Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mil treating baby like a doll

318 replies

tiaandduck · 07/02/2023 20:56

I know I'm probably bu. Mil has been annoying me recently and I don't know if I'm just feeling over protective or possessive of dd or what the problem actually is but she's grating on me.

She has this obsession about taking my baby out in the pram alone. She is always asking to come round to push the pram. She doesn't want me there.
Dd is sometimes a bit fussy in the pram and prefers the carrier and it's always been raining when she comes round, so I put her off as dd doesn't like the rain cover either. She's a bit fussy just now in general.
Sure enough though, mil has been asking to make plans so she can come and take dd out in the pram so I can have a break. Even though I've never asked for or needed a break.
The second thing is she keeps buying her these impractical dresses that are a bit full on party style...we don't go to parties and she grows out of them too quick to wear them. Her wardrobe is bursting at the seams with dresses she has never worn...as well as a furry white coat.
She keeps saying she's buying her designer stuff, has bought her converse which she just kicks off her feet. She keeps buying designer things in her taste and I prefer rompers, baby grows or a little top and leggings set.
She keeps saying she wants some gran time alone with the baby, but I just don't like being away from her just now. Maybe that's my issue. She is a fussy baby which is maybe why I don't want people to have her, incase they mess up my routine with her.
She has a boyfriend she's been seeing a few months now and he also keeps buying dd outfits.
I dunno if im just being overly sensitive or if she's been overbearing.

OP posts:
Calphurnia88 · 08/02/2023 13:39

If that means her taking baby out in the pram/carrier once in a while, it's hardly too much to ask.

It is if the baby is fussy in the pram.

I think people forget that babies are actual humans sometimes.

buttercupboots · 08/02/2023 13:24

A lot of the MIL complaints on here sound like things the child will absolutely love in years to come. What toddler/small child wouldn't love a grandma that is enthusiastic about seeing them, wants to buy them things, take them out and let them have cake and biscuits! Hopefully that relationship hasn't been suitably prevented by then.

It's also interesting to me that hardly anyone has these same issues with their parents, it always seems to be the MIL? Whilst my partner puts our family first, he has great respect for his mum and would always advocate for her being able to have decent/appropriate access to our baby. If that means her taking baby out in the pram/carrier once in a while, it's hardly too much to ask.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/02/2023 11:30

@CecilyP well MIL is in her early 70s.

She finds breastfeeding ‘odd’, thinks little girls should be dressed constantly in dresses/tights/flowery head bands, that if children aren’t constantly smiling from newborn then they’re ‘grumpy’, that cake and biscuits are a suitable daily snack, and that when overtired or hungry babies cry they should be further distressed by having toys waved in their face and distracted with something on the telly rather than being put down for a nap or fed.

Eyerollcentral · 08/02/2023 11:30

Also @CecilyP of course people used babygros, at night. Most baby clothes were made in softer fabric, do you think baby clothes were made out of horsehair? Bizarre.

Eyerollcentral · 08/02/2023 11:20

CecilyP · 08/02/2023 07:28

How old do you think these MILs are? While bottle feeding and feeding babies to schedule was the norm in the 60s and 70s breastfeeding on demand was common by the 80s. As was dressing babies in babygros, and other clothes in soft stretch fabrics. Unless these new mums are much older than average, I don’t think ‘doing things differently then’ is much of a reason for MILs behaviour.

How old are you? Because this is exactly what I saw people doing during my own childhood.

bussteward · 08/02/2023 11:20

bussteward · 08/02/2023 11:19

OK, Nostradamus.

Whoops quoted the wrong thing!

TicketBoo23 · 08/02/2023 11:20

Expecting to or presuming to take someone young baby on your own (even grandparents) is also someone who is simply not being empathetic ...... Parents esp mothers are, by necessity, very strongly bonded to their babies and young kids, might entirely naturally feel uncomfortable (even slightly anxious) about being separated from them. They don't feel particularly comfortable handing them over to someone alone who is si.oly not involved enough in their hour to hour card to know them well and look after them v well.

If a parent asks you for a break and says they desperately want do engine out on their own, by all means - you're doing something lovely ... if they don't, you should presume they don't want someone carrying off their baby on their own and would like to share time with you.

It's, again, presumptious and lacking in empathy.

Zero empathy for the baby removed from their main carer, their familiarity, their smell, their voice as well.

It's stupid, shit behaviour (and fairly selfish underneath it all) leys face it.

