Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Super nanny

267 replies

Marmaladeoncrumpets · 06/02/2023 14:59

Watched what I assume was an old show on tv today (is super nanny still going?) and fairly shocked by the tactics used. I remember seeing it on Sunday mornings many years ago, before dc and Dh and I saying to each other, what a nightmare having kids looked, as we lounged around probably hungover and with no commitments for the day 🤣
I do remember thinking she was great, but then, I had no kids or no idea 🤷🏻‍♀️
Did you ever follow her?

OP posts:
PineappleMel · 07/02/2023 21:01

Intrepidescape · 06/02/2023 15:35

South Park did an episode on her where Cartman called her a sad lonely woman who couldn’t have children of her own.

Actually, Cartman said this to the first nanny. Fictional, I presume.

Jo came after and ended up in a mental ward after 3 days. I won't say what she was doing in the ward!

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 07/02/2023 19:32

I like super nanny and think she generally had the right idea that said I wonder how many of the children she worked with were neurodiverse, I suspect a lot of them. I remember some families were all the kids were okay but one poor child who struggled with everything.

Some of her techniques, for example, clear boundaries, routine and clear expectations would be useful for a child with ASC but technique's such as the naughty step would not have helped at all!!

My dd is a teen now and I suspect she is autistic, I tried the naughty step with her when she was younger and it was always completely counterproductive. It taught her nothing and made her behaviour worse.

celticprincess · 07/02/2023 19:05

I think she must have been around pre my kids possible?? Mine are 13 and under. However I did watch her shows out of great interest as a psychology graduate and a teacher. I then recall having my own kids and trying the naughty step and no chance!! However I later found out my child is autistic and non of her methods really work with ND kids. She’s basically parenting in an ABA type approach which works great with dogs!! I read a few ‘parenting’ books, watched a few shows, listened to a few fiends and family give their advice and then did my own thing that worked for me and my children.

What’s more interesting is Marie Kondo, the decluttering and tidying expert has given up on her own home now she has 3 (?) children of her own!! I’ve tried a lot of her methods too. They were great but didn’t last and didn’t take into consideration the constant barrage of gifts the kids get from friends and family and the amount of stuff they need for various activities they do.

PeachyIsThinking · 07/02/2023 19:01

I worked for a parenting charity at the time and most of our families used her methods.

I went in to know a lot more about SEN / neurodiversity (bother professionally and personally), and feel sad at the families whose now obvious neurodiversity were missed by everyone, and same for her techniques- behaviour is communication is the mantra we use now in the field, not whack them on a step until they conform.

purpleme12 · 07/02/2023 19:00

Iam4eels · 07/02/2023 18:44

I work in a school and our whole behaviour policy is based around emotional regulation (we use the zones of regulation system for all of the children) and helping to move disregulated children back to a regulated state. We use restorative consequences and we talk about intent vs impact, how their actions made them/other people feel, and so on.

It works very well and Ofated have noted behaviour in the school to be excellent so yes, we do have time in school for "gentle parenting bollocks".

Would you rather we were shouting at small children and turning discipline into a battle of wills? Breaking children in order to reshape them is a very outdated concept.

What do you do?
Willing to listen to any tips for my child

anya21 · 07/02/2023 18:56

Iam4eels · 07/02/2023 18:44

I work in a school and our whole behaviour policy is based around emotional regulation (we use the zones of regulation system for all of the children) and helping to move disregulated children back to a regulated state. We use restorative consequences and we talk about intent vs impact, how their actions made them/other people feel, and so on.

It works very well and Ofated have noted behaviour in the school to be excellent so yes, we do have time in school for "gentle parenting bollocks".

Would you rather we were shouting at small children and turning discipline into a battle of wills? Breaking children in order to reshape them is a very outdated concept.

who has talked about shouting at small children? Certainly not me, and not supernanny.I have never seen her yell at a child!

