Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have thought this date was a pretentious plonker?

78 replies

JustOneMoreBiscuitPlease · 06/02/2023 09:37

I’m finding it very therapeutic to get views on dating encounters here, so here’s another one…

His profile gave his location as ‘Kensington & Chelsea.’ After our first date he made a big thing about getting a train off in the other direction from me.

Second date he got on my train home. Said he was going to visit some friends who lived out near me. This seemed a bit odd and unlikely somehow but whatever. He was clearly interested and wanted to keep the conversation going so I didn’t question it.

On date three he revealed that actually he lived in a flat-share in the very same dull end-of-the-line suburb I live in. Said he previously lived in ‘Kensington & Chelsea’ and hadn’t got around to updating his profile yet. (So what was all the pretence about going to visit friends last time then?). When quizzed a bit more carefully, it was quite a while back that he moved. He moved because ‘the landlady went barmy’ apparently. Not sure how this would be justification for moving right out to the sticks but anyway.

For our fourth date he suggested meeting up actually in Kensington or Chelsea.
I said I’d rather not go all the way into London after a long day at work in the opposite direction and that, since we were practically neighbours, I’d be quite happy just to meet somewhere locally. He seemed reluctant but went along with it.

Then I’m afraid I ended it. What was his obsession with Kensington and Chelsea about? What other shallow pretences was he keeping up? There was evidence of a few more. And how insulting really to lie about where he lived when he knew all along it was my own hometown. I’d have been mortified if we’d ended up a couple and he’d kept up this sort of thing, falsely bigging himself up to everyone we knew and met.

Would others have found this off-putting too? Or would you have given him a chance since there are so few truly decent men out there it seems?

OP posts:
potniatheron · 06/02/2023 15:47

I'm gonna go out on a limb and say I'd at least give him a chance to explain himself. As you said OP, OLD is a nightmare, so many profiles and from a bloke's perspective it can be hard to make yourself stand out (statistically more blokes on OLD then women) so I could sort of understand him hoping that adding a posh location would help him do so.

Or maybe he really likes the area and was hoping to meet someone from K&C as he's familiar with the good places to got there.

Either way, it feels to me more like an attempt to impress than a malign or sinister thing. I personally would give him a call to explain my decision and see what he said in response.

Amy1992Brighton · 06/02/2023 15:45

Winemygoodenemy · 06/02/2023 10:46

OLD is a chore. Full of odd people. No idea why people lie as it gets caught out. The genuine people do suffer because of the lying idiots. I dated for years. Finally met my DP on bumble. I was very hard to get and took me a while to trust him as I was used to BS. Just because of the idiots I met beforeHe was understanding when I told him a few stories. DP is a rare find.

Here are highlights to make you feel better

  1. lied about age, education and even fact he owned a cat. Fessed up hour into date after a few conversation inconsistencies. Especially saying he didn’t have a cat
  2. Lied about having 3 kids. Said he won’t let them come between us and he can ignore them if I want.
  3. lied about weight on pictures, using old ones. I am not skinny, but he was at least 10 stones more than his pictures
  4. All exes crazy. He was the one who sent them crazy. He is now a very close friend and still sending girls crazy due to actions
  5. lied about job, name marriage status. Found him on Facebook under who you may know under a different name and wedding pictures as profile. Was dating him at the time
  6. tried to convince me he was a project manager for MoD and had to go to war zones and couldn’t use his phone. Out of contact for weeks. I really new he was a BS, but was fun listening to stories.

DP does sound like a "rare find" if he did all that.

Winemygoodenemy · 06/02/2023 15:02

@ImJustMadAboutSaffron turns out it was his neighbours who visits him occasionally He had a picture of it on his profile. Why lie about this! I have a cat, but don’t really care if potential date has one. In fact current DP doesn’t really like cats, but tolerates mine as we are a package.

found out as he lied about his age on his profile. He mentioned his 50th birthday on the date, but profile said 43. I questioned him and he denied it. My phone came out and showed him his own profile, he couldn’t deny it then. Asked him about other things on there. It all came out as lies to make him look favourable.

