Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Super nanny

267 replies

Marmaladeoncrumpets · 06/02/2023 14:59

Watched what I assume was an old show on tv today (is super nanny still going?) and fairly shocked by the tactics used. I remember seeing it on Sunday mornings many years ago, before dc and Dh and I saying to each other, what a nightmare having kids looked, as we lounged around probably hungover and with no commitments for the day 🤣
I do remember thinking she was great, but then, I had no kids or no idea 🤷🏻‍♀️
Did you ever follow her?

OP posts:
Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 17:59

SafeAsAHero · 06/02/2023 17:54

You can absolutely overfeed a bottlefed baby because they have the sucking reflex, so they can and do take more than they need because they’re sucking on a comfort level too.

I think you definitely can in the early days. My son is 10 months and will move his head when he's had enough like when I give him expressed breast milk

SafeAsAHero · 06/02/2023 17:54

PinkButtercups · 06/02/2023 15:31

@SafeAsAHero You can't.
You cannot physically force feed a child. If they are not hungry they will not take it. Just like they wouldn't with being breastfed.

You can absolutely overfeed a bottlefed baby because they have the sucking reflex, so they can and do take more than they need because they’re sucking on a comfort level too.

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 17:54

PinkButtercups · 06/02/2023 15:21

She's useless. I actually saw an old clip the other day where she was telling a couple they were over feeding their newborn baby... you can't over feed a baby and the baby has 'no routine' this baby was about 2 weeks old!!

You can overfeed a bottle fed baby. Can't a breastfed baby

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 17:53

Toddlerteaplease · 06/02/2023 17:45

You absolutely can over feed a bottle fed baby!

You can over feed a bottle fed baby. Its breastfed that you can't

Emmamoo89 · 06/02/2023 17:52

Nothing wrong with the naughty step

Edthehorse · 06/02/2023 17:46

We used the naughty step and the stay in bed technique when going from cot to toddler bed. Worked a treat!

Hasn't scarred my child at all and they are a very well behaved pre teen

Toddlerteaplease · 06/02/2023 17:45

PinkButtercups · 06/02/2023 15:21

She's useless. I actually saw an old clip the other day where she was telling a couple they were over feeding their newborn baby... you can't over feed a baby and the baby has 'no routine' this baby was about 2 weeks old!!

You absolutely can over feed a bottle fed baby!

zingerdoo · 06/02/2023 17:41

I thought she was great when I used to watch her years ago- many years before I had kids! I've also rewatched some recently and there's no way we'd use any of her methods such as naughty step etc with our daughter. I was very surprised at how strongly I disagreed with alot of what she did.

Her style would be really counter to how we parent and wouldn't be right for us as a family at all, but then i guess times move on (and our hypothetical baby was very different to our real child in so many ways lol).

Boneweary · 06/02/2023 17:30

I think a lot of people forget that before the naughty step or time out or whatever you want to call it, the main form of discipline was smacking. Jo Frost’s techniques were a movement away from this.

I think with older children giving them a place where they are deprived of attention for a bit (like with the above example re spitting) or somewhere to calm down a bit if getting overly silly/angry/worked up is fine. I agree using it with toddlers is largely pointless - my two year old wouldn’t have a clue what I was doing if I tried to put him on a naughty step - but that doesn’t mean it’s always the wrong method.

heidbuttsupper · 06/02/2023 17:23

I use the naughty step technique with my dog Grin

Mojoj · 06/02/2023 17:21

I used her getting them back to bed method and it worked very well. I also found the naughty step useful but only if my kids understood why they were on the step.

Needmorelego · 06/02/2023 17:18

She's very marmite and the older episodes do have a lot of methods that now seem very outdated.
Some of the American episodes were very different due to the way punishments in America are (were?). In America it seems that 'spanking' is very common - spanking that included using a belt or cane. Apparently perfectly legal and many families accept it as normal.
In American episodes there was a lot of trying to get toddlers to nap in the afternoons - 'toddlers' that were actually 4 years old and clearly didn't need a nap but the parents were insisting on it and wondering why the children were up and down like yoyos. And the 'snack time'. They were obsessed with snacks before bed (ie supper I suppose) but quite often the children didn't want or need them - cue more "they're misbehaving".
It was all quite fascinating.

eighteenthirteen1 · 06/02/2023 17:11

TheEponymousGrub · 06/02/2023 15:19

We tried to follow her model/pathway of consequences, but, it never said what you should do if you put the kid on the naughty step and they just would not stay there. At all. For a moment. No matter how long you tried.

She walks them back repeatedly, that was shown a million times

DemBonesDemBones · 06/02/2023 17:06

Weirdly was talking about this yesterday. I think a lot of the children on the programmes were undiagnosed SEN and her methods weren't appropriate. Then, now or ever.

