Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how the strikes will end?

242 replies

Wingingit11 · 05/02/2023 19:52

This isn’t a thread about whether you agree with strikes as a concept or not (there have been soooo many) but to question how you think the strikes will end?! To me, the longer they go on, the less likely there is to be movement on either side ?

OP posts:
Wingingit11 · 06/02/2023 20:10

Actually just ran a pensions calculator and comes up at £433k

OP posts:
Wingingit11 · 06/02/2023 20:07

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 20:01

Oh - so our pensions are super good, but actually the private sector are like ours - so also good?
But it’s fine because you aren’t on strike?

Except we aren’t on strike about our pensions anyway, so your entire chain of thought (which reads like a fever dream, by the way) is largely irrelevant.

Again, please use your advanced knowledge of pensions to explain how you arrived at the figure that £26k for 10 years is somehow £500k. I’m curious.

I’m not finance at all but to be fair that does tally with my understanding of what I’d have to get to too (which I very definitely won’t!)

OP posts:
Boneweary · 06/02/2023 20:07

The problem is, what was an interesting thread has just descended into squabbling.

DontStopMeNow7 · 06/02/2023 20:06

Doesitmatteranyway · 06/02/2023 19:59

@Unphased basically doesn’t have any ideas bar ‘they should resign’ (and a weird obsession with pensions. Which many of us won’t see if NHS falls to pieces due to lack of staff).
She’s probably not even got a job. She’s probably sitting at home in her filthy underwear, smoking and picking her nose and typing the same old shit over and over again. Don’t engage with her anymore.

I have assumed this is a man. (Don’t mob me MN and yes I could be wrong).

Im genuinely interested to hear the answers to my questions. But, yes, if I still don’t get any, I will assume this person is just a biased, unthinking bigot.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 20:01

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:52

GneissGuysFinishLast
I and probably the vast majority of the public will have a pension like you, still we are not on strike

Oh - so our pensions are super good, but actually the private sector are like ours - so also good?
But it’s fine because you aren’t on strike?

Except we aren’t on strike about our pensions anyway, so your entire chain of thought (which reads like a fever dream, by the way) is largely irrelevant.

Again, please use your advanced knowledge of pensions to explain how you arrived at the figure that £26k for 10 years is somehow £500k. I’m curious.

DontStopMeNow7 · 06/02/2023 20:00

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:54

DontStopMeNow7
maybe we could all have a sensible debate about the NHS and what should happen to it in the future, because keep chucking endless amounts of money at it is not working

Yes, I agree. Please do start this debate by stating what you think should happen to the NHS.

?

Doesitmatteranyway · 06/02/2023 19:59

@Unphased basically doesn’t have any ideas bar ‘they should resign’ (and a weird obsession with pensions. Which many of us won’t see if NHS falls to pieces due to lack of staff).
She’s probably not even got a job. She’s probably sitting at home in her filthy underwear, smoking and picking her nose and typing the same old shit over and over again. Don’t engage with her anymore.

DontStopMeNow7 · 06/02/2023 19:59

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:50

DontStopMeNow7
what you want top pay good working conditions and excellent in job benefits, the main reason that the vast majority work in the public sector is not because the care about people,
pits up to the government to sort out the public sector, not mine,

Everyone wants decent pay, reasonable working conditions and a decent pension. Why do you have a problem with that?

You have said that people enter serving professions because they care about others. Now you imply it is because we don’t. Make up your mind! So why do you think people enter a caring profession then?

Your answer to the strikes is for people to leave rather than striking, and then it’s up to the government to sort it out…completely ignoring the fact they could avoid the whole issue by negotiating a pay deal.

If it’s up to the government to sort out the public sector, why have any opinion on it at all?
You are extremely opinionated considering how little you are willing to think things through and back up your arguments with any kind of logic.

It’s the definition of pure arrogance.

NearlyMidnight · 06/02/2023 19:57

There will likely be a compromise of sorts - Strikers can't go on for ever but they won't lose their jobs. The govt will fudge it - but there'll be concessions. There'll be much face-saving.

Then the likely response will be future - proofing. Just as they did with energy, miners, car production, printing, dockers. Outsource, relocate, privatise, modernise. That way the economy can get moving again - and the government protects itself from being held to ransom.

If you remember previous periods - what happened then? The govt gave in if they had to - but then dismantled the industry. It took years for people to recover from the damage, (small businesses, satellite businesses, individuals, families, towns, whole industries).

It did lead to social change though - not always in the way people expected - but it did. And some of it was for the better - although some of it possibly wasn't. A matter of opinion.

There isn't as much support as people think - but again it's not something people like to say because it's not "cool". So they'll say "Yay we support the NHS" and beep their horn and bathe in the approval of their mates. But they are fucking furious and frightened when yet again their hospital appointment is cancelled or it costs them £60 in cabs to get to work where they earn £75. (And if they don't go in sooner or later they'll lose the job anyway).

So that's how I think it will end. But I don't know any better than anyone else.

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:54

DontStopMeNow7
maybe we could all have a sensible debate about the NHS and what should happen to it in the future, because keep chucking endless amounts of money at it is not working

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:52

GneissGuysFinishLast
I and probably the vast majority of the public will have a pension like you, still we are not on strike

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:50

DontStopMeNow7
what you want top pay good working conditions and excellent in job benefits, the main reason that the vast majority work in the public sector is not because the care about people,
pits up to the government to sort out the public sector, not mine,

DontStopMeNow7 · 06/02/2023 19:49

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:35

DontStopMeNow7
nobody has to stay in a job, they don’t like the terms and conditions, it’s not up to the existing staff to fix the public services, it’s up to the government, you can vote for them every 5 years, What do you think a different government will give the strikers everything they want?

