Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hopeless about male violence

189 replies

brujarosada · 06/02/2023 08:21

Everywhere I turn I see news stories where it's implicitly understood that a man harmed a woman. An obvious family annhilator? Definitely the husband. Woman disappears while out? Obviously a man.

I know that this is nothing new, but it feels so inevitable and hopeless. Women getting angry gets some attention sometimes (like with Sarah Everard). But there's no real change and toxic masculinity seems to be ever more celebrated - for example, there's currently a story in The Guardian about an influencer who is capturing the imagination of secondary school boys everywhere.

Am I wrong to feel so hopeless? Is there some sort of inspiring change that I am missing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fairypeasant · 07/02/2023 13:46

And the men don't think "What is it about us that means it's obvious it was the husband?" No, they immediately go to DARVO, and NAMALT.

It's so wearing. OF COURSE the one with the y chromosome murdered his wife and daughter. We knew that. We knew that because it's what happens 95% of the time. And it's too much. Too much male violence.

brujarosada · 07/02/2023 12:51

@Sapphire387 I suppose it's appropriate not to speculate - but it was incredibly obvious that this was what happened

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 07/02/2023 11:54

So much for those posters telling us to reserve judgement in case it was carbon monoxide poisoning.

It always seems to be the husband. I'm so angry.

lifeturnsonadime · 07/02/2023 11:40

And totally unsurprisingly the Police have announced that Emma Pattison and her daughter were murdered by the man they should have been able to trust. RIP. You deserved better.

An average of 2 women a week are killed a the hands of violent men.

This is simply awful.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 07/02/2023 08:56

verystablegenius · 06/02/2023 23:39

i grant that i misinterpreted your post, but I don’t agree with your first point. You’re not more likely to be murdered than your OH.

The statistics show that in the UK, men are three times more likely to be murdered than women. Now, while some of them might have been dealing drugs or whatever, there are legion stories of men being killed through unprovoked attacks.

(As an aside I think there may be a mutual misunderstanding about what is to be a man or woman. On this thread, many women have posted about the constant threat of violence in their daily lives, but as a man, I particularly remember this constant threat as a young man. From a young age, boys become aware of the threat of “the hardest kid in school” ready to give you a beating, and I remember going out as a young man feeling the threat of other men (it’s less now I’m a middle aged father).

You’re implying that when men get murdered, then, it’s a good chance it was their own fault. That’s incredibly unfair.

Yup. An awful lot of violence is completely unprovoked and this idea that blokes who get killed or severely hurt were somehow in part to blame because they had to be involved in criminal activities is a bit naive. I have been attacked while walking home alone at night by a bunch of feral arseholes. I had never seen them before. I was 'lucky' that one of my assailants gave me a few seconds warning by shouting while charging at me which allowed me to start sprinting. Got clipped around the head with a few glancing punches but otherwise managed to flee. It was terrifying. I have other friends who were not so lucky and essentially got the shit kicked out of them. Their crime, walking home on their own and being an easy target for a gang of thugs. I am a bit older and wiser these days so I catch a taxi home rather then walk, I don't go to busy city centre pubs or known trouble spots or hang around at kick out time when there is a much higher risk of violence, I cross the road when I see a group of drunk men walking towards me, I will change carriages if a group of pissed up people get on board etc. Believe it or not most men don't actually go looking for a fight when they go out socialising , sadly a sizable violent minority take that choice away from the others.

MintyFreshOne · 07/02/2023 05:18

I think people often conflate a safe society with a less misogynistic society. I have lived in misogynistic societies that are extremely safe, and more equal societies that are actually more dangerous.

Tackling misogyny is ofc a good thing to pursue, but it won’t necessarily lower actual rates of violence.

MintyFreshOne · 07/02/2023 04:48

DoomedForLoneliness · 06/02/2023 17:19

But doesn’t this ’men are too scared to help women cause other men are scary’ really just prove how dangerous and horrible men are?

If men are willing to do that to another man, imagine what they are ready to do to a woman?

And man has more changes againts another than a woman in pretty much all cases.

And why are there so many making excuses for men not stepping up?

It’s not an excuse to be concerned about one’s personal safety first. If my DH intervened in this kind of situation I’d be PISSED because he could get seriously hurt or killed.

verystablegenius · 07/02/2023 00:06

One more thing, the fighting in pubs or football matches can overlook what is in effect an unprovoked attack.

verystablegenius · 06/02/2023 23:39

Matildalamp · 06/02/2023 19:33

@verystablegenius
Today 09:02
Men are not murdered for just being men, I am more likely to be murdered than my OH, however should OH start buying drugs, dealing drugs, fighting in pubs and football matches his chances go up.

“this is what bothers me. This is the “men deserve it” argument. Turn the tables - “she went out to a bar, …., her chances went up”. how does that sound?”

Dealing drugs, a criminal act
Buying drugs, a criminal act
Fighting in pubs? Not in the league of drugs but can also lead to arrest.
Going to a football match, not a criminal act.

You responded with “she went out to a bar”.

Going to a bar does not compare well with buying/dealing drugs. And it does not compare well with fighting in pubs.