Iam4eels · 07/02/2023 18:44

anya21 · 07/02/2023 17:24

Well i would argue that the current younger generations are less mentally healthy and well adjusted than others before, certainly allthe available information shows this so....
i think you must have been watching a different show to me .JF talked a lot to the children about how they felt about things AS WELL AS implementing firm consistent boundaries. I dont think i ever saw her discipline a child simply for expressing feelings of frustration, jealousy and so on, only for their behaviour, A child NEEDS firm consistent boundaries as well as attention and guidance
Too many kids start school without ever having experienced firm boundaries.A teacher may have 30 , small children to cope with he/she does not have time to do all this gentle parenting bollocks. Parents need to have done some groundwork on kids doing as they are told!

I work in a school and our whole behaviour policy is based around emotional regulation (we use the zones of regulation system for all of the children) and helping to move disregulated children back to a regulated state. We use restorative consequences and we talk about intent vs impact, how their actions made them/other people feel, and so on.

It works very well and Ofated have noted behaviour in the school to be excellent so yes, we do have time in school for "gentle parenting bollocks".

Would you rather we were shouting at small children and turning discipline into a battle of wills? Breaking children in order to reshape them is a very outdated concept.

anya21 · 07/02/2023 18:25

Rhino94 · 07/02/2023 17:53

My dc have consistent and firm boundaries and I have been using “gentle parenting” this is what it is about while helping them emotionally regulate amongst other things. What you are probably mistaking it with is permissive parenting which is not upholding boundaries for fear of upsetting the child. They are doing fantastic at school, they definitely know boundaries!

can i ask how you uphold your firm boundaries, when the child is just not listening?

Dacadactyl · 07/02/2023 18:17

SweetMeadow · 07/02/2023 18:04

Wait to advocate for an alternative approach that is based on common sense and science? It’s early days but I’m already seeing the benefits with my eldest.

We all do what we think is best for our own family and as we see fit.

I don't mind one bit if someone else wants to use gentle parenting, but in my view, this is not the way forward for my children. My approach is based on how my family have doen things for generations. We are strict, have certain expectations and ways of doing things.

If my child feels they want to do things differently with their children, they can do so. I do some thing differently to my parents too, but on the whole they are my template.

SweetMeadow · 07/02/2023 18:04

Dacadactyl · 07/02/2023 16:49

Mine are 16 and 10 so I'm a lot further forward in this journey. Might be an idea to wait until yours are older (and you have some idea of the results of your parenting) yourself.

Wait to advocate for an alternative approach that is based on common sense and science? It’s early days but I’m already seeing the benefits with my eldest.

SweetMeadow · 07/02/2023 18:01

anya21 · 07/02/2023 17:24

Well i would argue that the current younger generations are less mentally healthy and well adjusted than others before, certainly allthe available information shows this so....
i think you must have been watching a different show to me .JF talked a lot to the children about how they felt about things AS WELL AS implementing firm consistent boundaries. I dont think i ever saw her discipline a child simply for expressing feelings of frustration, jealousy and so on, only for their behaviour, A child NEEDS firm consistent boundaries as well as attention and guidance
Too many kids start school without ever having experienced firm boundaries.A teacher may have 30 , small children to cope with he/she does not have time to do all this gentle parenting bollocks. Parents need to have done some groundwork on kids doing as they are told!

Gentle parenting is all about firm boundaries. And it requires a lot of groundwork - that’s what it’s all about.

Rhino94 · 07/02/2023 17:53

anya21 · 07/02/2023 17:24

Well i would argue that the current younger generations are less mentally healthy and well adjusted than others before, certainly allthe available information shows this so....
i think you must have been watching a different show to me .JF talked a lot to the children about how they felt about things AS WELL AS implementing firm consistent boundaries. I dont think i ever saw her discipline a child simply for expressing feelings of frustration, jealousy and so on, only for their behaviour, A child NEEDS firm consistent boundaries as well as attention and guidance
Too many kids start school without ever having experienced firm boundaries.A teacher may have 30 , small children to cope with he/she does not have time to do all this gentle parenting bollocks. Parents need to have done some groundwork on kids doing as they are told!

