Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dr told me I'm three and a half stone Overweight but I'm in no place

209 replies

forelogger · 07/02/2023 19:35

To accept it or get motivated.
I have every reason to be motivated . But I'm not.

I've three kids, on my own , my knees and ankles are paining me, I've a back injury that can be healed woth walking and im single and would like to feel my best to look my best to meet someone one day.

I don't know how I got to this place.
I can carry two stone over. Im 5'7 but this is a new low for me.
Where do I even begin.

My mood is so low and I feel hopeless and full of despair for the future .
That chat we had was just the mail in the coffin.
AIBU to think I can do this in my own.
I can't afford a club or dietician.

I have so little time for planning or prep and as dr said to me ' once again, it's us women putting ourselves last and waking up unhappy with our weight and fitness one day'
All opinions appreciated and even a kick up the behind .
Thank you for reading.

OP posts:
SeaToSki · 08/02/2023 11:44

I lost 25 lbs and kept it off by
working out what my personal kryptonite was (the thing that I ate everyday that was calorific and difficult to only eat a little of) and switching it for an acceptable substitute that was low cal. For me it was bread and I switched it for multigrain crispbread. So 150 calories for 35. I would eat at least 4 slices a day, sometimes 8.

I then avoided fruit as it drove my sweet tooth and just ate as many steamed veg at every meal as I could.

If I was looking for a snack, I drank 8 oz of water and waited half an hour. That often just got me to my next meal time

In a weird way I embraced a little bit of hunger. It made me feel like my diet was working. If I was starving hungry, it was different and I would do the water thing..but a little bit of hunger was a useful encouragement

Hydrangeatea · 08/02/2023 11:33

emmathedilemma · 08/02/2023 11:15

1250 calories is so low! Your BMR is the number of calories you'd burn if you literally stayed in bed all day i.e. the minimum your body needs to function so you shouldn't be eating much less than that, even if you don't do any exercise.
I'm 5ft 6 and just under 70kg and I could lose weight on 1700 calories a day with a daily step goal of 10,000 and 2-3 weights session a week so at your height and weight you can definitely afford to eat more.

I am now 74kg reduced from 95kg and I did it on about 1850 cals per day, 10,000-12,000 steps per day and about 45-60 minutes of cardio and strength about 5-6 times a week.

My average output was about 2,400-2,500 cals per day on that.

Hydrangeatea · 08/02/2023 11:30

1250 is WAY TOO LOW. You'll be able to keep that up for a couple of weeks, maybe a month but you'll be miserable in no time and end up bingeing.

If you do no exercise other than moving around each day I would stick to your BMR of 1600 plus try and add on as much movement as you can. Doesn't have to be all out cardio classes to be effective but walking as much as you possibly can will have a great effect.

emmathedilemma · 08/02/2023 11:15

1250 calories is so low! Your BMR is the number of calories you'd burn if you literally stayed in bed all day i.e. the minimum your body needs to function so you shouldn't be eating much less than that, even if you don't do any exercise.
I'm 5ft 6 and just under 70kg and I could lose weight on 1700 calories a day with a daily step goal of 10,000 and 2-3 weights session a week so at your height and weight you can definitely afford to eat more.

misskatamari · 08/02/2023 11:09

I hear you! Am in a similar boat. One thing that’s helping me a lot is following rebelfit on Facebook (and I’m doing their current mission and have done a few others). They’re really focused on well-being and nourishment/strength and loving away from harmful diets and diet culture. Obviously a mission might not be for you but I’d really recommend checking them out. Weight gain and obesity is about so much more than calories in and out/eat less move more, and I’m find the rebelfit approach (along with some other work I’ve done this last year, like following Lisa Schlosberg’s out of the cave podcast), to be very helpful.

I wish you all the best. It’s hard and I’m sure you’ll get many responses telling you to do xyz, count calories etc. I find that does not work for me and leads to shame spirals and binges. I feel like I’ve finally found an approach that might actually lead to long term changes in my health ❤️

xJoy · 08/02/2023 11:08

works out more expensive i mean! It's definitely more expensive to buy the portioned out sizes of cheese but I have been finding it really helpful. It is 20 grams and it's wrapped. You don't keep slicing off another bit when it's wrapped. I find

xJoy · 08/02/2023 11:06

Here's a tip for anybody no the go, tesco do these little pouches of black pitted olives in brine, 70 grams., whether you're watching carbs or fat, they have fewer calories and fewer fat grams than a bag of crisps. I am off work today for a hospital apt but meeting a friend later. I just had a healthy porridge with frozen berries (again, tesco do frozen berries for 2 euro and that is enough to weigh out about 70 grams per day for 6 or 7 days. So much cheaper than buying fresh raspberries! anyway I'm heading off in to big bad dublin now and if I get hungry i have the pouch of olives in my bag and one kilmeaden cheese snack bar. Especially if you love cheese it's good to have these portioned out sizes. I know I know, packaging is excessive and it works out cheaper. But if you're on the go and afraid you'll be starving and order a carrot cake muffin with 580 calories :-p mmmmm that sounds lovely, figuring out what you can eat between meals if you are genuinely hungry will save you and in your case, with the intention to lower the cortisol levels, I wouldn't try and push through hunger for hours.

