Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Naturally dramatic life - unworthy of friendship?

137 replies

SparklingBalls · 05/02/2023 18:54

This is coming off the back off a few threads I've been reading across MN, and yes, I am a long-term poster and have NCed for this.

My life has always involved drama. For the most part I had nothing to do with why - abusive home, sexual abuse as a teen and young adult including multiple rapes, homelessness brought on by shitty friendships and lack of relatives who to this day give a shit, relationship abuse followed by single mum pregnancy, abusive marriage including an attempt on my life through him, escape from this, now financial difficulties.

I know that people always say that drama attracts drama, but honestly, I'd love nothing more than a simple life. Very little of my life drama is of my own making (suicide attempts and OCD-related disorders may be, but stem from childhood trauma, which won't cease to rear its ugly head despite meds and therapy), but the main thing in my life is, I am being constantly shat on from a great height.

I have always tried to do the right thing, got a job, got promotions, kept the kids, supported them as a single mum. I have tried again and again to build up friendships and relationships, but the continuous onslaught of shit happening in my life drives them all away. I try to stay upbeat; I have tons of gallow's humour; it is hard. But it seems I am doomed, not just through more shit happening by the month, but also by lack of friends, family, anyone.

On here people always say that it's people's own fault if their life is dramatic. But mine could fill several soap operas without me trying.

It pushes people away, I guess. So my AIBU - is it me, is it always people who are dramatic who have dramatic lives?

OP posts:
drunkornot · 07/02/2023 09:19

The thing is, everything you have mentioned is all very extreme. Some people might have experience with one of those things, but no one will have direct experience with every single thing you have gone through. Therefore, if you shared all that with me, I don’t know how I would react or what I could say to comfort you as you need professional mental help. So bare that in mind when you offload to people - they can’t be there for them in the way you want, as they don’t know how, and you need professional help to explore these topics.

NattyNamechanger · 07/02/2023 09:18

Greatly · 07/02/2023 09:00

BUT my life is never calm, there is always another blow around the corner, as it is for most people, but somehow my blows are always bigger ones and tend to hit at the worst times. Like a huge financial blow right after a big purchase (say, a boiler going bust in mid-winter just after almost all my savings went on replacing my old car, or interest rates increasing just before I managed to get a mortgage)

In the nicest possible way, things like this happen to absolutely everyone.

I agree with this.
Also when you have been a victim of trauma then you tend to go through life with a victim mentality.
So everyday occurrences are seen as yet another way in which you are a victim rather than " shit happens".
It's interesting that you use the word " fault".
It's a black and white term that tends to be used in Splitting.
This is when a fixed mindset occurs of good/ bad , there is no understanding of how people can be human beings who mess up sometimes.
It comes with a whole heap of blame and self judgement and a lack of growth mentality.
I think further trauma therapy would really help with this.

WinterFoxes · 07/02/2023 09:13

I think as @Greatly says, everyone has drama pile-ups in their lives - DC with D&V when the internet goes down and the car breaks down and a client at work isn;t happy with how you treated them etc etc.

the point is, when you are already running on empty all the time, these feel unbearable, whereas if you have had a life in which, generally you are fairly loved and supported by family and have a small amount of savings for emergencies, then you can ride these dramas out and get over them quickly.

People react badly to friends who seem to think they are the only ones ever to have a drama. Most people deal with them quietly behind closed doors. But i think not being able to do this naturally comes from being raised in a climate of trauma and resulting PTSD.

LemonAndLimeTree · 07/02/2023 09:12

Excellent post @WinterFoxes

LobeliaBaggins · 07/02/2023 09:07

What an interesting thread. I don;t think dramatic people attract drama, especially not when the dramatic part is sustained abuse. I think you deserve friends.

That said, everyone has compassion fatigue now. And most people have a full plate. I am not saying this is you, but some people with trauma can be very exhausting and turn every topic back to the trauma.

