Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naturally dramatic life - unworthy of friendship?

137 replies

SparklingBalls · 05/02/2023 18:54

This is coming off the back off a few threads I've been reading across MN, and yes, I am a long-term poster and have NCed for this.

My life has always involved drama. For the most part I had nothing to do with why - abusive home, sexual abuse as a teen and young adult including multiple rapes, homelessness brought on by shitty friendships and lack of relatives who to this day give a shit, relationship abuse followed by single mum pregnancy, abusive marriage including an attempt on my life through him, escape from this, now financial difficulties.

I know that people always say that drama attracts drama, but honestly, I'd love nothing more than a simple life. Very little of my life drama is of my own making (suicide attempts and OCD-related disorders may be, but stem from childhood trauma, which won't cease to rear its ugly head despite meds and therapy), but the main thing in my life is, I am being constantly shat on from a great height.

I have always tried to do the right thing, got a job, got promotions, kept the kids, supported them as a single mum. I have tried again and again to build up friendships and relationships, but the continuous onslaught of shit happening in my life drives them all away. I try to stay upbeat; I have tons of gallow's humour; it is hard. But it seems I am doomed, not just through more shit happening by the month, but also by lack of friends, family, anyone.

On here people always say that it's people's own fault if their life is dramatic. But mine could fill several soap operas without me trying.

It pushes people away, I guess. So my AIBU - is it me, is it always people who are dramatic who have dramatic lives?

OP posts:
MarieRoseMarie · 06/02/2023 10:54

I think people whose behaviour truly is “dramatic”, say through BPD etc are best off finding groups of similarly minded friends. I say this because I once entered joined a hobby club that seemed to consist of a friendship group of very chaotic people. There was lots of mental illness, suicide threats, affairs, addictions etc. Terrible boundaries all round but lots and lots of acceptance for inappropriate behaviour and “trauma”. Boundaries were so bad that there was a seemingly unending amount of sexual assault. It was pretty lefty liberal, so there was also lots of calling out for sexual harassment/assault. Endless “call outs” and “call ins”. It got tiresome almost immediately and I left quick. They seemed very happy though.

On the other hand, some people are not “dramatic” but instead are so distanced from reality that it’s actually unnerving to speak to them. There’s a thread currently running with a woman whose husband got arrested for drunk driving - four times over the limit. Crashed into a tree. Already been banned once. She has four kids. She is completely under reacting because this is her reality. This is normal to her. To the rest of us, it’s crazy. Some people in the thread are getting quite angry at her. People shrugging their shoulders at things others find reprehensible makes people wonder why you aren’t appalled and if you really think this behaviour is fine too.

for e.g., if someone talked very casually about CSA, it would make me more suspicious of their partner because it would make me think they would be more likely to have CSA in their own home (and the data bears this out).

sorry if that seems harsh.

NattyNamechanger · 06/02/2023 10:50

lowclouds · 06/02/2023 10:20

I have to say I really dislike this 'us and them' outlook that some people have.

'Our lives are so alien to them it scares them' is an extremely patronising thing to say about a human who, by virtue of simply being human, has a rich and varied life experience. This in itself pushes people away so much.

People are not 'scared' of your trauma. They just need a reason to want to develop a friendship with you - that means you have to give something to them first of all. If you are venting about all of your problems and your awful life, what are you giving to the other person to make them want to be your friend?

I think it's also worth remembering that many other people have difficulty in their lives.
That "boring Brenda" at baby group might be there to escape from her nasty husband or financial difficulties.
She might need that group just to forget it for a couple of hours per week.
Unfortunately one time my office colleagues got caught up in something as the Police called my work phone .
Awful and not something I would usually discuss or want in the work environment.
The next day one colleague quietly left a bunch of tulips and a card on my desk.
She had experienced something similar, I had no idea.
We know nothing about other peoples lives really.

