Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be annoyed at my son’s teacher?

106 replies

ChipmunksInAttic · 07/02/2023 23:48

I have a 9 yo and he’s brilliant at maths, history, geography and he’s a very good reader. We’ve always received good feedback from school so far at parent evenings etc, encouraged for grammar schools.

Today at school he took an equipment which he was specifically told not to play with yesterday, and broke it by mistake. It’s not an expensive thing, and we’ll replace it of course. It was wrong of him for sure, but in my eyes it’s just a mistake.

But the teacher was really cross with him. She pulled me in at school pickup and told me about this. Then she showed me some of his work at school, which she rightfully said was poorly done. She said these are not up to their standards at all, and she was not happy at all with his attitude too. I said I’d talk to him and we’d work on it to get it better.

I’m not saying any of these were wrong, I think in essence she believes her instructions are being ignored and I don’t blame her for complaining about it.

But to be honest presentation of his work was never very good, his notebooks were always messy but given the good feedback we thought they didn’t care about it so much. I’m a bit annoyed we’re being told about this only now, when she’s angry with him. That just makes all the previous praises questionable. I’m also annoyed she made all these complaints in front of him. He already thinks she has other favourites and he’s not one of them. Shouldn’t she have told this to me privately without upsetting and discouraging him? Or did he need this wake up call?

OP posts:
electricmoccasins · 08/02/2023 07:39

If your son does get into grammar school, please be aware he will no longer be the big fish in the small pond. I taught many boys who were ‘top of their primary school class’ who were bottom of their grammar school class. They were the sort who had an inflated sense of self, could do no wrong, and the presentation and content of their work was appalling. It didn’t matter though. They were ‘clever’. Mommy said so. And I was just ‘mean’.

grievinggirlneedsadvice · 08/02/2023 07:39

As someone who was disciplined in anger when I was a child, I have a sort of skewed view that all discipline is wrong and that somehow I don't have to listen to it because I cannot accept it, and it brings trauma back, so I learnt to ignore it.
But there's actually nothing wrong with being told off, and told you could do better. School is the perfect time to be taught that doing better, putting effort in is a requirement in holding down a job in later life or being self-disciplined enough to run your own business.
If you can teach your child that discipline is something they can use for their and others advantage instead of thinking they are above it because of the way it was being delivered, and make it constructive not shameful then really you are doing them a massive service in life.

plumduck · 08/02/2023 07:35

PinkElephantsInLemonade · 08/02/2023 07:15

Because just last week they used that tool to draw lines in the garden, and they all were allowed to use it outside then.

I feel like you need to see that cup of tea/consent analogy video.

And yes, you are that parent. Let the qualified professional do her job and maybe try and learn something about behaviour management from her.

Yes

plumduck · 08/02/2023 07:34

ChipmunksInAttic · 08/02/2023 00:09

I took it as a mistake because he was told not to touch yesterday, but he says he forgot about it today and felt sorry after being reminded. the tool was already flimsy and broke in pieces without him doing anything with it.

About neatness, she said the lines were not drawn with a ruler, sentences were too short, maths results were correct but there was no showing of it.

Then he needs to show his working. And put more effort in to making his work neat.

And the equipment is fair enough he wad told not to touch it, how could he forget.

Sounds like the teacher is trying to let you know he's not the little angel you think he is and she knows he can do better

BendingSpoons · 08/02/2023 07:32

I think the teacher is making a point that he is not listening and not focusing and it is impacting his work as well as broken equipment. I do understand your point about not raising other things when you are angry, and possibly this is what the teacher has done. However as she had reason to speak with you, she probably just took the opportunity to raise her other concerns, rather than ringing you later in the week.

I think if the complaint was attitude/trying then it seems reasonable for a 9yo to hear, but should be constructive rather than angry. He needs to know to make a difference and she has probably told him lots in class. In my mind it would be different if the issue was he tried really hard but struggled academically, as then he would already be 'aware', so wouldn't need it raising in front of him.

OchreDandelion · 08/02/2023 07:32

Gawpygertie · 08/02/2023 07:29

Poor presentation doesn't equate to laziness.

OP I would talk to him about checking before he takes things to use.
As regards his writing and presentation whilst your ds should be encouraged to be a little more organised perhaps I wouldn't worry too much.
A good teacher would realise that many brilliant minds are also poor writers.
My db is a physicist and has an outstanding brain, however his work wasn't tidy at school.
He earns 4x more than a teacher though.

The examples from the OP ARE laziness though - short sentences, not showing working, not using a ruler.

That is different from struggling with handwriting / presentation.