I have a friend who tried to kill herself recently and has bad trauma. I continue to meet her and listen to her, but if I talk about anything fun, she makes me feel guilty for having fun. I agree with posters who say you should find a support group.

I myself have a DC with chronic illness and I have stopped talking about it. Because most people don;t want to know and are too exhausted to listen. Instead, I use my friends for an escape, as others suggested.

Greatly · 07/02/2023 09:00

BUT my life is never calm, there is always another blow around the corner, as it is for most people, but somehow my blows are always bigger ones and tend to hit at the worst times. Like a huge financial blow right after a big purchase (say, a boiler going bust in mid-winter just after almost all my savings went on replacing my old car, or interest rates increasing just before I managed to get a mortgage)

In the nicest possible way, things like this happen to absolutely everyone.

Courgeon · 07/02/2023 08:59

MarieRoseMarie · 07/02/2023 08:35

It sounds like you are mixing up abusive things with normal life. Interest rate rises when you are house shopping are not traumatic, they are just normal life.

This. I don't think this is drama, it's normal life happenings. If this is drama then I've had loads. Am currently panicking a bit about how to afford a new car. As we get older there are ongoing financial hits. It's just life. I've just finally had an eye test and bought new glasses and prescription sunglasses. It's cost me ££ and I spent several months saving up for it. But that's one of the annoying things about life.

WinterFoxes · 07/02/2023 08:58

This might not help, and I'm sorry if it doesn't because you clearly deserve love and support in your life, but have you tried compartmenalising things more?

Try making some new friends and framing the friendship as an escape box from all the shit and drama, rather than a potential support over it. Just go to the cinema with them. go for walks where you just discuss the kids and TV shows - might feel like play-acting 'normal' but it will help you maintain friendships.

Look for (or start?) a support group for Survivors of abuse in your area. Make as much use as possible of the self-referral, not GP needed online counselling and CBT services that exist these days and offload any emotional weight in those sessions.

For decades I suffered very bad depression. In the end, after losing lots of friends over it, I just put it in its box and if I was too down I lied and said I'd come down with a virus or had a sudden work meeting if I couldn't face other people at the time. For all the #BeKind and MentalHealthAwareness posts plastered all over friends' FB pages - they'd all run scared if I ever actually mentioned it. I learned that from experience. Now I see friendship not at all for support and confiding but for taking my mind off any dramas and the friendships start lasting years. That is a wonderful support of its own kind, just not the one you might think.

Minteraye · 07/02/2023 08:58

I think people often don’t talk about these things.

One of my parents was an addict and had MH issues. They died when I was quite young. When I think of it, I’ve never really talked about that with friends, including those I grew up with who knew the parent. And friends who I know had violence or abuse at home have likewise not really gone into it or ever discussed much (although we’ll talk in detail about sex, relationships, at times current MH struggles / stress / depression).

Greatly · 07/02/2023 08:53

Stompythedinosaur · 05/02/2023 19:02

I'm sorry you have had such awful experiences.

I think maybe it is less the things that happen and more the high expressed emotions that make the difficulties of life seem like "drama"? Maybe also the context that awful things are shared in?

My personal experience is that I find it best to never speak about previous experiences of abuse to others. It is an uncomfortable topic, people do not know what to say. I talk to my partner, or if I needed I would speak to a therapist.

I'm not saying this is right, but I definitely fine it is the best approach for maintaining friendships.

This. I hope you are having and engaging in therapy.

If you were a new acquaintance and I heard even half what you've put in your OP before I knew you really well then I'd avoid you. I have too much of my own drama to want to take on anyone else's.

Fwiw I had a hideously chaotic childhood but only my dh and a few very old childhood friends know about it. My newer friends don't know and that's how I like it.

Palmface · 07/02/2023 08:44

I have a friend who i guess you could call a magnet for drama in her life, and I have distanced myself from her. She too experienced childhood trauma, and on some level I think she seeks out chaos and can't relax into the predictable every day life a lot of us lead. The difference between her and what I've read from you OP is that this stuff is happening to you whereas my friend actively sabotages good things in her life. She talks of nothing but her current drama, has no interest in the lives of others and sucks the emotional energy from many of her friends. I think that is the hardest part, always being the giver of time and an ear to her woes, when it's so one sided.

MarieRoseMarie · 07/02/2023 08:35

It sounds like you are mixing up abusive things with normal life. Interest rate rises when you are house shopping are not traumatic, they are just normal life.

MarieRoseMarie · 07/02/2023 08:33

SparklingBalls · 07/02/2023 05:35

I've finally had the time to read through all of this, apologies for the late response.

To answer a few comments.
Yes, I fully take responsibility for what happens in my life - as long as those things are my fault.

I knew living in a dodgy area would lead to issues when all I had was £300pcm on rent and got out of one as soon as I earned more money, but that I got burgled was not my fault.
I ended abusive relationships (some earlier than others - when I had regained independence) but getting strangled and raped weren't my fault.
I raised my firstborn and created a loving, responsible character who is top of their class and I do take credit for that, and I did so without much help and support, but while getting pregnant at one of the "worst" points this could have happened was my fault, being subsequently cheated on and made homeless by my so-called partner wasn't.

I have done multiple therapies, CBT, taken SSRIs and have become a stronger person as a result. And from a shallow perspective my life is "sorted" - I am a homeowner, successful in my job with multiple, strong promotions into leadership, my kids are amazing and well-liked by their peers and teachers and I mostly have my shit together. BUT my life is never calm, there is always another blow around the corner, as it is for most people, but somehow my blows are always bigger ones and tend to hit at the worst times. Like a huge financial blow right after a big purchase (say, a boiler going bust in mid-winter just after almost all my savings went on replacing my old car, or interest rates increasing just before I managed to get a mortgage).

I don't overshare, no. In fact, I'm careful not to, but sometimes you cannot help give a bit of context.

I don’t really understand. Why would interest rates increasing before you get a mortgage be something that specifically happened to you rather than to a huge percentage of the population?

Why would this need to be “dramatic”? Surely most people you know would be in the same situation.

Minimalme · 07/02/2023 07:53

Op, you sound as though you are still in active trauma.

When someone has been through prolonged abuse, short term therapy won't work.

I saw a Counsellor for the first time at 33 and I had my last session yesterday at 49.

I have gone through everything I've felt and experienced with her.

I have had the same friends for 20+ years. I was only able to share my experiences with them in the last two years. Even then it is in very short bursts.

I wouldn't find talking to unqualified people helpful at all. They are likely just to mirror my feelings and feel traumatised too.

I hope you can get help and move on. I will take SSRIs for ever now. I think long term abuse changes our brains and I would recommend that as a 'quick win' for you.

User45378754 · 07/02/2023 07:27

I think it’s sad (but understandable with unresolved trauma) that you have taken the insights shared as personal criticism and feel the need to become defensive when no one said anything was your fault.

You have done brilliantly to work your way out of difficult social, practical and financial situations with pure grit and determination.

However you currently are stuck emotionally (not your fault) and would recommend getting EMDR and/or trauma informed therapy as this would change your stance / approach to people which currently is understandably slightly “off” and jarring as evidenced by your response to this thread.

BlardyMinded · 07/02/2023 07:20

Hey OP. I’ve experienced a lot of trauma. There have been some excellent posts already which I won’t repeat.

What sticks out for me now, from your recent post, is that you’re focusing on saying things like this: “but somehow my blows are always bigger ones and tend to hit at the worst times” and not responding to any of the posts about how trauma distorts your personality and relationships, and leads to disruption on what is often an unconscious or subconscious level.

No, you’re still telling us the same story about how you have it worse and people don’t understand and are blaming you. That might be something of a clue.

Healthy people with good boundaries don’t form friendships to bring chaos into their lives. After you’ve formed a strong bond, some support might be reasonable to expect. But it takes some social and relational skill to navigate.

Another really difficult thing I had to work through in therapy is that my past made me vulnerable to abusive relationships. No, someone else’s actions are not your fault. But there are vulnerabilities in your system - missing boundaries, alarms that don’t trip - that mean you’re vulnerable to people like that in a way others aren’t. It’s not fair that any of your, or my, trauma happened. It’s not fair that I had to spend thousands on private therapy. But if you are carrying unresolved trauma, it can bring chaos into everything - how could it not affect your social relationships too?

LuvSmallDogs · 07/02/2023 07:13

How much drama my friends have doesn't necessarily matter to me - I've had some weird fucked up shit happen too, and trading gallows humour over a couple drinks is fun.

I did have to distance myself from one friend (who fair enough, had some trauma) who would constantly be blowing up my phone or visiting to rant about friendship drama or the fact her sister was the parents favourite - like, wanting me to help analyse the tone of someone's text message. She also wanted to see me every day which was just too much when she was often so negative - I like days where I just chill, thanks.

SparklingBalls · 07/02/2023 05:35

I've finally had the time to read through all of this, apologies for the late response.

To answer a few comments.
Yes, I fully take responsibility for what happens in my life - as long as those things are my fault.

I knew living in a dodgy area would lead to issues when all I had was £300pcm on rent and got out of one as soon as I earned more money, but that I got burgled was not my fault.
I ended abusive relationships (some earlier than others - when I had regained independence) but getting strangled and raped weren't my fault.
I raised my firstborn and created a loving, responsible character who is top of their class and I do take credit for that, and I did so without much help and support, but while getting pregnant at one of the "worst" points this could have happened was my fault, being subsequently cheated on and made homeless by my so-called partner wasn't.

I have done multiple therapies, CBT, taken SSRIs and have become a stronger person as a result. And from a shallow perspective my life is "sorted" - I am a homeowner, successful in my job with multiple, strong promotions into leadership, my kids are amazing and well-liked by their peers and teachers and I mostly have my shit together. BUT my life is never calm, there is always another blow around the corner, as it is for most people, but somehow my blows are always bigger ones and tend to hit at the worst times. Like a huge financial blow right after a big purchase (say, a boiler going bust in mid-winter just after almost all my savings went on replacing my old car, or interest rates increasing just before I managed to get a mortgage).

I don't overshare, no. In fact, I'm careful not to, but sometimes you cannot help give a bit of context.

OP posts:
Godlovesall26 · 06/02/2023 15:47

As for Brenda in the baby group, honestly that’s kind of the worst place to bring up parents biggest fears, but maybe you could have said, you know I had a bit of a tough upbringing at this time (mentioning why is a bit much in a baby’s group), I’m a bit worried about making mistakes about my baby, would you have any tips ?
You never know, you may have found the others would have rallied around with you with little tips.

Im sorry if I sound judgmental, I’m really not, I went through the same phase

Godlovesall26 · 06/02/2023 15:41

TheBigWangTheory · 06/02/2023 14:53

Lots of people have had plenty of drama, but they don't broadcast it to everyone. I don't understand people who do that.

"the constant onslaught of shit that happens" (which you take no ownership of or responsibilty for, as if you didn't make all of those choices as an adult yourself) is not what other people ant to deal with. People make choices to minimise drama and shit ion their lives, not invite it in from others.

And the point of the girls night out kind of just for one night at least forgetting about the shit stuff isn’t it ?

Work colleagues are definitely a no.

TW

And honestly, even the few friends I confided in about SA (again, after several years), apart from my best friend who had herself experienced trauma, didn’t really have much to say apart from ‘I m so sorry’… I didn’t take it personally, I mean I’m unsure what else they could have said ? I said I was having therapy to process so not to worry, it just felt like a stage in the relationship where I could share such an important event in my life ( I ended up terminating, I still have mixed feelings about it), but that’s about it. And I felt comfortable talking children at this point, so not to worry about tiptoeing around me. But terminating and SA were still sensitive subjects for me ( not that we’d ever really discussed them). And if I went isolated mode at Christmas that was why, and I didn’t expect them to ‘carry me through it’

TheBigWangTheory · 06/02/2023 14:53

Lots of people have had plenty of drama, but they don't broadcast it to everyone. I don't understand people who do that.