Courgeon · 06/02/2023 10:47

I know it sounds weak but am so sorry for the trauma you've experienced op. I'm so boundaried about what I talk to people about I probably might come across as cagey and aloof, however I've learnt the hard way about oversharing. .. I'm fortunate in that I have some amazing close friends but those friendships have grown organically over time and I'm very reluctant to share too much of myself as I inherently don't trust people.

I don't want to be a therapist/counsellor in my spare time. I will support my very close friends, H and kids but I'm guarded with my family as they've not only not supported me in difficult times they've actively avoided it and made out I'm the problem. Recently a local acquaintance has over disclosed to a number of people and as a result they've all backed off so she's feeling abandoned again. You have to contain some conversations to within the therapy room.

I've also developed an amazing sense of freedom by not becoming too attached to friends. I see them for things we mutually enjoy, theatre etc but I have no emotional attachment. That makes me sound cold but I'm not, I just don't want to have to deal with any messy relational dynamics unnecessarily.

thecatsthecats · 06/02/2023 10:46

MilkTwoSugarsThanks · 06/02/2023 09:56

If they're the sort of person that thinks that it's impossible for a mum to be estranged from their daughter, then I have no time to educate them or to mask the messy parts of my life.

You make it sound like you think you're superior to them. Be aware that you might come across like that in real life.

I'm plenty aware, haha.

But I don't require people to have experienced similar things to me, just to be the sort of person who understands the very thing that others have said - that other people have rich and complex lives with different experiences that shape them.

And I'm not very interested in the type of person who doesn't understand that. There's plenty of people who do to be friends with - I don't feel like I'm missing out by not having friends like that.

Dibbydoos · 06/02/2023 10:35

Hi OP, what a life story you have. I'm sorry it happened and completely get it rears it's ugly head and this is affecting you.

If people are judging you cos the person who gave birth to you died and you didnt spend time with her, that's on them, not you.

Do you want to write a book about your life? There's a young guy on fb reels that was abused by his step grandad and then found our after his dad committedcsuicide, his dad was also abused by tgexsame person. He helps people write their stories. This could help you in 2 main ways, additoonal income and exposure of those who treated you badly etc. It will likely be both harrowing, reliving the events, but cathartic.

It's your choice, but you are not at fault about what's happened to you. Sadly talking to others about it can be a weight on some people, hence why yiu may find it difficult to make friends, so Google how to make friends and follow the guidance. Practice by yourself so yiu get tge intonation and speed of saying things right.

Best of luck, you deserve a break xxx

DNBU · 06/02/2023 10:31

Hi OP, ‘Drama’ makes it sounds like it’s a fun, interesting gossip but it’s actually trauma and the way it’s affected you, and caused a chain of effects and events in your life.

Bad experiences growing up could mean any number of knock on effects; low self esteem, low self image, disorders like OCD, unconsciously and unwittingly seeking relationships (romantic or friendships) with people who are not good for you in some way, as your homelife growing up was unstable & abusive, and that is what is familiar to you.

It’s a series of connected events; you grew up in an abusive home and experienced trauma, which has had an effect on your brain chemistry, your behaviour and self image, you seek out connections based on what you unconsciously believe you deserve or what looks familiar, you were in an abusive marriage and then experienced financial difficulty, friends distance themselves because it all seems like it stems from you.

It is not a conscious fault of yours.
It’s not because you are a bad person. It’s not cos you are unlucky in some way and it’s not coincidence. It’s because your past trauma and experiences have shaped you in a lot of ways that you may need help with to recognise and break the cycles, from professional help and support.

I’m so sorry for what you’ve been through. My experiences are not the same but I understand the feeling of ‘why does this drama always happen to me?’

lowclouds · 06/02/2023 10:20

MichelleScarn · 06/02/2023 09:39

I was a bit worried id been harsh so re read thjs post We shouldn’t have to hold back about our experiences but people don’t want scary or sad life stories they want boring Brenda bitching about bad boy Barry in accounts. Our lives are so alien to them it scares them.
So what you're saying is you will force your life history on people no matter if they want to hear it or not. You don't care that they may also have similar trauma, and you doing this is harmful to them as long as you talk at them?

