Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how the strikes will end?

242 replies

Wingingit11 · 05/02/2023 19:52

This isn’t a thread about whether you agree with strikes as a concept or not (there have been soooo many) but to question how you think the strikes will end?! To me, the longer they go on, the less likely there is to be movement on either side ?

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 07/02/2023 08:13

Unphased · 07/02/2023 07:42

@Alexandra2001
please give me your solution for a proper functioning NHS, please don’t say give it more money, it’s like a bottom less pit, it just absorbs money

Staff retention has to be addressed.. as i said earlier madness to train staff then see them leave.
Pay cannot be allowed to fall even further behind.... so yes a 10% rise, if 10% can be found 12.1m pensioners, many of whom are very wealthy, then 10% can be found for front line NHS staff.

We should also allow visa free, EU healthcare staff to come and settle here too, we shouldn't be taking nurses etc from 3rd world countries.

We need to get back to pre pandemic levels of service and waiting lists before we can look at reform... yes we do need to look at how other countries fund healthcare but we cannot hide the fact that historically the NHS got 4% of GDP but from 2010 to 2020 got approx 1 to 2%.

Social care needs to come under the umbrella of the NHS, that way SC staff get the T&Cs and pay of NHS workers..... paying skilled staff 10.50ph is not sustainable and without SC, NHS becomes blocked.

Reform will take a decade plus... so needs x party support and min funding levels for 20 plus years but atm both parties have very different views of the NHS.

Unphased · 07/02/2023 07:50

GneissGuysFinishLast
i really think you need to do a bit of reading up on your pension, the pension pot is not related to your life expectancy, it a figure based on payments in pot growth, employers contributions,
if you retire at 67, and your life expectancy is an average of 80 for women, the whole pot doesn’t get divided by 13 years, it depends on many numerous things
you do realise that 80 is only an average, you could live longer or die earlier

Unphased · 07/02/2023 07:42

@Alexandra2001
please give me your solution for a proper functioning NHS, please don’t say give it more money, it’s like a bottom less pit, it just absorbs money

Unphased · 07/02/2023 07:40

GneissGuysFinishLast
I don’t know where you got the impression that I’m wealthy, I earn less than the striking Nurses,
FYI my mothers has passed away

Unphased · 07/02/2023 07:28

Alexandra2001
I'm talking about organised sport, Football, rugby, etc, dangerous sports, parachuting etc,
that’s why we need someone at the door, you don’t need A&E yes you do type of thing,
others should pay but do they, from outside of Europe, do we actually invoice other countries for work provided by the NHS?
paying more taxes would help towards a better Health care system and finance better pay,
you never did answer my question, how come the other countries can pay more for their staff, how is it funded?
not everyone will leave, they know they have a good job with pay and in job benefits

Alexandra2001 · 07/02/2023 07:08

Unphased · 06/02/2023 21:07

DontStopMeNow7,
No I’m not man, if your allowed to say that nowadays,
I think some of the NHS treatments should not be free, certain activities should have compulsory medical insurance, sports etc, Car insurance should carry a percentage of medical insurance, Unhealthy lifestyles should somehow be penalised, Pay more taxes for a better social care, foreign travellers must pay for NHS use, A&E should only be used in an A&E, not for a cut finger, bump to the head etc,

So discourage people from taking care of themselves? someone spraining their ankle out jogging should pay for insurance even though over time, they are far less likely to be a burden on the NHS compared to someone who leads a sedentary life style... mmmm

Yes AE is sometimes used inappropriately but a cut finger covers everything from a small cut needing a plaster to slicing into bone, a bang on the head may be very serious.... build more MIUs ?

UK has bi lateral healthcare treaties.. GHIC card... others should pay and do in all but emergencies before treatment.

People on average earnings cannot afford more taxes but if your calling for the wealthy to pay more on their assets and income then yes they should.

A good pension in 35years doesn't pay the rent bills etc...

Whilst you re entitled to a different opinion perhaps answer the question of what society does with no functioning health service because staff have done what you suggest and have left?

