Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Super nanny

267 replies

Marmaladeoncrumpets · 06/02/2023 14:59

Watched what I assume was an old show on tv today (is super nanny still going?) and fairly shocked by the tactics used. I remember seeing it on Sunday mornings many years ago, before dc and Dh and I saying to each other, what a nightmare having kids looked, as we lounged around probably hungover and with no commitments for the day 🤣
I do remember thinking she was great, but then, I had no kids or no idea 🤷🏻‍♀️
Did you ever follow her?

OP posts:
5128gap · 06/02/2023 19:32

jannier · 06/02/2023 19:02

I think they say oh dear I understand your upset it's okay to be upset take a deep breath and give me a hug let's talk it out.
Adults would be called abusive and leave them.

Indeed. A child learns that an episode of violence is met with increased affection and that their feelings are of paramount importance regardless of the behaviour in which they manifest; that if they are antisocial or aggressive, then that is the fault of another person for not meeting their needs.
I wouldn't like to be a partner who one day may reap what parents who follow this trend sow.

Choconut · 06/02/2023 19:27

I think she encourages calm consistency which is often lacking in the households she visits. She also encourages parents to get down to their children's level and to talk and really listen to them.

I never understood time out really though, it just seemed an enormous amount of unnecessary effort on the parents part for little reward. I mean no child is sitting on that step thinking about the wrongs of what they've done, let's face it - they're 3/4/5 years old! Having said that I know primary school teachers who used it with their kids and preschools that used it in the past. It's not for me though.

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 19:26

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 19:19

Obviously if my son is upset I'll deal with it differently.

But because they are not usually able to express their sadness, it might look like naughtiness, see? So your comment on he's not sad when he'd naughty doesn't hold water.

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 19:21

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 19:19

And if your partner hit you now in a similar way? What is the difference in your view? Not goading, just trying to point out the problem with it. I presume you don't plan on smacking your own.

I'm against that. And no I'm not going to smack my son. Just saying I have no issue with my parents

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 19:21

5128gap · 06/02/2023 19:19

Why? If you consider they brought you up well and you feel you're a competent confident adult as a result, why on earth would you not emulate them? Personally I'd take something my parents did that I knew from my own experience to be effective over the constantly changing trends pushed by 'experts' with money to make.

The experts I'm referring to are child and developmental psychologists, so not trends for making money.

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 19:19

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 19:01

Yes Emma, they often are, their behaviour, like our own when you think about, is most often a reflection of how they're feeling. So dealing with the feeling and helping them kindly through it, while preventing any hurtful or damaging behaviour, is much kinder. I wonder where you get your certainty that they're not sad when naughty? I assume you accept they might be angry? I'm hoping you don't think angry is not allowed.

Obviously if my son is upset I'll deal with it differently.

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 19:19

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 19:17

Well okay then but can guarantee most did. Some didn't. Like I said before I've got nothing against my parents for doing it.

And if your partner hit you now in a similar way? What is the difference in your view? Not goading, just trying to point out the problem with it. I presume you don't plan on smacking your own.

5128gap · 06/02/2023 19:19

SafeAsAHero · 06/02/2023 18:37

Doing something because your parents always did it is a terrible way to carry on.

Why? If you consider they brought you up well and you feel you're a competent confident adult as a result, why on earth would you not emulate them? Personally I'd take something my parents did that I knew from my own experience to be effective over the constantly changing trends pushed by 'experts' with money to make.

ReadtheReviews · 06/02/2023 19:17

I like her and enjoy her sorting out the relationships in the house. Always winced when she would say 'not asseptable' but suddenly in the recent ones she's saying it properly...and I sort of miss it. We quote it quite a bit.

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 19:17

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 19:02

Nope, was never smacked, not once (Mid 40s). No guarantee on that one.

Well okay then but can guarantee most did. Some didn't. Like I said before I've got nothing against my parents for doing it.

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 19:13

That's completely different tho needaholiday, that's a calm down, time in step by the sounds of it.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 06/02/2023 19:10

I used the step when dc were little. It wasn’t a punishment, more a safe space for them to be away from the situation and try to manage their own emotions. 2 of mine would be able to calm themselves but one of mine couldn’t - she has big emotions. She’d start to calm (stop looking like she was going to hit me and lash out) and I’d say “do you need help to calm down?” She’d say yes, and I’d give her a cuddle.

Different dc need different approaches and support. for me, the step was a safe space but also a clear boundary.

Iam4eels · 06/02/2023 19:05

Stillcountingbeans · 06/02/2023 18:54

So, please excuse my ignorance but what do you do instead of a 'naughty step' or time out?

Say a four, five or six year old throws a plate of food in a temper? Or stamps on a sibling's toy on purpose?

(Obviously it is a bad idea for a pre-verbal child or one who can't make the connection between behaviour and consequence.)

It depends on the behaviour and the situation.

