Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH refusing to consider me getting a boarder in (short term)

163 replies

ohblahdeeohblahdahlifegoeson · 06/02/2023 02:15

Hoping to get some perspective on this as at the moment I feel annoyed that I am being told 'No' to something which doesn't outright affect him (in my opinion)

Short summary,
Husband works away, is home every 2nd weekend.
I'm a SAHM and enjoying it but not enjoying the lack of financial freedom.

I've seen an advert for short term accommodation needed in our area for seasonal workers and as we have plenty of space I thought it would be a great way for me to get a little spending / saving money.

Husband has said an outright no.
His reasoning is that he wouldn't feel safe having someone else in our house but I would only consider a female boarder in any case.

Ironically we live rurally so 90% of the time I here on my own with 2 children so if anything I would feel more safe having someone else live here!

PS, awesome husband, dad and provider in all other ways, I'm just annoyed about this!

OP posts:
Namechangeforthis6 · 06/02/2023 10:32

Alexandernevermind · 06/02/2023 10:04

The op was about getting a lodger. I wish pp would stop hijacking threads like this to get their anti feminist women-commit-crimes-too crap.

How is it anti feminist to suggest women can sexually assult and kill children? They absolutely can and do

I do agree that it's mostly men, but it's very naive to suggest women don't do it

LuckySantangelo35 · 06/02/2023 10:29

No one gets their nails done on mumsnet op! It’s the height of frivolity especially when you’re a mum!!

LemonTT · 06/02/2023 10:27

My penny worth is that there really isn’t any point getting your nails done or your hair or your makeup every week whilst living rurally and working on a farm. It isn’t worth £110 per week. If that was the case then the OP would have time to do some seasonal work herself. But again the nails would suffer.

Alexandernevermind · 06/02/2023 10:04

The op was about getting a lodger. I wish pp would stop hijacking threads like this to get their anti feminist women-commit-crimes-too crap.

pattihews · 06/02/2023 10:00

ohblahdeeohblahdahlifegoeson · 06/02/2023 08:29

Lots of comments! Very interesting reading thank you.

One comment (that's been repeated a few times) has really resonated with me...is that even a female boarder could have potentially dodgy / unpleasant friends.
So that's probably the thing that's now swaying me away from the idea.

A few responses to some of the questions...

It's the vineyard owner who is arranging accommodation for his seasonal workers (just gave away that we aren't in the UK) so all the screening is done by him.
I can request a female and there are quite a few of them that do this type of seasonal work.

Money wise it would bring in around 110 pounds per week.

I shouldn't have used the term 'financial freedom', i should have said disposable income.

TTC, I'm not intending to ever return to work (kids and farm life are a full time job) and we are financially comfortable.
We do watch our pennies more than before (2 good incomes down to 1 good income) however our cost of living has also gone down.
I love our new rural lifestyle (we've been here just over a year) but I'll admit I miss some of my old treats and luxuries. Getting my nails done, eating out, shopping trips with my eldest daughter etc... and tbh I don't expect my husband to fund these things while he's away working his butt off and spending next to nothing on himself.
His working away job isn't forever, probably another 9-12 months.

Nice reading the favourable stories about boarders / seasonal workers from some posters.
I'll admit I have a romantic view on life and imagined something similar BUT some of the other comments have been a bit of a reality check for me!

Do you know the vineyard owner, OP? Can you have a word with him/ her and say that if he has a calm, pleasant woman who might appreciate living with a family, you would consider it? You set the parameters. If it doesn't work out then you can tell him and he'll have to find somewhere else for her.

The first thing you do when you take in a lodger is set the rules, which can include no visitors and then, if things go well and you get on, negotiating changes. IME women workers tend to come over with friends or partners. A single woman might be very grateful for the kind of accommodation you could provide. They can be very vulnerable. Female friends farming in west Wales have female seasonal workers who come back year after year because they know they will be safe with my friends.

slowquickstep · 06/02/2023 09:52

Findyourneutralspace · 06/02/2023 02:42

I think he has a point. I wouldn’t want strangers around my children, male or female. At a push I may accept a post graduate student, but even then I’d be exceptionally careful about references, contracts and boundaries, but I’d have to be really struggling for money to resort to that.

