Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mil treating baby like a doll

318 replies

tiaandduck · 07/02/2023 20:56

I know I'm probably bu. Mil has been annoying me recently and I don't know if I'm just feeling over protective or possessive of dd or what the problem actually is but she's grating on me.

She has this obsession about taking my baby out in the pram alone. She is always asking to come round to push the pram. She doesn't want me there.
Dd is sometimes a bit fussy in the pram and prefers the carrier and it's always been raining when she comes round, so I put her off as dd doesn't like the rain cover either. She's a bit fussy just now in general.
Sure enough though, mil has been asking to make plans so she can come and take dd out in the pram so I can have a break. Even though I've never asked for or needed a break.
The second thing is she keeps buying her these impractical dresses that are a bit full on party style...we don't go to parties and she grows out of them too quick to wear them. Her wardrobe is bursting at the seams with dresses she has never worn...as well as a furry white coat.
She keeps saying she's buying her designer stuff, has bought her converse which she just kicks off her feet. She keeps buying designer things in her taste and I prefer rompers, baby grows or a little top and leggings set.
She keeps saying she wants some gran time alone with the baby, but I just don't like being away from her just now. Maybe that's my issue. She is a fussy baby which is maybe why I don't want people to have her, incase they mess up my routine with her.
She has a boyfriend she's been seeing a few months now and he also keeps buying dd outfits.
I dunno if im just being overly sensitive or if she's been overbearing.

OP posts:
Eyerollcentral · 07/02/2023 22:34

Foxglovers · 07/02/2023 22:30

Yes, I’m definitely not saying that’s normal either but it’s not something we have ever wanted (also don’t live close to family so when they visit kids need time to warm up to them etc) more just that it would stress me out so we haven’t! I more just think it shouldn’t be something forced on someone who isn’t keen, as OP 5 month old is still v young!
although I actually just realised I’m wrong as when I was in hospital have DD2 my parents looked after my other daughter (in our house) and did take her out!

Yes but your children do need to be used to being round other people without you there. Do they go to crèche or nursery?

Foxglovers · 07/02/2023 22:33

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 07/02/2023 22:26

It’s also unhealthy for children who will be starting school before long.

No one is doing their child a favour by being over bearing and precious

I totally agree, and we mix and socialise all the time with friends and family. They are confident kids.
mad also don’t have family loving nearby. If a trusted family me member wanted to take my dd1 to the park or something I would let that happen now asong as she wanted to go. My point was more that no one should be having to do something they aren’t comfortable with - also 5 months is v young. Fine if she wants the break! But she doesn’t 🤷🏻‍♀️ perhaps it makes her feel more stressed out…I know that’s what would’ve happened to me.

Foxglovers · 07/02/2023 22:30

Eyerollcentral · 07/02/2023 22:25

I find it really unusual no one has left the house with your children without you or your husband at their ages. Not grandparents, aunts or uncles? Obviously you do whatever you want with your children but this is quite out of the ordinary

Yes, I’m definitely not saying that’s normal either but it’s not something we have ever wanted (also don’t live close to family so when they visit kids need time to warm up to them etc) more just that it would stress me out so we haven’t! I more just think it shouldn’t be something forced on someone who isn’t keen, as OP 5 month old is still v young!
although I actually just realised I’m wrong as when I was in hospital have DD2 my parents looked after my other daughter (in our house) and did take her out!

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 07/02/2023 22:26

Eyerollcentral · 07/02/2023 22:25

I find it really unusual no one has left the house with your children without you or your husband at their ages. Not grandparents, aunts or uncles? Obviously you do whatever you want with your children but this is quite out of the ordinary

It’s also unhealthy for children who will be starting school before long.

No one is doing their child a favour by being over bearing and precious

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 07/02/2023 22:25

All of you offended by being bought clothes and a grandma wanting to see their GC may be surprised when your own precious children shun you when you’re an old lady. And you’ll only have yourself to blame

Eyerollcentral · 07/02/2023 22:25

Foxglovers · 07/02/2023 22:22

You are not being unreasonable at all!! I’ve never had my kids taken out without me (other than by their dad!) and they are 3 and 2. She’s far too young (if you aren’t ready for it) she needs to back off.

I also cannot stand people buying clothes for my kids, they wouldn’t buy me clothes, so why buy for my kids. I can choose their clothes (until they are ready to start choosing!) I started returning everything MIL bought that I didn’t like and she did stop in the end. She was also buying from awful fast fashion type brands anyway, which I would never buy from. It used to irritate me as it’s so terrible for the environment too. Luckily no one had suggested taking my kids out without me being happy with it though!
I wouldn’t have let her, I’d just say in a nice way that it makes you feel a bit stressed and you appreciate the offer and will let her know when/if you’re ready for this.

