Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I missing something about US salaries here?

288 replies

Krayvon2 · 05/02/2023 18:27

I work in the UK, colleague works in the US for the same company.

We do a very similar job - Colleague earns around $158k per year. My salary is in £ and still a very good one but considerably less if you look at the exchange rate (probably half of US salary). However, this is a common trend with US vs UK employees in our company due to job market differences, experience etc (the sector we work in commands more of a premium over there).

With my UK salary I still manage to save a decent amount each month and pay all bills and mortgage etc.

Talking to US colleague about how in the UK we get paid on one set day every month (over there salary is paid in two installments each month) and they asked me how on earth I managed to make the money last all month.

They seemed to find it hard to believe it was possible to make a salary last 30 days and implied they struggled to make what they earn last over a couple of weeks! They've also made comments in the past about struggling with a surprise bill or having to put off a purchase.

I know lifestyles are more expensive over there but they spoke as if they earned peanuts so I'm wondering if I'm wrong to think that's a good salary? They get health cover through the company too so that's not an issue. Is there some other tax or something that I'm missing here? They are East Coast but not in most expensive area (not New York or Boston)

OP posts:
BeetlesForever · 06/02/2023 13:26

do you know that unemployment benefits in most states is higher than jobseeker’s allowance/UC for when you lose your job in the UK?

True, but AFAIK, unemployment benefit only lasts 18 months.

And you have to fund your entire health insurance payments, including the (much larger) proportion that would previously have been paid by the employer. It's called COBRA, and most people who lose their jobs cannot afford it.

You're not entitled to much unless you have previously paid in. There is no Universal Credit, child benefit, payment of rent for the unemployed, etc. Hence people living in cars, whole families living in one cheap motel room, tent cities etc. Despite the AFC act, a significant proportion of working people still cannot afford health insurance.

Yes, many are doing well, some maybe better than equivalent occupations in the UK. But fall through the cracks at your peril - there ain't much of a safety net.

pairofrollerskates · 06/02/2023 13:10

My friends in the US pay much, much more than we do for things like: water, car insurance, health insurance, garbage disposal, road taxes, dental charges, prescriptions, ... basically, everything actually, except material goods, which are often cheaper.

drspouse · 06/02/2023 12:53

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 05/02/2023 18:29

They don't get taxes deducted before being paid. They earn their money then do an annual tax return and work out how much to pay over to the government.

Yes they do, employers withhold taxes just like here. They may have to pay extra/get some back at the end of the year depending on extra allowances/extra pay.

Labraradabrador · 06/02/2023 12:42

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 05/02/2023 18:29

They don't get taxes deducted before being paid. They earn their money then do an annual tax return and work out how much to pay over to the government.

Not true, taxes are deducted based on estimated earnings. You then file a return (everyone does regardless of salary) and you may have more to pay or you may get a refund

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 06/02/2023 12:40

maddy68 · 06/02/2023 12:31

They have to do tax returns so that will come out afterwards. Healthcare is very expensive
They don't have the same holiday entitlement or maternity rights . Pensions etc

You are not comparing like for like

I don’t get your point about pensions (see my post above). Yes legally the holiday entitlement is lower than the UK but many many companies are offering more. I’ve had 3 employees in the Us and the lowest PTO I’ve had is 21 days. That still doesn’t explain the salary difference.

i was on £45k in the UK and transferred over on $105k and since then I come has jumped significantly faster that it would have in the UK.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 06/02/2023 12:35

@Lostinthecoop this thread is an example of how so many people in the UK have their stereotypes and misconceptions about the Us as continue to boldly make statements when they don’t know what they are talking about. One claimed they don’t take takes from paycheck, another claims no government pension despite living in the Us for 15 years.

There seems to be an u healthy obsession in the UK about the US and I don’t get it as you all don’t want to ever live there yet you all continue to act like you know everything about the Us and have these debates based on false information lol.

let me blow your mind again, do you know that unemployment benefits in most states is higher than jobseeker’s allowance/UC for when you lose your job in the UK?