Does DH working away leave you strapped? Is there another option, maybe some WFH or part time work?

Didn't realise being a Post Grad meant you couldn't be an awful human.

Mirabai · 06/02/2023 09:48

I don’t really understand why people move to areas where they can’t work.

A lodger only solves the problem short term, when DH stops working away, what then?

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 06/02/2023 09:45

It depends on the boarder and how well you know them. Me and DM (on separate occasions and separate houses) have had 2 male friends of DB stay mostly for work purposes and one lived here for a short period - 6 months, I just set firm ground rules and if they did eat with me or if at DM’s house they either ate with us or had their own food. Also had grandson of family friend stay for 6 months - all the males were people we knew and not randoms.

DM used to have foreign students when I was younger who were male and female but again ground rules and they attended a language school in Waterloo so we’re often out after work.

OP - as long as you lay ground rules etc this should be fine. Transport might be an issue in your area so just ensure they can drive.

Dibbydoos · 06/02/2023 09:41

I had a lodger via my employer once. He was a sponsored student they set the rent rate and all was good. I was single at the time though and had a lock on my bedroom door (I always put one on) so not worried about anything and as he wanted a job at my employers when he finished uni, the risk was very very low. Anyways he was peachy, but not sure with kids how I'd keep them safe if I'm honest. I'm veering towards DH position, OP.

Could you get a small job that's wfh - BT, Amazon and some other call centres use people who wfh...

Cailin66 · 06/02/2023 09:33

This was quite a common thing, for women in particular, to hire out a spare room to a boarder. My husband stayed in such an arrangement before he met me as did my brother recently. It's ideal for a SAHM if the person is out all day. Better to give them a larger room with it's own bathroom. In my brothers case he went home every weekend as he is married, but he needed accommodation in Dublin which was hard to come by. He liked it because he didn't have to think about bills and he rarely saw the lady who owned the house as he was out most of the time. I also let rooms when we bought our first home as we were short of cash. As long as you vet them there shouldn't be any problems.

MichelleScarn · 06/02/2023 09:30

MissTrip82 · 06/02/2023 08:31

Oh just saw your update - no way I’d do that for luxuries, I thought you meant you were struggling.

Same, there's no way I'd want mine and families life invaded and have to share facilities just to get nails done!

But @ohblahdeeohblahdahlifegoeson you are definitely 'at work' if you are running a farm on your own!!

FeinCuroxiVooz · 06/02/2023 09:28

lodgers can be very hit-and-miss and can be a nightmare. if you can make ends meet, live comfortably and have the freedom to treat yourself to luxuries within reason without this then don't go there. if you are being financially controlled by a partner who isn't sharing family income in full then you're being abused and need to get out, not just increase family income.

I was a lodger with a mum who had a toddler, and a partner (not the child's dad) who didn't live there due to working a long way away but would visit and stay the night occasionally. It was ok and I am sure that I was a reasonably good lodger, always paid rent on-time and didn't do anything madly antisocial, but it was still frustrating for her to have me there, never having full unrestricted access to her own kitchen, bathroom or laundry facilities due to having to share them, and that's the best-case scenario where the lodger doesn't turn out to have some kind of narcissistic personality disorder, or drug habit, or other issue that makes your life hell.

Acommonreader · 06/02/2023 09:24

I understand both your views OP, as a single parent my mum had boarders when I was a child. I have great memories of two lovely art students ( female) who stayed for a year and a family ( dad was post graduate) from Brazil too. We had a big house and it worked. Obviously we were lucky with our guests and as a child I saw no downsides. As an adult I may be more wary now!

