some kind of investment. She then went on to ask me about which charities I 'recommend' she donates to when she dies as she wants to give most of her money away. Today I have phoned to tell her I'm busy and can't drop her shopping round as I feel like she is taunting me. I DO NOT expect her to give me money, I just hate the way she is so tone deaf. She's completely switched on at 84 years old and seems to think I'm some poor hopeless person. Anyway. I just needed to get that off my chest as I am facing having a pre payment meter fitted and am struggling not to cry into my Cereal.

OP posts:
Scarriff · 09/02/2023 17:58

I'm in favour of the honest conversation. Short and direct. Say you are unable to listen any more to her conversations about money. You are struggling as she knows and they are upsetting you. She mustn't mention any investments charities or any other financial planning if she wants you to continue to visit. In my experience some people can't hear how they sound to others. If you decide to be direct prepare to leave immediately, saying you will give her some peace to think over what you said. If she feels she can agree, to let you know, but you won't be having any argument.

The point about carers allowance is a good one.

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 09/02/2023 17:00

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 08/02/2023 09:04

Just tell her you think it is extremely vulgar to brag about money, and extremely impertinent to ask someone else about their own financial situation. Disapprove of her. She won't know what to do with that.

I agree wholeheartedly with this.

9outof10cats · 09/02/2023 16:45

It is up to your gran what she does with her money. However, I find her attitude rather strange and incredibly selfish. I could never sit by and watch a family member struggle if I had the financial means to help them.

Fair enough if she was modest about her wealth, but to keep discussing money in front of you, knowing you are struggling, is incredibly insensitive.

I would stop doing her shopping for her; she can afford to pay someone to do it.

I would tell her you can no longer help her out as you cannot afford the petrol to visit her, or something similar.

danblack87 · 09/02/2023 16:34

I love my 84 year old father and I visit and help him because I wish to -- I am not interested in what money he has and I do not know what is in his Will or how much his house is worth - just simply I love my father and if he left me nothing he will have left me memories and time spent together, I do not like this post ... no-one, not anybody is ENTITLED. The choice is of the person that you love.

GasPanic · 09/02/2023 16:31

She's being cruel.

I would lay it on the line. Tell her you are really stuggling and that you are going to have to spend more time working/earning.

If she is happy to see you struggle and make your own way without her help, then she needs to understand that means you will have less time for her.

If she shes that as you being "grabby" and decides to cut you off, what have you lost ? Zero contact with someone who constantly throws their wealth in your face sounds good to me.

danblack87 · 09/02/2023 16:16

My feeling is that she is testing you to see if you are around to help her, be kind to her, visit because you wish to do so and not for any monetary gain. If she thinks you are visiting her only for monetary gain then she will cut you off. Some people are like that ... they want to feel loved and valued.

earsup · 09/02/2023 15:32

I think this is about some sort of control issue...my late GM [ mums side ]..was wealthy, owned about 7 houses let out, but very low rents then, and made comments about my sister only being able to afford a small flat when she got married. Ultimately, the church was left 30k, me and my sister £100 each and the rest of the cash to my mum, only one property was left by then so mum also inherited that...Ironically the biggest winner was HMRC with the inhertiance tax bill...!!...Mum distributed out the cash fairly so we could use the money as deposits for houses. GM gave one house to my mum when she got married but kept it in her name so that also was hit for the tax as part of her estate...madness !!