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 23:57

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2023 23:52

So @Unphased once all of the staff have done as you suggested, upped and left, who will be coming to your mother's aid when she's fallen and broken her hip? How long will she be left to lie there before you realise that you can't run an ambulance service with no staff left?

Duuuh she’ll go private, her mum ain’t going to no lowly NHS hospital with their scummy public service workers. All those nurses are interested in is their pension!

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2023 23:52

So @Unphased once all of the staff have done as you suggested, upped and left, who will be coming to your mother's aid when she's fallen and broken her hip? How long will she be left to lie there before you realise that you can't run an ambulance service with no staff left?

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 23:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 23:45

Unphased · 06/02/2023 23:06

GneissGuysFinishLast
your pension payments are not worked out on your life expectancy age, whatifyou lived for 15 years past it

Your payments aren’t, but the “pot” you need is. The pot you quoted is based on living to the average life expectancy - which is around 88 years. So based on claiming pension for approximately 20 years. However, given that life expectancy where I live is 10 years less than the national average, it’s likely I’ll not be able to pull from my pension for that long.

Pensions don’t sit in individual pots - they are all lumped in together. Roughly half of all people claiming them don’t get their whole “pot” - and roughly half of the people claiming it get more than their whole “pot” - that’s how averages work. It balances on the whole.

The population of the UK is skewed towards the south of England, which is incidentally the most affluent and the most long-lived. Therefore, life expectancy is skewed. Parts of Glasgow have a life expectancy that is less than Iraq or the Gaza Strip.

These differences occur even when statistics are adjusted for poverty levels.

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2023 23:37

Unphased · 06/02/2023 16:13

verdantverdure
Avarage teacher’s salary 35,000 plus pension, sick pay , holidays, above the national average wage,
what private sector jobs, They could always get a teaching job in a private school instead of depriving children of their education esp after Covid

So the best teachers get snapped up by private schools, while schools in challenging areas end up with TAs teaching firefighting classes of 60 because the school can't recruit good, qualified staff. Is this the sort of society you want to live in? One where only rich kids can read and write.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 06/02/2023 23:36

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2023 19:33

Plenty of hospitality businesses have talked about the impact train strikes have had on them. Not everyone can work from home either. It's certainly cost the government money, it's cost more than giving the staff a rise would have done.

Well yes, this is my point; they’re not backing down even though it’s costing money.

I’ve not heard of any hospitality businesses having issues where we are, they’ve all been packed as normal. Appreciate this may be different elsewhere. I didn’t say there would be no impact of strikes, but that their impact has been reduced.

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2023 23:34

Unphased · 06/02/2023 15:55

Why is it in the best interests of the government to negotiate a settlement, Can’t they just tough out the high inflation, it will come down,

Inflation coming down doesn't mean that prices will. Inflation is only the rate of change. When inflation comes down then lower pay offers would be acceptable. While inflation is high then people need a raise.

DdraigGoch · 06/02/2023 23:25

Unphased · 06/02/2023 15:26

The people that are striking could always go and get a different job if they don’t like their existing terms and conditions, it will lead to higher taxes if they have a 10%. + pay rise, what about their lovely in job benefits, Pensions, holiday pay and above average days, sickness pay and often no questions asked,

In at least one of the disputes, the workers are fine with their existing terms and conditions but the government wants to take away things like predictable shift patterns that make it possible to have some semblance of a social life - I might work two weekends in three, but at least I know that I can make plans and book tickets for events on the third one. Many have said "I would rather have no raise at all than accept that". Meanwhile inflation continues to nibble away at the value of their pay.

Oh, and people ARE leaving. Why do you think that TPE is in such a mess? They are losing staff to freight hauliers and devolved operators faster than they can train replacements, two and a half times as many drivers are leaving as you would usually expect from the normal level of retirements and resignations. In the same way hospitals can't recruit enough staff to replace those who are leaving to take up better paid work abroad or with agencies, schools are having to use unqualified staff to teach on a regular basis because it is so difficult to recruit qualified teachers, particularly in certain specialisms.

