Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

or ungrateful about Inlaws offering help?

72 replies

Strawb83 · 06/02/2023 12:32

So let's me start by saying I get on with my partners parents they are very caring and loving towards us so in that way I feel very lucky. However... I do feel at times they are too involved and I think that's probably because my parents aren't really involved at all. We still have a good relationship with my parents but they tend to leave us to it an we don't really see them unless we arrange things. I suppose a happy medium between the 2 sets of parents would be great!!
Anyway... we are currently expecting our first child and my MIL has made a few comments that are making me feel anxious. I have spoken to my OH abut this but she gets upset as she is so close to her parents she would basically let them do what they want.
Firstly my MIL visited us the other week and went for a walk with my OH, I'd been with them the rest of the time and it was only when they were alone she brought up that they are going to book a hotel for 2 or so weeks around baby due date so they are around to help as much as possible. She didn't ask my OH she told her and without me being there I don't really know what was said but when my OH told me this I said I feel it will be too much. Not only will we want to find our own ways of parenting without an audience, my OH will only be off for 2 weeks and other people are going to come and meet the baby too I don't want us to feel obliged to have my inlaws round everyday because they have spent money on a hotel we never asked them to book.
Then my MIL lives close to her other grandchildren and is VERY involved in their lives. Which is great each to their own but I'm not sure I'd be comfortable with that level of involvement. She said to me the other day "We are going onto want to be as hands on with this baby you know? As relationships are important for children with their grandparents" I feel she is testing the water but I said we'll it will be different naturally because of the distance and she said "we are going to make sure we are as close to this baby as the other grandchildren. We will make sure of it"
I don't know maybe I am being ungrateful but I feel like I am going to feel pressured into making sure they are seeing our baby as much as they want to when actually it should be a lovely time of us 3 bonding.

OP posts:
SafeAsAHero · 06/02/2023 15:06

deplorabelle · 06/02/2023 14:51

Honestly they sound like they are trying to be nice. Emphasize to everyone (your OH included) that babies do not arrive on schedule and they should keep their plans fluid. They could spend their entire two weeks visiting a very fed up and pregnant lady if you go overdue so encourage them to wait and see.

I think it will be okay

It’s not nice to just invite yourself.

LimeCheesecake · 06/02/2023 15:06

It might be their clumsy way of saying just because you are a same sex couple and it’s not their dd who’s having a baby, they will still treat this dgc the same. Also they might be super excited.

id speak to your dp alone and say that you aren’t sure you are going to be comfortable having them in the house when you are recovering from having a baby, if it’s a straight forward delivery you might be fine, but if it’s not, you know you are going to want to hunker down and recover without feeling you have to host people - and however much they say they will be there to help, you won’t want help from them for you and will feel you have to put on a brave face. That while you are sure your dp would be happy being vulnerable and sick in front of her parents, they aren’t your parents and you know you will hate it.

MsMarch · 06/02/2023 15:09

I think as you are the one carrying the baby, it's not unreasonable for yo to feel a bit nervous and vulnerable. The key thing is that your OH needs to support you. So, if her parents are planning to be around, she needs to be prepared to step in and "protect" you if they are overstepping. My mum was around when I had DS1 and it was really helpful to me - she was very hands on, helped with cooking and cleaning, held the baby etc. When MIL turned up a bit later, she was less helpful but it was okay because DH also made it clear that she needed to respect that I was the baby's mother and I didn't really mind having her here at all. She can be quite opinionated though so with the best of intentions, if DH hadn't been in my corner, it could have got messy quite fast.

MsMarch · 06/02/2023 15:10

I also wonder if the fact that your OH is a woman is affecting things? Lots of parents feel that when their DD has a baby, they'll be there for them, supporting them and being very hands on. But this is complicated by the fact that your OH is having a child, but isn't the one actually having the baby and therefore less likely to need quite the same level of hands on help and support?

007DoubleOSeven · 06/02/2023 15:12

I think you need to tell her that they will both have a very special relationship with your baby and will be very important figures in its life. That they don't need to be around that first 2 weeks, you'd rather have space, but that you know they will be there to support whenever you need them and for that you're very grateful.

ittakes2 · 06/02/2023 15:13

I think you need to take a breathe - its likely she thinks you need reassurance she is planning to divy up her time fairly between the grandkids....how many posts are their on mumsnet about parents moaning things with childcare are unfair! but your partner does need tp tell her the hotel is a nice gesture but you would prefer not.

custardbear · 06/02/2023 15:15

That does sound like a lot of time with you guys in the first few weeks, I'd feel overwhelmed too plus you need time to establish bonds.

Am I reading this right that the egg donors are your partners parents (or did I read that wrong?) if this is the case you both need to establish that they're the GP, and that's a firm boundary.

