Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hopeless about male violence

189 replies

brujarosada · 06/02/2023 08:21

Everywhere I turn I see news stories where it's implicitly understood that a man harmed a woman. An obvious family annhilator? Definitely the husband. Woman disappears while out? Obviously a man.

I know that this is nothing new, but it feels so inevitable and hopeless. Women getting angry gets some attention sometimes (like with Sarah Everard). But there's no real change and toxic masculinity seems to be ever more celebrated - for example, there's currently a story in The Guardian about an influencer who is capturing the imagination of secondary school boys everywhere.

Am I wrong to feel so hopeless? Is there some sort of inspiring change that I am missing?

OP posts:
StayGoldenPonyGirl · 06/02/2023 18:20

I have witnessed thousands of chances men I know have had to safely challenge other men on sexism. My XH, my dad, my brother, my uncles, my colleagues, my (ex) friends, ex boyfriends. Sure there have been times when it could have been dangerous, but i'm thinking of sexist jokes by text, sharing porn, comments on women's appearance and fuckability, strip clubs/ buying sex, calling me naggy names, having a good old laugh about women's issues and initiatives at work, endless 'on-the-rag' jokes (I can give a thousand examples and details if they aren't good enough) and these are just things i was permitted to witness. In the vast majority of those cases there would have been no threat of violence if they had spoken up. There could have been lost friendships, tense work relationships, and in the case of the landlord at the pub I worked at from 13-17, potential financial loss if he told patrons to stop groping and sleazing.

Men care more about money and their social comfort than about women's lives. They just do. I'd be willing to bet ALL men have let something slide when they could have physically safely done something at some point and the VAST majority do it on a regular basis. They don't care, they want the status quo. No fcking idea how to change that - agree with the word hopeless in the OP.

KimWexlersPonyTail · 06/02/2023 18:12

verystablegenius · 06/02/2023 09:02

Men are not murdered for just being men, I am more likely to be murdered than my OH, however should OH start buying drugs, dealing drugs, fighting in pubs and football matches his chances go up.

this is what bothers me. This is the “men deserve it” argument. Turn the tables - “she went out to a bar, …., her chances went up”. how does that sound?

I wasn't implying men deserved it, just that they are not targeted in the same way as women. When a man kills another man there is usually some back story to it.

MiaMoor · 06/02/2023 17:24

How often do you see a thread where challenging boys are seated next to girls in primary school?
The conditioning of girls to take responsibility for boys behaviour starts young.

MiaMoor · 06/02/2023 17:20

DanseAvecLesLoup · 06/02/2023 17:02

By calling out sexist banter and rape jokes every single time they hear it.

Fine in theory, but what following scenario is more likely:

Scenario 1

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Oi love, show us your tits"

Other random male pub patron: "Come on mate, no need to say that, it's really disrespectful"

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Hmmmm, yeah, sorry you are right, that was bang out of order. I will be more considerate and respectful in future, thanks for the heads up "

Scenario 2

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Oi love, show us your tits"

Other random male pub patron: "Come on mate, no need to say that, it's really disrespectful"

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Fuck off you prick"

Other random male pub patron: "Seriously, it's not cool to treat women like that"

Pissed bloke outside pub: "What the fuck are you going to do about it..................oi I'm talking to you.....come on then.....<sound of glass breaking>"

etc etc

It's not a case of not wanting to challenge crap behaviour, it is a genuine fear of what the dickhead you have just challenged is going to do.

As someone has pointed out upthread, at that point many potential steps have been missed out.

At my dc’s secondary school sexist comments to girls from boys was rife, it was dismissed each and every time as boys being boys, and in one case, where a very creepy boy would mock choke girls, dismissed as him having poor social skills (so teach him that choking girls is dangerous?).

When girls were groped at parties it was never the boys who were at fault - he’s drunk, doesn’t know what he’s doing, and if the girl complains she’s just attention seeking.

Boys need some decent role models who will show them and teach them that isn’t ok, so hopefully by the time they are middle aged and drunk outside a pub the first thing in their heads won’t be to harass women. At the same time girls need good strong role models to teach them the common red flags and help them grow up to be assertive.

If every time a teenage boy behaved badly towards a girl all his friends and all the girls called him out, it would stop. Right now he is almost congratulated - how does that teach any boy to grow up to be a decent man, and how does it teach any girl to expect more from life?