I have to say I really dislike this 'us and them' outlook that some people have.

'Our lives are so alien to them it scares them' is an extremely patronising thing to say about a human who, by virtue of simply being human, has a rich and varied life experience. This in itself pushes people away so much.

People are not 'scared' of your trauma. They just need a reason to want to develop a friendship with you - that means you have to give something to them first of all. If you are venting about all of your problems and your awful life, what are you giving to the other person to make them want to be your friend?

NattyNamechanger · 06/02/2023 10:01

I had a similar background to you - lots of stuff, not my fault, couldn’t get going in relationships, felt like I had to hide my real feelings to be socially acceptable

The thing here is that your feelings,are yours,no-one else's.
Why would you subject others to your feelings when they have just had a restless night with their baby and are at baby group for a much needed break?
This is something for you to work through and deal with until such time that you can deal with social situations.

MilkTwoSugarsThanks · 06/02/2023 09:56

If they're the sort of person that thinks that it's impossible for a mum to be estranged from their daughter, then I have no time to educate them or to mask the messy parts of my life.

You make it sound like you think you're superior to them. Be aware that you might come across like that in real life.

Littlemountainhum · 06/02/2023 09:55

SparklingBalls · 06/02/2023 04:33

Thanks all. Yes, I definitely used to attract the wrong sort into my life and I have been working hard to change that.

Making new friendships is where I struggle; I am very conscious that people have enough going on in their lives without needing to hear the latest issue that's been happening, but likewise it feels wrong not to mention anything when people ask what I've been up to that month, if that makes sense? It always feels like such a huge balance act, even if my general demeanour is quite upbeat.

Stop caring what people think and looking after other people. You’ve got to look after yourself and tend to your own feelings. If you feel sad, feel sad. Don’t plaster on a smile for others.

No gallows humour - that’s just denial, pushing your sad/angry/‘negative’ feelings away in favour of being acceptable to other people. You’ve got to feel it to heal it. There’s no such thing as negative btw - allowing yourself to feel whatever you feel is key to healing and being able to move forward and stop attracting the bad stuff.

Listen to Abraham Hicks (loads on YouTube - search Abraham hicks + people pleasing, might be a good place to start). Sounds utterly batty to begin with but go with it, google any terms you don’t understand.

No one will understand, people will try to keep you happy and upbeat - ignore them. You’re better off going through a period alone to heal and work out what you really want in life. Then you’ll start to attract the good things, because you’ll say no to those situations that force your grief to rise up (because you will have felt your grief it won’t be there pulling you towards catharsis) and you’ll say yes to things that truly bring you joy. (at the moment you’re probably subconsciously looking for ways for your grief to come out, so you attract more and more bad situations/relationships until those feelings have been felt).

Prioritise your joy above all else, even when that means going into a cave to let yourself cry.

It works! I promise. I had a similar background to you - lots of stuff, not my fault, couldn’t get going in relationships, felt like I had to hide my real feelings to be socially acceptable.

NattyNamechanger · 06/02/2023 09:51

User45378754 · 06/02/2023 09:03

A lot of valuable insight and life experience on this thread.

I have had a traumatic upbringing which has left me with emotional resilience deficits that have impacted / hijacked other areas of my life at random times.

I learnt about being “emotionally leaky” and how this both repelled some and attracted dodgy / flaky others. I learned to contain this leakiness to therapy and very specific settings.

I look now at most friendships as acquaintances for short term shallow fun - I have a couple of trusted long term friends who occasionally I will open up to - but I want to preserve these.

I look at my trauma as a chronic disease / illness - I manage it myself and with my therapist - like you would with a Dr - I wouldn’t be interested in knowing and seeing a blow by blow account of an open wound or disease up close and personal all the time - as I can’t cure it or really comfort it.

I am just looking for light hearted interactions which are really valuable in getting you through the moment. Our friends aren’t skilled therapists or our emotional skips.