Naunet · 06/02/2023 09:23

M340 · 06/02/2023 09:05

On the official MOJ website it says

125 of these are recorded as female and another 76 are known to be males who identify as womenn_. For sexual offences.

The statistic may be off in regards to 27% on sexual offences. But it still states 27% of convictions are women, who still commit crimes. Included in that will be sexual offences.

Women are so desperate to make men the awful horrible opposite sex and women can't do no wrong. It's pathetic really. The 27% may be wrong, but it's not 'vanishingly rare' as posters have said above. A quick look on MOJ website and the gov website shows that.

So, you were wrong, and only 27% of ALL crimes are committed by women and you have no stats at all about the percentage of child sexual abuse and murders carried out by women??
Well when men get their crime rates down to that of women, THEN we can start shifting the focus, but for now, you look like the desperate one here.

emptythelitterbox · 06/02/2023 09:21

How did you end up being on a farm in a remote area but your DH doesn't even work the farm?

Is there an option to move to where your DH works?

jannier · 06/02/2023 09:19

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn as it quotes a deleted post.

But they can be criminals....and they can support their partners in accessing children. I'd want a DBS

Liorae · 06/02/2023 09:17

JamMakingWannaBe · 06/02/2023 06:20

I think you should look into it OP. I have had lodgers for a number of years and it's a great way to boost the household income. Mine are predominantly male medical students on rotation at the local hospital.

If they are seasonal farm workers it's likely they are going to have long working hours. They might just need your house to shower and sleep. If you have an ensuite you can offer, all the better.
Find out how long the season is as at least you know they'll be leaving at the end of it.

This thread has surprised me as the responses are the polar opposite of all the people who opened up their homes to the refugees from Ukraine - at very short notice.

I'm not saying you have to do it but you can at least find out a little more information about what's expected from a host.

There is no virtue to be signaled from a lodger.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/02/2023 09:14

Why are people constantly derailing threads with this argumentative nonsense!?

xycyxb · 06/02/2023 09:09

Icecreamandapplepie · 06/02/2023 09:07

I can't even handle the nonsense being spouted now 🙄

Stop being ridiculous.

Icecreamandapplepie · 06/02/2023 09:07

I can't even handle the nonsense being spouted now 🙄

M340 · 06/02/2023 09:05

On the official MOJ website it says

125 of these are recorded as female and another 76 are known to be males who identify as womenn_. For sexual offences.

The statistic may be off in regards to 27% on sexual offences. But it still states 27% of convictions are women, who still commit crimes. Included in that will be sexual offences.

Women are so desperate to make men the awful horrible opposite sex and women can't do no wrong. It's pathetic really. The 27% may be wrong, but it's not 'vanishingly rare' as posters have said above. A quick look on MOJ website and the gov website shows that.

Alexandernevermind · 06/02/2023 08:57

Myra Hindley for example. ahh yes, once in the 60 there was a female murderous csa (working with a man), there have been a couple of other since (working with men), but I'm pretty sure the other well know woman cso have been men in dresses calling themselves something like Susan.
I think a female lodger is a good idea op.

tenbob · 06/02/2023 08:56

amberjoleaf · 06/02/2023 08:43

@tenbob here you are. 'Righty-oh'

Errr, that says ‘total number of criminals’

Now show us where it says that more than 1 in 4 child raping murderers are women

Because surely you can’t assume that violent sexual criminals are as likely to be women as shoplifters?

Naunet · 06/02/2023 08:51

amberjoleaf · 06/02/2023 08:43

@tenbob here you are. 'Righty-oh'

Where does this refer to murders and child abusers?! This seems to be about general crime.

Naunet · 06/02/2023 08:50

amberjoleaf · 06/02/2023 08:32

It's actually not. In 2020 the statistics were 27% women and that remained for 5 years. It's on the gov website.

Link? And this is from 2020, when men’s crimes could now be recorded as women’s?

Swipe left for the next trending thread