Restinggoddess · 09/02/2023 15:20

I think in a bizarre way older relatives think their experiences apply to your life / life in 2023. They will have had times of hardship over the years ( the 1950s and 70s were a challenge) - some of them believe if you do as they did then all will come good ie they don’t need to help
I agree with the other posts - call her out on this / reality check. The result may surprise you ( or confirm your concerns)

I would also suggest she gets some advice re her money otherwise the tax man will be doing really well, based on these figures! It would be interesting to see what she thinks to that

SleeplessInEngland · 09/02/2023 14:58

Just stop seeing her. Don't be a martyr.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 09/02/2023 14:56

Moveoverdarlin · 09/02/2023 08:58

Don’t get on the wrong side of her. Bite your tongue. I had a relative who said for the last 20years that she was leaving everything to the dogs home. She didn’t, she was very generous to family. She’s testing you. Play the game, don’t ask for a loan or handouts but next time she’s talking about the cost of living say ‘I’ve just put £80 in the car for fuel, electricity was £460 this month, and ooh Granny, do you know that Clark’s school shoes are now £50? Oh it’s terrible granny.’ If you help her out with shopping, she come good in the end.

There's no guarantee of this. I'd say do what's best for you & your family now.

Ineedaduvetday · 09/02/2023 14:50

KatherineJaneway · 08/02/2023 10:05

Is she trying to punish you for a choice you've made she disagreed with i.e. a career decision you made etc?

OP? @TetherEndOfMy

Good question

gumball37 · 09/02/2023 13:37

So how did she earn her money?

Bearlady · 09/02/2023 12:56

I have had this issue my parents obsessed over saving money. They stinted themselves and others I found it weird. They actually had a lot but couldn't seem to see it. They knew I was struggling when I had to move far away with no job/childcare which I used to have. I once asked for a bit of help even before I left and was offered a fiver. When I said don't worry they took it back. I knew they didn't care and got very tired of hearing how poor they were. They would gladly tell people that too but I was the one who really was. Apparently they kept saving for nursing home fees which I understood. In the end they never made it there and passed away. Very sad as they weren't able to enjoy what they could have.

speakout · 09/02/2023 09:25

I wouldn't ask her for money- that would leave you indebted to her and on the back foor.
I would be cutting contact though- and certainly wouldn't be doing her shopping.
If she has money then she can pay someone to do her shopping or order online.

Aleaiactaest · 09/02/2023 09:16

Some old people are not very nice, some young people are also not very nice.

I have seen this kind of thing happen before. Old rich person actually looks down on younger, poorer person and considers her less and considers that lesser person should look after them, because they are lesser. If that is the case I would cut ties gradually and just say you are having lots of money struggles and need to work overtime. I have also seen rich people leave all their money to another rich and successful person in the family, rather than those who would have needed it. Because they respect the rich person in the family more.

Even if she is just playing games OP to test you, it is cruel. Neither of my grandmothers would have done this. The opposite would have been the case, they would have given me everything they could if I were struggling as a single mum. That is what a kind grandmother who has empathy would do.

I would speak openly to her about all of this and how her behaviour hurts you and undermines your confidence and how you have to be strong for your children.

Eleganz · 09/02/2023 09:03

ilovesushi · 09/02/2023 08:58

Oh yes! There are times I have sent him round to their house and got him to practically frog march them to a cash point. But of course then I look like the baddy. He doesn't get it at all. He has complete faith that they will pay up eventually, whereas I don't think I should have pay anything if it is their gift and their offer. When DS joined scouts I was going to buy the shirt and nothing else but the in laws insisted they would pay for the whole kit - fancy belt, leather woggle, trousers, new necker everything. The whole reason I was only getting the shirt was it was all I could afford. I kept asking for the money in advance, didn't get it, naively went ahead and got the whole kit and never saw the money. I think I made DH pay me back in the end. That wasn't the biggest purchase but it was the last. Now I just say no thanks no thanks on repeat. If they really wanted to they could just go and buy it themselves.

Sounds like you've got a bit of a DH problem there as well.

Nutmegger · 09/02/2023 09:01

Every time she brings up her money give her an analysis about why she has lots of money and why you don't. Generally the rich person has been luckier . If this is the case she needs to be reminded of this all the time

TrudyProud · 09/02/2023 09:01

@TetherEndOfMy why do you feel guilty for stopping seeing you when she has no qualm watching you and your DC struggling.
Personally, id remind her charity starts at home. If she doesn't want to help you she can set up educational trusts for the grandkids or for housing.