This is such a helpful and wise post.
Try to empathise with others Op and how they might feel about your disclosures

They are at baby group/ playdate etc
Why would you "dump" your trauma onto someone in these settings ?
It's inappropriate
I say this btw as someone who had ACE .
It's a very hard lesson to learn and one I have learned myself.

Our friends aren’t skilled therapists or our emotional skips
This

thecatsthecats · 06/02/2023 09:41

On the gallows humour front - I have a dark sense of humour myself, but it's not for everyone. It won't come across as remotely upbeat to a lot of people.

I don't know if it helps any, but I much prefer to engage with people who understand that life can be messy. They seem strangely incomplete to me. I find it a useful yardstick of assessing someone's personality if they can accept without blinking that my mum and sister are estranged.

If they're the sort of person that thinks that it's impossible for a mum to be estranged from their daughter, then I have no time to educate them or to mask the messy parts of my life.

MichelleScarn · 06/02/2023 09:39

I was a bit worried id been harsh so re read thjs post We shouldn’t have to hold back about our experiences but people don’t want scary or sad life stories they want boring Brenda bitching about bad boy Barry in accounts. Our lives are so alien to them it scares them.
So what you're saying is you will force your life history on people no matter if they want to hear it or not. You don't care that they may also have similar trauma, and you doing this is harmful to them as long as you talk at them?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 06/02/2023 09:39

Could there also be an element of over sharing / lack of filter? A lot of people will back off if you just seem to be 'too much'

This will be it. From infancy humans can recognise abnormal social interaction and tend to back away from it (unless they themselves lack social boundaries or are predatory).

And StinkyWizzleteets, you should not be so arrogant as to assume you know anything about Brenda or her past life. She may have lived a life that makes yours look idyllic, but come through it with enough social skills to stick to neutral topics when chatting to a stranger at baby group.

4timesthefun · 06/02/2023 09:38

I’ve also had a ‘dramatic’ life, including severe childhood trauma, which contributed to issues like further victimisation during my late adolescence, and poor relationship choices etc etc. It took years and years of therapy to get on a far more even keel, both emotionally and circumstantially. I previously had the same issues with friendships. If I’m honest with myself, I was an oversharer. I would confide in friends too quickly and too much. Now, several of my really close friends have no idea the kind of trauma I have experienced. It doesn’t actually compromise the friendship, if anything, the friendships feel more mutual!

Comewithmefriday · 06/02/2023 09:37

SparklingBalls · 05/02/2023 18:54

This is coming off the back off a few threads I've been reading across MN, and yes, I am a long-term poster and have NCed for this.

My life has always involved drama. For the most part I had nothing to do with why - abusive home, sexual abuse as a teen and young adult including multiple rapes, homelessness brought on by shitty friendships and lack of relatives who to this day give a shit, relationship abuse followed by single mum pregnancy, abusive marriage including an attempt on my life through him, escape from this, now financial difficulties.

I know that people always say that drama attracts drama, but honestly, I'd love nothing more than a simple life. Very little of my life drama is of my own making (suicide attempts and OCD-related disorders may be, but stem from childhood trauma, which won't cease to rear its ugly head despite meds and therapy), but the main thing in my life is, I am being constantly shat on from a great height.

I have always tried to do the right thing, got a job, got promotions, kept the kids, supported them as a single mum. I have tried again and again to build up friendships and relationships, but the continuous onslaught of shit happening in my life drives them all away. I try to stay upbeat; I have tons of gallow's humour; it is hard. But it seems I am doomed, not just through more shit happening by the month, but also by lack of friends, family, anyone.

On here people always say that it's people's own fault if their life is dramatic. But mine could fill several soap operas without me trying.

It pushes people away, I guess. So my AIBU - is it me, is it always people who are dramatic who have dramatic lives?

