Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

STILL making money from slavery?

121 replies

4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 12:56

AIBU here?

www.theguardian.com/world/2023/feb/04/british-slave-owners-family-apologise-reparations-trevelyans

It seems so craven

OP posts:
4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 19:05

Well YES.

For goodness sake !

Does No dogs, No Irish No Blacks ring a bell at all? 1970s.
Robbed of ability to apply for accommodation, or for a jobs.

More recently - sending people back from whence they came with WIndrush gen. A policy that was introduced by politicians under 50 years old.

Yes robbed twice. Robbed of FULL, EQUAL, non racist citizenship.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 06/02/2023 19:02

Are you trying to be pedantic, @BeKindersDismount? Robbed is the correct word there.

Or are you saying there's no racism in the UK?

BeKindersDismount · 06/02/2023 18:54

Robber twice -freed but living under racism and all that entails

In the UK 'robbed', really?

4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 18:52

BeKindersDismount · 06/02/2023 18:12

I suspect the descendants of enslaved people would have less of an issue if they weren’t robbed twice, once for the labour of their ancestors and then again in terms of their ability to live on equal terms in the 180 years since then. It’s actually outrageous, when you think about it - to be enslaved and then vilified

Are you in the UK? What do you mean by this? 'Robbed twice'? 🙄

FGS

It is clear to me what the poster is saying.

Robbed once - slave.

Robber twice -freed but living under racism and all that entails.

OP posts:
4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 18:47

SueVineer · 06/02/2023 16:57

We didn’t really. Government borrowing from the time of slavery abolition was rolled over (redeemed by issuing new gilts) as well as being repaid many times over the years. It’s impossible to trace borrowing from that time and the actual gilts (loan notes) are long gone). However 2016 was when the Bank of England decided to redeem all undated gilts (so ones with no end date for repayment). Gilts are transferable instruments too and are used similarly to cash in many contexts.

so again the situation is much more complicated. Any compensation was paid out about 200 years ago. Any debt issued to repay the original gilts would have changed ownership many millions of times like other government debt and was just part of government debt. It’s not that we were paying slave owners in 2016 - they are long long dead.

See - that is very interesting. I need to do some reading on this- thank you.

OP posts:
MMBaranova · 06/02/2023 18:29

@pinata For comparison - would anyone argue against the holocaust reparations agreed between Germany and Israel? Of course not. Britain, meanwhile, has never really faced up to its own horrendous history in the same way and people are now awake to the fact, as they take a proper look at where the disparities of today’s world come from.

Not being British I'm looking on from the sidelines. However, I live here at the moment and spent much of my childhood here in the care of an Irish grandmother who was part of a diaspora because... well, guess the rest.

Has Germany faced up to its past? In ways for sure as you point out. Currently? Putin's war has shown that Germany post the fall of the Wall (and to an extent in the run up) has some self-searching to do.

Debate over things that ended in the British empire before the living memory of anyone alive today is rather strong in the UK compared to say debate in Spain. That doesn't mean it is perfect and it doesn't mean there aren't things that can be addressed now, next year and over coming generations. That doesn't mean that there aren't people in the UK who blindly stand up for its past without seeing it warts and all (and how perhaps their ancestors may have had a raw deal). There is debate and history is contested. My hope that the debate is informed and on this thread there has been some useful sharing of thoughts and information as well as 'the usual'.

BeKindersDismount · 06/02/2023 18:12

I suspect the descendants of enslaved people would have less of an issue if they weren’t robbed twice, once for the labour of their ancestors and then again in terms of their ability to live on equal terms in the 180 years since then. It’s actually outrageous, when you think about it - to be enslaved and then vilified

Are you in the UK? What do you mean by this? 'Robbed twice'? 🙄

FGS

pinata · 06/02/2023 18:09

@MMBaranova not sure if what you mention changes things materially? The point is, these things are still with us in recent times, even if it’s final tidy ups or similar

I suspect the descendants of enslaved people would have less of an issue if they weren’t robbed twice, once for the labour of their ancestors and then again in terms of their ability to live on equal terms in the 180 years since then. It’s actually outrageous, when you think about it - to be enslaved and then vilified.