Very often you find men and boys behave in a civilised manner when trying to get a girlfriend. Once she’s slept with him he’s off. Or once she’s had children and can’t easily leave, he turns into a 1950s man who expects his dinner on the table and sex whenever he wants, or he’ll sulk.

Honestly men get away with behaving like animals.

DoomedForLoneliness · 06/02/2023 17:19

DanseAvecLesLoup · 06/02/2023 17:02

By calling out sexist banter and rape jokes every single time they hear it.

Fine in theory, but what following scenario is more likely:

Scenario 1

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Oi love, show us your tits"

Other random male pub patron: "Come on mate, no need to say that, it's really disrespectful"

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Hmmmm, yeah, sorry you are right, that was bang out of order. I will be more considerate and respectful in future, thanks for the heads up "

Scenario 2

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Oi love, show us your tits"

Other random male pub patron: "Come on mate, no need to say that, it's really disrespectful"

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Fuck off you prick"

Other random male pub patron: "Seriously, it's not cool to treat women like that"

Pissed bloke outside pub: "What the fuck are you going to do about it..................oi I'm talking to you.....come on then.....<sound of glass breaking>"

etc etc

It's not a case of not wanting to challenge crap behaviour, it is a genuine fear of what the dickhead you have just challenged is going to do.

But doesn’t this ’men are too scared to help women cause other men are scary’ really just prove how dangerous and horrible men are?

If men are willing to do that to another man, imagine what they are ready to do to a woman?

And man has more changes againts another than a woman in pretty much all cases.

And why are there so many making excuses for men not stepping up?

DanseAvecLesLoup · 06/02/2023 17:02

By calling out sexist banter and rape jokes every single time they hear it.

Fine in theory, but what following scenario is more likely:

Scenario 1

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Oi love, show us your tits"

Other random male pub patron: "Come on mate, no need to say that, it's really disrespectful"

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Hmmmm, yeah, sorry you are right, that was bang out of order. I will be more considerate and respectful in future, thanks for the heads up "

Scenario 2

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Oi love, show us your tits"

Other random male pub patron: "Come on mate, no need to say that, it's really disrespectful"

Pissed bloke outside pub: "Fuck off you prick"

Other random male pub patron: "Seriously, it's not cool to treat women like that"

Pissed bloke outside pub: "What the fuck are you going to do about it..................oi I'm talking to you.....come on then.....<sound of glass breaking>"

etc etc

It's not a case of not wanting to challenge crap behaviour, it is a genuine fear of what the dickhead you have just challenged is going to do.

MiaMoor · 06/02/2023 16:16

Fixed that for you there. If delta-male behaviour like this happens among farm animals they’re generally castrated and/or slaughtered.

Pretty much all male farm animals are slaughtered for meat. Keeping them beyond this becomes a logistical nightmare if they are a particularly aggressive breed.

Many will live peacefully in bachelor groups (thinking rams and cockerels here), but only if well away from females of the species - if too close the males will fight each other constantly.

It’s all very well blaming parents, and specifically mothers, as a poster here has tried, but parents aren’t the only influence on growing children. Once at secondary school they become more influenced by each other. Porn is easily accessible and largely accepted as normal and ok for men to watch (thank libfems), and teaches boys that women and girls are ready and willing to do anything at the drop of a hat, and that dangerous and painful practices are a huge turn on. This teaches boys that women are objects to look at, to use, rather than equal members of society. This is compounded by every single person who spouts “boys will be boys” or “NAMALT” or “sex work is work” or “TWAW”. Every one of these takes away women’s humanity.

Men can sort it by stopping watching porn. By calling out sexist banter and rape jokes every single time they hear it. By not dismissing women’s natural fear of men and respecting their spaces. By not treating women as the go-to childcare, housekeeper, carer. So many things they could do, but you hear so many excuses why they can’t possibly.

Dd is a young adult, lives in a big city. She is harassed by men every day. She’s bothered by men in places where there are rules stating she’s in a place where male employees are not allowed to approach women in a flirty/sexual way, and yet they do, every time she goes to work, to the gym, to the swimming pool. It’s endemic. You cannot escape from it.

I have a few men in my life that I love, but on the whole I now find men to be entitled wankers who make a shit ton of excuses as to why they can’t just be decent people. It’s always someone else’s fault.

Does anyone remember the case where loads of men were drugged and raped? The outcry from that from the men was heart rending. I actually thought it might make a difference to how men treated female rape victims, but nope, straight back to supporting <sporting hero rapist> <poor drunk friend who didn’t know what he was doing> <poor brother who definitely hasn’t raped anyone>. It’s like this sick man code stops a large proportion of men from being decent human beings. It’s sickening.