Oh wow op I could have written this. I completely understand. It's so hard friends either back off or treat me like a spectacle.
It's very hard to have any authentic friendship without sharing otherwise where you land has no context and keeping quiet leaves you just as lonely.
I've recently had a sequence of things happen, many of which were definitely through no fault of my own but I can sadly see why people back off, It's changed my character and I have little to offer socially anymore , health means constant cancelling of meetups with those who still want to see me and my employer must be regretting taking me on.
spending more time online is my main interaction now.

cupofbeanslike · 06/02/2023 09:35

Speedweed · 06/02/2023 06:46

The thing with trauma is that it's not just a bad thing that happened to you, it's something which happened to you which has a distorting effect on your personality. When the traumatic event happens, different areas of the brain shut down as a protective mechanism. Something like ongoing abuse, where there are lots of instances of it happening, means that the brain learns to shut those area down. So for example, someone suffering cptsd may have an impaired sense of risk twenty years later, because in a risky situation when a non-traumatised person's brain would process the danger and tell them to get themselves out of the situation, a traumatised person's risk processing area of the brain would sense the risk but then shut down as its learned response, meaning that person stays in the bad situation with all that ensues. It's not really their personality to be a risktaker, but it would feel that way to them (as the trauma has altered their brain so erased their knowledge of how they would have acted before the trauma), and it would look like that to someone on the outside.

An added problem is that predators and other wounded souls recognise the distorted personality - like an injured fish in the sea twitching in a way that attracts sharks and repels healthy fish. That obviously multiplies the chances of more drama, and is also incredibly lonely.

There are good books, like The Body Keeps the Score which explain this in more detail, and a good trauma therapist will be able to help you unpick what your brain is doing in different situations so you can start to separate yourself from your learned response. It's a tough situation to be in op, and it sounds like you're really trying to overcome things so all credit to you.

This is an excellent post.

lowclouds · 06/02/2023 09:32

Having said that i do have a couple of close friends that I will talk to about difficult stuff - but it’s rare and usually our interactions are more happy and positive so there is a good balance.

I think this is a really good point @Minfilia

My closest friendships are very much focussed on positivity and fun most of the time. For a very long time whilst they were building (a couple of years!) it was almost purely about enjoying time together and enjoying their company, very simple and straightforward.

After that (once we already loved one another from all the fun times we had), we began to share more about ourselves, our pasts, our traumas. You really need a stable foundation before you start to do that.

It takes time, OP, and most people won't appreciate you going full force with all of your feelings when you are just getting to know them. To build stable friendships you have to take some ownership and put up some boundaries, give more than you get and focus on the good things.

That's hard coming from a background of trauma, but it's just what you have to do.

MilkTwoSugarsThanks · 06/02/2023 09:28

Tbh SparklingBalls you would benefit from a good therapist.

People who are untrained will have no idea what to say or do about other people's trauma, past or present, and that's not unreasonable. People step back to protect their own mental health and they are not wrong to do so.

Yes I am currently letting a friendship slide because my own mental health is taking a battering.

Minfilia · 06/02/2023 09:25

I’ve had a naturally dramatic life too and share some of your experiences. I’ve also had a hell of a lot of deaths.

I also have friends and acquaintances that I perceive as “dramatic”.

The differences between us are:

  1. I don’t relish the drama and I don’t indulge in it.
  2. I don’t post my dirty laundry on Facebook in an attention seeking way for all to see.
  3. It doesn’t stem from poor life choices that I’ve made (repeatedly) despite other peoples advice.
  4. I don’t moan and I’m not one of those people who complains repeatedly but never seeks to change anything.
  5. I don’t feel the need to tell anyone my life traumas (I have a therapist for that). I definitely wouldn’t be telling a work colleague that I just met that I’d had several terminations (looking at you ex colleague).
  6. I try to keep my interactions with people light and positive and concentrate on the good. People are either radiators or vacuums, and having friends who constantly moan when asked “how are you” is just draining!

Points like the above make people drama llamas, not the actual difficulties in their life.

