Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

STILL making money from slavery?

121 replies

4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 12:56

AIBU here?

www.theguardian.com/world/2023/feb/04/british-slave-owners-family-apologise-reparations-trevelyans

It seems so craven

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Misunderestimated · 10/02/2023 18:52

WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 06/02/2023 15:03

What is confusing to me is the utter contempt with which people respond when transatlantic slavery is brought up.

Get over it

Move on

Far worse has happened/is happening

Etc etc

The same is not said when other atrocities are discussed.

Conflating the transatlantic slave trade with the entire historical concept of slavery without nuance is both confusing and infuriating to me and suggests that people often don't know much about the transatlantic slave trade beyond the fact that there's were giant ships involved. I'm not sure why I'm even raising an eyebrow though, this conversation often follows the same track on this site. Depressing.

Colston's statue was tossed into the harbour in Bristol for offences to humanity committed 300 years earlier, hundreds of people demonstrated.
When Maros Tancos, and Joanna Gomulska were jailed for keeping slaves in Bristol within the past decade it didn't seem to prompt any kind of public outcry at all.

anyolddinosaur · 10/02/2023 18:39

Ireland I grant you.

Afghanistan was never a colony, it always had its
own rulers. Britain wanted to control it's foreign policy.

South Africa – you are presumably thinking of the Boer wars so between 2 colonial powers and partly caused by the British abolition of slavery. The Union of South Africa was an independent Dominion from 1909. If it had been a British colony I doubt they would have had apartheid. for so long.

Somalia- part occupied by Italy, another colonial power. Britain handed British Somaliland independence in 1960 when the area that had been under Italian control became independent.

Kenya – Legislative Council from 1957 before independence in 1963. Some people call the fighting a civil war. It was certainly a very dirty fight.

Rhodesia – was the self governing colony of South Rhodesia from 1923 after the British South African company's charter was revoked. Fighting was against its own government. They were mostly settlers of British origin but it was not a war against Britain. Zambia became independent in 1963 after elections.

Egypt- technically never a colony. Britain withdrew its influence gradually apart from a misguided attempt to capture the Suez canal..

Iraq -Britain was given a League of Nations mandate to govern in 1920, established a hashemite monarchy and Iraq became independent in 1932.

Palestine -Britain had a mandate from 1918-1948, then withdrew. Palestine and Israel are still fighting it out, not a war with Britain.

India from 1919 British policy was to develop self-governing institutions. India had a Legislative Council until independence. Gandhi went for civil disobedience rather than war.

Ones you prefer not to cover - Canada, Australia, Malta (which once voted to integrate with Britain in a referendum but got independence), Bermuda, Gibralter, Falkland Islands – all choosing to stay British. Anguilla preferred to be a British Overseas Territory rather than part of independent St KittsThe Carribbean Islands – all given independence without a war although Haiti fought France. . Botswana, Ghana, Malta and others.

Grassisbluer · 10/02/2023 16:14

Not exactly true that most colonies had to " go to war" though. America did - where else were you thinking of?
The UK's closest neighbours maybe?
Ireland's War of Independence was fought just over 100 years ago now.

Freedom for the world and democracy for those willing to accept it.
You really have no idea do you @anyolddinosaur ?

4plusthehound · 10/02/2023 14:10

anyolddinosaur · 10/02/2023 10:56

@4plusthehound British pirates stole from the Spanish and there certainly was some theft and murder. Not exactly true that most colonies had to " go to war" though. America did - where else were you thinking of? Mostly a form of government was established and eventually the colonies were handed back. There was generally a lot of bloodshed, quite a bit of it British blood, before it got to that point but it wasnt open warfare.

Freedom for the world and democracy for those willing to accept it. What do you think would have happened if Britain had not taken the rule of law and the idea of democracy to half the world? Do you think the French, Spanish, Portugeuse, Belgians, Moguls would have done better as those are who the British generally displaced. Would any of them have abolished slavery sooner? Spain kept slavery longer than Britain, India has the largest number of modern slaves. France was a bit better. Read about what the Belgians did in the Congo if you really want to feel sick.