My dc have consistent and firm boundaries and I have been using “gentle parenting” this is what it is about while helping them emotionally regulate amongst other things. What you are probably mistaking it with is permissive parenting which is not upholding boundaries for fear of upsetting the child. They are doing fantastic at school, they definitely know boundaries!

Dacadactyl · 07/02/2023 17:37

anya21 · 07/02/2023 17:24

Well i would argue that the current younger generations are less mentally healthy and well adjusted than others before, certainly allthe available information shows this so....
i think you must have been watching a different show to me .JF talked a lot to the children about how they felt about things AS WELL AS implementing firm consistent boundaries. I dont think i ever saw her discipline a child simply for expressing feelings of frustration, jealousy and so on, only for their behaviour, A child NEEDS firm consistent boundaries as well as attention and guidance
Too many kids start school without ever having experienced firm boundaries.A teacher may have 30 , small children to cope with he/she does not have time to do all this gentle parenting bollocks. Parents need to have done some groundwork on kids doing as they are told!

100% this and I'd 'like' it a thousand times if I could.

I would also say that you can be a "strict" parent and your child can grow up to be empathic and emotionally regulated.

Rhino94 · 07/02/2023 17:28

Dacadactyl · 07/02/2023 16:49

Mine are 16 and 10 so I'm a lot further forward in this journey. Might be an idea to wait until yours are older (and you have some idea of the results of your parenting) yourself.

I can imagine they will grow up to be great empathetic and emotionally regulated adults

TimeToFlyNow · 07/02/2023 17:27

Dacadactyl · 07/02/2023 16:49

Mine are 16 and 10 so I'm a lot further forward in this journey. Might be an idea to wait until yours are older (and you have some idea of the results of your parenting) yourself.

Mine are 28, 20, 12 and 10. I'm quite glad I didn't find mn until 11 years ago!

anya21 · 07/02/2023 17:24

SweetMeadow · 07/02/2023 09:13

There is an astounding lack of knowledge about child development in many of these posts which is so sad. Super Nanny was horrendous and some of these comments about children growing up to be narcissists because everything is made to be about them is depressing. If we want a better society and world for our children, it starts with understanding and implementing developmentally appropriate parenting for the individual child. That’s absolutely not time out, CIO, punishments. I could go on but a read of what actually gentle parenting is would enlighten many. Sadly I think it’s too convenient for people to be negative about it because the ‘it never did me any harm’ narrative is easier parenting and gentle parenting is much harder but a brilliant investment in a child’s future. And let’s face it, we need happy, well adjusted and healthy children for the future to help us get out of some of the mess previous generations have created.

Well i would argue that the current younger generations are less mentally healthy and well adjusted than others before, certainly allthe available information shows this so....
i think you must have been watching a different show to me .JF talked a lot to the children about how they felt about things AS WELL AS implementing firm consistent boundaries. I dont think i ever saw her discipline a child simply for expressing feelings of frustration, jealousy and so on, only for their behaviour, A child NEEDS firm consistent boundaries as well as attention and guidance
Too many kids start school without ever having experienced firm boundaries.A teacher may have 30 , small children to cope with he/she does not have time to do all this gentle parenting bollocks. Parents need to have done some groundwork on kids doing as they are told!

jannier · 07/02/2023 16:58

DragonHouse · 07/02/2023 11:53

The information is readily available out there if they cared to find out. They’re just not bothered to put in the effort.

How do you put in the effort if your not aware of any issue....there are no gentle parenting TV shows so where do they find out that there are alternatives. Most gentle parents don't even get it right.

Dacadactyl · 07/02/2023 16:49

SweetMeadow · 07/02/2023 13:43

A one year old and a 4 year old. I’m wondering if you will tell me that I ought to wait a bit longer before I come to my conclusions? How old are yours?

I am still learning how to parent my children and I imagine I always will. But for now, I personally feel keeping informed with the latest research on children’s neurological and emotional development helps. To be fair though, it’s not so complicated to treat your children with respect whilst holding firm boundaries.