This woman needs a reborn, not a real baby whose needs she is clearly oblivious or indifferent to.

bussteward · 08/02/2023 11:19

Nevermind31 · 08/02/2023 11:07

But why the need for the pram when the baby doesn’t like it? Why the need to do it without the parent? It’s not what baby wants or needs - this is purely for grandma’s entertainment

OK, Nostradamus.

YesILikeItToo · 08/02/2023 11:17

My mother wanted alone time with my child, which I tried my best to arrange, and then found that this wasn’t enough - she started asking for the child to be happy to spend alone time with her. I couldn’t arrange that!

Calphurnia88 · 08/02/2023 11:16

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/02/2023 10:48

And in 30 years time when you are a grandma YOUR parenting and tactics will be sneered at.

I see this type of comment on these threads all the time and it's so unimaginative.

If I become a MIL in 30 odd years time I will do DS and DIL the decency of doing some research on the latest guidance before telling them how it's done, or spending time alone with GC.

And I'll happily admit if any of the practices from 'my day' are no longer advised.

TicketBoo23 · 08/02/2023 11:12

ForThisUn · 07/02/2023 21:26

How dare a Grandmother want to take her Grand child out in a pram for a walk. WTF is the world coming to?

Lots of babies don't fkg like prams.

They only time they might is when they're sleepy/sleeping.

As op said they vastly prefer carriers.

And being stuck in a pram is bad enough, without having a rain cover over you as well

Gran is lacking empathy for the baby. She's clearly not open to listening properly to op about baby's preferences ... Which are very common preferences.

My dd hated the buggy/pram and esp hated being under a rain cover. Extremely cut off and boring for a baby.

Most babies do very well in carriers and it's the original, natural way (from what I've seen in developing countries) ..... She needs to enter the 21st century. Decent parents and grand parents don't treat babies like dolls and props.

BubziOwl · 08/02/2023 11:09

Johnnysgirl · 08/02/2023 11:04

but I just don't need childcare at the moment so I can count on my hands the times I've left him with anyone but myself (bar my husband), just for things like appointments etc
Just about sums it up, really. Back in your box till I need childcare, you old bat.
But when I do, you'll be expected to jump when I click my fingers.

Oh bloody hell, people love adding nonsense like this don't they.

I'm just explaining why they've been alone with him so infrequently - there just has never been a need, so it never comes up.

Where exactly did I say that I'm going to click my fingers and expect childcare when I need it? If they want to help, they can. If they don't, no problem, they don't have to. Everyone's happy!

Calphurnia88 · 08/02/2023 11:08

As expected this thread is full of all the classic tropes e.g.

Alone time! How dare she! <sarcasm>/You'll be begging her for free childcare soon enough/Just wait until you're a MIL! Etc.

Yawn.

I get it OP. I had a very fussy baby who is still particular about being in the pram, so the idea of just popping by and 'taking him out for a walk' in the pram isn't a thing.

His temperament is also heavily influenced by his feeding and napping routine (as are most of my friend's babies), and if either of these are disrupted it'll make for a difficult day and night, which fall onto me. How I have navigated this with family is to let them know when is a good time to visit, and if their visit does end up coinciding with feeding or napping then these take priority. I will literally bundle him up and take him out for walk when it's nap time, and if anyone wants to join me they can, but if not I'll see them in an hour or so.

I don't get the obsession with alone time either, although I only ever read about it on here. Grandparents should wait until both parents are ready for this IMO.

BubziOwl · 08/02/2023 11:08

I agree with @Cuppasoupmonster that if by the time I have grandkids my own parenting methods are out of date according to the current science, I will adapt accordingly. Why would I take offence at times and thinking changing? All we can do is go by the current research, thinking, expert consensus, whatever.

I'm not going to get personally offended if studies are done in the future showing the way, for example, I weaned my baby was actually damaging and my kids want to do it differently with their baby, because I'm confident that I'm going by the most up-to-date thinking today. That's all I can do!

Nevermind31 · 08/02/2023 11:07

ForThisUn · 07/02/2023 21:26

How dare a Grandmother want to take her Grand child out in a pram for a walk. WTF is the world coming to?

But why the need for the pram when the baby doesn’t like it? Why the need to do it without the parent? It’s not what baby wants or needs - this is purely for grandma’s entertainment

JackieDaws · 08/02/2023 11:04

bussteward · 08/02/2023 10:52

Never said they won’t be. Still doesn’t mean I or OP have to leave our babies with anyone we don’t want to. Leaving my DC with my incapable MIL isn’t some get-out-of-jail-free futureproofing to ensure I get some grandchild alone time in 30 years. Why would I want some, anyway? Babies are hard work and I’ll be 73.