LimeTreeGrove · 06/02/2023 12:19

He's probably decided you were only interested in him when you thought he lived in Kensington /Chelsea so will do it even more now

milkyaqua · 06/02/2023 12:17

OneGoodThing · 06/02/2023 10:14

'barmy landlady' = previous girlfriend who lived in a flatshare in Shepherd's Bush but kicked him out five years ago

GrinGrin So good!

Shouldweno2 · 06/02/2023 12:11

Postcode envy. It happens. He sounds insecure.

Biddie191 · 06/02/2023 12:09

DanseAvecLesLoup · Today 11:14
Pixiedust1234 · Today 11:12
Any man who calls another woman barmy, crazy, physco, mental or has mh problems etc to another woman who is essentially a stranger throws up so many reg flags its ridiculous. Its never their fault the previous woman was like that, is it.
The outright lies of where he was living makes you wonder what else he will lie about.
What if his ex was Glen Close?

To be honest, I always thought he deserved everything he got - if he hadn't been having an affair, it wouldn't have happened, would it? He was the married one (the bunny and wife did, of course, deserve none of it).

Namechangethisonetime · 06/02/2023 11:35

Sawmiller · 06/02/2023 11:27

I live in Kensington & Chelsea. Not all of it is posh - Grenfell Tower for example.

Nobody calls it that who lives here. You’d say, Notting Hill, South Ken, Ladbroke Grove, Golbourne, World’s End, Kings Road etc.

Sounds like a delusional nutcase to me. Maybe went through it on a bus once.

Brilliant 😂

And, probably accurate.

PonyPatter44 · 06/02/2023 11:32

You're not wrong, OP, he sounds like an absolute numpty. I doubt there was anything sinister in it, but he sounds rather silly and a bit odd and frankly, no-one needs that in a boyfriend.

Sawmiller · 06/02/2023 11:27

I live in Kensington & Chelsea. Not all of it is posh - Grenfell Tower for example.

Nobody calls it that who lives here. You’d say, Notting Hill, South Ken, Ladbroke Grove, Golbourne, World’s End, Kings Road etc.

Sounds like a delusional nutcase to me. Maybe went through it on a bus once.

MeridianB · 06/02/2023 11:25

He sounds like a petty snob. Not sure how he has lasted so many dates with you. I wouldn't invest more time in someone who couldn't be honest about something so basic.

Lovemusic33 · 06/02/2023 11:21

He’s obviously hiding something and/or pretending to be something he’s not.

online dating is just full of weirdos.

I dated a guy once, he was army, told me he was based not far from my home. One day my car broke down right next to the army camp so I messaged him for help. Turns out he wasn’t based there at all and he was based 50+ miles away 🤔, I also think he was married.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 06/02/2023 11:19

Winemygoodenemy · 06/02/2023 10:46

OLD is a chore. Full of odd people. No idea why people lie as it gets caught out. The genuine people do suffer because of the lying idiots. I dated for years. Finally met my DP on bumble. I was very hard to get and took me a while to trust him as I was used to BS. Just because of the idiots I met beforeHe was understanding when I told him a few stories. DP is a rare find.

Here are highlights to make you feel better

  1. lied about age, education and even fact he owned a cat. Fessed up hour into date after a few conversation inconsistencies. Especially saying he didn’t have a cat
  2. Lied about having 3 kids. Said he won’t let them come between us and he can ignore them if I want.
  3. lied about weight on pictures, using old ones. I am not skinny, but he was at least 10 stones more than his pictures
  4. All exes crazy. He was the one who sent them crazy. He is now a very close friend and still sending girls crazy due to actions
  5. lied about job, name marriage status. Found him on Facebook under who you may know under a different name and wedding pictures as profile. Was dating him at the time
  6. tried to convince me he was a project manager for MoD and had to go to war zones and couldn’t use his phone. Out of contact for weeks. I really new he was a BS, but was fun listening to stories.

Lying about having a cat? Did he pretend he had one, or cancel the cat he actually did have? Either way it is a weird thing to lie about!