MaryBary · 06/02/2023 16:16

When we talk about intervention though, there is a common denominator. Women are afraid that men will harm them, and men are afraid to help because they are also afraid that men will harm them.

The conversation has to be how do we stop men from harming people?

SideEyeSally · 06/02/2023 16:08

My partner got between a man and the women he was repeatedly slapping in the street one night. He gave my partner and black eye and then the women kicked him in the ribs and spat on him. He doesn't intervene now.

IneedanewTV · 06/02/2023 15:54

DanseAvecLesLoup · 06/02/2023 14:27

I reckon most of the men on that train did not think it was okay to assault a lone woman, they were just scared of intervening and getting beaten up. Not much consolation for you but there is a difference. Intervention is always hard, even just a polite verbal challenge can very quickly spiral out of control and become physical, I have sadly seen on more then a few occasions the good Samaritan get publically thumped for his efforts which always makes others think twice about getting involved even if they know it is the right thing to do. It is a shit situation. I have offered a woman on the train the option of moving to another carriage with me when a group of lads started to verbally harass her. Problem is these lads followed us both into the next carriage but directed their abuse at me instead. I was a big rugby playing bloke at the time and it was still fucking scary, we got off at the next stop and informed the guard who in turn arranged for the transport police to rock up. I hate these aresholes.

Yes 100% agree. I suppose I’ve always told my adult son not to get involved as you don’t know if they have a knife and you don’t get any thanks when you are dead. So I can see it both ways. I would expect my son to call the police, get help etc but necessarily jump in and get involved.

C8H10N4O2 · 06/02/2023 15:39

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 10:49

There’s isn’t one.
I know that. It’s awful, I know.

what should I, specifically, do about “male behaviour “? I don’t do it, I don’t see it (I know full well it happens though), I don’t have friends or family who do it.

im vocally against it but I find so is everyone I know. I bring up my son with the same beliefs. I’m an ally here.

the only but I’m a bit uncomfortable with is being told I need to deal with this. It’s not me doing it, it’s men I have connection with, or influence over, much as I could try

That's a long way of saying you are not doing anything, that you assume all the men around you are just fine and there isn't a problem.

From my PoV - without that little tag on your ear, the only safe thing to do is to assume you are a risk. Basic safeguarding. You don't like that - then start campaigning and lobbying for change, actively looking around you and intervening etc.

If I had a quid for every man I've met who insists they are one of the "good guys" but who still benefits from the labour of women, who just "doesn't hear" the dodgy jokes, and whose first reaction to a story of male violence is not "what can I do more to change things" but to jump in saying "not all men" then I'd be able to buy Neckar from Richard Branson and retire there.

SerafinasGoose · 06/02/2023 14:40

Addicted2Kale · 06/02/2023 11:35

There is no such thing as toxic masculinity. That obfuscates the issue and solves nothing. There are only men, boys and animals. Men as a collective are not represented by the animals. If 50% of men were as the OP describes, society would cease to function.

So learn to recognise savages at the earliest point. Share your findings. Stop dating and procreating with these animals. Keep your mace and pepper spray strapped on & locked in. Involve the police at the first instance of savagery, so there's a record on them and we can get them off the streets asap.

The enemy isn't men. It's the savages. Lets work together, with men, for a safer society for us all.

NAMALT. We've all heard this defence before.

There is, very much, such a thing as toxic masculinity, only this is is commonly misunderstood as an assertion that every man and boy is toxic. It's not. Toxic masculinity is a set of harmful stereotypes, perpetuated throughout the vast majority of human cultures, which are held up as exemplars of how males are 'expected' to behave. It often manifests in macho culture: the dominant male, the provider, the protector of his own (and sometimes the attacker of those who threaten them), the successful CEO, the sex to whom women owe our respect and servitude, the alpha male. There are images of this stereotype disseminated through every level of our societies: from education to faith to the justice system to reality TV to advertising.

Some men don't fit that pattern (cf the 'new man' of the 1990s), and are happy and confident enough not to fit it. However, a great many more who don't fit the pattern feel they've failed in some way. And they are being failed, in turn, by society itself. Male suicide rates, the present angst and confusion about 'gender' (which is to blame for all the above in the first place), unbridled anger, VAWG, the furious men who blame women for this predicament and come together as incel groups. And many of the casualities of this mess are women.

