Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

EA not telling us about offers coming in!

135 replies

Sellsellseller · 06/02/2023 15:30

We are selling a house. Turns out the estate agent has not put two offers to us by someone who wants to buy our house. One offer was over the asking price. The reason seems to be because the buyer won’t go with the estate agents mortgage and solicitors (to help them hit more sales targets).

The reason I know this is because the buyer has popped a note through my door also with a print out of an email the estate agent sent them basically saying she can’t guarantee the property to the buyer unless she goes with their in-house services.

We have a contract with the estate agent, does them not putting offers forward to us void the contract?

AIBU to pull the contract and sell to her privately or will I end up still having to pay agency fees if that doesn’t make the contract void?

OP posts:
AlanThePig · 09/02/2023 22:06

it doesn’t surprise me.
when DH and I bought our current home it had been with the EA for a few months (simpler times lol). The owners had it as a rental managed by the EA but if was up for sale or rent. We desperately wanted to buy and had decided on seeing it from the outside alone that we wanted it.
called the EA who told us that they couldn’t pass on our details. They were obstructive and quite rude.

A bit of detective work and I tracked the owner down via Facebook, unfortunately a day too late as it had been rented with a 12 month agreement. We carried on looking but nothing really came close to this house for us. The owner contacted us at the end of the 12 months and we met for a coffee and agreed to buy, involving no EAs.
Our seller eventually sued the EA for mismanagement and included their refusal to pass on interest in her case. She did win and got all her management fees etc back.

Im probably pig headed enough to speak to my solicitor and see if I can extracts myself from the agent to be honest OP. Good luck.

BananaSpanner · 09/02/2023 21:56

This has been going on for several days. What have you done about it?

StillWantingADog · 09/02/2023 21:53

Sounds altogether very dodgy but have you not asked the agent what they are playing at?

it does sound like you were a bit offhand with the lady that came round. I’d be taking down numbers and asking them to put in offers again once the issue with the agent is sorted. As pp suggested, mentioning getting in touch with the the ombudsman is likely to get them to fall in line.

best case scenario though is get them to agree they’ve broken the contract and either instruct a different agent or buyer directly if you have one you’re happy to deal with

SnarkyBag · 09/02/2023 21:47

Sellsellseller · 09/02/2023 21:32

UPDATE! It gets worse!

I haven’t read all the posts yet but will.

Had another lady knock on our door last night, the estate agents are saying they can’t guarantee her the property unless she goes with their in house services too. She lives not too far so knocked to explain to us that she already has a mortgage in principle and is desperate to stay with them as she has a good rate and would we please reconsider!!

We said the EA can’t promise it to anyone as we’re selling it to who we choose and also we don’t care what mortgage people you go with.

So that’s 2 people now. The EA has probably put other people off who would have offered but just accepted the response from them (and maybe didn’t want to knock on our door to plead their case)

Can you believe this! This is a well known ea around these parts too.

Have you not challenged the estate agent yet?

DashboardConfessional · 09/02/2023 21:42

They are not allowed to do this. They can be fined by the regulator. Tell them you know they're doing this and you want all the offers right now or you will complain to the ombudsman.

larchforest · 09/02/2023 21:42

Sellsellseller · 06/02/2023 16:07

All I have is a letter from the lady and also the fact I know the estate agent hasn’t told me about the second and third offer and a few text messages exchanged between the two of us including an email about how the EA can’t guarantee the property to her without her using in house services.

Basically they know she wants my home and bullying her to go with their mortgage guy instead but she said no and had a feeling they wasn’t putting her offers through so dropped a note through my door and it’s true as they didn’t tell me about her other offers

What does the agent mean by they "can't guarantee the property to her without her using in house services"?

They are an agent. It isn't their house to sell, it's yours. I wouldn't be happy about that at all. There shouldn't be anything stopping you from selling the house to whoever you want to, whether they use the agent for their other services or not.

I would be livid.

LookItsMeAgain · 09/02/2023 21:38

@Sellsellseller - please bring this to the attention of your solicitor so that they can advise you if it's possible to break your contract with the EA with no financial penalties.

Your EA has not lived up to their legal requirements at their end of the contract so I would be hoping that you can leave without having to pay them anything, not even their printing and advertising fees.

Please check with your solicitor though.

Sellsellseller · 09/02/2023 21:32

UPDATE! It gets worse!

I haven’t read all the posts yet but will.

Had another lady knock on our door last night, the estate agents are saying they can’t guarantee her the property unless she goes with their in house services too. She lives not too far so knocked to explain to us that she already has a mortgage in principle and is desperate to stay with them as she has a good rate and would we please reconsider!!

We said the EA can’t promise it to anyone as we’re selling it to who we choose and also we don’t care what mortgage people you go with.

So that’s 2 people now. The EA has probably put other people off who would have offered but just accepted the response from them (and maybe didn’t want to knock on our door to plead their case)

Can you believe this! This is a well known ea around these parts too.

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 09/02/2023 13:48

honeylulu · 07/02/2023 11:31

Isn’t it illegal to sell or rent a property without having seen it in person first?

No, why would it be? Overseas buyers do it all the time. Are you thinking of caveat emptor (buyer beware)? I.e. the buyer is responsible for undertaking its own enquiries - viewings, surveys etc. But you can opt for no enquiries. It doesn't make the sale "illegal".