Yes it’s up to the government to fix public services. Therefore, they can give a decent pay settlement in order to stop people leaving. I’m glad we agree. Or..,What would you state as an alternative??

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 19:47

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:44

GneissGuysFinishLast
the private sector,
yes you would, pension pot of £500,000 is needed for a annuity of £26,000

So if the private sector is “real” then what is the public sector?

How are you arriving at that figure you keep parroting on about?

How’s your pension pot looking?

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:44

GneissGuysFinishLast
the private sector,
yes you would, pension pot of £500,000 is needed for a annuity of £26,000

DontStopMeNow7 · 06/02/2023 19:43

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:30

GneissGuysFinishLast
you would need a pension pot in the real world of £500,000 to get an annuity of £26,000

Do you work in finance or in pensions?

I don’t, so I’ll leave it to you to educate me, assuming that you do.

You’re still completely avoiding the point.
Even if someone gets a huge pension, it doesn’t justify poor working conditions which are unsafe for everyone. Having an amazing retirement would not make a gradually reducing salary, along with those unsafe working conditions, okay. If it did everyone would be signing up to work in the public sector, including YOU

You don’t see how you are contradicting yourself:

-People shouldn’t strike, they should resign
-You don’t seem to care if the public sector has even fewer employees but fail to have an answer for that eventuality
-But they shouldn’t be complaining anyway because the salary is fine, and even if it’s not, the pension makes up for it.
-People in the public sector are better off because they have a better pension, yet you don’t choose to work in the public sector for some reason.
-The people striking don’t care about you. But at the same time they do, otherwise they wouldn’t do the job in the first place.

Shall I continue or do you fancy doing some actual thinking?

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 19:40

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:30

GneissGuysFinishLast
you would need a pension pot in the real world of £500,000 to get an annuity of £26,000

In the real world? What is the real world?

And no, I wouldn’t. That’s based on me living 20 years beyond retirement age, which may be the case in your leafy suburb of Surrey, but is not the case for us who live in working class areas. I can expect 10 years.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 19:37

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:25

GneissGuysFinishLast
that’s nearly a pension pot of £500,000, that’s amazing, avarge pension pot is £70,000, you’ve done very well in the public sector

I’m significantly more qualified than average. I work significantly more hours per week than average. I pay in a higher percentage of my wage than average. I’ve been paying in for my whole working life, which is something that many older people didn’t do.

Only 6.2% of people of working age are qualified to the minimum requirements to work as a teacher. So of course the people who work in these jobs should be better compensated, given their level of expertise.

www.thehealthyjournal.com/faq/what-percentage-of-uk-students-do-a-masters

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:35

DontStopMeNow7
nobody has to stay in a job, they don’t like the terms and conditions, it’s not up to the existing staff to fix the public services, it’s up to the government, you can vote for them every 5 years, What do you think a different government will give the strikers everything they want?

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2023 19:33

DrMarciaFieldstone · 06/02/2023 11:50

Nothing much will happen, they’ll peter out, I can’t see the gov’t compromising much and there’s so many industries striking now, they won’t meet one and not another.

Tbh, I think working from home has dampened the effects of strikes for many more well-off people (unless they need an ambulance etc). People can just stay at home if teachers, train drivers, civil servants strike. I’ve not heard anyone talking about the impact of them at all, here in the SE. Compare this to ten years ago when a tube strike would paralyse London; it’s very different now.

Plenty of hospitality businesses have talked about the impact train strikes have had on them. Not everyone can work from home either. It's certainly cost the government money, it's cost more than giving the staff a rise would have done.

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:30

GneissGuysFinishLast
you would need a pension pot in the real world of £500,000 to get an annuity of £26,000

DontStopMeNow7 · 06/02/2023 19:30

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:25

GneissGuysFinishLast
that’s nearly a pension pot of £500,000, that’s amazing, avarge pension pot is £70,000, you’ve done very well in the public sector

Please give an example of a private sector pension pot from a person who works to save lives after gaining a bachelor’s degree plus continuing education.

You have also not addressed the gaps in your logic regarding how a pension is a good enough reason to put up with terrible, unsafe working conditions ?

You have also not addressed what your answer would be for fixing public services without the staff who are currently striking?

I suggest to you that you do not have any answers to these issues and therefore keep going on and on about pensions and ignoring basic logic.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 19:28

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:25

GneissGuysFinishLast
that’s nearly a pension pot of £500,000, that’s amazing, avarge pension pot is £70,000, you’ve done very well in the public sector

How in the fuck did you get that figure? I’ll be working to 68 and life expectancy is 78. Annual pension salary is £25k. 25k x 10 = £250k.

Im guessing you don’t work with figures.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 19:27

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:20

GneissGuysFinishLast
what, you don’t call a pension of nearly £26,000 as good, people that work the same if not more hours than you would love a final pension like that, get real

I was referring to retiring at 57, which according to your case study of 1, we all do. It’s simply not possible. I can survive in £25k, I can’t live comfortably on £12k. And why shouldn’t I live comfortably?

Not to mention that life expectancy where I am is 77, and healthy life expectancy is 61.

If I work to 68 and live to my “expected” age, my pension payout will be in the region of £250k. The majority of that is likely to go straight to paying for care, since I’m likely to be living in poor health for the last 6 years of my working life, plus for my entire retirement.

Why don’t you consider switching over if the oh and pension is much better than what’s available in the private sector?

Unphased · 06/02/2023 19:25

GneissGuysFinishLast
that’s nearly a pension pot of £500,000, that’s amazing, avarge pension pot is £70,000, you’ve done very well in the public sector