Many years ago I read a book called King Leopald's Ghost . The horror of it is with me to this day.

So much of our (human) history is plagued by greed. Our country is a guilty as every other country. Unfortunately.

OP posts:
4plusthehound · 10/02/2023 14:05

@anyolddinosaur I suppose it could depend on the definition of war. But if we accept a defination as they resorted to violence in order to have self governance then yes, most of ex colonies went to war with us.

I am pretty sure that we must have taken over violently too. I don't imagine our forefathers rocked up and said look - "we will teach you English in exchange for x, y, z" and had the locals jumping for joy.

Without looking anything up and off the top of my head -

Afghanistan
Many African countries including, South Africa, Somalia, Keyna, Rhodesia ( as it was know then), Egypt, Iraq? , Nigeria and where else?
Ireland
Palestine
Obviously the Untied Staes
India

I don't think the white Australians ever bucked, Canada ditto? I am not sure about that and willdo a bit of reading. I am also unsure about the Carribean countires.

OP posts:
anyolddinosaur · 10/02/2023 10:56

@4plusthehound British pirates stole from the Spanish and there certainly was some theft and murder. Not exactly true that most colonies had to " go to war" though. America did - where else were you thinking of? Mostly a form of government was established and eventually the colonies were handed back. There was generally a lot of bloodshed, quite a bit of it British blood, before it got to that point but it wasnt open warfare.

Freedom for the world and democracy for those willing to accept it. What do you think would have happened if Britain had not taken the rule of law and the idea of democracy to half the world? Do you think the French, Spanish, Portugeuse, Belgians, Moguls would have done better as those are who the British generally displaced. Would any of them have abolished slavery sooner? Spain kept slavery longer than Britain, India has the largest number of modern slaves. France was a bit better. Read about what the Belgians did in the Congo if you really want to feel sick.

4plusthehound · 08/02/2023 22:20

*redeem

OP posts:
4plusthehound · 08/02/2023 22:18

jcyclops · 08/02/2023 16:57

So a journalist called Trevelyan must be denounced for making money writing about the transatlantic slave trade that involved a certain ancestor. Note that dating back to 1835 only 1 of maybe around 64 ancestors was a Trevelyan - the one following the male line of descent (although this doesn't preclude others of the 64 also benefitting from slavery).

Should another journalist that made millions from writing about the transatlantic slave trade involving ancestors also be denounced? Or does Alex Haley fully deserve the praise and awards for Roots?

Should another journalist that made millions from writing about the transatlantic slave trade involving ancestors also be denounced? Or does Alex Haley fully deserve the praise and awards for Roots? 😂😂Nice try!

It has less to do with writing about slavery and much more to do with the rather dramatic, wide eyed, showy mea culpa. And indeed if it was only 1 of maybe around 64 ancestors was a Trevelyan then it seems even more dramatic for the family to have a collective intake of breath now, no?

OP posts:
4plusthehound · 08/02/2023 22:11

anyolddinosaur · 08/02/2023 13:22

@mathanxiety I cant be arsed. Making profits from manufacturing raw goods into finished materials was what Britain did. We did it well and we had a large navy that shipped goods around the world. That is what built what wealth Britain had and we spent a lot of it protecting freedom and democracy. We also invested quite a bit in other countries, who tend to forget how much they benefit from that investment.

Very few countries survive on what they produce and manufacture themselves, it's called free trade. Now I dont personally think it is a great idea, as we'll find out when China decided to pull the strings, but it's what made Britain money for a time.

That is what built what wealth Britain had and we spent a lot of it protecting freedom and democracy.

Freedom and democracy for whom?

Most colonized countries had to go to war with us in order to have a democracy!

We were the bullys, and thieves and murderers.

Horrible to accept but true unfortunately.

I do believe that between then and now we have done a LOT to redeme ourselves. But we should not decieve ourselves about who we were.

OP posts:
4plusthehound · 08/02/2023 22:03

anyolddinosaur · 06/02/2023 22:23

The "wealth" of Britain - in quotes because there really isnt that as much as you think - came from the wool trade and then the industrial revolution. You can argue that some of that benefited from the proceeds of slavery but it's wrong to ignore the contribution of Britain used to manufacture and to sell and to ship goods around the world. Amazing how ignorant so many people are of British history.

