Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I missing something about US salaries here?

288 replies

Krayvon2 · 05/02/2023 18:27

I work in the UK, colleague works in the US for the same company.

We do a very similar job - Colleague earns around $158k per year. My salary is in £ and still a very good one but considerably less if you look at the exchange rate (probably half of US salary). However, this is a common trend with US vs UK employees in our company due to job market differences, experience etc (the sector we work in commands more of a premium over there).

With my UK salary I still manage to save a decent amount each month and pay all bills and mortgage etc.

Talking to US colleague about how in the UK we get paid on one set day every month (over there salary is paid in two installments each month) and they asked me how on earth I managed to make the money last all month.

They seemed to find it hard to believe it was possible to make a salary last 30 days and implied they struggled to make what they earn last over a couple of weeks! They've also made comments in the past about struggling with a surprise bill or having to put off a purchase.

I know lifestyles are more expensive over there but they spoke as if they earned peanuts so I'm wondering if I'm wrong to think that's a good salary? They get health cover through the company too so that's not an issue. Is there some other tax or something that I'm missing here? They are East Coast but not in most expensive area (not New York or Boston)

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/02/2023 18:29

So far we’ve mythbusted

  • the $30K baby price tag
  • the $18 eggs
  • the no taxes being deducted
  • the no housing assistance
  • the no unemployment assistance
  • the pay period variation
  • the no paid vacation

What else was there?

Liorae · 06/02/2023 18:21

Girasoli · 06/02/2023 18:09

Sorry I was misremembering where I read about the $18 eggs, it was this Guardian article:

amp.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jan/25/18-a-dozen-how-did-americas-eggs-get-absurdly-expensive

The homesteaders must have been complaining another food was really expensive!

A "gourmet food store " is more expensive than a supermarket. Who would have guessed?
Eggs have gone up though. About $5.50 a dozen around here, which I consider high.

MissConductUS · 06/02/2023 18:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Unemployment programs are funded and managed by the states, with the funding coming mostly from employers. In NY, benefits are limited to 26 weeks. During the pandemic, the Federal government provided funding to extend benefits for longer periods. The same has happened previously during periods of high unemployment. So it's not as simple as a standard 18-month benefit period.

Girasoli · 06/02/2023 18:09

Sorry I was misremembering where I read about the $18 eggs, it was this Guardian article:

amp.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jan/25/18-a-dozen-how-did-americas-eggs-get-absurdly-expensive

The homesteaders must have been complaining another food was really expensive!

nonheme · 06/02/2023 17:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Neededanewuserhandle · 06/02/2023 16:22

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/02/2023 16:08

And seniority 🙂

that brings up an interesting question, That I really have not been able to figure out so would love to take the opportunity to ask. Who pays for all the sick leave in the UK… so I read on here about people being off sick for months. Is that paid leave or unpaid? What about maternity, I get that there are different kinds, who pays for what and how?

In the US typically you get PTO which is combined sick time and vacation buckets or separate sick time and vacation time (with different rules) then extended sick leave partially covered by short and long term disability insurance paid for by the employer.

My real question is…are UK employers paying more for all of these different leaves?

It's a complex picture. We have basic minimum standards of paid leave in the UK - and unlike the US these are national (the equivalent of Federal) so there aren't State variations.
Sick pay has to be paid by employers (trivia - it used to be funded from NI) subject to some qualifications rules BUT it's a very low value (below min wage). It runs out after 28 weeks and then the employer doesn't have to pay any more (it's a bit more complicated but that's the basic).
Many employers add their own schemes on top but very few are insurance backed or outsourced as they commonly are in the USA.

Maternity Leave also has a basic minimum that some employers (but by now means all) add to. It's a stupidly complex formula based on earnings during a set period, and pays 90% of earnings for 6 weeks, then an amount below min wage for 33 more weeks. You are allowed to take a year off on Mat leave, but anything over the 39 weeks is unpaid.

This is a very basic summary only.

Combing sick and vacation into a single PTO isn't done in the UK and would likely be illegal - it's going to be less common in the US as more States mandate paid sick leave.

Liorae · 06/02/2023 16:21

MissConductUS · 06/02/2023 15:54

I get ten paid holidays and five weeks of annual leave. Perhaps that's "very little" by UK standards.

The amount of leave you get is tied to your job level and is negotiable.

I wonder about negotiating leave and salary in the UK. Is it a thing there? When I hear people from the UK saying that people in the US get very little pto etc, are they unaware that these things are negotiable?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/02/2023 16:08

MissConductUS · 06/02/2023 15:54

I get ten paid holidays and five weeks of annual leave. Perhaps that's "very little" by UK standards.

The amount of leave you get is tied to your job level and is negotiable.