Having said that i do have a couple of close friends that I will talk to about difficult stuff - but it’s rare and usually our interactions are more happy and positive so there is a good balance. But the only person who actually knows how difficult my life has been is my therapist! Without her I probably wouldn’t be able to be quite so positive in day to day life with my friends and colleagues.

lowclouds · 06/02/2023 09:22

I would have a think about what you are expecting from your friends, OP.

You say that your drama pushes people away - why is that, though? Do you share it all with them in detail? Do they have to sit and listen to you for long periods of time?

How much interest are you showing in them and their lives?

Friendship is two way and you need to give as much as you take. You also don't have to share everything with friends, you can just focus on enjoying the moment with them.

User45378754 · 06/02/2023 09:19

CrystalCoco · 06/02/2023 09:11

People (even those with the potential to be good friends) get fed up of the drama and eventually they just want to meet with friends who are stable - unless they themselves are into drama, but, when drama meets drama this tends not to work out either as there are now two people in the scenario filling the conversation with drama and not really listening to the other person.

With the drama-filled 'friend' I recently released myself from it was a relief to not have to see her or hear 'all of her shit' ever again. Her drama was relentless and tbh I'm not convinced that she was entirely the innocent party all of the time, no one ever is.

Most people have some level of shit going on at any given time, but we don't need to let it all hang out or dramatise every situation (I'm not saying you're doing that OP but just something to be conscious of)

There's 'being there' for a friend going through a rough patch, and then there's drama drama that is endless, it becomes exhausting and for the sake of my own mental health I can't be around endless tales of woe and dramatic stories. Especially when it's all one sided - again I'm not saying you're doing this OP, but if the conversation is all me, me, me then there's literally nothing in it for the other person.

I agree with this.

We all need balance and as we get older we collect more burdens which means we need to hold steady even more.

I now see new friends who spill trauma/drama as someone to swerve and it is serving me well. I am also conscious that I would have been one of these emotionally dysregulated / incontinent people in the past as well.

It’s fine in time to briefly lift the curtain in an established friendship - but to be reflective and bring to the friendship rather than slip into victim stance - and IME this was easy to do - so I avoid picking at my scabs with friends.

Opaljewel · 06/02/2023 09:19

housemaus · 05/02/2023 19:05

It's not your fault. I have someone very close to me who is similar - lots of trauma throughout their life and it does seem like the shit always falls on them. It genuinely isn't their fault, there's nothing they could have done differently.

But they do struggle because even with gallows humour or trying not to mention it at all, it's there (and their CPTSD is too).

People find other people's pain and trauma uncomfortable and I suspect there is a suspicion eventually by others that it's somehow their 'fault'. Which is 100% unfair, but I do think it happens.

It makes getting back up and keeping going so much harder when you don't have a network, and I really feel for you.

Lovely kind response and I agree with it all.

CrystalCoco · 06/02/2023 09:14

Could there also be an element of over sharing / lack of filter? A lot of people will back off if you just seem to be 'too much'

CrystalCoco · 06/02/2023 09:11

People (even those with the potential to be good friends) get fed up of the drama and eventually they just want to meet with friends who are stable - unless they themselves are into drama, but, when drama meets drama this tends not to work out either as there are now two people in the scenario filling the conversation with drama and not really listening to the other person.

With the drama-filled 'friend' I recently released myself from it was a relief to not have to see her or hear 'all of her shit' ever again. Her drama was relentless and tbh I'm not convinced that she was entirely the innocent party all of the time, no one ever is.

Most people have some level of shit going on at any given time, but we don't need to let it all hang out or dramatise every situation (I'm not saying you're doing that OP but just something to be conscious of)

There's 'being there' for a friend going through a rough patch, and then there's drama drama that is endless, it becomes exhausting and for the sake of my own mental health I can't be around endless tales of woe and dramatic stories. Especially when it's all one sided - again I'm not saying you're doing this OP, but if the conversation is all me, me, me then there's literally nothing in it for the other person.