@anyolddinosaur It "owned" half the world by that point, and had a market to sell to and resources to take.

Amazing how ignorant so many people are of British history. This is rude. The discussion here is interesting and respectful.

But as you brought it up you could also look at it another way - amazing how naive so many people are of British history.

What do you think?

OP posts:
jcyclops · 08/02/2023 16:57

So a journalist called Trevelyan must be denounced for making money writing about the transatlantic slave trade that involved a certain ancestor. Note that dating back to 1835 only 1 of maybe around 64 ancestors was a Trevelyan - the one following the male line of descent (although this doesn't preclude others of the 64 also benefitting from slavery).

Should another journalist that made millions from writing about the transatlantic slave trade involving ancestors also be denounced? Or does Alex Haley fully deserve the praise and awards for Roots?

unsureatthispoint · 08/02/2023 15:57

You are making a lot of sense @anyolddinosaur, but beware of continuing with your line of thinking on this thread as you may risk being reported

Grassisbluer · 08/02/2023 15:52

We also invested quite a bit in other countries, who tend to forget how much they benefit from that investment.

Do you mean the British colonies @anyolddinosaur ?

anyolddinosaur · 08/02/2023 13:22

@mathanxiety I cant be arsed. Making profits from manufacturing raw goods into finished materials was what Britain did. We did it well and we had a large navy that shipped goods around the world. That is what built what wealth Britain had and we spent a lot of it protecting freedom and democracy. We also invested quite a bit in other countries, who tend to forget how much they benefit from that investment.

Very few countries survive on what they produce and manufacture themselves, it's called free trade. Now I dont personally think it is a great idea, as we'll find out when China decided to pull the strings, but it's what made Britain money for a time.

DemiColon · 08/02/2023 02:13

I think it's useless virtue signalling but it certainly seems to be what is being promoted these days. I was at a public ceremony a few days ago for the opening of the local African Heritage month, and the MC at the beginning when on at some length about the necessity of constant acts of reparation both symbolic and material, and called racism the "original sin" responsible for all of the ills in modern society.

I'd say this would be right up her ally.

mathanxiety · 08/02/2023 01:26

The "wealth" of Britain - in quotes because there really isnt that as much as you think - came from the wool trade and then the industrial revolution. You can argue that some of that benefited from the proceeds of slavery but it's wrong to ignore the contribution of Britain used to manufacture and to sell and to ship goods around the world. Amazing how ignorant so many people are of British history.

Describe the Industrial Revolution please.

What products were manufactured in Britain purely from raw materials sourced in Britain?

What products were manufactured in Britain from raw materials that came from other parts of the world?

What were the working conditions of the people who produced those raw materials?

What were the political arrangements that facilitated the extraction of raw materials from places outside of Britain and then the sale of finished goods back to those places, or on to other places?

4plusthehound · 07/02/2023 17:02

anyolddinosaur · 07/02/2023 07:49

Of course slavery was wrong. The attitudes behind slavery persisted and were the reason ex slaves and their descendants were denied opportunities available to others. Meanwhile the descendants of slave traders benefited - but that benefit didnt extend significantly beyond those descendants while every tax payer in this country has been paying off slave traders. Similar attitudes were applied to the poor in this country and in others - look up how the Canadians treated British Home Children and how some died of frostbite and malnutrition. Be aware of how Scots were cleared from the land so landowners could run sheep there.

The rich have always exploited people, they still do. Slavery is an extreme form of that exploitation.

Interesting points @anyolddinosaur .

I read a story a while ago about an American slave woman (in Rhode Island I think) who was an amazing baker. She sold her goods at a market with wild success.

Instead of using the profits to start a baking empire, and personify the American Dream like a white poor person would/could have done, she used the money to but her freedom, that of her husband and that of her children.

It took a life time.

That is why I find this idea of the Trevelyan clan so self serving. To me they are still feeding off it.