ThreeblackCats · 08/02/2023 11:05

Don’t buy the unhealthy snacks, biscuits etc. If you don’t have them,you can’t eat them.
Do buy veggies, fruit, cottage cheese with pineapple and nice crackers to snack on.

Add lots of veggies to your meals, make time for a short daily walk which will eventually become a long walk, nobody else can do this for you. There are no shortcuts, no easy way to do it. You have full responsibility but it can be done.

Remember it will not be quick but it’s not impossible.

Drink lots of water, I like fizzy water, but try the zero calories fruit water etc. You need to get used to a new way of life. But you absolutely can do this. You’ll feel so much better once you start losing weight.

Thatcatisdrivingmenuts · 08/02/2023 10:54

Really you don't need any weight loss processes or special diets to lose weight, once you get to the stage of being able to face it. Cut out sugar, refined (white) carbs, and massively up your veg intake to at least a third of every meal. Those things will help anyway, and might be enough.

tootiredtobother · 08/02/2023 10:16

Please get yourself the book by Jessie Inschape Glucose revolution, easiest weight I have ever los.t a year later its still off, and im ramping up my application of the method as two more stones would be fab, i doubt ill get back to the 11 stone i was when married, but im 60, 5ft 6 and through the menopause
Please try it, it was life changing

KnottyKnitting · 08/02/2023 10:15

I second trying intermittent fasting. If I stick to 16:8 ( I skip breakfast and cut down on the snacks) with a few 5:2 days thrown in - it really helps to loose the weight without totally depriving yourself.

The 5:2 days can be a bit hard to start with but once you get into a routine it is much easier.

I think it useful not to call it a diet but simply a "way of eating" and the mindset that I might not be able to have that bit of cake today but I can tomorrow, or not feeling guilty about having a little treat with lunch on a non fast day is much easier than totally denying yourself something or giving up on a diet when you fall off the wagon.

Good luck

Snowpaw · 08/02/2023 10:12

Do you have stairs at your place of work you can use instead of taking the lift? Can you park a bit further away from work and walk part of the way there? Or go on a brisk walk on your lunch break? Is there a local responsible teenager you could use to watch your kids, just for say 1 hr in the evening while you go on a walk a few times a week?

I lost a stone just by walking more, when my DD was about 2. I felt very down on myself and like I had no time or energy to do it, but I managed it. I didn't really change what I ate, I just prioritised going on a brisk walk every day. It really helped me. You don't have to embark on any kind of fad diet or massive change in the way you live. Just carve out a little bit of time for you every day and it will all add up.

BarrelOfOtters · 08/02/2023 10:11

And I bought the Paul McKenna book and listened to his hypnosis talks. I think that's helped too....

BarrelOfOtters · 08/02/2023 10:10

I'm in a similar position to you, it all crept on last year, I finally got on the scales after Christmas and from being a stone overweight I'm now 3.5 stone overweight.

I'm concentrating on eating more protein and veg, fairly simple meals, but definitely more veg. I know I feel better when I do. Still eat carbs but try and make most of meal veg and protein.

So I've got frozen fish in that I can cook from frozen, chicken thighs, prawns.

It's working, slowly, but it's working. I'm also walking every day. I used to be fit and getting fitter is motivating me. I'm feeling more like my old self and sleeping better.

Small steps.

xJoy · 08/02/2023 10:07

re-reading I see you're 50 @forelogger I just went on hrt, tiny patch, and I lost half a kilo finally after three weeks of a plateau.
Not saying that i didn't eat rings around myself the last two years, but I think being 50 can bring with it a load of extra challenges (hormonally)

My BMR is not as as high as the calculators would tell me, due to be short, old, metabolic adaptation, I don't knoiw! But now, if I ate my BMR I'd put on weight!

I must look at the operation transformation site. I stopped watching that show years ago because they started having a few people who ''weren't fat'' in my opinion! I was outraged Grin They may have been overweight medically but to me they looked fine! So in protest I stopped watching. I can laugh at myself now. I think it was a message to the complacent. And I switched off instead of tuning in! I used to like to watch OT feeling (comparatively) slim and by putting people with a BMI of 29 on the show they robbed me of my comfort.