In Illinois for example the maximum unemployment Benefit if you lose you job is $484 a week and up to $669 if you have children. that’s the maximum, the actual amount depends on your income and how long you worked etc. This varies by state with Massachusetts having the highest at about $800 a week but you will also contribute for that benefit.

During Covid the federal government paid an additional $400 a week on top of the state benefit for people to stay at home in addition to stimulus payments which were in every way more generous than what the Uk government gave Brit’s but yet the narrative is no social net in the US.

www.illinoislegalaid.org/legal-information/getting-unemployment-benefits

I just think Brits should stop talking about the US and leave them to sort themselves out. You all make it clear you will never live there yet continue to de ate and debate and debate with false information everyday.

maddy68 · 06/02/2023 12:31

They have to do tax returns so that will come out afterwards. Healthcare is very expensive
They don't have the same holiday entitlement or maternity rights . Pensions etc

You are not comparing like for like

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 06/02/2023 12:23

@madeleine85 your statement re pension has also reinforced what I have noticed with people in the Uk having this grand image in their head about state pension without truly knowing how much it is. I have friends who make statements such as no need to save for retirement as I’ll just live on state pension, get these same people expect to be able to travel during retirement etc ok what £800 a month?

we’ve seen how increase in gas prices put many retirees in difficulty so no one should be planning to live only on state pension, it’s a small amount and will not give a comfortable life.

Lots of people are in for a shocker when they retire and find out how much they will get, and the ~£800 is if you contribute for the full 35 years which means some people will get less.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 06/02/2023 12:16

madeleine85 · 06/02/2023 04:25

Brit here whose been in the US 15 years almost now. I’d add to this that you’ve got to factor in retirement costs. The US jobs are in part paid higher as there is no real government funded retirement (maybe a bit of social security, but the system is night and day vs the UK). I put in around 15% of my salary a year. People even still have to pay health insurance premiums which are huge in their retirement years, with no income coming in. I worked in nyc in my 20s and it wasn’t until I was earning over $100k that things were “ really comfortable”. And even on that, I had flatmates and had to try to save. I could never have supported a family solo on that salary. We’re out west now and just bought a house. It’s 3 beds, decent space, but we’re in a major city, so it’s not giant/the stereotyped McMansion size. But cost more than $1m and is not in a good school district, so we will be paying $4k in school fees month on top of a $6k mortgage, insurance etc. and then still have to buy food etc. you can live cheaper if you plan well and really don’t spend. The UK feels much more affordable to me, but that is based on the NHS and public pension holding it together in our lifetime and I’m not sure (but hope) that will happen…

You’ve lived in the US 15 years and still claim there is no government funded retirement so what is social seniority for?

Social security payments for retirement is even higher than the UK state pension isn’t it? And state pension is NOT funded by the government, it is funded by NI deductions from your paycheck same as you also have social security deductions from your paycheck in the US that fund pension, disability payments and a few others.

And as with the UK your pension is made up of 3 parts, the government paid pension ie state pension in the UK and SS in the US, your company pension plan so in the UK employer and employee paying into a pension plan which in the UK will be a 401k etc, and your personal savings. You saving 15% for retirement is based on sensible financial decision making not because there is no government pension. What you’re saying is in the Uk you will spend it all and depends on state pension which is what? £180+ a week??? You’re making it sound like some huge amount which it is not.

The average social security payment for retirement is about $1800 a month with max about $3500 and can be higher depending on the age you start taking it. The max state pension in the UK is £740. As a couple the couple in the Us will be better off especially if they have a paid for house with no rent or mortgage to pay.

Having said that you should not be depending on state pension in the UK or social security in the US alone for retirement, it is one of 3 parts for a comfortable retirement.

Unless you’re a very very low earner all your career in the UK the pension options in the US are actually better.