Many congratulations, but do have those discussions with your DW and carefully but firmly let them know you guys have feelings and needs too for this new arrival

saraclara · 06/02/2023 15:19

Quitelikeit · 06/02/2023 14:45

I am your MiL. I’ve also decided to go and stay for two weeks after my girls have children.

I’ve told them too. They didn’t seem to mind…….

I don't tell my girls what I'm doing. I either ask what they'd like me to do to help/how they see the early days working for them, or offer a suggestion and ask if it suits them.

And I really hope you're not OP's MIL.

HungryandIknowit · 06/02/2023 15:20

My in-laws booked a hotel nearby staying for 5 days a few days after baby was born. Spent all day at our (tiny) house when I was trying to establish breastfeeding. I like them but it was far too much. You can't send them away once they're there without straining the relationship. Total nightmare. Don't let it happen to you.

UsingChangeofName · 06/02/2023 15:31

Another who thinks they are just trying to be lovely and supportive.
They are making it clear this grandchild will be loved and as close to them as their other grandchildren despite the fact you aren't local.
They have even done the MN thing of booking into paid for accommodation rather than inviting themselves to stay.

Yes, both halves of a couple ought to be able to check in with each other and get back to anyone about arrangements that affect them, as Saraclara said, but do see all this as a positive from your partners parents. Just because it is different from your family doesn't make it wrong.

I think the suggestion of going back to them saying that firstly you have no idea when the baby will arrive of course, and secondly you want to have those first few days together, alone but would they be able to come up after you go back to work, when your partner will still want some help but you won't be so available, is a good one. Don't rebuff their wanting to support you both, just because it is unexpected by you. Make it work for all of you.

TiaraBoo · 06/02/2023 15:40

Could you say come a week after you get home from hospital (if you are having a hospital birth) as you want to establish breast feeding, recover from stitches etc without visitors, but as a compromise they can come after a week rather than 2 weeks after you get home or something.
Just repeat it’s overwhelming and you don’t want a lot visitors when you’re going to be half naked/in pain

tattygrl · 06/02/2023 15:46

TiaraBoo · 06/02/2023 15:40

Could you say come a week after you get home from hospital (if you are having a hospital birth) as you want to establish breast feeding, recover from stitches etc without visitors, but as a compromise they can come after a week rather than 2 weeks after you get home or something.
Just repeat it’s overwhelming and you don’t want a lot visitors when you’re going to be half naked/in pain

Exactly this!! I don't understand why people (anyone!) feel it's appropriate, helpful or "nice" to insert themselves as a houseguest or regular visitor directly after childbirth. Of course, make it known that you are keen to help and see the baby and parents, and take the lead from the new parents.

Calphurnia88 · 06/02/2023 15:48

Quitelikeit · 06/02/2023 14:45

I am your MiL. I’ve also decided to go and stay for two weeks after my girls have children.

I’ve told them too. They didn’t seem to mind…….

Assuming this is real, how incredibly self-centred of you.

Why you would not extend them the basic courtesy of asking them first?

UsingChangeofName · 06/02/2023 15:55

I don't understand why people (anyone!) feel it's appropriate, helpful or "nice" to insert themselves as a houseguest or regular visitor directly after childbirth.

Maybe because many of us remember how relieved we were to see another person during those first few days, and really appreciated people turning up with a meal, or doing the washing up, or taking away the washing, or holding the baby when we just wanted to sleep, or going off to do the shopping, or being able to share our worries with someone. I wouldn't have coped without the support and love of family in those first scary weeks.

Everydayitsgettingcloser · 06/02/2023 15:55

My MIL came to stay when ours were around 6-8 weeks old which I think is perfect - the babies were still all newborny but we had feeding established and I was ready to let her take the baby for an hour or so so I could rest. For me that was when the tiredness really kicked in so I appreciated the odd nap

HostessTrolley · 06/02/2023 15:55

Quitelikeit · 06/02/2023 14:45

I am your MiL. I’ve also decided to go and stay for two weeks after my girls have children.

I’ve told them too. They didn’t seem to mind…….

That's terrible. You've had your babies. When you're a grandparent then the wishes and needs of the parents are the priority, not what you've 'decided' is going to happen. Being so self centred will result in you being sidelined from the lives of your grandchildren and their parents.

tattygrl · 06/02/2023 15:56

UsingChangeofName · 06/02/2023 15:55

I don't understand why people (anyone!) feel it's appropriate, helpful or "nice" to insert themselves as a houseguest or regular visitor directly after childbirth.

Maybe because many of us remember how relieved we were to see another person during those first few days, and really appreciated people turning up with a meal, or doing the washing up, or taking away the washing, or holding the baby when we just wanted to sleep, or going off to do the shopping, or being able to share our worries with someone. I wouldn't have coped without the support and love of family in those first scary weeks.