First and foremost, presuming everyone is safe and not in any immediate harm, I would look at exactly what just happened and any reasons why it might have happened. Any consequences would be fitted to the action as much as possible - for example, throwing the food they would have to help clean it up and when I plate up a fresh meal it will consist of whatever is leftover so might not have their favourite bits or the deliberately broken toy they would have to buy a new one using what's in their piggy bank. We would talk about why they did what they did, how that's made other people/them feel, and what they could do differently next time to avoid it happening again. I also use it to inform my own parenting, for example if I realise that 5yr old gets volatile when overtired then I'd manage that situationin future so that I can pre-empt it and intervene before they reach the plate throwing stage.

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 19:05

gettingalifttothestation · 06/02/2023 19:01

Every programme I've watched has been brilliant. She sorts the parents out first. I bet all you saying she's rubbish have badly behaved kids

😆 🤣
Because there are no other options than this for well behaved children. And clearly behaviour is your priority.
The close mindedness on this thread is eye-opening, ironically!

Dyslexicwonder · 06/02/2023 19:05

Stillcountingbeans · 06/02/2023 18:54

So, please excuse my ignorance but what do you do instead of a 'naughty step' or time out?

Say a four, five or six year old throws a plate of food in a temper? Or stamps on a sibling's toy on purpose?

(Obviously it is a bad idea for a pre-verbal child or one who can't make the connection between behaviour and consequence.)

I'm a great believer of natural consequences. So throw your food on the floor - no food, misbehave at the park- go home, drink a bottle of vodka and end up needing to be rescued- grounded for a month.

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 19:02

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 19:00

Yeah well I love my parents. And I can guarantee all parents did it at some point

Nope, was never smacked, not once (Mid 40s). No guarantee on that one.

jannier · 06/02/2023 19:02

Stillcountingbeans · 06/02/2023 18:54

So, please excuse my ignorance but what do you do instead of a 'naughty step' or time out?

Say a four, five or six year old throws a plate of food in a temper? Or stamps on a sibling's toy on purpose?

(Obviously it is a bad idea for a pre-verbal child or one who can't make the connection between behaviour and consequence.)

I think they say oh dear I understand your upset it's okay to be upset take a deep breath and give me a hug let's talk it out.
Adults would be called abusive and leave them.

Noluthando · 06/02/2023 19:01

PinkButtercups · 06/02/2023 15:31

@SafeAsAHero You can't.
You cannot physically force feed a child. If they are not hungry they will not take it. Just like they wouldn't with being breastfed.

If you are tipping the bottle too steeply you can over feed via bottle before the baby realises they are too full.

gettingalifttothestation · 06/02/2023 19:01

Every programme I've watched has been brilliant. She sorts the parents out first. I bet all you saying she's rubbish have badly behaved kids

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 19:01

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 18:57

Erm nope not poor kid. He's going to get raised right and loved.

When they do something naughty they are not sad.

Yes Emma, they often are, their behaviour, like our own when you think about, is most often a reflection of how they're feeling. So dealing with the feeling and helping them kindly through it, while preventing any hurtful or damaging behaviour, is much kinder. I wonder where you get your certainty that they're not sad when naughty? I assume you accept they might be angry? I'm hoping you don't think angry is not allowed.

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 19:00

Iam4eels · 06/02/2023 18:59

You grew up thinking it was okay for your parents to physically assault a child, that's pretty far from alright.

Yeah well I love my parents. And I can guarantee all parents did it at some point

Iam4eels · 06/02/2023 18:59

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 18:53

I got smacked and turned out alright. Don't have anything against my parents for doing it but obviously not going to do that.

You grew up thinking it was okay for your parents to physically assault a child, that's pretty far from alright.

Dacadactyl · 06/02/2023 18:59

mikado1 · 06/02/2023 18:54

Would you not? I think it is worthwhile reading up on reasons behind things and going the informed route for my children's long-term emotional and mental health, and my own sanity, I wouldn't be able to keep returning a distressed toddler who's not capable of understanding or fully controlling their behaviour anyway. I guess we're all different.

I use techniques as I see appropriate at the time tbh. But if the words "you are going to stay there for 4 minutes" had left my mouth, that was what is going to happen, even if it took 90 minutes for them to do it.

My kids are 10 and 16 and they know I'm serious and will follow through with consequences, because I have always done so.

But like you say, we are all different and I don't think my parents did a bad job, so im ok with using them as a rule of thumb.

jannier · 06/02/2023 18:59

Led9519 · 06/02/2023 18:43

Don’t think there is one particularly but her rule was to return them to the naughty step over and over again until they did the full x minutes. Took this little girl 90 minutes to get there.

I would’ve just done an x minute time out regardless of the kid wondered and then calmed her down.

How can you have a time out with the kid wondering around doing what they want? Isn't that just saying do whatever you want child you kicked me never mind

Patineur · 06/02/2023 18:58

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 18:53

I got smacked and turned out alright. Don't have anything against my parents for doing it but obviously not going to do that.

I too turned out all right, I think, but it soured by relationship with my parents forever. I didn't use either smacking or the naughty step for my kids, who turned out great and used to get embarrassingly good school reports.