I find it really unusual no one has left the house with your children without you or your husband at their ages. Not grandparents, aunts or uncles? Obviously you do whatever you want with your children but this is quite out of the ordinary

Foxglovers · 07/02/2023 22:22

You are not being unreasonable at all!! I’ve never had my kids taken out without me (other than by their dad!) and they are 3 and 2. She’s far too young (if you aren’t ready for it) she needs to back off.

I also cannot stand people buying clothes for my kids, they wouldn’t buy me clothes, so why buy for my kids. I can choose their clothes (until they are ready to start choosing!) I started returning everything MIL bought that I didn’t like and she did stop in the end. She was also buying from awful fast fashion type brands anyway, which I would never buy from. It used to irritate me as it’s so terrible for the environment too. Luckily no one had suggested taking my kids out without me being happy with it though!
I wouldn’t have let her, I’d just say in a nice way that it makes you feel a bit stressed and you appreciate the offer and will let her know when/if you’re ready for this.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 07/02/2023 22:21

VladmirsPoutine · 07/02/2023 21:59

I don't think I will ever fail to be shocked at the cultural norms when it comes to the family unit in this country. On some threads you'd be forgiven for thinking the MiL is not at all related to the family/baby in question and just a random woman who followed the OP home from Tesco wanting to hug the baby. Remarkable stuff.

Totally agree.

I think people forget that these MILs have heaps more experience raising children than their DIL does too.

GordonShakespearedoesChristmas · 07/02/2023 22:19

VladmirsPoutine · 07/02/2023 21:59

I don't think I will ever fail to be shocked at the cultural norms when it comes to the family unit in this country. On some threads you'd be forgiven for thinking the MiL is not at all related to the family/baby in question and just a random woman who followed the OP home from Tesco wanting to hug the baby. Remarkable stuff.

Mumsnet hates MILs.
They forget that they will probably be someone's MIL one day.

roarfeckingroarr · 07/02/2023 22:13

I don't get why she has to take your daughter on her own.

Spongecake556 · 07/02/2023 22:12

Oh god- my mum was like this. Love her to bits but she just loves babies and can’t wait to take them out “in the pram”
I think, it must be an age thing- maybe your mother in law is of an older generation.
my mum loved dressing them up and always wanted to take them out in the pram by herself- she loved me taking photos of her and the baby in the pram too! 😂
Before I had any- it was friends babies!
I think- it maybe comes down to an old fashioned need of wanting to look after/ take care or maybe just brings back lovely memories?
Im not sure- I can’t see me wanting to do it- I was always so busy with work/ kids etc I was never able to feel joy bringing them out in the pram- it was a necessity.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 07/02/2023 22:08

I am not for one second saying that you should give in to her every whim and let her take baby out whenever she wants etc.

However, I have the exact opposite experience and it's a bit crap really. My parents have both passed away (my mum when my eldest was 3m old so she never really got to be a grandma). My DH's parents aren't really interested at all. They were and hour away and have recently moved a further 45 mins away and when we do see them, it's a very formal "cooked meal at the table, polite conversation, and very little interaction with the gc beyond giving them a token gift as they arrive" situation.

I'd work to find a happy medium where your mil can have a half decent relationship with baby without you feeling like you're just pandering to her.

Oh and I'd definitely have a word about the clothes, maybe point her in the direction of useful items so she still gets to "spoil" gc but it's with stuff you can actually use?

Aldisfinest · 07/02/2023 22:07

Wait, I am confused why it would be bad for a grandmother to ask for alone time with baby? As long as there's no safety concerns, it's her grandchild so I don't know why she wouldn't want to spend one on one time with baby. I would be fine for my mum or mother in law to ask for this. Everyone's different I guess..

CustardGoodJamGoodMeatGood · 07/02/2023 22:05

I completely understand this. When I had DD1, my MIL was asking if she could babysit from 2 weeks old, I was still bleeding! Or she'd text every week to ask if we wanted to go out and she would watch the baby, if she came over, she'd ask if I needed to go and rest or if I needed to go out and she would watch the baby, I felt like I was getting in the way. So much so, that we went to the supermarket one evening for half an hour just to shut her up. DP started managing her visits and texts and although we still get texts with DD2, she knows now that if we needed her to have the kids, we would ask. DD2, she did start asking again quite frequently but I BF her so have a good excuse not to leave her.

