Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hopeless about male violence

189 replies

brujarosada · 06/02/2023 08:21

Everywhere I turn I see news stories where it's implicitly understood that a man harmed a woman. An obvious family annhilator? Definitely the husband. Woman disappears while out? Obviously a man.

I know that this is nothing new, but it feels so inevitable and hopeless. Women getting angry gets some attention sometimes (like with Sarah Everard). But there's no real change and toxic masculinity seems to be ever more celebrated - for example, there's currently a story in The Guardian about an influencer who is capturing the imagination of secondary school boys everywhere.

Am I wrong to feel so hopeless? Is there some sort of inspiring change that I am missing?

OP posts:
MintyFreshOne · 06/02/2023 09:39

Brefugee · 06/02/2023 09:17

Honestly I’ve seen too many stories of people (men and women) beaten and stabbed for intervening. I personally wouldn’t risk it.

you don't have to step in. You can call the police. And on other occasions where mates are saying things? Speak to them. Before it escalates. Your mate beats his gf? check on her, call the police. Your mate gets beligerant when he's drunk - tell him to pack it in before he gets to that stage.

There is so much more people, partlicularly men since many men don't listen to women, can do before it gets to "oh i might get stabbed". Or is that just: well i might get stabbed so i'll do absolutely fuck all?

You seem to think I’m a man?

I am just saying that intervening in public is risky behaviour and I am not surprised people won’t do it. People have been murdered for less.

I don’t disagree with anything else you are saying.

FatSealSmugSoup · 06/02/2023 09:36

BlueKaftan · 06/02/2023 09:08

In Pakistan the government are laying on pink buses for the exclusive use of women, who can rarely take public transportation without being sexually harassed by men.

There’s an article in the mail this morning about a young woman who “mysteriously died” when she took her children to visit their maternal grandmother on her death bed. Children and husband have since disappeared…

I think most of us can figure out what happened - but as her mother says “nobody gives a shit about a poor woman from Burnley”.

I am sick of it.

there were rumours years ago that bromide (?) was slipped in the tea at Colchester (uk military prison) to keep the inmates “docile”.

perhaps that could be extended…

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 09:35

verystablegenius · 06/02/2023 09:00

victims of other men. And it isn't overlooked. But men don't do anything about it.

At a societal level, I agree men don’t do enough, but on an individual level, if a “good man” sees a threatening “bad man”, by wading in, he’s more likely to get assaulted and/or killed.

This
im a smaller bloke, but I know full well that the kindnof harassment in public you’re talking about rarely escalated into violence unless the men are challenged. They won’t hit or stab a woman, but if you intervene you’re very likely to be assaulted or worse.

so yes of course I’d call out people I know behaving badly (although I wouldn’t have friends like that anyway), and of course I’d help anyone is real distress or danger, but honestly I’m not sure about low level harassment. I’m sorry. I feel I’d be in danger that a woman would not.

my partner (female) agrees and has intervened, but says she understands it’s somehow safer for a woman than a man.

as for “we should do something about bad men” well… yes. But you tend to only have friends you like, so not the people who are the problem. I’m also not sure it’s entirely right to say good men are at fault for bad men.

Soopermum1 · 06/02/2023 09:33

It will never change unless everyone takes a stand. Not just feisty young women going on marches. This includes all those family members who just keep the peace, the mates who don't challenge their friends, the new girlfriends who get with these men, even when they have criminal records.

Naunet · 06/02/2023 09:30

SamanthaCaine · 06/02/2023 09:20

Yes and you're the one who started writing nonsense about women being whiter than white.

Here, have your 🙄 with bells on 😂

Ugh, I’m so sick of posters jumping in with this “women are just as bad” shit. I mean statistics prove it’s bullshit yet women like you still feel the need to jump onto these threads to tell us men are no worse than women. Why? Are you trying to fool yourself so that you can feel safer? What’s the drive on a thread about male violence to jump in and post about women?

Slimjimtobe · 06/02/2023 09:29

Two women a week is a shocking statistic
😥

blubberball · 06/02/2023 09:27

I didn't see it either growing up. I went to a mixed school, so I saw myself having the same opportunities as the boys. I got a job in a traditionally male industry, and got paid a man's wage.

Of course, things changed and my eyes were opened once I became pregnant. Maternity allowance and going back to work part time. Working and doing everything at home. The mental load, the house work, the night feeds. Abused financially, emotionally, sexually, physically by my ex.

I now have a chronic health condition, and here I am at the bottom of the heap. A divorced, disabled single mother, relying on universal credit. I definitely see the inequalities now. I am raising 2 sons, and trying my best to have them check their privilege, and treat women with respect.