Mine are 16 and 10 so I'm a lot further forward in this journey. Might be an idea to wait until yours are older (and you have some idea of the results of your parenting) yourself.

Lottapianos · 07/02/2023 16:25

'He's loved and cherished. You are NOT witnesses. Have no fucking clue.'

You're doing a huge amount of protesting for someone who had had enough of the 'judgemental bitches' on here and was leaving the thread yesterday

Emmamoo89 · 07/02/2023 15:58

DragonHouse · 07/02/2023 09:01

And what fears and anxieties are being projected here?

It is not “attacking” to call our child abuse. That is every human’s job.

I know I'm not a perfect parent. I don't make out to be but I know I'm a fantastic mother because my son is looked after. I wouldn't harm a hair on his body. I love him so fucking much. Everyone parents differently and not going to take any notice of strangers on the Internet. I've never abused my son and if you could see him you'd see that he hasn't been abused. He's loved and cherished. You are NOT witnesses. Have no fucking clue.

SweetMeadow · 07/02/2023 14:36

Boomboom22 · 07/02/2023 14:24

But @SweetMeadow that is what she advocated for! Understanding.g children and boundaries. You may be too young to have seen her actual methods. She doesn't do xry it out, she sat next to then quietly showing she wasn't leaving. Time out is all about reflection and why they did it not punishment. Your own lack of understanding of how her theories fit into child development theories tells me you do not understand gentle parenting and are likely a permissive parent.

Sadly I’m definitely not too young to have watched her programme in the UK. I think I actually thought a lot of it was reasonable at the time.

Do you think a child of say, 3 or 4 has the mental capacity or emotional maturity to reflect or think about what they have done wrong? They honestly don’t. Beyond 7, maybe they can start but when a child is sat ‘thinking’ about what they’ve done ‘wrong’, they are feeling like love has been withdrawn and not understanding why.

And with respect to CIO. You may be still sat next to them but the baby may still be distressed because it needs your touch. The baby won’t understand why that’s being withdrawn.

Finally, I am definitely not a permissive parent - that would also be an easy option and in my opinion, not in the best interests of the child. I absolutely understand what gentle parenting is. I’ve spent the last four years immersed in it, making mistakes and trying again. And as I said before, we can throw around labels of parenting but when did treating your child with respect, disciplining in accordance with age appropriate behaviour and expectations and firm boundaries get so controversial?

DragonHouse · 07/02/2023 14:32

Boomboom22 · 07/02/2023 14:24

But @SweetMeadow that is what she advocated for! Understanding.g children and boundaries. You may be too young to have seen her actual methods. She doesn't do xry it out, she sat next to then quietly showing she wasn't leaving. Time out is all about reflection and why they did it not punishment. Your own lack of understanding of how her theories fit into child development theories tells me you do not understand gentle parenting and are likely a permissive parent.

Time out is not about “reflection”. It’s an attempt to shut the child’s emotions down and shut them up.

When children have big feelings they need their caregiver to coregulate with them. Dismissing the child, and reacting with an action that is not a natural consequence (as all discipline should be), does not teach them anything not allow them to work through their emotions with you.

Boomboom22 · 07/02/2023 14:24

But @SweetMeadow that is what she advocated for! Understanding.g children and boundaries. You may be too young to have seen her actual methods. She doesn't do xry it out, she sat next to then quietly showing she wasn't leaving. Time out is all about reflection and why they did it not punishment. Your own lack of understanding of how her theories fit into child development theories tells me you do not understand gentle parenting and are likely a permissive parent.

Lottapianos · 07/02/2023 14:10

'@SweetMeadow absolutely agree with everything you’ve said!'

Same here. Too many parents seem to do whatever is most convenient to themselves in the moment, and have little thought for the impact on their children. Some parents seem actively resistant to learning anything about how children develop and what they need at various stages

Rhino94 · 07/02/2023 14:07

@SweetMeadow absolutely agree with everything you’ve said!

Swipe left for the next trending thread