I do not know where you live in NY but NYC has good public schools so it’s a preference for you to pay private school fees of $4k a month.

MountedbyHarryWindsor · 06/02/2023 10:41

Hi sis!!!!!!!

Liorae · 06/02/2023 10:16

MountedbyHarryWindsor · 06/02/2023 06:43

Forgot to add that DSis has less qualifications and experience than me and she's doing the same job as me (albeit in the USA). We studied the same course initially but I took the qualifications further and got more, she didn't.

And yet she's doing better. Perhaps you should ask her for career advice.

Liorae · 06/02/2023 10:02

AliceOlive · 06/02/2023 00:31

I read earlier today on MN that it costs $30K to have a baby in the US.

Where do people get these ideas?

From other threads of stupidity on Mumsnet.

Liorae · 06/02/2023 09:57

OntarioBagnet · 05/02/2023 23:33

Because they’re paying $11 for an iceberg lettuce!

I don't know anyone who buys iceberg lettuce. It's devoid of any nutrients.

MintyFreshOne · 06/02/2023 07:59

I wonder that too. DH is American and the US requires he files a joint married tax return every year even though he hasn’t lived in the US for fifteen years! I think they are only country that tax by citizenship as well as residency

He isn’t required to file jointly, but he must have done the calculation that it’s advantageous for him to do so.

I file separately to avoid taxes on my DH assets, everything must be keep strictly separate, it is such a PITA

Onnabugeisha · 06/02/2023 07:47

SenecaFallsRedux · 06/02/2023 00:17

Where does this notion come from among some posters that we in the US are paid gross? Millions of Americans are in the middle of working on their taxes or getting their information ready to give to an accountant at this very moment. And a key portion of that documentation are statements that show the amounts that have been withheld for income tax, social security tax, Medicare tax, state income tax, if applicable, and a few other things as well. I'm inclined to take a photo of my dining room table just to show what this can look like.

I wonder that too. DH is American and the US requires he files a joint married tax return every year even though he hasn’t lived in the US for fifteen years! I think they are only country that tax by citizenship as well as residency.

And so we pay tax to U.K. and then more tax to the US every year…..
Hes doing his spreadsheets with his U.K. earnings and such now.

Onnabugeisha · 06/02/2023 07:42

MissConductUS · 05/02/2023 23:04

Spot on, with one minor correction. Only the interest portion of the mortgage payment is tax deductible. Early in the loan, that will be most of it, then it declines over time as the mortgage amortized and you are paying more in principle. It is a huge incentive to buy a house regardless. And I agree that a like for like comparison is not possible.

Yes, not only is it only the interest that is deductible, but you also have to have enough other tax deductions on top to exceed the standard deduction, otherwise you are not saving any money on your taxes at all.

Onnabugeisha · 06/02/2023 07:35

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 05/02/2023 18:29

They don't get taxes deducted before being paid. They earn their money then do an annual tax return and work out how much to pay over to the government.

That’s not true, taxes are withheld from your pay AND you have to do a tax return to see if you owe more taxes or get a bit refunded back.

You will have these taxes withheld from your pay:

  • Federal Income Tax
  • State Income Tax (only a few states don’t have this)
  • City/Local Income Tax (major cities)
  • Social Security Tax
  • Medicare Tax
knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 07:00

MountedbyHarryWindsor · 06/02/2023 06:40

I'm glad this thread was posted as my DSis lives abroad (we don't get on) and has been bragging about her latest promotion which pays her $80,000pa. I earn nearly £33,500pa before tax with an additional income from benefits that amounts to about £6000pa. I am not sure what her salary is after tax and if its really as good as she makes out.
She has a much bigger house than us, with a pool, and apparently paid less than we paid for us back in the UK so I also don't understand house prices there.

Everything depends on location. Just like the UK. Impossible to judge house prices as a whole.

i will say that the recent jump in house prices and mortgage rates means that we would need a bigger income to afford a house now. I thought prices were bad enough when we bought. (We have a standard American 30 year fixed mortgage, so our costs are locked in.)