At the moment, i'm trying to ''reverse diet'' 5 days a week and eat only 800 the other two. It's two new to tell if it will work. Week one. I hit a plateau. So I agree it's good to reduce your calories gradually to avoid metabolic adaptation.
If you go down to 1200 your body can adapt so don't go so low (as I did, I regret it now).

Hydrangeatea · 08/02/2023 10:04

I lost 3 stone a few years ago and what worked for me that was different to what I had done before was to cut down to 1800-1900 calories a day rather than try to cut down to 1200-1500 which was just unsustainable.

I went to Team RH and to James Smith Academy and used their TDEE calculators and basically one told me I needed 1900 cals a day and the other told me 1700 so I compromised and said I would do 1800 which I sometimes went over on.

I didn't care what I ate in those calories and didn't get myself worked up if I ate 800 calories of cake a day and 1,000 calories of other meals. I just stuck to that and lost 3 stone in about 8/9 months.

I do quite a bit of exercise but the calculators for that are ALWAYS wrong! I have tried fit bits, garmin, apple watch, my exercise equipment etc and every single one of them was out as they would say I was burning 900+ of activity calories a day yet simple maths and how much weight I lost over those 9 months proved that not to be the case so I always ignore the exercise and NEVER eat exercise calories back. I lost about 1.2lbs a week, generally by dropping 2-2.5lbs every 12-14 days.

For the first time in my adult life I have also managed to keep it off by sticking with the same approach but having around 2200-2400 calories a day and eating what I like for those calories.

I know not all calories are equal, I know I would be healthier if I ate more protein and veg but somedays I just fancy a cake/ice cream day and that's what I have! One thing I did give up was alcohol as that was pure empty calories.

Good luck, it doesn't have to be too complicated.

Hydrangeatea · 08/02/2023 09:55

Hop27 · 07/02/2023 20:07

Stop immediately not eating until 11:30. That will not be helping you and ultimately will be fuelling your poor food choices.
Is there a reason why you are doing that?
Work out your BMR ( the calories you need to survive) and then work out a deficit, 20% with little exercise will see you drop a small amount a week, that will lead to sustained weight loss. Accept the fact you are eating more than you think.
Happy to work out your BMR if you'd happy to share your activity levels, height, age and weight.
You can do this OP, both options are hard there is no easy solution but if you don't sort it now it will impact your lifespan and future quality of life for your children.

Think you are getting your BMR and your TDEE mixed up.

Most peoples BMR will be around 1400-1600 calories a day, to take away 20% of this is far too much for someone already struggling.

forelogger · 08/02/2023 09:32

I'm delighted that this thread has given some solidarity to others. There seems to be many of us !
I am on hrt.. only recently stabilised so I expect some positive mood changes .. the rage I felt was no one's business !!!
I've loaded up my work bag with fruit, celery sticks, low fat hummus and soups. I will do a tesco online shop through my break or even start to add bits.
I think it's the examining products for calories, working out how much I can eat and prep so I'm going to try to get as much prepped veg to start with .
Maybe some social media calorie deficit experts could help to relieve the boredom of it.
I'm also interested in podcast, Hypnosis , and meditation as I can easily do that in bed . I go to bed very early now for peace and privacy.
My GP agreed that going back to my counsellor was number one to reset.
We are kind of friends so she was very honest about her own attempts to stay within a frame where she was comfortable .
We would have been the same build and always hovered around ten and half stone at school.
She recommended local personal nutritionists just to have that person to motivate me locally but who have strong on line presence also as my phone is always with me and I can and do communicate mostly through it with people .
Gp looks super and you wouldn't think she ever battled with it ! But she does and calorie Counts as she said she had to make completely different meals for herself as chicken and a massive salad followed by yoghurts and fruit will not cut the mustard with her teens... I get that!!
Thank you ,thank you , thank you !

If anyone knows of podcasts, hypnosis on line, videos, audiobooks to support us, I'd really appreciate that. There seems to be endless lists of them but personal recommendations are unbeatable and again ,thanks for all thusfar.

OP posts:
livingthegoodlife · 08/02/2023 09:28

I think dropping to 1250cal might be a bit of a shock, I think you'd still see results with 1500.

Try the Hairy Dieters books. It's full of healthy recipes which are easy & have all the calories written down. I meal plan a whole week and write a long shopping list so I know I have all the ingredients.

My food today (aiming for 1200)

Breakfast: soft boiled egg (72), porridge made with water (111) and handful blueberries (42)

Lunch: chicken soup (162) + apple (75)

Afternoon snack: banana (105)

Dinner: beef Ragu (232) plus green veg (100)
Yoghurt (55)

Mini choc bar (83)

According to mfp I'm a bit high in sugar today but I won't be hungry.