Dismantling these stereotypes is the only way of freeing both men and women from them. There's just as damaging a set of toxic feminine stereotypes out there, but a good many more women are sick of the whole shebang and are turning our backs on it.

None of the above is not helped by an aggressive gender ideology which seems hellbent on upholding these tired, dated, passe stereotypes for the majority of society so that they can subvert them on some very individual level of identity politics.

To deny this reality exists is to lose any opportunity of fixing it.

verystablegenius · 06/02/2023 14:28

SerafinasGoose · 06/02/2023 14:22

There's an important aspect you are also ignoring.

Men are the problem.

It’s literally the first thing I said in the post you quoted

DanseAvecLesLoup · 06/02/2023 14:27

MaryBary · 06/02/2023 13:58

@DanseAvecLesLoup that's my point, you're unlikely to know if there is an abuser amongst your family or friends. I certainly don't know those men through hanging round in dodgy pubs with horrible people.

And intervention doesn't have to be physical. But what you could do if you saw a woman being assaulted on the train is:

  1. press the alarm for help
  2. call the police
  3. ask the victim if they were OK
  4. ask if they'd like me to walk with them to the station office

The way I see it, every single man on that train thought it was OK to assault a lone female. They all turned the other way.

I reckon most of the men on that train did not think it was okay to assault a lone woman, they were just scared of intervening and getting beaten up. Not much consolation for you but there is a difference. Intervention is always hard, even just a polite verbal challenge can very quickly spiral out of control and become physical, I have sadly seen on more then a few occasions the good Samaritan get publically thumped for his efforts which always makes others think twice about getting involved even if they know it is the right thing to do. It is a shit situation. I have offered a woman on the train the option of moving to another carriage with me when a group of lads started to verbally harass her. Problem is these lads followed us both into the next carriage but directed their abuse at me instead. I was a big rugby playing bloke at the time and it was still fucking scary, we got off at the next stop and informed the guard who in turn arranged for the transport police to rock up. I hate these aresholes.

SerafinasGoose · 06/02/2023 14:22

verystablegenius · 06/02/2023 08:53

I agree the problem of male violence is depressing, but one thing that does bother me is that men are more likely to be victims of violence too, and that aspect is often overlooked, as if men deserve it.

There's an important aspect you are also ignoring.

Men are the problem.

MaryBary · 06/02/2023 13:58

@DanseAvecLesLoup that's my point, you're unlikely to know if there is an abuser amongst your family or friends. I certainly don't know those men through hanging round in dodgy pubs with horrible people.

And intervention doesn't have to be physical. But what you could do if you saw a woman being assaulted on the train is:

  1. press the alarm for help
  2. call the police
  3. ask the victim if they were OK
  4. ask if they'd like me to walk with them to the station office

The way I see it, every single man on that train thought it was OK to assault a lone female. They all turned the other way.

IneedanewTV · 06/02/2023 12:49

I know of a man that frequents prostitutes. I don’t know if his wife knows. He has always done this. He isn’t my friend. He has a group of male friends that know this. They still meet him for drinks, meals out etc. The only change over the many years is that the friends wife’s/partners refuse to socialise if he is there. The men still go. But these are old men ie late 50s early 60s. I can only hope the younger generation would refuse to go out…….

DanseAvecLesLoup · 06/02/2023 12:34

MaryBary · 06/02/2023 11:49

I don't believe that bad men only associate with other bad men and vice versa. The 3 domestic abusers I know/knew are all "salt of the earth" men, in heroic type jobs (paramedic, police, lifeguard) and have reputations as very very nice men. One of them put his wife in hospital for 3 months.

The sexual predator I know of is a decorated war hero and very popular.

And intervening in a witnessed attack doesn't have to be a violent intervention. I was the only woman in a tube carriage once, a man climbed on top of me and tried to force a bottle of wine down my throat. Every men in the carriage looked the other way. When I finally managed to push him off me he screamed that I was a slut and a whole, until I could get off at the next stop. No one asked if I was OK or saw that I safely got off the train. There were at least 8 other men there

I would argue that there is a very strong correlation between someones moral compass and values and the company they keep. I tend drink in pubs not full of twats so I don't have to listen to casual racism or sexism. I try and make sure my social circle is not full of pricks. I would also imagine that most abusers do not casually admit to friends or strangers alike that they physically/financially/emotionally/sexually abuse their partners. If I found out a friend was an abuser I would end that friendship. I have also learned the hard way that 'stepping in' to try and moderate or stop some strangers offensive behaviour is fraught with the very real risk of getting the shit kicked out of you.