WhenItIsRaining · 06/02/2023 16:36

She did some fantastic work. So many parents had absolutely no idea... filling their children with snacks then wondering why they wouldn't eat dinner; running up and down the stairs 40x to deal with bedtime; never letting their children do anything that might mess up the house etc. There were some shocking situations: one where the dad "looked after the baby twins" while wfh...except that what he actually did was leave them in their cots all day. And another where 2 teenage girls had to homeschool in order to look after their little siblings all day while their parents worked. Straight up child abuse.

BuffaloCauliflower · 06/02/2023 16:26

@PinkButtercups that’s great but your opinion doesn’t trump actual research and the opinions of infant feeding specialists

Sukisal · 06/02/2023 16:04

@ilovepuppies2019

i remember the episode too.

for those of you commenting about how you can’t overfred a baby, that’s sort of the point of the episode clip!! The woman couldn’t remember when she had last fed baby, so every time baby cried she went straight to a bottle to try and feed again. Inevitably the baby suckled a bit, gagged it back up, and 90% of the formula got left on the side in a collection of partly used bottles. The whole point was the woman was trying to feed the baby when it didn’t need feeding, it was in need of comfort/changing/ another reason for crying.

PinkButtercups · 06/02/2023 15:42

I get what you're saying I just don't think you can overfeed a baby. None of mine have ever latched onto a bottle if they do not want it and that's from birth. Maybe I'm going off my experience so in my opinion you can't over feed a baby.

ilovepuppies2019 · 06/02/2023 15:41

She did a new season in more recent times, 2018 perhaps. She's since gone on to do a few more shows that dealt with bigger problems and families with trauma.

She's not completely rubbish. It very much depends on your starting position. Some parents only solved problems by yelling, smacking or walking away and leaving the other parent to deal with it. Her techniques are better than those approaches. She always encouraged staying calm, never using physical force, adapting the environment to suit the child, giving clear expectations and using positive reinforcement and lots of praise. Those core elements are still important. The original show ran from about 2005 so it was made for a different time and it's obviously aimed at parents who are in over their heads. I'd you look at the participants in the USA version it was always wealthy families, with huge homes, the majority of children under 6 and at least one parent who worked all the time and had no idea. Screaming, giving up and depression were quite common so it offered a ear path forward for those types of parents. There were quite a few parents who smacked, uses hot sauce on the tongue or used a belt so her techniques are obviously much better.

As a society we have changed our approach and not many high quality parents would endorse all of her techniques. The beauty step ages particularly badly I think. Teaching a child that they must comply immediately for any request or will be punished by being forced to sit away, with no engagement and support to learn to manage behaviour is pretty bad. The back to bed technique was solid but I hated the idea of sitting with your back to the child. I did like that she seriously considered the impact of boredom on behaviour and valued parents having fun to rebuild the relationship. She never blamed the kids either but always the parent which was great.

She wasn't all bad! Yes I remember the family with the baby. It was a bottle fed child and they did seem to be over feeding him as he gagged up the milk. She encouraged them to write down the feeds and they spoke about it being revolutionary 😂 I think that they would have been familiar with the concept.

Sazzling · 06/02/2023 15:37

Whichusernametocreate · 06/02/2023 15:36

@Intrepidescape That’s horrible.

errrrr, it's South Park..........

BuffaloCauliflower · 06/02/2023 15:37

The whole naughty step bollocks is so outdated and it makes me sad people still do it. Little children don’t have the brain development to ‘think about what they’ve done’ in that way. Just removes connection which is the opposite of what they need

Whichusernametocreate · 06/02/2023 15:36

@Intrepidescape That’s horrible.

Intrepidescape · 06/02/2023 15:35

Sazzling · 06/02/2023 15:26

Did she ever have kids? Reading books by "experts" only gets you so far.

South Park did an episode on her where Cartman called her a sad lonely woman who couldn’t have children of her own.

BuffaloCauliflower · 06/02/2023 15:35

@PinkButtercups that makes sense in theory, but if you’re not pace feeding a bottle the teat will trigger their suck reflex and they will drink that bottle whether they’re truly hungry or not. Especially when they’re very small and can’t easily push away or resist the bottle

Plumbear2 · 06/02/2023 15:34

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 06/02/2023 15:25

I thought her naughty step method was brilliant. Until i spent what felt like a billion hours (no idea how long it was) putting a toddler back on the step. He got more and more upset and by the end I don't think he even knew what he did wrong. Talking to him about it was much more effective.

Yes this. I tried it was and never again. He need a calm mum and hold him untill he calmed down and a quick discussion about what he did then it was forgotten about.

Swipe left for the next trending thread