Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of my grandmother and all her money

409 replies

TetherEndOfMy · 08/02/2023 08:42

Went to see my grandmother last night. She's in her mid 80s and constantly talks about how much money she has. I am a lone parent struggling to pay my bills and childcare. Every time I see her she asks 'how are you coping with paying bills?' and talks about how awful the cost of living crisis is for people like me. I never raise the topic of money. Last night she then continued on to talk about the two houses she needs to sell which will hopefully see £600k into her savings, and was talking about 200k she had 'lying around' and needed to put into some kind of investment. She then went on to ask me about which charities I 'recommend' she donates to when she dies as she wants to give most of her money away. Today I have phoned to tell her I'm busy and can't drop her shopping round as I feel like she is taunting me. I DO NOT expect her to give me money, I just hate the way she is so tone deaf. She's completely switched on at 84 years old and seems to think I'm some poor hopeless person. Anyway. I just needed to get that off my chest as I am facing having a pre payment meter fitted and am struggling not to cry into my Cereal.

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 08/02/2023 12:25

TheSilveryPussycat · 08/02/2023 12:17

She should start giving some of it away asap, after taking professional advice on Inheritance Tax Planning. Otherwise the tax man will take a big chunk when she dies, 40% of anything over the Inheritance Tax Threshold.

We had to explain this to my DF, it was awkward, but he did start passing some of it on, and lived more than 7 years after the gifts.

What do your GM's offspring think? They should be the ones approaching her about this.

Given her age and possible health problems she would need to be very careful about giving anything away. Should she need full time care, social services may view this as deprivation of assets to avoid care home fees and in some cases they may press for gifts to be repaid.

Eightiesgirl · 08/02/2023 12:20

@Untitledsquatboulder because he's 94 and we are the only family he has. Before my husband became ill he looked after him but now he can't and its just fallen on me. I've been brought up to look after family, its just in me. I've told him I'll arrange a cleaner for him as I can't do it anymore, I have my own health issues, but he's too tight to pay anyone. I actually will end up walking away from all the responsibility of him and, as a previous poster suggested, get him a social care assessment but he'll have an absolute fit.

smileladiesplease · 08/02/2023 12:18

How horrible she sounds op. Normal people would love to help their children snd grandchildren. Agree stop doing things for her tell her you had to up your hours

TheSilveryPussycat · 08/02/2023 12:17

She should start giving some of it away asap, after taking professional advice on Inheritance Tax Planning. Otherwise the tax man will take a big chunk when she dies, 40% of anything over the Inheritance Tax Threshold.

We had to explain this to my DF, it was awkward, but he did start passing some of it on, and lived more than 7 years after the gifts.

What do your GM's offspring think? They should be the ones approaching her about this.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/02/2023 12:17

Blessedwithsunshine · 08/02/2023 12:14

Or does the gran suspect op has her eye on a big inheritance and is there to benefit herself only ?
ie good digger or pretending to care when she doesn’t etc. Its possible. Likely even. Hence the sarky comments, charity donations in her will etc.

I always find this sort of thinking really weird. That family has to meet some kind of test before they ‘get your money’. My family will get my money unless there’s a good reason not to leave it (drug addiction etc). Why wouldn’t they? They don’t need to meet some kind of ‘deserving’ or ‘purity of intention’ test, they’re family Confused

PomPomSugar · 08/02/2023 12:17

I haven’t read the full thread so someone else may have mentioned this but could she be testing you? In that she is saying she has money but she will leave it to charity, therefore testing whether your continued support/visits are genuine and not ‘after her money’.

Blessedwithsunshine · 08/02/2023 12:14

Or does the gran suspect op has her eye on a big inheritance and is there to benefit herself only ?
ie good digger or pretending to care when she doesn’t etc. Its possible. Likely even. Hence the sarky comments, charity donations in her will etc.

Carlycat · 08/02/2023 12:13

ABigSpot · 08/02/2023 08:49

We'll just be honest. Say to her that if she keeps talking about money you aren't going to be around as much. That while you are pleased for her you are genuinely struggling and that you need hers to be a pleasant place to be not somewhere where you are always reminded of what you don't have. If you must, reassert you aren't asking for money, just some compassion in what she discusses.

Then if she can't do it you've given her fair warning, no need to feel guilty, and back you step.

This. She sounds really nasty
It's probably a power thing to make her feel superior
I'd have no qualms about telling her straight. Her behaviour is disgraceful

evtheria · 08/02/2023 12:09

SillySalmonX · 08/02/2023 11:12

Gran definitely sounds tone deaf but also as if she is seeking some nice words from you. Perhaps she wants to hear that you think she is a kind person for considering donating some of her money to charity.

If you generally talk about day to day things but don't have much of a loving/caring relationship, she may be (in her own strange way) trying to soften things up a bit between the two of you.