So yes, people are leaving. Public services are falling apart without them. Any real business would see this happening and make itself more attractive to employees through offering better pay and conditions than its competitors. Not the government though, they'd rather everything disintegrated than pay skilled workers the market rate and treat them like human beings instead of robots.

Unphased · 06/02/2023 23:06

GneissGuysFinishLast
your pension payments are not worked out on your life expectancy age, whatifyou lived for 15 years past it

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 22:29

croppedhimout · 06/02/2023 21:11

I do support nurses striking but I do feel a little envious. I can't strike. I am a carer.

I'm paid less than £70 a week for 24/7 on call care and about 19/20 hours worth of care a day Sad

Carers should absolutely be paid more - this teacher would 100% support you in getting a raise. It doesn’t have to be one or the other. The government wants to see all of us workers fighting over the scraps.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 06/02/2023 22:26

Wingingit11 · 06/02/2023 20:10

Actually just ran a pensions calculator and comes up at £433k

Right - but is that based on a life expectancy of only 10 years more than retirement age - because my life expectancy is only 10 years more than retirement.

strongallowed · 06/02/2023 21:57

caramac04
It’s a crown jewel to the people

No it really isn't.

Look at the thread on private dentistry. People may be dissatisfied with what they're getting with the NHS currently but the alternative is potentially far far worse and a kin to what we're all experiencing currently with private dentistry.

croppedhimout · 06/02/2023 21:11

I do support nurses striking but I do feel a little envious. I can't strike. I am a carer.

I'm paid less than £70 a week for 24/7 on call care and about 19/20 hours worth of care a day Sad

Unphased · 06/02/2023 21:07

DontStopMeNow7,
No I’m not man, if your allowed to say that nowadays,
I think some of the NHS treatments should not be free, certain activities should have compulsory medical insurance, sports etc, Car insurance should carry a percentage of medical insurance, Unhealthy lifestyles should somehow be penalised, Pay more taxes for a better social care, foreign travellers must pay for NHS use, A&E should only be used in an A&E, not for a cut finger, bump to the head etc,

DontStopMeNow7 · 06/02/2023 20:30

I’m just trying to challenge an opposing view. I was interested to see if someone who thought differently to me has any logic to their reasoning, that’s all.

I don’t enjoy doing it but I’m just so fed up with comments like this. I’ll leave it to everyone else to continue with more interesting parts of the conversation :-)

Wingingit11 · 06/02/2023 20:26

Yep I’m getting a bit lost in the arguments! Some thought provoking comments re the politics of it all - I’m neutral on strikes so always good to hear both sides (that’s the point of these forums right…)

OP posts:
Boneweary · 06/02/2023 20:23

It’s not interesting now it’s just two people arguing.

Plenty of people care: there is support on this thread. Not everyone thinks the strikes will work, though. That doesn’t mean no one cares about them.

DontStopMeNow7 · 06/02/2023 20:22

Wingingit11 · 06/02/2023 20:10

Actually just ran a pensions calculator and comes up at £433k

Whatever the figure is, it doesn’t make everything else in the public sector okay.

I couldn’t care less about my pension right now. I’m chronically ill after contracting covid at work and have debts up to my eyeballs from nursing school. I am also burnt out from nursing critically ill patients.

I chose my profession because I deeply care about other people, not because I want a good pension. I have opted out of it in order to survive the cost of living.

Its one thing for people to oppose the right to strike. It’s really something else when they try to make out we are selfish. It’s icing on the cake to have very little logic to back up an opinion.

Uncaring is one thing.
Stupid, bigoted and uncaring is really pushing the boat out.

Doesitmatteranyway · 06/02/2023 20:14

Well I don’t think it is that interesting actually. I think it’s bloody depressing to think that no one cares and nothing will change after my third day standing in the cold on the Pickett line.
but if you think it’s really interesting then go ahead.