For comparison - would anyone argue against the holocaust reparations agreed between Germany and Israel? Of course not. Britain, meanwhile, has never really faced up to its own horrendous history in the same way and people are now awake to the fact, as they take a proper look at where the disparities of today’s world come from.

the proceeds of slavery and colonialism directly built large parts of our economy, notably the financial sector and the city. How else do people think an otherwise small island with relatively few natural resources became a top 10 global player?

It’s never too late to right past wrongs

MMBaranova · 06/02/2023 17:46

>We finished paying the loan the paid the slave owners in 2015. Still very relevant I would say!

Or not.

It's complicated as @SueVineer points out.

Osborne settled what were otherwise perpetuals. When given as compensation they were never intended to be paid off, although they could be called in. So the compensation for the ending of the slave trade was never something to be completely taken off the books. Osborne terminated them after 178 or so years as opposed to... never.

Tim Worstall blogging on the Adam Smith site (absolutely no affiliation with them) suggests he paid them off by borrowing, so in a way we are still in neverland.

www.adamsmith.org/blog/britain-still-hasnt-paid-off-the-slavery-compensation-debt

anyolddinosaur · 06/02/2023 17:41

The loans taken out by the government to stop slavery were finally paid off in 2015. The payments to stop slavery were not only made to people in the uk there were payments to at least foreign country, cant remember off hand which one. Britain founded Freetown and we've been making foreign aid payments for years.

None of my family were slave owners (unusually I do know my ancestry a fair way back) but as a tax payer I have been paying slave owners for years. So personally I dont want the government making any more payments. The nearest I have come to "benefitting" from slavery is a free public library and that doesnt outweigh my tax payments.

Some of the young people in Britain suggesting seeking "reparations" be paid now have personally benefited more from slavery than I have - because they are not paying off the loans now.

eveoha · 06/02/2023 17:21

I’m asexual and Irish and I want to know what there is ‘no need for’ 🙄. Laura Trevelyan is quoted in a Cornish newspaper saying her Great great gramps Charles T ‘ really didn’t want people to die’ from starvation and actually he attributed all that happened to God’s will being done- 👍🏿☘️

SueVineer · 06/02/2023 16:57

4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 16:10

Plus! Re the Romans and Vikings?

We finished paying the loan the paid the slave owners in 2015. Still very relevant I would say!

We didn’t really. Government borrowing from the time of slavery abolition was rolled over (redeemed by issuing new gilts) as well as being repaid many times over the years. It’s impossible to trace borrowing from that time and the actual gilts (loan notes) are long gone). However 2016 was when the Bank of England decided to redeem all undated gilts (so ones with no end date for repayment). Gilts are transferable instruments too and are used similarly to cash in many contexts.

so again the situation is much more complicated. Any compensation was paid out about 200 years ago. Any debt issued to repay the original gilts would have changed ownership many millions of times like other government debt and was just part of government debt. It’s not that we were paying slave owners in 2016 - they are long long dead.

SueVineer · 06/02/2023 16:23

WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 06/02/2023 16:17

And this s the type of comment that drives me mad.

Nobody sued them. They apologised of their own volition. Why is that such a problem?

Because they didn’t do anything. Ancestors that they never met and are not responsible for did it.

SueVineer · 06/02/2023 16:22

RosaDeInvierno · 06/02/2023 13:33

But the children and grandchildren etc descendants of the slaves are still suffering, and the children and grandchildren etc descendants of the 'owners' are still benefitting from the money they made from slave owenership, and the money they were given. (As of January 9, 2023, Laura Trevelyan’s net worth is $5 Million - not verified anywhere else)

www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/06/17/most-americans-say-the-legacy-of-slavery-still-affects-black-people-in-the-u-s-today/

www.brookings.edu/articles/an-american-tragedy-the-legacy-of-slavery-lingers-in-our-cities-ghettos/

diversity.berkeley.edu/impact-slavery-today

It’s far more complex than that. Many people of black Caribbean and black American descent are descendants of both slave owners and slaves. Many black Americans and some Caribbean are descendants of neither. No one alive today was a slave or slave owner in the Atlantic slave trade. There is no one that compensation that could be paid to.

WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 06/02/2023 16:17

Hups · 06/02/2023 16:03

Hmm, maybe the British should start suing the Romans and the Vikings.
Maybe the Scots should start suing the English.
No one can be responsible for what their ancestors did.
The whole thing drives me insane.

And this s the type of comment that drives me mad.

Nobody sued them. They apologised of their own volition. Why is that such a problem?

4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 16:10

Hups · 06/02/2023 16:03

Hmm, maybe the British should start suing the Romans and the Vikings.
Maybe the Scots should start suing the English.
No one can be responsible for what their ancestors did.
The whole thing drives me insane.

Plus! Re the Romans and Vikings?

We finished paying the loan the paid the slave owners in 2015. Still very relevant I would say!

OP posts:
4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 16:09

Hups · 06/02/2023 16:03

Hmm, maybe the British should start suing the Romans and the Vikings.
Maybe the Scots should start suing the English.
No one can be responsible for what their ancestors did.
The whole thing drives me insane.

Agreed!

BUT - don't profit from it either.

This "apology for what my ancestors did, aren't I great" is continuing to profit from it, and is really bloody unsavory.

OP posts:
Hups · 06/02/2023 16:03

Hmm, maybe the British should start suing the Romans and the Vikings.
Maybe the Scots should start suing the English.
No one can be responsible for what their ancestors did.
The whole thing drives me insane.

4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 16:01

BeKindersDismount · 06/02/2023 15:35

Have we OP?

How old are you and what's your line of work?

Have you asked what slavery means to Uber drivers, Deliveroo riders or small businesses selling on on-line platforms having 20% taken of what they make?

There are real issues affecting people as we speak, and none of them are driven by 'evil UK people or ancestors'

If you want to 'ponder' and write about stuff that you find 'fascinating', why don't you start with the above? Of course that won't please the woke crowd and 'grants' won't land on your lap

Point taken @BeKindersDismount and very well made.

I think when I say we have come so far I refer to an increase in overall wealth, and health in todays world as compared to 1800s. In that context we have indeed come far.

However - as you rightly point out we still have far to go.

*If you want to 'ponder' and write about stuff that you find 'fascinating', why don't you start with the above? Of course that won't please the woke crowd and 'grants' won't land on your lap *
**
I think the "quality" of my writing shows clearly that I am not in a "grants" position in society. I did not even go to uni actually. I just read the paper yesterday, and genuinely thought that the journalist was profiteering from slavery just like her ancestors but in a slightly different way. I wanted to discuss.

OP posts:
MMBaranova · 06/02/2023 15:53

@Pinata ...reparations to slave owners only finished being paid in 2015...

Yes. To an extent. As I understand it (I did a fair bit of work on earlier than1837 British sate funding and debt a decade ago now, not this) there were two broad forms of compensation: 'cash' payments (financed by borrowing) and annuities that gave an income and were passed on, traded etc. These were paid off in 2015.

Chancellors Brown and Osborne were keep on tidying up past long running state debts. So far as what were big UK debts go:

Second World War - paid off 2006

First World War - cough, never, so much got lost in the interwar crises. Some War Bonds were paid off in 2014. There are still elements that are being repaid, might be repaid, and have been put to one side and forgotten.

Slave Compensation Act 1837 - last bits in 2015 as your link reported.

Irish Distress Loan of 1847, Napoleonic Wars, earlier conflicts in the 18th Century and back to the South Sea Bubble - a lot of debt was rolled up into Consols at various stages which Osborne redeemed. A contact who is far more clued into this than me thinks elements of C17th debt can still be found in Treasury Bills etc.

WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 06/02/2023 15:51

LakeTiticaca · 06/02/2023 15:27

Basically it's people who have never owned slaves paying people who have never been slaves.
Where will it all end? Can I have compensation for the fact that my great grandparents were working from the age of 8? And surely the families of those small children sent up chimneys would have something to say

I have never been a slave. My taxes still paid compensation though. Surely by your own example you can then see why the conversation is still relevant?