And seniority 🙂

that brings up an interesting question, That I really have not been able to figure out so would love to take the opportunity to ask. Who pays for all the sick leave in the UK… so I read on here about people being off sick for months. Is that paid leave or unpaid? What about maternity, I get that there are different kinds, who pays for what and how?

In the US typically you get PTO which is combined sick time and vacation buckets or separate sick time and vacation time (with different rules) then extended sick leave partially covered by short and long term disability insurance paid for by the employer.

My real question is…are UK employers paying more for all of these different leaves?

mathanxiety · 06/02/2023 16:02

nudnikit · 06/02/2023 04:21

I've lived in the US. Definitely more expensive than UK for similar kind of locations.
These were the big ticket items - others already mentioned them

  1. Daycare. Expensive for all (but more in the US than UK for lwoer quality) up until 3, then UK starts to become cheaper. Most school districts don't have universal pre-k (reception) and if they do it's only half a day. My friend's school district provided no pre-k and only a half-day for kindergarten
  2. Holiday care. There is also far less annual leave and sick leave than standard in the UK. And holiday camps were eye-wateringly expensive. More than anything I paid in the UK.
  3. Rent/property taxes (folded into the rent if renting as on LL to pay). Yes, UK is high but US is higher
  4. And of course health insurance. Yes, employers provide it in the US but there are contributions to the premiums, deductibles, copays and then endless additional costs (using a doctor who was not 'in network' during an emergency...). The prices are ridiculous so even a 10% copay can add up.
  5. Food. Cheap food is as cheap as the UK but poorer quality. As soon as you want decent food, the prices are higher.
  6. Not for us but from colleagues - student loans. It's becoming more like that in the UK sadly but student debt wasn't think for my generation and it absolutely was for the US and to a lesser extent
  7. Lack of public transport outside major cities meaning you had to run a car for each household member and all the associate costs

It was really just "things" that were cheaper in the US or services that could be provided by the absolutely lowest paid workers

Rent varies enormously even within the same zip code.

You can eat very well in the US without breaking the bank. Cooking ability makes a difference.

If you don't want to live in a place where there is reliable public transport, then you have to take practicalities into account. Yes, this means running cars in far flung suburbs, which is what people living in rural areas of the UK have to do too.

It doesn't take a lot of effort to locate a doctor who takes your insurance, and to have this sort of info to hand in case of emergency.

Low paid workers provide essential services in the UK. Hence the current strikes.

MissConductUS · 06/02/2023 15:54

I get ten paid holidays and five weeks of annual leave. Perhaps that's "very little" by UK standards.

The amount of leave you get is tied to your job level and is negotiable.

Neededanewuserhandle · 06/02/2023 15:43

catgirl1976 · 05/02/2023 18:32

It’s the fact they get paid gross and are not taxed at source. Plus they get very little annual leave

apart from the bi-monthly pay I would not want to swap. Hardly any employment right either. Next to no mat leave, little protection from being fired etc

Most US employes are taxed at source -

www.irs.gov/payments/tax-withholding#:~:text=For%20employees%2C%20withholding%20is%20the,employer%20on%20Form%20W%E2%80%934.

Partyandbullshit · 06/02/2023 15:37

Mamanyt · 06/02/2023 01:10

Oh, yes, we do get taxes deducted before being paid. An entire LIST of taxes. Before your paycheck is issued, the employer will have deducted Federal income tax, state income tax where applicable, Social Security and Medicare taxes, and Unemployment taxes. Also your portion of group insurance, if applicable. Since Federal income tax varies by married/single/married filing jointly, and how many dependents you claim, you must ALSO work out how much over or under you had deducted, and then either pay the difference, or get a refund.

And paydays are up to the individual company. You might be paid weekly, bi-weekly (ie: every other Friday), bi-monthly (ie: 15th and 30th of each month), OR monthly. Personally, I've always preferred to be paid on the last day of the month. It allowed me to pay all regular bills (rent, utilities, etc) on the first of the month, and then budget the rest.

Off-topic: I've never understood how "bi-weekly" means every two weeks, but "bi-monthly" doesn't mean every two months, but twice a month. Grrrr.

On topic: people have raised entire families for generations off the income generated by working through the confusion of personal taxes, healthcare, pensions provisions etc in the US. The misinformation in this country is partly down to organic growth of various systems, and there's no impetus to clear up confusion because working through the confusion/working the confusion to your advantage is an entire industry. No wonder foreigners find it difficult to comprehend!

EllieM27 · 06/02/2023 15:37

MintyFreshOne · 06/02/2023 04:58

Americans do have more disposable income. That’s just a fact. Hasn’t it always been that way?