Totally! That's why I added the last sentence, about being sure to make it known that you are keen to help and support. Maybe I should have been clearer about my point being that I think it's inappropriate and unhelpful to "insert yourself" as a guest or visitor. Many people want time, space and privacy, or at least to be able to control their environment and who is around them at that time.

Calphurnia88 · 06/02/2023 16:06

UsingChangeofName · 06/02/2023 15:55

I don't understand why people (anyone!) feel it's appropriate, helpful or "nice" to insert themselves as a houseguest or regular visitor directly after childbirth.

Maybe because many of us remember how relieved we were to see another person during those first few days, and really appreciated people turning up with a meal, or doing the washing up, or taking away the washing, or holding the baby when we just wanted to sleep, or going off to do the shopping, or being able to share our worries with someone. I wouldn't have coped without the support and love of family in those first scary weeks.

That isn't the point.

The point is asking first.

Quitelikeit · 06/02/2023 16:14

No I’m not the actual MiL who this post is about but I did suggest this to my girls and they were fine………

not sure why posters are getting offended on their behalf

but people do love to do that these days don’t they?

CosyKnits · 06/02/2023 16:15

UsingChangeofName · 06/02/2023 15:55

I don't understand why people (anyone!) feel it's appropriate, helpful or "nice" to insert themselves as a houseguest or regular visitor directly after childbirth.

Maybe because many of us remember how relieved we were to see another person during those first few days, and really appreciated people turning up with a meal, or doing the washing up, or taking away the washing, or holding the baby when we just wanted to sleep, or going off to do the shopping, or being able to share our worries with someone. I wouldn't have coped without the support and love of family in those first scary weeks.

It's great that it helped you but not everyone is the same.

My (also very wonderful and loving) ILs stayed in a hotel nearby for the first week after I had my DC, then came back when she was 3 or 4 weeks old for another week.

I really struggled after the birth (I think looking back it was PND) and having them there all the time made it so much harder. I would dread getting a text from them saying they were popping round every day. I was a mess and even though they were kind and tried to help, really it was just them sitting on the sofa drinking endless tea while I breast fed continuously, conscious that I hadn't showered yet and trying not to cry.

It wasn't a help at all, and I wish very much that I'd been firmer at the time.

Calphurnia88 · 06/02/2023 16:17

Quitelikeit · 06/02/2023 16:14

No I’m not the actual MiL who this post is about but I did suggest this to my girls and they were fine………

not sure why posters are getting offended on their behalf

but people do love to do that these days don’t they?

So did you tell them you were staying with them or did you suggest it?

Because they're two very different things.

Winniepoo · 06/02/2023 16:25

If you're carrying and birthing the baby they ARE biologically yours 💐 xx

RingRingRingGoesTheTelephone · 06/02/2023 16:28

TiaraBoo · 06/02/2023 15:40

Could you say come a week after you get home from hospital (if you are having a hospital birth) as you want to establish breast feeding, recover from stitches etc without visitors, but as a compromise they can come after a week rather than 2 weeks after you get home or something.
Just repeat it’s overwhelming and you don’t want a lot visitors when you’re going to be half naked/in pain

You do realise you don't actually start producing milk for a few days after you have a baby (i think it's day 5 from memory), stitches don't heal in a week, they take way longer. 1 week in is an awful time to insert yourself into someone who has just given birth's space. I think it's actually better to allow people to meet the baby not long after the birth (when you are still on the immediate post birth high), as in flying visit, half an hour, then retreat to home and be left in peace for at least a couple of weeks. I wouldn't want people expecting to be around all day long until at least a month after giving birth, it actually took me about 2 months to be walking ok and feeling half human again after a traumatic forceps birth. I'm amazed people think you're back to yourself and have breastfeeding nailed 7 days in, ready to host lol.

tattygrl · 06/02/2023 16:29

Calphurnia88 · 06/02/2023 16:17

So did you tell them you were staying with them or did you suggest it?

Because they're two very different things.

Strongly agree. Offering with genuine freedom from expectation and obligation is lovely. Suggesting with the assumption they'll want you there is not nice. Telling them you're going to be there is even not-nicer. Maybe this person's girls are fine with it, which is great, but there is definitely a world of difference between offering guilt-free and "telling".

Pleasecreateausername13 · 06/02/2023 16:30

OP don’t let your MIL walk all over you.

When myself and my wife had our baby( I carried) and by day 3 of constant visitors we told EVERYONE, my family included we wanted a week with no visits so we could get into a routine and enjoy time as a family. Everyone was really good about it and it helped massively.

I just couldn’t have had my MIL there or even my own mum hovering about all the time.

Put your foot down.