CaraVann · 06/02/2023 09:25

YANBU and listening to the stories my 14 year old dd tells me about the boys in her year and their opinions and attitudes towards girls frankly scares the hell out of me especially as so many girls her age accept these boys attitudes towards girls as being normal.
The likes of Andrew Tate and other misogynistic arseholes are fuelling this belief that girls and women are ‘up for it’ and will do what they are told.

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/02/2023 09:23

SamanthaCaine · 06/02/2023 09:20

Yes and you're the one who started writing nonsense about women being whiter than white.

Here, have your 🙄 with bells on 😂

Oh stop it, there’s no comparison to be made.

SamanthaCaine · 06/02/2023 09:20

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/02/2023 09:08

The only thing women seem to lack is the capacity to be as violent

This is literally a thread about male violence 🙄

Yes and you're the one who started writing nonsense about women being whiter than white.

Here, have your 🙄 with bells on 😂

SamanthaCaine · 06/02/2023 09:18

verystablegenius · 06/02/2023 09:00

victims of other men. And it isn't overlooked. But men don't do anything about it.

At a societal level, I agree men don’t do enough, but on an individual level, if a “good man” sees a threatening “bad man”, by wading in, he’s more likely to get assaulted and/or killed.

This

In context here, but it's not easy for good men (yeah diddums). Violent or aggressive men who do stuff openly in public are wired to protect their egos and will do almost anything to save face. So if confronted by some mild mannered man who's trying to do the right thing by women, he'll be on the receiving end of a beating, unless other people step up and there's safety in numbers.

But people don't step in, because no-one ever knows if the perpetrator might be carrying. Then you're falling into the 'disposable male' trap by basically putting good men in potential harm, just to satisfy your belief that good men step up.

Sadly most truly decent men aren't like Jason Statham, which would be off-putting for anyone in public, but you don't solve violence with more violence so what we're asking for is a visual deterrent that isn't violent. That's as rare as rocking horse shit.

So all you're really left with is decent men calling out stuff between mates or at work. This doesn't really solve the issue that the OP is fearful of.

IneedanewTV · 06/02/2023 09:17

BigMadAdrian · 06/02/2023 08:44

Sadly I don't think young women will, because they all think like you say you did when you were younger - they believe that it isn't a problem. We only start to see the cracks appearing as we get older and can see with hindsight what it was like the whole time. You only have to look at how fiercely many young women defend self ID, thinking that they are being liberal and open-minded (and that older women who object to it are 'TERFS' and 'Karens'), whilst allowing their own rights to be trashed.

This. It wasn’t until I was in my 40s that I’ve become so angry about the number of women killed every week. Before that I just did not know or probably just accepted it as boys will be boys behaviour. Terrible I know. But I was brought up to admire and look after men.

Brefugee · 06/02/2023 09:17

Honestly I’ve seen too many stories of people (men and women) beaten and stabbed for intervening. I personally wouldn’t risk it.

you don't have to step in. You can call the police. And on other occasions where mates are saying things? Speak to them. Before it escalates. Your mate beats his gf? check on her, call the police. Your mate gets beligerant when he's drunk - tell him to pack it in before he gets to that stage.

There is so much more people, partlicularly men since many men don't listen to women, can do before it gets to "oh i might get stabbed". Or is that just: well i might get stabbed so i'll do absolutely fuck all?

Naunet · 06/02/2023 09:17

FriedEggChocolate · 06/02/2023 09:00

With the Epsom case, maybe wait to check it's not something like carbon monoxide poisoning before jumping to that conclusion. With the woman near Blackpool, I'm more saddened that she's got the level of press attention that she has, when similar "person disappears and no trace is found" cases, like the case of Richard Okorogheye, get nothing like the press coverage. No companies volunteering to do radar searches for him.

You realise most missing women don’t make the press? Just like most of our rapes and murders don’t either.

MintyFreshOne · 06/02/2023 09:14

Brefugee · 06/02/2023 09:03

What if your DH had been stabbed?

then he would have been a victim of m-on-m violence. He wasn't going to get stabbed, once he and one other man stepped up, others took the cue and stepped in too.

Don't make excuses. Sure there are times when what you do is call the police, and other times you can step in. Heck i've stepped in on occasions like this in the past. It usually takes one person in a crowd to say "no" and others will support you.

Honestly I’ve seen too many stories of people (men and women) beaten and stabbed for intervening. I personally wouldn’t risk it.