Aria2015 · 07/02/2023 22:04

I get where you're coming from. I didn't want to leave mine with others for quite a while. I'd pick your battles though, maybe put her off for walks as much you can but accept the outfits, pop baby in them once and take a photo to show some appreciation for the gesture and then gift them on (discreetly). She's just a keen grandmother. As your child gets older and you start to want the odd day or evening off, you may welcome her support and help so don't push her away too much.

Eastereggsboxedupready · 07/02/2023 22:03

She wants you to hand over your dd it her and a new bf?. Def bloody not..

WandaWonder · 07/02/2023 22:03

The clothes things would annoy me but I would happily have wanted someone to take my baby for walls so I could get some time to myself, I get you think she is treating you baby like a doll but a baby is not a possession to you either

I don't get this if a baby is not with the mum 24/7 the world will end thing

Eyerollcentral · 07/02/2023 22:02

VladmirsPoutine · 07/02/2023 21:59

I don't think I will ever fail to be shocked at the cultural norms when it comes to the family unit in this country. On some threads you'd be forgiven for thinking the MiL is not at all related to the family/baby in question and just a random woman who followed the OP home from Tesco wanting to hug the baby. Remarkable stuff.

These threads absolutely do not my reflect my experience of the real world whatsoever. It amazes me too.

Flossiemoss · 07/02/2023 22:01

It’s an overexcited grandma. Ah at least she dotes on dd that’s something to hold onto.
my df was obsessed with walking ds in his pram at every opportunity. Ds seemed to like it too. The other 2 grew out of being walked quite quickly - they were more of a handful. Df and dm settled eventually.

although now they have a new dgc on way. I shudder to think what frilly monstrosities they will inflict on dsil if it’s a girl.

no advice really just solidarity. They chill out a bit when baby gets more mobile. Can you exchange any of the outfits? Or drop heavy hints as to what dc actually need?

VladmirsPoutine · 07/02/2023 21:59

I don't think I will ever fail to be shocked at the cultural norms when it comes to the family unit in this country. On some threads you'd be forgiven for thinking the MiL is not at all related to the family/baby in question and just a random woman who followed the OP home from Tesco wanting to hug the baby. Remarkable stuff.

Eyerollcentral · 07/02/2023 21:57

IVFbeenverylucky · 07/02/2023 21:51

This isn't the case at all. In the past, with young babies like OPs, babies just wore sleepsuits all the time. My DM says this was just normal; people did not dress their children up in special clothes at all. Of course, with older children you are right.

I am over 40, from a poorer background and the only time I was in a babygro was bedtime, as was completely standard for everyone I knew growing up and there were a LOT of babies around. People took pride in dressing their babies in nice things, not just for special occasions.

juneonthemoon · 07/02/2023 21:55

I find it very odd that she wants to take the baby out in the pram without you there, and to some new mums this can cause anxiety rather than be nice. Why should her needs trump yours. It's partly about who's top dog, I often think, with this sort of behaviour. YANBU

IVFbeenverylucky · 07/02/2023 21:53

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 07/02/2023 21:43

Do not return clothes that people have bought your baby! That is so shockingly rude. Just take them to the charity shop - I cannot believe people actually do this

Actually buying mountains of clothes is shockingly rude. Buying the odd thing which is expensive and not to your taste is one of those things and of course you should not give it back. But if someone is buying lots and lots it becomes insensitive and overwhelming (for me) felt very much like a criticism of how I was parenting. Ultimately giving them back is the best way of stopping it and the sooner this happens the better for all and the ongoing family relationship.

Eyerollcentral · 07/02/2023 21:53

Mischance · 07/02/2023 21:46

Any grandmother who is asking for "alone time" with a GC is totally out of order.

I have 7 GC. I have never once ever asked for alone time. It is not mine to ask for. They are not my children. In fact I have had them on their own a fair bit - but only when asked to in order to help them - school pick-ups, care whilst DDs working etc. Of course I love it - we have a great time together. But if my DDs did not have a need for me to do this then it would not happen. The GC are not my playthings - they are not there for my pleasure.

I have never understood this attitude on the part of grandparents - all my friends who are also GPs feel the same. We have had our children - enjoyed them and been worn down by them at times - and now it is our time to have a completely different role, but one that is at the discretion of our children. That is fine. We had our turn.

I’ve never heard of anyone in real life asking for alone time with a baby. I do wonder if there is a miscommunication between what is said and what is heard. Most people would think it was helpful to take the baby out for a walk, not a nefarious plan for alone time with a baby

OdeToBarney · 07/02/2023 21:53

@Mischance you honestly sound like the perfect DGM!

OP yanbu, I would be annoyed too. Get your DH to have a word, she needs to tone it down a bit. Your DD isn't her dolly.