Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Return train tickets to be scrapped

166 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 05/02/2023 22:32

Yet more punishment for rail users

Back to the car for me!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GarlicCrackers · 20/02/2023 17:07

EmmaEmerald · 05/02/2023 23:37

Thanks Garlic

do you know what they're aiming for with this move?

I forgot to come back to you, and news has been released since. But just in case you haven't seen it, LNER is trialling single leg pricing, where single tickets should be halfish the price of returns.

www-cityam-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/www.cityam.com/rail-travel-lner-government-halving-the-cost-of-single-fares-in-a-move-that-will-unleash-more-competition-innovation-and-growth/?amp=1

Ozgirl75 · 12/02/2023 09:40

So you would assume that the govt would like more people to use the trains. For a family of 4 it costs us £57 to get a train into London on a Saturday. Plus around £7 to park at the station.
Parking in central london is £45 at the most expensive car park in Cadogan Place, and in Covent Garden it’s £30. Plus petrol of say £10 and if you arrive before 12 and leave after 6 you don’t pay the congestion charge.
I actually really like the train as it’s easy and convenient, but it would save us nearly half in driving over getting the train.

DdraigGoch · 08/02/2023 22:10

GCAcademic · 07/02/2023 23:36

The Guardian (admittedly not the most reliable source) is reporting that ministers are considering demand-based / dynamic pricing.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/feb/07/uk-train-tickets-could-be-priced-like-airline-seats-in-rail-shake-up

So, the more overcrowded your train, the more you pay? I’m assuming that “like airline seats” doesn’t mean that you’ll actually get a seat on the train?

Why does this country have to be so bloody dysfunctional and in hock to The Almighty Market?

If it just meant discounts for quiet trains, while the Anytime tickets stayed at a reasonable price then that would be fine.

The sooner HS2 is built (in full), the better. We desperately need more capacity which would allow for reductions in the absurd Anytime prices going into Euston: £369.40 return from Manchester for example, that's £1.00/mile, compared with Manchester-Edinburgh return at £139.50 which is 25p/mile.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 08/02/2023 12:02

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2023 18:53

For most journeys, I would abolish peak restrictions entirely. In many parts of the North, off peak trains are just as busy as peak ones. I used to bring a full train of commuters into Manchester, return to the coast with a full train of holidaymakers/ferry passengers, then the late shift would take more ferry passengers/holidaymakers back to Manchester before bringing the commuters home. With more hybrid working the balance is as good as equal.

Towards the end of the Virgin franchise, the 1800ish trains to Liverpool, Manchester etc. were dead quiet on Fridays, while the first off peak trains were so overloaded that the trains had to have speed restrictions because they were too heavy to tilt. The solution was to abolish afternoon peak restrictions on Fridays. The increase in passengers more than paid for the significant cut in fares.

I would also start calculating fares based on a mileage rate to make them much fairer, and abolish the TOC-specific fares and other silly routing restrictions. A day return from Chester to Manchester should be a day return from Chester to Manchester, in reality I think that there are at least four options before even considering peak restrictions.

That's really interesting.

DowningStreetParty · 08/02/2023 11:22

Exactly ChungusBoi
cheaper, greener, less economic disparity
I despair of this government

ChungusBoi · 08/02/2023 07:55

PitYerTapOan · 08/02/2023 00:27

I don't think I'd mind so much if it really was the Almighty Market. That at least I could understand. But it's not. It's a bent market funnelling upwards.

This.

Other European countries have responded to the climate and cost of living crises by making their public transport cheaper! Supporting their people, and paying their rail workers properly too.

HellcatSpangledShalalala · 08/02/2023 07:32

Well demand pricing is one way to ensure people won't be returning to offices and travelling at peak times!

Surely there already is demand pricing with peak/off peak?

PitYerTapOan · 08/02/2023 00:27

I don't think I'd mind so much if it really was the Almighty Market. That at least I could understand. But it's not. It's a bent market funnelling upwards.

GCAcademic · 07/02/2023 23:36

The Guardian (admittedly not the most reliable source) is reporting that ministers are considering demand-based / dynamic pricing.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/feb/07/uk-train-tickets-could-be-priced-like-airline-seats-in-rail-shake-up

So, the more overcrowded your train, the more you pay? I’m assuming that “like airline seats” doesn’t mean that you’ll actually get a seat on the train?

Why does this country have to be so bloody dysfunctional and in hock to The Almighty Market?

PitYerTapOan · 07/02/2023 23:25

Bless.

ancientgran · 07/02/2023 17:00

StarlightLady · 06/02/2023 13:16

@ancientgran - You think they will reduce prices of singles 😂😂😂?

No idea but that's what should happen. Presumably at the moment people who buy one way tickets are subsidising people who buy returns. Not sure why that's a good idea.

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2023 18:53

For most journeys, I would abolish peak restrictions entirely. In many parts of the North, off peak trains are just as busy as peak ones. I used to bring a full train of commuters into Manchester, return to the coast with a full train of holidaymakers/ferry passengers, then the late shift would take more ferry passengers/holidaymakers back to Manchester before bringing the commuters home. With more hybrid working the balance is as good as equal.

Towards the end of the Virgin franchise, the 1800ish trains to Liverpool, Manchester etc. were dead quiet on Fridays, while the first off peak trains were so overloaded that the trains had to have speed restrictions because they were too heavy to tilt. The solution was to abolish afternoon peak restrictions on Fridays. The increase in passengers more than paid for the significant cut in fares.

I would also start calculating fares based on a mileage rate to make them much fairer, and abolish the TOC-specific fares and other silly routing restrictions. A day return from Chester to Manchester should be a day return from Chester to Manchester, in reality I think that there are at least four options before even considering peak restrictions.