DatasCat · 06/02/2023 12:30

I’ve come to the conclusion that men as a sex are often toxic

Fixed that for you there. If delta-male behaviour like this happens among farm animals they’re generally castrated and/or slaughtered.

IneedanewTV · 06/02/2023 12:23

Fizbosshoes · 06/02/2023 08:37

I agree how depressing it feels to have the likes of Andrew Tate influencing teenage boys with their misogynistic and offensive views on women. And the Emily Atack programme where she documents how many dick pics and disgusting messages she gets daily (and the men that she confided in - despite not being implicated themselves - either found it funny or were pretty nonchalant about the whole thing)

However I don't think its right to speculate on a new story that's just broken and of which very few details have been released.

I wonder how many men have watched the Emily Atack programme? Very few I would imagine. I watched it with my partner and he admitted he would not have watched it otherwise. He was surprised by the amount of abuse she got. It needs to be shown at schools. It’s about education.

watching an episode of riptide last night. The extended family were celebrating a birthday. 3 men 2 women. At the end of the meal the two women got up and cleared the table. It’s ingrained in us all. I’m only starting to notice it now.

MaryBary · 06/02/2023 11:49

I don't believe that bad men only associate with other bad men and vice versa. The 3 domestic abusers I know/knew are all "salt of the earth" men, in heroic type jobs (paramedic, police, lifeguard) and have reputations as very very nice men. One of them put his wife in hospital for 3 months.

The sexual predator I know of is a decorated war hero and very popular.

And intervening in a witnessed attack doesn't have to be a violent intervention. I was the only woman in a tube carriage once, a man climbed on top of me and tried to force a bottle of wine down my throat. Every men in the carriage looked the other way. When I finally managed to push him off me he screamed that I was a slut and a whole, until I could get off at the next stop. No one asked if I was OK or saw that I safely got off the train. There were at least 8 other men there

takealettermsjones · 06/02/2023 11:40

Addicted2Kale · 06/02/2023 11:35

There is no such thing as toxic masculinity. That obfuscates the issue and solves nothing. There are only men, boys and animals. Men as a collective are not represented by the animals. If 50% of men were as the OP describes, society would cease to function.

So learn to recognise savages at the earliest point. Share your findings. Stop dating and procreating with these animals. Keep your mace and pepper spray strapped on & locked in. Involve the police at the first instance of savagery, so there's a record on them and we can get them off the streets asap.

The enemy isn't men. It's the savages. Lets work together, with men, for a safer society for us all.

The "animals" as you say were once boys. They were babies, wrapped in their parents' arms, and they were cheeky little children who played and laughed and went off to school like everybody else. Somewhere along the line they became animals. That's where toxic masculinity comes in; it's society's influence on that process.

"Learning to recognise the savages" again puts the responsibility on the victims, does it not? What if we're bad at recognising them; do we get what we deserve? Involving the police is not always possible, and in any event will very rarely "get them off the streets" at the first sign of violence.

Incidentally, carrying mace and pepper spray is illegal in the UK.

Rainbowclimbinghigh · 06/02/2023 11:38

FriedEggChocolate · 06/02/2023 09:00

With the Epsom case, maybe wait to check it's not something like carbon monoxide poisoning before jumping to that conclusion. With the woman near Blackpool, I'm more saddened that she's got the level of press attention that she has, when similar "person disappears and no trace is found" cases, like the case of Richard Okorogheye, get nothing like the press coverage. No companies volunteering to do radar searches for him.

Possible, but why would the police have been called at 1am if that was the case? They surely would not have been discovered until the following day?

Tekkentime · 06/02/2023 11:38

I heard that people with a dark triad personality are more likely to be successful and therefore reproduce, so more people with the same personality traits are being born.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_triad

Addicted2Kale · 06/02/2023 11:35

There is no such thing as toxic masculinity. That obfuscates the issue and solves nothing. There are only men, boys and animals. Men as a collective are not represented by the animals. If 50% of men were as the OP describes, society would cease to function.

So learn to recognise savages at the earliest point. Share your findings. Stop dating and procreating with these animals. Keep your mace and pepper spray strapped on & locked in. Involve the police at the first instance of savagery, so there's a record on them and we can get them off the streets asap.

The enemy isn't men. It's the savages. Lets work together, with men, for a safer society for us all.