Tbf I'm petty. If I was struggling I'd stop visiting her . If she misses me and the kids she can pay for our time given she wants to spend money on herself so badly. She sounds like a crank and if she's lonely it's get own doing.

BeginningToLookALotLike · 09/02/2023 08:59

Sounds like a lot of money has come her way simply from owning two properties - does she rent them out? She can't have it both ways, either she helps you out financially or she hires someone to do all her shopping, etc, for her. She is being cheap.

Moveoverdarlin · 09/02/2023 08:58

Don’t get on the wrong side of her. Bite your tongue. I had a relative who said for the last 20years that she was leaving everything to the dogs home. She didn’t, she was very generous to family. She’s testing you. Play the game, don’t ask for a loan or handouts but next time she’s talking about the cost of living say ‘I’ve just put £80 in the car for fuel, electricity was £460 this month, and ooh Granny, do you know that Clark’s school shoes are now £50? Oh it’s terrible granny.’ If you help her out with shopping, she come good in the end.

ilovesushi · 09/02/2023 08:58

I was replying to @Eleganz in case that was confusing! 😅

ilovesushi · 09/02/2023 08:58

Oh yes! There are times I have sent him round to their house and got him to practically frog march them to a cash point. But of course then I look like the baddy. He doesn't get it at all. He has complete faith that they will pay up eventually, whereas I don't think I should have pay anything if it is their gift and their offer. When DS joined scouts I was going to buy the shirt and nothing else but the in laws insisted they would pay for the whole kit - fancy belt, leather woggle, trousers, new necker everything. The whole reason I was only getting the shirt was it was all I could afford. I kept asking for the money in advance, didn't get it, naively went ahead and got the whole kit and never saw the money. I think I made DH pay me back in the end. That wasn't the biggest purchase but it was the last. Now I just say no thanks no thanks on repeat. If they really wanted to they could just go and buy it themselves.

Kendodd · 09/02/2023 08:57

Tell her you can't come see her/do jobs for her anymore because you've had to get a second job. Tell her your working for a lovely old lady doing her shopping and helping her out and how much this woman appreciates her and pays her really well.

Eleganz · 09/02/2023 08:56

OP, if she is rich then she can pay a carer to get her shopping and run around after you. If she wants to taunt you about her wealth why are you allowing her to exploit you for some free labour.

Perhaps not cut her off but just do visits and not chores.

Sadly I've also experienced older female relatives being nasty with me too. I had a great aunty (now dead) who had some pretty fixed views about marriage and was clearly unimpressed that I had both got divorced (after ex cheated on me) and the did not get married again before having children with my partner. She would generally make snide comments and also referred to her money on occasions (which was actually mostly her husband's private pension). I can be a pretty blunt person and when it got too much once just said "I neither asked for or need your opinion on my life" which prompted a bit of awkward silence and less nastiness to me afterwards although I think my mum just ended up getting it more in the neck as a result sadly.

My view though is life is too short to surround yourself with people who make you feel shit about yourself.

Eleganz · 09/02/2023 08:49

ilovesushi · 09/02/2023 08:45

@Japril my in laws do this. Make some generous offer but always in front of the kids and DH. DH will do this effusive excessive thanking them, tell the kids to thank them then I am expected to buy the thing with my money and the money will never materialise or only after lots of blunt asking and I'm out of pocket. They do it with Christmas presents and birthday presents. I have stopped now as its such a pattern and it stretches me financially. They just love getting all the thanks and praise but can't follow through with the purchase. It's like it's paid off for them they got what they wanted, so why bother actually doing what they were thanked for. My blood actually boils when DH asks if I thanked his parents for something when all they did is make the offer and I paid. Feel annoyed just writing about it!

Are you clear with your husband that they never pay up?