OntarioBagnet · 06/02/2023 07:00

steff13 · 05/02/2023 23:34

Also no.

Well it’s $11 somewhere . I’d post my screenshot but MN says my files are too big these days so I can’t (which is really annoying me) 😬

www.montereyherald.com/2022/12/16/11-for-a-head-of-lettuce-nationwide-shortage-causes-outrageous-prices-2/

Citygirlrurallife · 06/02/2023 06:56

I d mo agree though with PP that U.K. wages are shit. DH and I work in totally different industries - 30-40% pay cut and the cost of living difference doesn’t reflect that (moved to and from comparable areas in both countries)

but talk of $18 eggs, $18 sandwiches and $11 lettuces are not true at all.

Having said that $5 is very cheap for bread and it’s fucking awful

MountedbyHarryWindsor · 06/02/2023 06:43

Forgot to add that DSis has less qualifications and experience than me and she's doing the same job as me (albeit in the USA). We studied the same course initially but I took the qualifications further and got more, she didn't.

MountedbyHarryWindsor · 06/02/2023 06:40

I'm glad this thread was posted as my DSis lives abroad (we don't get on) and has been bragging about her latest promotion which pays her $80,000pa. I earn nearly £33,500pa before tax with an additional income from benefits that amounts to about £6000pa. I am not sure what her salary is after tax and if its really as good as she makes out.
She has a much bigger house than us, with a pool, and apparently paid less than we paid for us back in the UK so I also don't understand house prices there.

MintyFreshOne · 06/02/2023 06:27

knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 05:58

My experience has been that there is good quality food in the USA, but the baseline standard is somewhat lower, and you have to relearn how to shop. It's not all chlorinated chicken and food additives like some would have you believe, though. What I miss are supermarket chilled ready meals, which are not really a thing.

(Example: the cheapest chicken at the supermarket is raised in crap conditions, but there's higher welfare there too. However, regular supermarket strawberries are all grown to be shipped from California or florida, so they are too firm and have no flavour. If you want a decent strawberry, you have to wait till the local ones are in and buy them from the farmers' market.)

The $11 iceberg lettuce was in Canada, IIRC. it was the double whammy of bad weather in Salinas, which grows early winter lettuce, and a supply chain problem. For a few weeks, restaurants in Canada were taking lettuce off the menu. Once the season started in Yuma and Coachella, the lettuce prices all went down again.

Canada though is the worst of all worlds, high cost of living, high food prices, ‘stuff’ is costly too and the salaries inexplicably low.

Guihgesfy5es · 06/02/2023 06:26

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 05/02/2023 18:32

That number is not always the monetary value though - that number can be total comp of other benefits and insurance. So that $158K could be a whole lot less in take home salary terms.

With regards to monthly or fortnightly, I guess it just what you’re used to budgeting. It’s still the same amount of money - it’s just halved every two weeks.

Really?!?

FluffyBellyMeowMeow · 06/02/2023 06:00

catgirl1976 · 05/02/2023 18:32

It’s the fact they get paid gross and are not taxed at source. Plus they get very little annual leave

apart from the bi-monthly pay I would not want to swap. Hardly any employment right either. Next to no mat leave, little protection from being fired etc

Incorrect. We get taxed right away. We have to pay social security, state, and federal taxes.

Annual leave is dire on average (you are right about that), most in regular jobs get two weeks and holidays. Each state has sick day policies. If you’re making 6 figures you’re getting at least 3 weeks off with some floating days unless you’re in a lower status job.

employment rights vary be state. For instance California is awesome for employees rights but Arizona and many other states are dismal.

There are federal laws that govern the land which are to be considered minimum. Each state has their own labor laws and some are actually quite good. Others are… the minimum.

You can’t paint it with one brush because that’s not reality in the US.