Does it compare with going to a football match, yes, if a man goes to a football match and is endangered simply because he was there he should not be blamed for that.

But I’m sorry your “women going to the bar” response doesn’t work with the rest. If a man or woman gets involved in crime and it leads to violence against them, that’s a risk they run!

i grant that i misinterpreted your post, but I don’t agree with your first point. You’re not more likely to be murdered than your OH.

The statistics show that in the UK, men are three times more likely to be murdered than women. Now, while some of them might have been dealing drugs or whatever, there are legion stories of men being killed through unprovoked attacks.

(As an aside I think there may be a mutual misunderstanding about what is to be a man or woman. On this thread, many women have posted about the constant threat of violence in their daily lives, but as a man, I particularly remember this constant threat as a young man. From a young age, boys become aware of the threat of “the hardest kid in school” ready to give you a beating, and I remember going out as a young man feeling the threat of other men (it’s less now I’m a middle aged father).

You’re implying that when men get murdered, then, it’s a good chance it was their own fault. That’s incredibly unfair.

StayGoldenPonyGirl · 06/02/2023 20:22

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 20:07

But yeah, anyone not admitting to being a problem is useless…

You have repeatedly said you don't see any sexism (or are unwilling to intervene in the stuff you do see). Keep doing what you are doing - you have declared yourself useless to do anything else.

BabyOnBoard90 · 06/02/2023 20:21

Like with all violence across the world, we haven't unfortunately evolved enough

harrassedmumto3 · 06/02/2023 20:17

I was having a chat with the Year 8 girls at work today. It was depressing. They are generally treated abysmally by their male peers.

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 20:07

But yeah, anyone not admitting to being a problem is useless…

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 20:06

StayGoldenPonyGirl · 06/02/2023 20:04

Ok, you @FloydPepper bear no responsibility, have no sexist friends, acquaintances or experiences and are useless in the fight against sexism.

You have nothing to contribute of any use except to add to the hopelessness. Ta

I was hoping the conversation could move on from the basic “call out your mates or you’re just as much at fault” to being able to suggest what I / we can actually do to help, and how to reach the men who don’t have any mates who would think anything other than “it’s fine”

StayGoldenPonyGirl · 06/02/2023 20:04

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 19:58

I literally said I know it’s widespread and probably the majority of men to some degree are awful. What I’m saying is you can say it’s mens fault and men’s responsibility, but unless you get through to the ones actually doing it, all you’ll do is tell the ones who are not that they aren’t helping right.

I’ve said on previous threads I want to help, and I’m open to how I can. But I know it won’t be “call out your mates”

Ok, you @FloydPepper bear no responsibility, have no sexist friends, acquaintances or experiences and are useless in the fight against sexism.

You have nothing to contribute of any use except to add to the hopelessness. Ta

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 19:58

StayGoldenPonyGirl · 06/02/2023 19:54

Either you live in a bubble or you don't notice sexism. The fact that you have joined this thread to say no man you know is sexist...is proof of the latter to me. Telling women sexism is so rare in your experience, contrary to us giving you our experience...is sexist. You aren't listening. Men do not listen. Like I said, they don't care.

I literally said I know it’s widespread and probably the majority of men to some degree are awful. What I’m saying is you can say it’s mens fault and men’s responsibility, but unless you get through to the ones actually doing it, all you’ll do is tell the ones who are not that they aren’t helping right.

I’ve said on previous threads I want to help, and I’m open to how I can. But I know it won’t be “call out your mates”

NocturnalClocks · 06/02/2023 19:54

You've put it in a very confrontational way but there's absolutely a truth in what you're saying. On one hand it's men needing to do more to call out other men and the other is rolling our eyes when these same men take objection to being lumped in together.

We roll our eyes because they are not calling it out, yet claiming they are somehow better. If they aren't calling it out then they are so insignificantly better - because they are perpetuating it by not doing so - that their "poor me being tarnished with this brush that I am quite happy to use to polish" act is pathetic and meaningless.

StayGoldenPonyGirl · 06/02/2023 19:54

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 19:40

Rarely
ve said no to strip clubs on stag nights. I’ve said “that’s not on mate” to the occasional colleague or acquaintance, but proper friends, no.

I know it’s a huge problem. I know probably most men are arseholes. I want to help. I just know the aresholes don’t listen to me

Either you live in a bubble or you don't notice sexism. The fact that you have joined this thread to say no man you know is sexist...is proof of the latter to me. Telling women sexism is so rare in your experience, contrary to us giving you our experience...is sexist. You aren't listening. Men do not listen. Like I said, they don't care.

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 19:40

DoomedForLoneliness · 06/02/2023 19:32

Not even the porn / strip club / talking about looks part?

If this is true, and they are honest about themselves around you, you have found unusual group of men.
Seriously.

Rarely
ve said no to strip clubs on stag nights. I’ve said “that’s not on mate” to the occasional colleague or acquaintance, but proper friends, no.

I know it’s a huge problem. I know probably most men are arseholes. I want to help. I just know the aresholes don’t listen to me

Matildalamp · 06/02/2023 19:33

@verystablegenius
Today 09:02
Men are not murdered for just being men, I am more likely to be murdered than my OH, however should OH start buying drugs, dealing drugs, fighting in pubs and football matches his chances go up.