MLMsuperfan · 06/02/2023 11:19

People lie about things when dating because they think those things are what makes them attractive. People often have a naive one dimensional idea of what potential partners are looking for and they're playing into that. It comes from insecurity basically.

Unfortunately as OP has found out, being caught lying is a deeply unattractive quality.

EmmaEmerald · 06/02/2023 11:14

I reckon the "landlady" is his mum.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 06/02/2023 11:14

Pixiedust1234 · 06/02/2023 11:12

Any man who calls another woman barmy, crazy, physco, mental or has mh problems etc to another woman who is essentially a stranger throws up so many reg flags its ridiculous. Its never their fault the previous woman was like that, is it.

The outright lies of where he was living makes you wonder what else he will lie about.

What if his ex was Glen Close?

Pixiedust1234 · 06/02/2023 11:12

Any man who calls another woman barmy, crazy, physco, mental or has mh problems etc to another woman who is essentially a stranger throws up so many reg flags its ridiculous. Its never their fault the previous woman was like that, is it.

The outright lies of where he was living makes you wonder what else he will lie about.

youngmotherhubbard · 06/02/2023 11:11

JustOneMoreBiscuitPlease · 06/02/2023 10:21

You must be right actually as I just found this guy on FB and he has now changed his name. He used to be called Olly Something and now he’s called Sam Something Else (I don’t even care if I out this one). Same pics and everything so I’m guessing he wasn’t given a new identity by a witness protection programme.

Being exceptionally kind... he's not a teacher or something along those lines? The teachers I know will often use a middle name plus a family name (e.g. mother's maiden name) in an attempt to hide from their pupils.

I'm finding it harder to explain the location. Either he's trying to cover up who he really lives with (girlfriend? parents?), or he's embarrassed by where he actually lives (which is an issue, given he lives down the road and that would mean he's embarrassed by where you live).

CrazyCorgi · 06/02/2023 10:51

He’s probably had a few shags after saying he lives in Kensington and was hoping for the same from You. He sounds very insecure and a bit of a prat so I think you did the right thing.

Winemygoodenemy · 06/02/2023 10:46

OLD is a chore. Full of odd people. No idea why people lie as it gets caught out. The genuine people do suffer because of the lying idiots. I dated for years. Finally met my DP on bumble. I was very hard to get and took me a while to trust him as I was used to BS. Just because of the idiots I met beforeHe was understanding when I told him a few stories. DP is a rare find.

Here are highlights to make you feel better

  1. lied about age, education and even fact he owned a cat. Fessed up hour into date after a few conversation inconsistencies. Especially saying he didn’t have a cat
  2. Lied about having 3 kids. Said he won’t let them come between us and he can ignore them if I want.
  3. lied about weight on pictures, using old ones. I am not skinny, but he was at least 10 stones more than his pictures
  4. All exes crazy. He was the one who sent them crazy. He is now a very close friend and still sending girls crazy due to actions
  5. lied about job, name marriage status. Found him on Facebook under who you may know under a different name and wedding pictures as profile. Was dating him at the time
  6. tried to convince me he was a project manager for MoD and had to go to war zones and couldn’t use his phone. Out of contact for weeks. I really new he was a BS, but was fun listening to stories.
SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 06/02/2023 10:42

naaahhhhhh don't tell him... then he'll just be in under-cover pretentious plonker and some poor mug will waste even more time on him.

EmmaEmerald · 06/02/2023 10:42

Mellymoon · 06/02/2023 10:39

I’d tell him why you changed your mind so he doesn’t do it again or explains himself

I'd actually tell him to see if he explains why

we did have a poster recently say she didn't want to date anyone from two particular London boroughs.

Mellymoon · 06/02/2023 10:39

I’d tell him why you changed your mind so he doesn’t do it again or explains himself

JustOneMoreBiscuitPlease · 06/02/2023 10:39

JudgeJ · 06/02/2023 10:28

I wonder if it was the Kensington and Chelsea location that was attractive to the OP in the first place??

Nah, I’m pretty confident I’ve dated at least one man from every borough of London by now.

OP posts:
Duckingella · 06/02/2023 10:39

Smells like a cheating husband especially with the different names on Facebook