She may have regrets about not 'giving back' to the community over the course of her life, or perhaps she has done so and wants to talk about it and receive a bit of praise from you.

She may also fear that you are only doing things for her because you are hoping to inherit a good sum from her. She is looking for your reaction when she suggests that most of her money will go elsewhere.

You are showing you care about her by doing practical things for her but she probably senses that it's a burden and you may not actually be enjoying her company. That's hard for her. Try to warm her up a bit with your words. Gently steer the conversation to things you can both enjoy talking about together so that your reactions are genuine. Look for opportunities to praise her and tell her she is kind and generous.

You may find she reciprocates, and as things thaw between the two of you her tone deafness may improve.

If not, at least you will have tried to tackle the problem with kindness. I don't like the idea of confronting her directly about it or reducing the amount you do for her or see her.

I was fuming when I read the OP, all for leaving her to it etc as she's clearly trying to get you to 'prove her right' by asking for money, but this comment has made me think.

OP, like someone else has said, try telling her 'I'm not asking for money, but I am asking you for compassion and kindness. You can help me by not making every conversation about a topic that is extremely stressful for me, and frankly quite irrelevant for you. When I come over it's nice to see you*, I don't want to waste time with you thinking about money!'

Whether she changes will then decide if it is best you actually distance yourself from her.

*okay, this is a lie, but it could change!

Rosscameasdoody · 08/02/2023 12:08

OopsAnotherOne · 08/02/2023 11:58

You don't need to have lost capacity for a Property & Financial Affairs Lasting Power of Attorney if it has been drafted so it can be used as soon as it has been registered, regardless of whether or not the donor has capacity. It would still need to be set up by the donor while they still have capacity though.

Sorry, yes, you’re right, I should have pointed that out, but my main point was that if the OP wanted to be in control she would need an LPA. Problem with drafting it to be used immediately is that if granny is so obsessed with her money it’s doubtful she’d agree to someone having control over it while she was able herself !!

katseyes7 · 08/02/2023 12:07

My mother was like this. I think with her, it was a 'power' thing.
I was divorced, working shifts, and only just keeping my head above water.
She'd say stuff like "I can't spend my money, l can't enjoy it" because she wouldn't go anywhere. Every time l, or one of the family took her anywhere, she didn't like it, complained constantly, "there was nothing for me there."
She'd say to me "Well you know, katseyes, you've got that car...." l had a tiny runaround which was essential for me, I worked shifts and weekends. I couldn't have got to work without it.
She didn't 'earn' any of 'her' money. She gave up work when she had me (only child), the money was what my dad had earned, or they'd inherited.
She'd say "Well, you'll get it when l'm gone...." which l did. But as my cousin commented, "I can't believe she let you pay interest on your mortgage for years when she had enough in the bank to pay it off, and enough for her to be comfortable. I'd want to help my kids out."
I think l'd be doing what someone else suggested, OP. Either tell her it's vulgar to talk about money, or ask her how exactly she 'earned' her money.
I still suspect it's a power thing, though. Some people revel in that.

Iwantabloodypizza · 08/02/2023 12:06

Dogscanteatonions · 08/02/2023 11:33

Wow that is next level vile!!

I do totally admire her commitment to carrying on a lifetime of being an absolute bitch for the sake of it (according to PIL), to beyond the grave though.

Now that’s a lesson in seeing things through.

Supersimkin2 · 08/02/2023 12:06

Granny’s getting a kick out of this.

saraclara · 08/02/2023 12:04

OopsAnotherOne · 08/02/2023 11:58

You don't need to have lost capacity for a Property & Financial Affairs Lasting Power of Attorney if it has been drafted so it can be used as soon as it has been registered, regardless of whether or not the donor has capacity. It would still need to be set up by the donor while they still have capacity though.

Yes, my mum has capacity, but as she is largely paralysed after a massive stroke, she finds it hard to deal with life admin.
My brother and I have POA which we can use with her permission, which means that her bank etc will deal directly with us.

Having a lasting power of attorney allows you to act for the person before they lose capacity, but with their knowledge.

Velvetween · 08/02/2023 12:02

OP I think you should tell her like this…

“DGran, I’m really struggling with bills etc and I find it especially hard when I visit and you talk about all the money you have at your disposal. Can we agree not to talk about money/bills etc and keep our chat to other subject matters?
I enjoy our catch ups but I find talking about money stressful and hope you can understand”

If she asks about charity donations, suggest she gets advice from someone in a more similar position to herself, who has more relatable experience.

If you need to make it clear you don’t expect a handout then do. If she keeps this up then she will be well aware of the reason when your visits dry up.

Rosscameasdoody · 08/02/2023 12:02

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 08/02/2023 09:29

Tell her you think people should pay for help and not expect handouts of time and assistance from their grandchildren.

This. All day long.