MintyFreshOne · 06/02/2023 09:11

FriedEggChocolate · 06/02/2023 09:00

With the Epsom case, maybe wait to check it's not something like carbon monoxide poisoning before jumping to that conclusion. With the woman near Blackpool, I'm more saddened that she's got the level of press attention that she has, when similar "person disappears and no trace is found" cases, like the case of Richard Okorogheye, get nothing like the press coverage. No companies volunteering to do radar searches for him.

I’m sorry, but it’s very true that men are not considered valuable. There is a social hierarchy

If a man disappears, it is usually just a personal or family tragedy. No one else particularly cares. If a woman or child disappears, people do tend to care more.

I don’t see why this is a problem tbh

Luredbyapomegranate · 06/02/2023 09:08

JuneOsborne · 06/02/2023 08:42

Well, it starts with data. Police forces don't bother to count the number of women and children killed by men. You can't ask a police force how many women were killed by men in your authorities area because they don't fucking know.

Karen IS and Jess Phillips appear to be the only people doing it.

I think this is the only practical starting point.

Use a central database and count all the crimes of violence against women and girls, divided into regions and types of offence. Then in a year, look at the stats and decide a programme to deal with it, with targets and regular reviews.

Once it becomes a big named problem, with big posters on buses and data backed solutions being sought, that will help a lot.

Right now it's a toxic drip drip drip.

BlueKaftan · 06/02/2023 09:08

In Pakistan the government are laying on pink buses for the exclusive use of women, who can rarely take public transportation without being sexually harassed by men.

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/02/2023 09:08

The only thing women seem to lack is the capacity to be as violent

This is literally a thread about male violence 🙄

BlueKaftan · 06/02/2023 09:05

Deathbyfluffy · 06/02/2023 08:37

It’s exhausting being a man and seeing everything pinned on us these days - there needs to be some kind of balance.
I’ve come to the conclusion that humans as a species are generally toxic, so avoid most of them on principle 😁

Oh ffs. Read the room.

SamanthaCaine · 06/02/2023 09:03

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/02/2023 08:48

I’ve tried explaining to DH how mentally exhausting going through life as a woman is. 99.9% of the misery in the world is caused by men, either at the very top end - dictators, warmongerers, corrupt leaders - right down to unpleasant interactions the moment you step out your front door. Men themselves are spared a lot of the lower level stuff, of course - they don’t get cat called or followed or have random nutters approaching them in the streets leaving them feeling intimidated.

But YANBU, it’s completely draining.

It CAN be draining for sure, if you let it drag you down. It's depressing listening to my DD's perspective on going out and how it's a lottery. She never quite knows whether she's going to be on the end of male BS or abuse if she turns down a man's advance. She's only bloody 18 so a great into to adult life. However despite this she compartmentalised it as she'd never go out if she spent her life worrying about it. So it's there, but not. Hats off to her TBH.

But let's not kid ourselves that women don't have the capacity to make people's lives an utter misery. Sure Kwasi Kwarteng was the face of the budget but he was Liz's puppet and she's basically wreaked havoc on our lives and ruined many. All in 45 days. Some will never recover from what she's done to this country and she has zero remorse. Then we have Michelle Mone, Theresa May, both self serving assholes who have made millions from being utter shite. Thatcher sent us to war. The list goes on. It's a shorter list but women are gaining traction at the top (in all areas of life) and often showing us that they can be equally evil and self serving at our expense.

The only thing women seem to lack is the capacity to be as violent but some will happily use violet men to achieve their aims, this perpetuating things.

Hups · 06/02/2023 09:03

This goes against the general consensus, but I can honestly say that I don't give it any headspace.
If you want to change the way things are, then start with your own sons.

Brefugee · 06/02/2023 09:03

What if your DH had been stabbed?

then he would have been a victim of m-on-m violence. He wasn't going to get stabbed, once he and one other man stepped up, others took the cue and stepped in too.

Don't make excuses. Sure there are times when what you do is call the police, and other times you can step in. Heck i've stepped in on occasions like this in the past. It usually takes one person in a crowd to say "no" and others will support you.

AgathaMystery · 06/02/2023 09:03

It’s exhausting. I’m so, so tired of it.

how weird to think that the man I married, father of my children, who I lie next to in bed at night - is the most dangerous person (to me, personally) that I will ever meet. How depressing.

what can we do to persuade men to stop murdering us.

why should we even have to persuade them.

verystablegenius · 06/02/2023 09:02

Men are not murdered for just being men, I am more likely to be murdered than my OH, however should OH start buying drugs, dealing drugs, fighting in pubs and football matches his chances go up.

this is what bothers me. This is the “men deserve it” argument. Turn the tables - “she went out to a bar, …., her chances went up”. how does that sound?