Hope this helps.

Spudina · 08/02/2023 09:26

My friend lost loads of weight just doing Leslie Sansone walking YouTube videos. They are walking on the spot briskly (5 kms in an hour) You could put this on and let the kids do it with you (or not) so you don’t even have to leave the house. On weekends take them out and do walks. Get some healthy snacks in and stop buying junk. You can do this!! I actually singed up for one of the Conqueror virtual walking challenges which has been amazing for me, but I get that’s not so easy when you are a single parent. Good luck OP.

MooBaggage · 08/02/2023 09:17

I found this thread by chance this morning - on the day I've finally gone to the GP this morning to ask for anti depressants... Lots going on in my life but as a result, or maybe partly because, I'm currently about 6 stone overweight and realise I need to do something about it.

I'm 54, on HRT, recently separated and struggling with all aspects of life, including my weight. Am hoping that Sertraline and making small changes starts to make an impact over the coming months, so will also take on board all the small things that people are suggesting.

A few months ago I was doing some Get Fit with Rick walking exercise videos - they're brilliant! He does 10/15/30 min videos - all walking (but fast!) and to different mainly 80's artists - the get fit with Whitney was definitely my favourite..! I've got out of the habit due to life stuff, but am going to do Whitney today, to try to start the good habits again.

Thanks @forelogger for starting this thread and I hope you have a good day - it's the only place to start 🙂

Strongboat · 08/02/2023 08:12

Did you talk to the doctor about how low and hopeless you feel?

itsgettingweird · 08/02/2023 08:06

forelogger · 07/02/2023 19:44

I can do intermittent fasting as I don't eat until 1130 amyway.
I think my downfall is being unprepared and picking up anything I can get
My hands on when hungry.
I really do not each a massive amount of food or even thousands of calories.
It's gone in over about 15 years but mainly in the last three .

I get you. I was exactly the same and adjusting my diet so I wasn't getting those hunger pangs really has helped me and I've lost 9lb in 5 weeks.

I'm a huge believer in doing it slowly and not denying yourself anything because lifestyle changes for the long term should be the aim.

My biggest change has been making overnight oats with muller yoghurts. I use the toffee or cinnamon ones which are really tasty and quite sweet.

Because it's made I don't need to worry about time in the morning.

Then having cous cous for lunch. Again I make a few days at a time to avoid the lack of time issue.

Boil eggs for a few days.

Swapped crisps for lentil chips. The popper ones are lovely.

I'm also consciously walking more. Just parking a bit further away (which for me is difficult as my ds is disabled and when with him use a disabled bay right outside where we are going!).

Jogging on the spot whilst cooking. Standing to watch tv whilst cooking or inbetween jobs and marching on the spot.

What has surprised me the most is that by eating more healthily and refusing to deny myself nice foods if I want them I've naturally cut back in them. I'm not hungry and so don't want that whole bar of galaxy caramel as a quick fix. I don't want a whole packet of biscuits because I'm full.

I was 14st 9 at the beginning of the year and I'm now 13st 14.

Like you with my height I can carry it ok - but the top end of normal is 11st 12 for up our height.

I'm realistic that's unlikely and so have set myself an initial realistic goal of 13st and after that will consider my next move!

Iceysuperslide · 08/02/2023 08:01

My friend has just lost a stone over the last 5 months.
She eats dinner from a small plate now, an old one from the 1970’s, hardly ever drinks alcohol and has stopped snacking. She also does a couple of exercise classes a week.

Be careful eating too much fruit. My family are prone to diabetes my sisters were told two pieces of fruit a day max.

Bubblebubblebah · 08/02/2023 07:58

forelogger · 08/02/2023 07:33

Thanks for all your overnight posts.
So many great stories and positive ideas. I need to figure out how many calories I need to spend in a day to lose 1-2 lbs per week. I think that's reasonable and sustainable to begin with ?
That looks like 1250 cal per day I think , if my bmr is 1600?
I will find some YouTube videos to support me at night . Helpful to go to sleep too especially if there is a 🛏 hypnosis element to it !
Does anyone know what a 1250 cal day looks like? I guess lots of bulking veg and fruit to begin anyway?
Maybe there are meal plans on Google . I will check.
Again, thank you all kindly 😊

There is difference between BMR and TDEE. One is base and one is with your daily expenditure from your normal moving etc.
Don't go too low for you. There are calculators yo calculate how many calories.
For example this tdeecalculator.net/
Then you adjust as you go based on your results in few weeks