OopsAnotherOne · 08/02/2023 11:58

Rosscameasdoody · 08/02/2023 11:54

She’d need lasting power of attorney to do this, and her grandmother would need to have lost the capacity to deal with her own affairs.

You don't need to have lost capacity for a Property & Financial Affairs Lasting Power of Attorney if it has been drafted so it can be used as soon as it has been registered, regardless of whether or not the donor has capacity. It would still need to be set up by the donor while they still have capacity though.

Teateaandmoretea · 08/02/2023 11:57

I’m assuming this is tongue in cheek !! On a more serious note, If she’s 84 and showing any sign of ill health (sounds like possible onset of dementia given her behaviour) it’s too late to do a trust and even money willed to people won’t mean anything if she has to go into care. If Social Services suspect that someone has given away funds at a time when there is a reasonable expectation that they will require care, they will regard it as deprivation of assets and assess as though they still have those funds.

This is true, but you are allowed to gift 3k per year to individuals. Plus she could let the OP get some of her shopping at the same time as her own. She could pay the OP for what she does for her. That would help the OP a lot. She isn’t expecting her to hand it all over.

OP meanness is a very unpleasant characteristic. You sound lovely and she’s taking advantage of you.

billy1966 · 08/02/2023 11:55

What an awful person to have in your life.

You poor woman.

Stop visiting and stop all contact.

Do not put yourself through this any more.

Block her number and be done with it.

With her money she can pay for help.

She is disordered and is getting a kick out of this.

You cannot change her, so step away and live your best life.

She is a sad ugly person and you cannot change that about someone.

Rosscameasdoody · 08/02/2023 11:54

IHaveNoSoul · 08/02/2023 09:16

The next time you do her shopping tell her it will be the last time and that seeing that she has so much money she can pay a Care Company to do it as you need to pick up extra hours for your ever increasing bills etc
Offer to set it up for her so that you're not completely washing your hands of the situation then deal with anything via phone/email so that you're in control

She’d need lasting power of attorney to do this, and her grandmother would need to have lost the capacity to deal with her own affairs.

Rosscameasdoody · 08/02/2023 11:50

Intrepidescape · 08/02/2023 09:58

So she hasn’t done her will yet?

Set up a trust and put you as its beneficiary. Suggest your grandma give the money to the trust before her death. Tell her the trust is for single mothers to help with the cost of living. Just don’t tell her you’re the single mother.

Your grandma is awful and she is using you - but won’t even help you out financially.

You want money you’re going to have to think like a rich person and be utterly ruthless.

I’m assuming this is tongue in cheek !! On a more serious note, If she’s 84 and showing any sign of ill health (sounds like possible onset of dementia given her behaviour) it’s too late to do a trust and even money willed to people won’t mean anything if she has to go into care. If Social Services suspect that someone has given away funds at a time when there is a reasonable expectation that they will require care, they will regard it as deprivation of assets and assess as though they still have those funds. They can investigate financial transactions as far back as they need to if they suspect assets have been given away to avoid care fees.

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/02/2023 11:48

Eightiesgirl · 08/02/2023 10:29

We have the same things with FIL. He is absolutely loaded, he literally has thousands just sat in his current account, yet my dh, his son, is disabled and cannot work, we have struggled financially over the last 4 years, dh losing his job through Ill health, me giving up work to be his full time carer, having to sell our home to survive etc Also, our ds, his only grandchild is in uni and typically student poor. I know its FILs money and it's his choice but a small handout would be much appreciated. Instead, he tuts about student debt, the cost of living, asks us how on earth we all manage, he'd hate to be in our position etc whilst handing over his bank card at church every Sunday (yes, forget the collection plate, its been replaced by a card machine). Then if tradespeople call he tips them and taxi drivers massively. I go round at least 3 times a week, do his cleaning, sort out his meals, sort his admin, appointments etc give him lifts, bring him back here for tea one day a week. A couple of hundred quid would make a massive difference to our lives but I darent ask him, it makes me determined to always help out my son, future grandchildren, if I can afford it.

But why do you run around after him? If you like him, just go see him - he can pay for his own care and errands.

purpledalmation · 08/02/2023 11:42

Tell her straight. I find it a daily struggle financially, but I can cope, I'm not asking you for money, however your constant talk of how much you have and don't need, is upsetting me. Please can you not talk to me about money.

Zipps · 08/02/2023 11:41

First thought was that she hasn't earned it.
Some people want to die millionaires.
Some people like to rub other people's noses in how much they have.
When you have loads of money but can't be generous to your loved ones you are very poor indeed.
Tell her about all the generous older people who share their good fortune and say
"Imagine being related to someone so kind, giving and generous"

blondiepigtails · 08/02/2023 11:41

Sounds like there's a whopping great Inheritance tax bill coming her way too!

Swipe left for the next trending thread