Bought my last house without viewing.
Bought a couple of flats without viewing,

If I had waited to view I would have missed out on buying

honeylulu · 07/02/2023 11:34

OP this is serious misconduct by the EA, a breach of the duty of mutual trust and confidence. You can propose to terminate the contract on this basis so they don't get the commission if you sell to this buyer. They are likely to resist but I suggest if you propose to refer the issue to the Ombudsman they will rapidly back off and let you go as they are in a very difficult position, professionally and legally.

honeylulu · 07/02/2023 11:31

Isn’t it illegal to sell or rent a property without having seen it in person first?

No, why would it be? Overseas buyers do it all the time. Are you thinking of caveat emptor (buyer beware)? I.e. the buyer is responsible for undertaking its own enquiries - viewings, surveys etc. But you can opt for no enquiries. It doesn't make the sale "illegal".

Greentree1 · 07/02/2023 11:25

I would play innocent and tell the agent you have had a message from someone who is interesting in buying (and has already been in touch with the agency), were the agency waiting for more offers before discussing with you? You think it looks like a good offer, etc.

Years ago we were interested in buying a house, the agent told us not to talk to the seller as they were 'fragile', we later found out someone (who did talk to the seller) bought the house for less than we were willing to pay. Another house we were interested in at the time was bought (privately) by one of the agents selling it, at a knock down price. I had hoped things would have changed, but probably not a lot!

America12 · 07/02/2023 11:20

This happened to me as a buyer.
I ended up not buying the property but the seller sacked the agent.

Sirius3030 · 07/02/2023 11:08

Why can't you just go in and have a polite conversation with them in person? You will hear their version of events and then you can make an informed decision. Seems fairly straightforward to me.

Jmaho · 07/02/2023 11:03

This happened to us about 8 years ago
We put an offer in on a house we liked through a very large national firm
We had already SSTC. They didn't pass our offer on as we wouldn't have an interview with their mortgage advisor. This was despite me working in mortgages myself and at the time being able to get a discounted staff rate. They still insisted we speak to their advisor as they were sure they could get us a better deal
We ended up finding a different house

ncedforthisone · 07/02/2023 10:41

(not a lawyer, so perhaps I misunderstood what I read.)

ncedforthisone · 07/02/2023 10:39

I had this, where an EA did not want to put my offer through because I was not willing to use their mortgage services. I already had a mortgage broker, who had put time and energy into helping me get a decision-in-principle, etc., and felt bad then going with someone else! They refused to put my offer through to the seller. The estate agent said the sellers insisted on the buyer using in-house services. 🤔

I have no idea if this is true. I wish I had reached out to the buyer directly, but felt this was intrusive, and was afraid they would not believe me. (I was told in person by an estate agent.)

At the time, I looked into their standard of practice. It appears they have a non-binding kind of charter for the profession. It is not illegal for them to not put through an offer on the basis of not being willing to use in-house services, but it is considered unethical.

Kennykenkencat · 07/02/2023 10:33

The reason I know this is because the buyer has popped a note through my door also with a print out of an email the estate agent sent them basically saying she can’t guarantee the property to the buyer unless she goes with their in-house services

I had this with a buyer phoning my private home telephone number complaining that the EA had guaranteed her the house as she had paid them a deposit (£50) to hold it for her. I had to point out the EA were agents and couldn’t guarantee anything as they didn’t own the property

We had gone with someone who was offering the full asking price

Bluebellysmell · 07/02/2023 10:21

Not Foxton was it?

Chickenly · 07/02/2023 10:09

99percentchocolate · 07/02/2023 10:03

Isn’t it illegal to sell or rent a property without having seen it in person first?

No?! Why on earth would that be illegal?

CowSnail · 07/02/2023 10:08

Was it Connells? They did the same to us.

99percentchocolate · 07/02/2023 10:03

Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 06/02/2023 17:06

When I was selling last year, an offer was made by someone who hadn’t seen the flat. The EA took it upon themselves to tell them that they wouldn’t put forward an offer until they’d actually seen the property. I have no idea what the logic was behind this. Fortunately, they still wanted the flat after they saw it.

When the flat was sold, the EA asked me if I’d give them a 5* rating. I said, politely, not a chance. Strangely, the customer service questionnaire never arrived in my inbox.

Isn’t it illegal to sell or rent a property without having seen it in person first?

bilbodog · 07/02/2023 09:57

Ive worked in EA - they HAVE TO report any offers received and should always put them in writing as well. I would speak to the manager or above and ask for a list of all offers received so far as well as speaking to your solicitor. Hope you manage to sort it out.

BatshitBanshee · 07/02/2023 09:54

Sellsellseller · 06/02/2023 16:27

Haha! The good reputation! Spat my coffee out laughing at that one. You’ve made me smile : )

"Good reputation" also made me chuckle.

Can you go back to prospective buyer and ask them for proof of their follow up offers?

In any case I would speak to solicitor pronto and ask them where you stand before I engage with the EA anymore.

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 07/02/2023 09:51

I'd be ensuring this estate agent made no money from my sale. Can't abide this below counter unprofessional conduct.