OP posts:
MMBaranova · 07/02/2023 09:22

Good thread with worthwhile discussion.

anyolddinosaur · 07/02/2023 07:49

Of course slavery was wrong. The attitudes behind slavery persisted and were the reason ex slaves and their descendants were denied opportunities available to others. Meanwhile the descendants of slave traders benefited - but that benefit didnt extend significantly beyond those descendants while every tax payer in this country has been paying off slave traders. Similar attitudes were applied to the poor in this country and in others - look up how the Canadians treated British Home Children and how some died of frostbite and malnutrition. Be aware of how Scots were cleared from the land so landowners could run sheep there.

The rich have always exploited people, they still do. Slavery is an extreme form of that exploitation.

Johnisafckface · 07/02/2023 02:27

RosaDeInvierno · 06/02/2023 13:33

But the children and grandchildren etc descendants of the slaves are still suffering, and the children and grandchildren etc descendants of the 'owners' are still benefitting from the money they made from slave owenership, and the money they were given. (As of January 9, 2023, Laura Trevelyan’s net worth is $5 Million - not verified anywhere else)

www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/06/17/most-americans-say-the-legacy-of-slavery-still-affects-black-people-in-the-u-s-today/

www.brookings.edu/articles/an-american-tragedy-the-legacy-of-slavery-lingers-in-our-cities-ghettos/

diversity.berkeley.edu/impact-slavery-today

This. Slavery didn’t just affect the ones enslaved. The results, which were very negative, trickled down to their ancestors. It may be difficult to perceive that unless you are a part of a minority group that was enslaved.

anyolddinosaur · 06/02/2023 22:23

The "wealth" of Britain - in quotes because there really isnt that as much as you think - came from the wool trade and then the industrial revolution. You can argue that some of that benefited from the proceeds of slavery but it's wrong to ignore the contribution of Britain used to manufacture and to sell and to ship goods around the world. Amazing how ignorant so many people are of British history.

VerveClique · 06/02/2023 19:52

My family on all sides really has obviously been poor and run of the mill.

I’ve never researched a lot but I only actually know the dates of birth of three of my grandparents. There’s a family mystery as to how one of my grandmother’s maiden name was spelled. I know nothing of my great grandparents. My grandparents were variously shop worker, factory worker, housewife, plumber. So not bad in the general scheme of things. They were literate at least and had some basic schooling.

I’m sure there are public records but I’ve never looked. But there are no family bibles, no trust funds, no paintings, no inheritances, no heirlooms or even sentimental treasures. There are a couple of photo albums and one wedding ring. None of them belong to me or my parents. That’s it.

So beyond that, I have no idea who my ancestors were. I presume that they were white, because I’m white. I’ve no idea what the did for a living, where they lived, how they lived.

I don’t think I owe anyone anything. I don’t think anyone owes me anything. I was born poor because I came from generations of poor people who were, no doubt, taken advantage of by richer people. But there are no signs of this. No records. Nothing. It’s an invisible inequality and it’s everywhere. The human race is immeasurably, inevitably unequal, and always has been.

So whilst I think that modern-day slavery in all its forms is abhorrent and should be stopped, and whilst I know that there are poor communities everywhere that need help today no matter what their roots, I can’t work out how to square the circle of very-much historic slavery.

pinata · 06/02/2023 19:20

@4plusthehound yes, exactly. Could add robbed x3 by post colonial structures/trade set ups and debt that impoverish countries and definitely keep money very much flowing back to the UK and the west

@BeKindersDismount yes, I’m in the uk - racism to people who are the descendants of slaves also exists here

@MMBaranova I’m not suggesting Germany is perfect by any means. I was just pointing out that atrocities attract reparations and acknowledgment that a wrong has been committed. People don’t have a problem with the principle

Also, the idea of righting historic wrongs is hardly new - why are people posthumously pardoned, for example, if these things don’t matter? Why not just move on, they’re dead? Because it does matter if we are to be able look at ourselves in the mirror, as a society, and so does this

BeKindersDismount · 06/02/2023 19:18

It's 2023

4plusthehound · 06/02/2023 19:06

The above post is for @BeKindersDismount

OP posts: