Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I missing something about US salaries here?

288 replies

Krayvon2 · 05/02/2023 18:27

I work in the UK, colleague works in the US for the same company.

We do a very similar job - Colleague earns around $158k per year. My salary is in £ and still a very good one but considerably less if you look at the exchange rate (probably half of US salary). However, this is a common trend with US vs UK employees in our company due to job market differences, experience etc (the sector we work in commands more of a premium over there).

With my UK salary I still manage to save a decent amount each month and pay all bills and mortgage etc.

Talking to US colleague about how in the UK we get paid on one set day every month (over there salary is paid in two installments each month) and they asked me how on earth I managed to make the money last all month.

They seemed to find it hard to believe it was possible to make a salary last 30 days and implied they struggled to make what they earn last over a couple of weeks! They've also made comments in the past about struggling with a surprise bill or having to put off a purchase.

I know lifestyles are more expensive over there but they spoke as if they earned peanuts so I'm wondering if I'm wrong to think that's a good salary? They get health cover through the company too so that's not an issue. Is there some other tax or something that I'm missing here? They are East Coast but not in most expensive area (not New York or Boston)

OP posts:
knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 05:58

My experience has been that there is good quality food in the USA, but the baseline standard is somewhat lower, and you have to relearn how to shop. It's not all chlorinated chicken and food additives like some would have you believe, though. What I miss are supermarket chilled ready meals, which are not really a thing.

(Example: the cheapest chicken at the supermarket is raised in crap conditions, but there's higher welfare there too. However, regular supermarket strawberries are all grown to be shipped from California or florida, so they are too firm and have no flavour. If you want a decent strawberry, you have to wait till the local ones are in and buy them from the farmers' market.)

The $11 iceberg lettuce was in Canada, IIRC. it was the double whammy of bad weather in Salinas, which grows early winter lettuce, and a supply chain problem. For a few weeks, restaurants in Canada were taking lettuce off the menu. Once the season started in Yuma and Coachella, the lettuce prices all went down again.

MintyFreshOne · 06/02/2023 05:46

The UK wages are way too low in comparison. Some things may be more expensive in the US, here and there but it's a lot less expensive

This is my impression too. I found the general COL a bit too high in the UK, especially as wages are not quite matching, although I will admit the food is better value and of better quality. As much as it pains me to admit that 😆

knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 05:38

Statistically the UK is actually more expensive than the US for child care, though I can't remember if that was in absolute dollar terms or relative to wages. I was somewhat shocked by that. #1 was Switzerland. Remember, huge country, so small towns will pull down the average.

the low value of the pound makes everything in the US (and Canada) look insanely expensive. That said, groceries are more (but not as bad when compared to wages). Mobile phones and home internet are more expensive, lack of competition.

We pay $350 in health insurance contributions per month. Property tax $6k. Texas, by the way, is known for high property taxes because there's no income tax. New York and New Jersey are the most expensive. An ordinary suburban house can easily pay $20K in taxes. However their teachers make over $100k a year.

You can't make huge assumptions about student loans. There's multiple parts to the system. The basic government guaranteed undergraduate loans are capped at $30k. Many of the outrageous numbers are either from going to expensive private universities or from graduate school (many professional degrees are mostly self-funded and you can borrow the whole cost from the government. PhDs have funding.) I borrowed to get a master's degree for a career change, so I'm paying that off again, but it increased my salary and will pay off.

Any given individual, in any country, could just be bad at budgeting, at any wage.

Also, some people in the US are paid weekly, not biweekly; I am.

nonheme · 06/02/2023 05:14

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

nonheme · 06/02/2023 05:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

MintyFreshOne · 06/02/2023 05:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

British expats are by and large going to be in dispatched to big cities so they will be hit with these extra costs, and no family or church groups to help with childcare.

Regional cities are far cheaper on all those costs, but you wouldn’t be sent there as an expat usually (although I knew a few sent to very regional cities in the Midwest lol)

nonheme · 06/02/2023 05:00

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

MintyFreshOne · 06/02/2023 04:58

Americans do have more disposable income. That’s just a fact. Hasn’t it always been that way?

madeleine85 · 06/02/2023 04:49

@alanabennett good to know! Family I have here don’t talk highly of SS benefits, and my retired MIL recently went back temp teaching to help her income levels. But I’m guessing the affordability varies state to state, then factor in healthcare costs and costs of living. Adulting (no matter where) is no fun 🤦‍♀️

alanabennett · 06/02/2023 04:40

madeleine85 · 06/02/2023 04:25

Brit here whose been in the US 15 years almost now. I’d add to this that you’ve got to factor in retirement costs. The US jobs are in part paid higher as there is no real government funded retirement (maybe a bit of social security, but the system is night and day vs the UK). I put in around 15% of my salary a year. People even still have to pay health insurance premiums which are huge in their retirement years, with no income coming in. I worked in nyc in my 20s and it wasn’t until I was earning over $100k that things were “ really comfortable”. And even on that, I had flatmates and had to try to save. I could never have supported a family solo on that salary. We’re out west now and just bought a house. It’s 3 beds, decent space, but we’re in a major city, so it’s not giant/the stereotyped McMansion size. But cost more than $1m and is not in a good school district, so we will be paying $4k in school fees month on top of a $6k mortgage, insurance etc. and then still have to buy food etc. you can live cheaper if you plan well and really don’t spend. The UK feels much more affordable to me, but that is based on the NHS and public pension holding it together in our lifetime and I’m not sure (but hope) that will happen…

What you're saying about the US retirement system is inaccurate. According to my recent statement, and my work history is less than 15 years, I'll get about $3k a month in SS when I retire. Currently the full state pension in the UK is less than £900 a month.

madeleine85 · 06/02/2023 04:25

Brit here whose been in the US 15 years almost now. I’d add to this that you’ve got to factor in retirement costs. The US jobs are in part paid higher as there is no real government funded retirement (maybe a bit of social security, but the system is night and day vs the UK). I put in around 15% of my salary a year. People even still have to pay health insurance premiums which are huge in their retirement years, with no income coming in. I worked in nyc in my 20s and it wasn’t until I was earning over $100k that things were “ really comfortable”. And even on that, I had flatmates and had to try to save. I could never have supported a family solo on that salary. We’re out west now and just bought a house. It’s 3 beds, decent space, but we’re in a major city, so it’s not giant/the stereotyped McMansion size. But cost more than $1m and is not in a good school district, so we will be paying $4k in school fees month on top of a $6k mortgage, insurance etc. and then still have to buy food etc. you can live cheaper if you plan well and really don’t spend. The UK feels much more affordable to me, but that is based on the NHS and public pension holding it together in our lifetime and I’m not sure (but hope) that will happen…

nudnikit · 06/02/2023 04:21

I've lived in the US. Definitely more expensive than UK for similar kind of locations.
These were the big ticket items - others already mentioned them

  1. Daycare. Expensive for all (but more in the US than UK for lwoer quality) up until 3, then UK starts to become cheaper. Most school districts don't have universal pre-k (reception) and if they do it's only half a day. My friend's school district provided no pre-k and only a half-day for kindergarten
  2. Holiday care. There is also far less annual leave and sick leave than standard in the UK. And holiday camps were eye-wateringly expensive. More than anything I paid in the UK.
  3. Rent/property taxes (folded into the rent if renting as on LL to pay). Yes, UK is high but US is higher
  4. And of course health insurance. Yes, employers provide it in the US but there are contributions to the premiums, deductibles, copays and then endless additional costs (using a doctor who was not 'in network' during an emergency...). The prices are ridiculous so even a 10% copay can add up.
  5. Food. Cheap food is as cheap as the UK but poorer quality. As soon as you want decent food, the prices are higher.
  6. Not for us but from colleagues - student loans. It's becoming more like that in the UK sadly but student debt wasn't think for my generation and it absolutely was for the US and to a lesser extent
  7. Lack of public transport outside major cities meaning you had to run a car for each household member and all the associate costs

It was really just "things" that were cheaper in the US or services that could be provided by the absolutely lowest paid workers

gwenneh · 06/02/2023 04:10

BeetlesForever · 06/02/2023 03:11

Sadly, most US grocery stores still sell eggs from caged hens. In some places, only a minority of eggs are cage-free, and those tend to be quite a bit more expensive.

Whereas most eggs sold in the UK are free-range.

I’m in the US right now, visiting family for a milestone birthday.
Eggs, purchased this morning at a large regional chain supermarket cost $4 for a dozen, local cage-free. They were not on offer, that was just the cost.

nudnikit · 06/02/2023 04:07

Major difference in that council tax does not pay for schools in the UK, this is paid by central taxes. If you're in an expensive school district in the US, your property tax bills can easily be $20,000 plus. Of course, if you have kids this is a great deal because the quality of education in one of those school districts is amazing. But it's expensive.

aloris · 06/02/2023 03:25

I would say the main difference between US and UK, from my stance as US person, is that in the US, when we calculate salary, we expect to be taking from that salary to save for retirement, for medical expenses, for long-term care, and all sorts. If we need a nursing home as an elderly person, we would either be expected to pay via previously purchased long-term-care insurance (which is dicey as sellers of such insurance are incentivised to charge high prices and provide as little care as possible, and to find legal loopholes to avoid paying at all), or you pay out of pocket, or you get none (i.e. live with younger family members, if you have any, and hope they take care of you). One hospital stay can be very, very expensive (my son visited A&E last year for about 3 hours and so far my bills have been around $1000 and that's WITH excellent health insurance. Every time a member of my family visits an A&E our co-pay will be about $100 minimum, and most likely a lot more), and insurance companies are always looking for ways to avoid paying out even if you have a contract for insurance with them. Basically in the US you use your salary to build your own safety net and it needs to be as big as you can make it.

Taxes are generally withheld before we get our paycheck but when we
think about our salaries we generally think about the amounts pre-tax, even though we'll only keep 60% of it by the time it gets to our bank account.

nokidshere · 06/02/2023 03:15

Meant to add and cheap. £5.50 per tray from a local farm

nokidshere · 06/02/2023 03:13

(no idea how anyone gets through that many eggs).

Completely off topic but we - family of 4 - buy 2 trays of 30 eggs every 8-10 days or so

2 each for breakfast every day = 40, about 10 for baking, another 10 for hard boiled lunchbox snacks/omelettes. Great versatile healthy food!

BeetlesForever · 06/02/2023 03:11

Sadly, most US grocery stores still sell eggs from caged hens. In some places, only a minority of eggs are cage-free, and those tend to be quite a bit more expensive.

Whereas most eggs sold in the UK are free-range.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 06/02/2023 02:53

SenecaFallsRedux · 06/02/2023 02:49

Eggs are definitely more expensive than they were just a few months ago but I just checked the price for my local grocery store (Publix) and they are $5.53 a dozen.

There is an egg shortage due to Avian flu outbreak a salmonella outbreak hence the recent increase in price of eggs but I’ve not seen the $18 some people are reporting on MN. My local grocery store has 18 eggs for about $6.

Hopefully things will ease up soon and prices come back down.

www.kktv.com/2023/01/11/heres-why-we-are-seeing-nationwide-egg-shortage/?outputType=amp

SenecaFallsRedux · 06/02/2023 02:49

Eggs are definitely more expensive than they were just a few months ago but I just checked the price for my local grocery store (Publix) and they are $5.53 a dozen.

Saschka · 06/02/2023 02:37

Girasoli · 05/02/2023 19:06

Groceries also seem really expensive in the US...I like watching US homesteaders on Instagram and they often mentions eggs in a store cost around $18.00

That isn’t for six eggs from Walmart. For one thing, you can’t actually buy eggs in sixes in the average US supermarket, a dozen is often the smallest size stocked, and they usually also sell trays of 2 and 3 dozen (no idea how anyone gets through that many eggs).

So it’s possible they are spending $18 on a tray of 36 eggs - still pricey, but if they are in somewhere like Planet Organic it is potentially believable.

Or they are actually buying hundreds (are they a Quiverful family with like 28 kids?), and the price per egg is the same as in the UK.

SenecaFallsRedux · 06/02/2023 02:31

Sunnyswfl · 06/02/2023 02:13

I live in the US, everybody has federal taxes, 401 k retirement( if participating) employees portion of health insurance ( if required) , and state taxes ( however we do not have state income tax here in Florida) taken out of their check every time they get paid. We file income tax once a year, we use our mortgage interest , medical expenses etc. as deductions and either get some of the money we paid in taxes back or we can end up owing the federal government.

Very true that in Florida we have no state income tax. Instead, because the economy is heavily dependent on tourism, we rely heavily on sales tax for state revenue. Sales tax is a regressive scheme and hits lower income people harder, but I don't see it changing anytime soon. But for those of you on Mumsnet who come to Florida and buy stuff, we thank you. 🌴

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 06/02/2023 02:26

Liorae · 06/02/2023 02:18

It's the same old misinformation regurgitated on every one of these threads on Mumsnet. Critical thinking is not taught in UK schools if Mumsnet is anything to go by.

And don’t forget the obligatory way they have to state that they will never want to live in the US lol.

Liorae · 06/02/2023 02:18

AliceOlive · 06/02/2023 00:31

I read earlier today on MN that it costs $30K to have a baby in the US.

Where do people get these ideas?

It's the same old misinformation regurgitated on every one of these threads on Mumsnet. Critical thinking is not taught in UK schools if Mumsnet is anything to go by.

Sunnyswfl · 06/02/2023 02:13

I live in the US, everybody has federal taxes, 401 k retirement( if participating) employees portion of health insurance ( if required) , and state taxes ( however we do not have state income tax here in Florida) taken out of their check every time they get paid. We file income tax once a year, we use our mortgage interest , medical expenses etc. as deductions and either get some of the money we paid in taxes back or we can end up owing the federal government.