I bet your DH - no matter how messy his handwriting - wouldn't try to do column addition without lining it up, for example. Those are the kinds of skills teachers are trying to teach and it is not helpful to dismiss them.

LucyWhipple · 08/02/2023 07:32

As a teacher, I can’t think of many neurotypical 9 yos I’ve taught who wouldn’t be able to remember an instruction from one day to the next. In fact I would also expect the 5yos I teach now to be capable of remembering if they are not permitted to use something.

I can also understand why the teacher chose to show you his work at the same time - she’s been noticing a capable child who isn’t working to their full potential / maintaining previous high standards over a period of time. Then his behaviour yesterday escalated her concern to the point it was appropriate to discuss it with you. She was trying to give you the whole picture so you can work together to resolve things. Completely appropriate to involve the child in the discussion as he’s the one who’s got to work to change & improve things.

You’re feeling attacked because none of us want to think our dc aren’t doing well and it came as a surprise to you. That’s natural. The teacher is not in the wrong though. Probably no one has raised it before because it wasn’t such an issue earlier on, now his peers are catching up / overtaking him things like his presentation stand out in a way they didn’t earlier. He’s older so the expectations become higher. This is a normal thing that happens to some dc.

Thank goodness this teacher is in his corner enough to notice it, care about it and raise it with you. You can work on it with him and watch him make progress or excuse and minimise every bad choice he makes and create a monster. Your call.

Karwomannghia · 08/02/2023 07:31

I’ve been a teacher for a long time and I agree that whilst he shouldn’t have broken the piece of equipment it sounds like she’s annoyed and expressing that annoyance. She could have been much nicer about it. My ds in y4 his writing went downhill and they teacher spread his book out in front of me in a kind of look at this way. It was terrible. What she hadn’t appreciated was that he was trying to keep both arms touching the table because he’d developed slight tics/ocd. I also pointed out he needed lines to keep his writing on track but then again I was able to suggest strategies because of my experience.

So while it’s important to know what’s happening, she could have voiced it in a more friendly way.

BigSwingingJeremyClarkson · 08/02/2023 07:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 08/02/2023 07:29

Btw, if he does go to grammar school, they will likely have very high standards in terms of laying out work correctly, so it would be good for him to get into the habit now.

PriamFarrl · 08/02/2023 07:29

Sarahcoggles · 08/02/2023 00:09

My take on this is that the teacher was deliberately showing your son's poorly presented work at the same time as telling you about his act of disobedience , perhaps to demonstrate that he seems to be dipping in terms of general standards. That he seems to be changing from being a high achieving well behaved kid to a child who disobeyed a clear rule and is being slack with his work too.

I agree with this. It was to show a general drop in standards and behaviour.

Also, at 9 he is fully capable of understanding that being told ‘don’t touch that’ on Monday means it is also the case on Tuesday.

DeliberatelyObtuse · 08/02/2023 07:29

YABU and ridiculous

Gawpygertie · 08/02/2023 07:29

maddy68 · 08/02/2023 07:20

It sounds as though your son is becoming naughty and is now ignoring her instructions not only behaviour wise but also being lazy and ignoring instructions to improve his presentation.
She's right to inform you , she's right to challenge. She is annoyed with him

Not understanding why you are annoyed with her ?

Poor presentation doesn't equate to laziness.

OP I would talk to him about checking before he takes things to use.
As regards his writing and presentation whilst your ds should be encouraged to be a little more organised perhaps I wouldn't worry too much.
A good teacher would realise that many brilliant minds are also poor writers.
My db is a physicist and has an outstanding brain, however his work wasn't tidy at school.
He earns 4x more than a teacher though.

rainbowstardrops · 08/02/2023 07:28

The teacher has done nothing wrong and was quite right in filling you in with regards to his declining behaviour and sloppy, lazy work. She knows he is capable of far more and he needed to hear her telling you, so that he knows you are aware too.

As she mentioned his attitude and the fact he 'forgot' he wasn't allowed to touch the piece of equipment (of course he didn't forget!) and subsequently broke it, I imagine she's becoming quite frustrated with him.

Imagine if the other 29 children in the class behaved like him. No wonder teachers are leaving in droves.

Changechangechanging · 08/02/2023 07:28

Your child didn’t make a mistake. He very deliberately did something he had been told not to do and more than that, broke school property in the process. You should be livid. It is appalling behaviour and by making it all about the teacher you are telling your son he can do whatever he wants with very few - seemingly no - consequences. You are actually expecting the teacher to encourage him!

You need to have a serious word with yourself.

Xol · 08/02/2023 07:27

I took it as a mistake because he was told not to touch yesterday, but he says he forgot about it today and felt sorry after being reminded. the tool was already flimsy and broke in pieces without him doing anything with it.