"the constant onslaught of shit that happens" (which you take no ownership of or responsibilty for, as if you didn't make all of those choices as an adult yourself) is not what other people ant to deal with. People make choices to minimise drama and shit ion their lives, not invite it in from others.

Godlovesall26 · 06/02/2023 14:46

Interestingly my best friend is the one I talk to the less about our traumas.
And we only started talking about them after 3 years of knowing each other.
It just became a mutual agreement that we want to talk about happy things, that we’re not defined by our traumas in a way.

I enjoy my other friendships equally because we do fun things, and it makes me feel happy and ‘normal’.

With my best friends we will share if there is a specific event, but not everyday struggles, we know we have them, and it becomes really depressing after a while.

neurodiverge · 06/02/2023 12:53

A lot of PPs judging people for not wanting to talk about trauma, assuming they're sheltered from trauma or in denial about trauma, but @MichelleScarn raises a good point... I spend so much of my own life in therapy, doing inner work, being in recovery etc. So when I meet up with someone to have fun or talk about the other things life offers (books, music, hobbies, current affairs) I want to do just that – have pure positive fun.

It's totally fine to confide and share, but only with the right friendship, or right time and place.

pattihews · 06/02/2023 11:45

How old are you, OP? I think as people age and mature they get more and more careful about who they choose as friends because they are less interested in taking on people's emotional baggage. I know that sounds horrible, but most people over the age of 40 just want 'sorted', uncomplicated friends. Can you be one of those?

When I was in my late teens, all the way through to my mid 30s, I made friends easily. Among those friends were people with mental health issues, abuse issues, relationship issues and personality disorders and I spent years supporting and learning from them. But a lot of them were quite transactional relationships, where my job was to listen or assist, and gradually as I got older I got tired of the constant calls on my energy and sympathy and put distance between us. I have perhaps six close friends, people I can be myself with, and we have a good balance. None of us asks or expects much in the way of help or emotional support from each other: we support each other but we're not dependent.

About six months ago I encountered an interesting woman at a group I attend. We hit it off in the group, where the conversation is fast and sparky and upbeat, and have gone on to meet each other one to one for coffee and dog-walking. She's not long out of a really bad marriage and her two sons have a myriad of psycho-social issues and they, quite understandably, form the basis of her conversation. I change subjects and try and lighten the tone but time after time she brings it back to her boys and ex-husband. I'm really torn, because I can see that she needs to offload in order to come through her bad experiences get to the other side. But I'm 60-ish and I've done my fair share of support friendships. I just want some intelligent conversation, someone to talk music or books or politics with. I'm very sorry for the clearly awful time she's going through with her children, but I don't want to be involved. I've cut our contact to a dog walk each week: walking seems to make it easier to listen and we get distracted by other people.

Perhaps this is why you're finding it difficult, OP. I think trauma seeps through and it can be quite off-putting. I don't know what you do except try to be aware of it and focus on being in the moment instead of being dragged back to the past.

YesItsMeIDontCare · 06/02/2023 11:02

thecatsthecats · 06/02/2023 10:46

I'm plenty aware, haha.

But I don't require people to have experienced similar things to me, just to be the sort of person who understands the very thing that others have said - that other people have rich and complex lives with different experiences that shape them.

And I'm not very interested in the type of person who doesn't understand that. There's plenty of people who do to be friends with - I don't feel like I'm missing out by not having friends like that.

Self awareness is the key really isn't it. You don't want to spend time with people you can't share with and they don't want to spend time with people who do. Neither is right, neither is wrong.

It's also give and take. For example, off loading about your shit marriage is fine as long as you don't get offended when someone mentions something nice they did with their husband.

Swipe left for the next trending thread