“this is what bothers me. This is the “men deserve it” argument. Turn the tables - “she went out to a bar, …., her chances went up”. how does that sound?”

Dealing drugs, a criminal act
Buying drugs, a criminal act
Fighting in pubs? Not in the league of drugs but can also lead to arrest.
Going to a football match, not a criminal act.

You responded with “she went out to a bar”.

Going to a bar does not compare well with buying/dealing drugs. And it does not compare well with fighting in pubs.

Does it compare with going to a football match, yes, if a man goes to a football match and is endangered simply because he was there he should not be blamed for that.

But I’m sorry your “women going to the bar” response doesn’t work with the rest. If a man or woman gets involved in crime and it leads to violence against them, that’s a risk they run!

DoomedForLoneliness · 06/02/2023 19:32

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 19:28

For all those items on your list I can honestly say the times I’ve come across them have been very very rare, to never, and I have called those out.

i know men are the problem. Just not men I know. Which of my friends should I be calling out or accusing when (to my knowledge) they don’t do these things?

Not even the porn / strip club / talking about looks part?

If this is true, and they are honest about themselves around you, you have found unusual group of men.
Seriously.

DoomedForLoneliness · 06/02/2023 19:29

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 06/02/2023 19:08

You've put it in a very confrontational way but there's absolutely a truth in what you're saying. On one hand it's men needing to do more to call out other men and the other is rolling our eyes when these same men take objection to being lumped in together.

But being nice and pandering to men doesn’t work either.
Most women make nice and try and stay on men’s good side.
They still hate us/ think women are less than them.

FloydPepper · 06/02/2023 19:28

StayGoldenPonyGirl · 06/02/2023 18:20

I have witnessed thousands of chances men I know have had to safely challenge other men on sexism. My XH, my dad, my brother, my uncles, my colleagues, my (ex) friends, ex boyfriends. Sure there have been times when it could have been dangerous, but i'm thinking of sexist jokes by text, sharing porn, comments on women's appearance and fuckability, strip clubs/ buying sex, calling me naggy names, having a good old laugh about women's issues and initiatives at work, endless 'on-the-rag' jokes (I can give a thousand examples and details if they aren't good enough) and these are just things i was permitted to witness. In the vast majority of those cases there would have been no threat of violence if they had spoken up. There could have been lost friendships, tense work relationships, and in the case of the landlord at the pub I worked at from 13-17, potential financial loss if he told patrons to stop groping and sleazing.

Men care more about money and their social comfort than about women's lives. They just do. I'd be willing to bet ALL men have let something slide when they could have physically safely done something at some point and the VAST majority do it on a regular basis. They don't care, they want the status quo. No fcking idea how to change that - agree with the word hopeless in the OP.

For all those items on your list I can honestly say the times I’ve come across them have been very very rare, to never, and I have called those out.

i know men are the problem. Just not men I know. Which of my friends should I be calling out or accusing when (to my knowledge) they don’t do these things?

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 06/02/2023 19:08

midgetastic · 06/02/2023 10:15

Offs

You really think you will make men as a whole think twice with that attitude?

You've put it in a very confrontational way but there's absolutely a truth in what you're saying. On one hand it's men needing to do more to call out other men and the other is rolling our eyes when these same men take objection to being lumped in together.

NocturnalClocks · 06/02/2023 18:41

NAMALT. We've all heard this defence before.

There is, very much, such a thing as toxic masculinity, only this is is commonly misunderstood as an assertion that every man and boy is toxic. It's not. Toxic masculinity is a set of harmful stereotypes, perpetuated throughout the vast majority of human cultures, which are held up as exemplars of how males are 'expected' to behave. It often manifests in macho culture: the dominant male, the provider, the protector of his own (and sometimes the attacker of those who threaten them), the successful CEO, the sex to whom women owe our respect and servitude, the alpha male. There are images of this stereotype disseminated through every level of our societies: from education to faith to the justice system to reality TV to advertising.

Some men don't fit that pattern (cf the 'new man' of the 1990s), and are happy and confident enough not to fit it. However, a great many more who don't fit the pattern feel they've failed in some way. And they are being failed, in turn, by society itself. Male suicide rates, the present angst and confusion about 'gender' (which is to blame for all the above in the first place), unbridled anger, VAWG, the furious men who blame women for this predicament and come together as incel groups. And many of the casualities of this mess are women.

Dismantling these stereotypes is the only way of freeing both men and women from them. There's just as damaging a set of toxic feminine stereotypes out there, but a good many more women are sick of the whole shebang and are turning our backs on it.

None of the above is not helped by an aggressive gender ideology which seems hellbent on upholding these tired, dated, passe stereotypes for the majority of society so that they can subvert them on some very individual level of identity politics.

To deny this reality exists is to lose any opportunity of fixing it.

This post ^^ needs pinning to the opening page of mumsnet, adding to the national curriculum, and putting up on a billboard in every single city and town, on posters on the sides of buses and inside trains. Everywhere.

Swipe left for the next trending thread