4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 15:47

ShimmeringShirts · 06/02/2023 15:09

@4plusthehound yes we can make the link between the past and present relating to wealth - that I wasn’t disputing. But to claim the only reason they are currently well to do is because of slavery is narrow minded. There are many circumstances that would be at play and the fact is the current generations of those families have nothing to do with historic slavery and should not be held accountable for it. It is not their sins to pay for. If it came to light those people are still using and benefiting from slavery in the current day then that is an entirely different story and they should be held accountable for that.

I think it’s on the population to petition the government to apologise for the past, it should not be on individual families themselves. I also object to Europe and Britain taking the sole blame on slavery, as others have pointed out there was a lot of countries that benefited from this, including those in Africa and the Middle East.

You can absolutely compare the two. Both caused mass death, destruction and harm worldwide. Length of time does not mean anything in either case. I’d argue mass genocide is a hell of a lot worse, as many people that lost their lives through slavery and through the transportation process it was not intended to eliminate an entire population of people.

I do apologise regarding the comment on Jewish people not calling for reparations though, I did not know the Israeli government was calling for reparations from newer generations of Germans - and I do believe this is wrong too unless said family members were directly involved in the holocaust.

I also object to Europe and Britain taking the sole blame on slavery, as others have pointed out there was a lot of countries that benefited from this, including those in Africa and the Middle East.

We clean our own houses. You do not say "my neighbor's house is filthy so I won't clean mine".

OP posts:
WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 06/02/2023 15:46

GloomyDarkness · 06/02/2023 15:08

It is taught in schools. I cover it very quickly but we did. My children have covered it in more depth.

It usually ignores the Arab slave trade which went on longer, moved more people and was also brutal. Also ignore other history of slave trading and other forms.

Often ignores only Empire to abolish slavery I believe and then try and impose it on other was British Empire and money and resources were expended to do so - Georgian England basically bought the remains slaves - compensating the slave owners which is distasteful to modern ears but did free the slaves and running the The West Africa Squadron - and then ordinary people you refused to buy sugar and Manchester mills Manchester support for cotton embargo - enough probably not but more nuanced than white bad attidtue that seem to go along with reparation demands.

It ignore the African countries/tribes that got wealthy of the trade - and were ones doing the kidnapping. Ignore the detrimental affects their behavior had on continent - meant everyone had to spend on military rather than tech or art.

It ignore modern day slavery that included in the USA - A nationwide movement hopes to close the ‘slavery loophole’ that enables the exploitation of 800,000 prisoners in the US

I do think attempts to cover it have gain apace in last few years.

Personally I'm not sure about this because it's this family money and they can do what they want with it - if they do feel some generational guilt well that's how they feel- and maybe some good can be done with the money.

I didn't say it wasn't taught in schools.

Also, no school I've ever taught in has ever taught in has ever presented the transatlantic slave trade as reductively as big bad europeans.

I was referring specifically to this thread and the all too common notion that the transatlantic slave trade is something to just "get over".

BeKindersDismount · 06/02/2023 15:39

LakeTiticaca · 06/02/2023 15:27

Basically it's people who have never owned slaves paying people who have never been slaves.
Where will it all end? Can I have compensation for the fact that my great grandparents were working from the age of 8? And surely the families of those small children sent up chimneys would have something to say

Am I going to be paid reparations for my data being harvested every day? I am doing unpaid, forced labour after all

BeKindersDismount · 06/02/2023 15:35

4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 14:29

Yes - wealth was created by and large by the right to free or very cheap labour.

We have come so far!

Have we OP?

How old are you and what's your line of work?

Have you asked what slavery means to Uber drivers, Deliveroo riders or small businesses selling on on-line platforms having 20% taken of what they make?

There are real issues affecting people as we speak, and none of them are driven by 'evil UK people or ancestors'

If you want to 'ponder' and write about stuff that you find 'fascinating', why don't you start with the above? Of course that won't please the woke crowd and 'grants' won't land on your lap

Swipe left for the next trending thread