Ozgirl75 · 06/02/2023 16:58

They should simply do 7-8.30 peak 5-6pm peak and fares are (eg) 20% higher across the board. Outside of that, tickets should be a standard price - more for the quick non stop services, cheaper for the stopping trains. They could “band” each route and it would have a standard price per mile. So the busy commuter routes would be band 1 - the most expensive (with the 20% uplift in peak times) and then band two cheaper etc etc.
Then if you pay for a month, 6 months or a year you get a discount but that’s it.
I really think that public transport should be a public good in a similar way to health or other services. Personally I don’t think it should be run for profit, I think we should be incentivised to get off the roads and onto public transport but it’s just way too expensive for that the way it is at the moment. I do think it should be publicly run and financed by a mixture of taxes and fares.

VickyEadieofThigh · 06/02/2023 16:26

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2023 11:22

Ironically BR, though nationalised was just handed its (miserly) sum of money each year and told to get on with running the railway. Despite the poor funding it was reasonably competent at doing so Under this so-called privatisation Whitehall micromanages everything with appalling incompetence.

I was just about to post something similar myself. British Rail might not have been as glamorous as the privatised rail companies but you didn't have to spend hours trawling the internet to find and book a ticket in advance - you just rocked up to the station, paid for the ticket of your choice (after 9.30am they were much cheaper) and that was that. You could ring up your nearest station and ask for advice and they could tell you (a) the times trains were available totake you to your destination and (b) what it would cost.

And their dining car breakfasts were the stuff of legend.

larchforest · 06/02/2023 13:55

From our local station we can buy a Day Travelcard (outside peak times) for whichever zone in London we are going to, which is also valid on the underground for as many journeys as you want within that zone and the ones outside it. I wonder whether they will keep that, as it is really convenient for visitors to London.

StarlightLady · 06/02/2023 13:38

@Ozgirl75 - I agree it is far too complex.

I spend some time working at Gatwick Airport, the confusion caused by our railway "system" (huh!) has to be seen to be believed. Given the multitude of ticket types and different railway companies people get totally bewildered on arrival. Add to that, almost all signage is only in English. What a welcome it is to the UK where we want tourists to come and spend their money.

kitsuneghost · 06/02/2023 13:29

So long as a single is actually half the current return, I welcome it
I have always found it really unfair a day return is not 24 H

You go into town 7am and home at 1am you are fine on a day return
You go into town 7pm and home at 2pm you are technically not so pay nearly double.

Belladonna208 · 06/02/2023 13:27

@Redflower2 We moved to one of the big former Greater Manchester mill towns....point taken on describing it as almost unliveable - I should have added "for us at the moment", as it does sound a bit dramatic, but I'd been looking forward to it so much, having remembered the north as friendly and pleasant and with plenty of space and decent-ish public transport.

I was warned a bit, but I thought people were exaggerating. So it's really come as a bit of a shock to discover just how neglected this part of the country has been for the last 15-20 years (even worse than the north east in some ways, where I grew up, though the population on the east side of the Pennines is generally a lot lower and the towns and cities are a bit further apart whereas Greater Manchester to Liverpool is all crammed in together).

And the state of the public transport is jaw dropping. We chose to move to our current address as, on paper, it would have been about a 45-60 minute journey to work for me on the days I can't WFH. It regularly ends up being 2 to 2.5 hours in either direction, which is just not sustainable. I can actually fly to Bristol in less time than that, including the trip to Manchester airport!

And yes, I know it's winter and that's always the worst time of year. I suppose in parts of the south the weather does compensate for a lot (and yes, plenty of neglected and run down towns in the West Country too...)

FixTheBone · 06/02/2023 13:25

Won't directly affect me, as the two times I've resorted to using a train this year have put me off from ever trying it again.

Coventry to Bradford - 3 trains, took 5 hours and cost £135, driving would have taken 2hr15-2hr30.

Bradford to manchester (ironically to collect my new car) Took 3 1/2 hours door-to pickup and cost £48. The return drive took 55minutes and cost £4.

Ozgirl75 · 06/02/2023 13:20

I also agree with everyone up thread who has said that it’s waaaaayy too complex. It really is. I want to just turn up and buy the cheapest ticket for that particular service.
Trying to work out what tf ticket my son needs for a day trip into London, using the tube but only a couple of stops is mental.
I agree with this for everything - the amount of choices for every single fuckin thing drives me round the bend.

StarlightLady · 06/02/2023 13:16

@ancientgran - You think they will reduce prices of singles 😂😂😂?

ancientgran · 06/02/2023 13:14

I hate it when I buy a one way ticket and pay the same or only slightly less than a return. Reducing the price of single tickets seems much fairer to me if that is what they are doing.

StarlightLady · 06/02/2023 13:12

The whole ticketing thing needs reviewing. Sometimes singles are cheaper than a return. Sometimes they are not. Sometimes it is cheaper to go further. I think one great saving that will be missed will be end of the day return. Spontaneous travel on a nice day, when you have a day off will become a thing of the past.

meanwhile the railway companies are getting government subsidies and paying shareholders as a result of your hard earned cash.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 06/02/2023 12:54

I agree with you that the govt need to communicate better with the public. But the public also need to change. They need to not just accept news from one source which will have their own preferred spin on it.

I don't think you can blame to public for the government's ridiculous method of "leak a half story and wait til everyone has their own take on it and then release the actual policy". You can't (reasonably) get annoyed at people forming an opinion based on a headline when the headline is all they have access to.

If your target audience is regularly misunderstanding your message then any half-competent person / organisation would look to change themselves, not blame the audience.

Lcb123 · 06/02/2023 11:58

It sounds beneficial to me, always weird it barely costs more for a return. I often do single trips. Usually 2 x advance singles are cheaper than a return anyway.