No doubt that's what he told you, but why on earth did you believe him given that it was a tool the whole class had been using for measuring last week without it falling apart?

OchreDandelion · 08/02/2023 07:27

I would imagine she was trying to show you a pattern.

For example, this week in my class (younger than nine) we have been working on extending sentences with conjunctions. So, I would not expect to see all short sentences at the moment.

So too in Maths, I imagine in every class in the land children are supposed to show their working out. It is an important step so you don't get caught out once the numbers get too big to do accurately in your head (and you get marks for it). It also helps the teacher see what has gone wrong if the answer is not correct so is an excellent practice to get into.

And not using a line for a ruler is just a basic! Books / work soon end up looking appalling with scribbled lines. How could you do an accurate graph or diagram? Again, I would imagine most teachers expect a ruler to be used for every line every time. It is hardly a big ask.

So, if her classroom is similar to mine, which seems likely:

  • taking something you are not allowed (not following instructions)
  • the lines were not drawn with a ruler (not following instructions)
  • sentences were too short (not following instructions)
  • maths results were correct but there was no showing of it (not following instructions)
RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 08/02/2023 07:27

I think you’re being a bit naive OP. At nine he’s perfectly old enough to understand that tools are okay to use for supervised class tasks and not okay to be poked with by individuals who’ve been told not to use them.

Being positive as a parent is great, but sometimes we just need to tell our kids to sort themselves. Blaming the teacher is a defence mechanism, but ultimately you’ll help your son more by supporting the school and not trying to shift blame.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 08/02/2023 07:26

Not showing workings in maths is a problem though. It's not just that you get marks for it in exams but also that it's very hard as a teacher to work out where someone went wrong if all you have is a number on a page. So it's not a helpful habit to get into. Even if the answer are right now, they may not always be in the future.

Has this teacher praised his work and said there are no problems before? Or did previous teachers? Because obviously all teachers have different standards and different things they care about. Which may be why he feels the teacher has favourites - as in she values different things to his previous teachers and praises students who do these things. For these students it might be their first experience of regular praise.

In terms of annoyance, even if it's basic classroom equipment it may be something the teacher bought herself or she knows won't be replaced (especially right now at the end of the financial year) and then it's very hard not to get annoyed. At the end of the day it sounds like he has broken a resource meant for everyone, and it is important there are consequences to this.

Quitelikeacatslife · 08/02/2023 07:26

Treat this as a serious wake up call. He can have all the natural ability in the world and sounds like good stable home (so he's got a better start than a lot of kids) , but it sounds like his attitude is bad and he has been arrogant and lazy at school (I think the teacher probably has sugar coated it to you so it's probably worse than she said ) and if this doesn't get nipped in the bud he will struggle later. You need to start working on and praising , politeness, obedience, listening skills and respecting others. These skills are just as important as academic milestones at this age

LittleBearPad · 08/02/2023 07:23

The breaking equipment wasn’t acceptable. Not sure how positive encouragement is going to help there.

On showing his working - if he’s likely to sit the 11+ he needs to show his working to get the marks he’ll need.

The other points, it may be she’s given feedback on neatness before, ageing workings etc and he’s ignored her - like he ignored the instruction not to touch whatever he broke. It may be a general attitude issue.

maddy68 · 08/02/2023 07:20

It sounds as though your son is becoming naughty and is now ignoring her instructions not only behaviour wise but also being lazy and ignoring instructions to improve his presentation.
She's right to inform you , she's right to challenge. She is annoyed with him

Not understanding why you are annoyed with her ?

SecretSophie · 08/02/2023 07:16

He's much more likely to pull his socks up if you support the teacher, instead of trying to find reasons the teacher was wrong. You could make this a valuable learning opportunity for him. Or not.

PinkElephantsInLemonade · 08/02/2023 07:15

Because just last week they used that tool to draw lines in the garden, and they all were allowed to use it outside then.

I feel like you need to see that cup of tea/consent analogy video.

And yes, you are that parent. Let the qualified professional do her job and maybe try and learn something about behaviour management from her.

Hercisback · 08/02/2023 07:15

He's 9, took something that wasn't his and broke it. My six year old would be told off for that, by 9 he knows its wrong. If he did forget, then he needs further investigation into his brain function.

The fact he doesn't listen doesn't surprise me. You've turned an incident that was his fault, into someone else's fault. I bet he's never faced the consequences of not doing what he's asked the first time ever.

The teacher has put up with his work not being the best it can be for a while it seems. The positive in class encouragement hasn't worked.

Swipe left for the next trending thread