It seems you'll be the type of grandmother who'll have no relationship with their grandchildren even when the mother is crying and asking for some help. Maybe once a year for 5 minutes at Christmas.

Johnnysgirl · 08/02/2023 11:04

but I just don't need childcare at the moment so I can count on my hands the times I've left him with anyone but myself (bar my husband), just for things like appointments etc
Just about sums it up, really. Back in your box till I need childcare, you old bat.
But when I do, you'll be expected to jump when I click my fingers.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/02/2023 11:03

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/02/2023 11:02

But what if your DIL says “Oh no but you did gentle parenting which has since been proven to be damaging” etc - why should she trust you

Firstly I’m not gentle parenting 😂

secondly I would say okay, what would you like me to do instead? And actually listen/do it.

Its about the unwillingness to change, not retrospectively judging for things that were done at a time when it was acceptable to do so.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/02/2023 11:02

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/02/2023 10:52

If something I’m doing now will be seen as unsafe or outmoded when I’m a granny, then I will be more than happy to learn the new ropes. It’s about the best care for a baby, not validating the MIL’s outdated parenting skills and letting her relive her own baby days. The fact you think improving knowledge is ‘sneering’ shows you think the validation comes before safely caring for a baby.

But what if your DIL says “Oh no but you did gentle parenting which has since been proven to be damaging” etc - why should she trust you

tiaandduck · 08/02/2023 11:01

@RainyDaysareCarp I understand from the mums point of view that she has worked hard to implement a routine that works for her and the baby. All it takes is for someone to take baby, distrupt feeding and sleeping routine and baby is left overtired, screaming and not going to bed at usual time which is havoc for the babies mother. It's why I'm reluctant to leave her with anyone yet. It's a nightmare when well meaning family members are trying to soothe baby and try and settle them without giving back to the mother, saying things like oh I think she's wet, or I think it's
Wind...when the mother has already said numerous times it's because she's tired and needs a nap.
Just because someone has raised several kids, doesn't mean they are going to care for the baby like the mother does...every baby is different.
My mother told me to get dd to sleep through to bath her and put straight to bed. I've been doing that every single night since three months and she's still up every hour or two.

OP posts:
BubziOwl · 08/02/2023 11:00

None of my 1yo's grandparents have ever asked for alone time with my child. I'd find that extremely odd. They come over frequently, my son loves them, but I just don't need childcare at the moment so I can count on my hands the times I've left him with anyone but myself (bar my husband), just for things like appointments etc.

The fact that I'm always around when they come over hasn't impacted their relationship with my son at all - as I said before, he adores them (and I adore them too tbh!).

I don't understand why you have to be alone with a child to bond with them. What exactly are you doing that you don't want to do with their parents there?! Just weird all round.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/02/2023 10:59

5128gap · 08/02/2023 10:09

I've had mine alone from 3 days old. The benefits are that GC are completely comfortable with me and I with them, knowing their routine, how to comfort them etc, so I can drop onto caring for them at any time, without any strangeness or distress on GCs part or worry on the parents part.
As an extended family we are able to provide a greater level of care than could be provided by parents alone. No one needs to get over tired, frustrated or bored, as there's another person to step in, fresher and more enthusiastic to meet the child's needs, which obviously has benefits for the child.
I appreciate its not for everyone, but its worked well in my family for three generations.

I agree with this completely.

When I see kids who have no relationship with their grandparents I feel so sad and so lucky that mine are close to theirs

5128gap · 08/02/2023 10:59

bussteward · 08/02/2023 10:50

That’s not an answer to “why”, it’s just being ornery. What benefit does MIL get from pushing a fussy baby in a pram alone Vs pushing an angry baby in a pram with her DIL and son for company?

She gets a more relaxed experience. The sort of DiL who wouldn't want her to take the baby out alone will typically be the sort who will hover over her when she is interacting with the baby, micromanaging the interaction, which tends to make people feel on edge.
She also gets to walk without the need to make conversation with other adults.
Totally different experience.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/02/2023 10:56

RainyDaysareCarp · 08/02/2023 09:14

My friend was babysitting her GD and the Mum left her a minute by minute list of instructions eg 11 am gets 1 snack, 11.05 check nappy, blah blah. I was there - we just laughed. My friend reared 4 of them.

Oh god I did this with MIL who raised 3 children. I even laminated the bloody thing 🙈 she was so gracious bless her, and we laugh about it now.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/02/2023 10:55

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/02/2023 10:52

Where’s your husband? Is he sitting in the corner doing as he’s told?

Usually he’s complaining about his mum!