Yes, exactly. It is strange that there is now a need to explain this away and try to make things “even” when it has always been the case. The US is larger and more prosperous, just as it has been for over a century. Of course their salaries are higher.

When I moved to the US one of the things that struck me is that when Americans want to be patriotic they think of positive things to say about the US, like their research or the national parks or the eye-watering amount of money they send to support developing nations. When Brits want to be patriotic we tend to just slag off the US. Funny how that works. Grin

mathanxiety · 06/02/2023 15:31

'Payment of rent for the unemployed' -

Section 8 is a federal housing assistance programme authorizing payment to private landlords on behalf of low income tenants. It's cumbersome but it definitely exists.

mathanxiety · 06/02/2023 15:22

@BeetlesForever

You don't have to pay COBRA.

You can apply for health insurance under the ACA even if open enrollment is closed.

You can apply for Medicaid too.

EffortlessDesmond · 06/02/2023 15:08

Work is definitely better paid in the US, and has been for yonks. I took a 50% cut when I returned to the UK -- in 1986. I also had a four-day week in the summer months.

ThePriceOfSugar · 06/02/2023 15:05

I make $95K in NYC
Federal marginal tax rate: 22%
State marginal tax rate: 6.25%
NYC local tax rate: 3.8%

After maxing out retirement contributions (employer matching) and paying health insurance I make $3800/m.

Rent is a heavy percentage of that sum.

Luckily I don't have student loans...

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 06/02/2023 14:59

knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 14:50

@Cantstandbullshitanymore sorry - bad phrasing. I know about SSDI and SSI. I meant that if you fall into neither the employed nor disabled categories, there's not a lot available. (I should say elderly, too.) SSDI can pay more than its UK equivalent, also, as it's wage-linked, though getting it is a nightmare process.

I don't think the UK is paradise either having lived in both countries and the Tories have cut the safety net in the UK too. The US is always held up as a scare tactic to distract people while the UK government makes things just as bad: using Ivy League universities to make £9000 tuition fees look reasonable when average English student debt is now greater than American.

I see your point and agree it’s not an amazing rosy life on welfare hence why I said I prefer to be in a position to earn more and save and inches for myself but I get that doesn’t appeal or apply to everyone.

and yea I agree re the student debt point which I’ve made so many times as people on MN keep using the extreme high amounts like that applies to the average American when it doesn’t.

In summary I would rather not be on benefits in either country and once you get past a a certain income limits with a mortgage last a certain amount the benefits in the UK don’t do much for you.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 06/02/2023 14:56

BeetlesForever · 06/02/2023 13:26

do you know that unemployment benefits in most states is higher than jobseeker’s allowance/UC for when you lose your job in the UK?

True, but AFAIK, unemployment benefit only lasts 18 months.

And you have to fund your entire health insurance payments, including the (much larger) proportion that would previously have been paid by the employer. It's called COBRA, and most people who lose their jobs cannot afford it.

You're not entitled to much unless you have previously paid in. There is no Universal Credit, child benefit, payment of rent for the unemployed, etc. Hence people living in cars, whole families living in one cheap motel room, tent cities etc. Despite the AFC act, a significant proportion of working people still cannot afford health insurance.

Yes, many are doing well, some maybe better than equivalent occupations in the UK. But fall through the cracks at your peril - there ain't much of a safety net.

Given the size and scope of the US economy that’s more than enough time to get another job isn’t it? And if there is an economic situation like Covid of the financial crisis etc the federal governance enacts emergency laws that extent the duration.

Surelry the point of benefits when you lose your job is to tide you over till you get a new job not to become your new life.

The path we’re going in the UK where people are earning £50k - £60k and still feel they need government support is not exactly sustainable.

knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 14:50

@Cantstandbullshitanymore sorry - bad phrasing. I know about SSDI and SSI. I meant that if you fall into neither the employed nor disabled categories, there's not a lot available. (I should say elderly, too.) SSDI can pay more than its UK equivalent, also, as it's wage-linked, though getting it is a nightmare process.

I don't think the UK is paradise either having lived in both countries and the Tories have cut the safety net in the UK too. The US is always held up as a scare tactic to distract people while the UK government makes things just as bad: using Ivy League universities to make £9000 tuition fees look reasonable when average English student debt is now greater than American.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/02/2023 14:41

This thread is a hoot. So many misconceptions and misinformation being presented as fact. One thing that hasn’t come up yet is standard of living. While it’s true some things are more expensive here but what you get for that is IMHO different than what is available in the UK. so even while you can compare some things the details start to make the price differences understandable.

To name a few that I’ve picked up on both while studying in the UK and here:

  • Emergency response times minutes vs. hours
  • space -house/lot sizes
  • availability and access to health care
  • Hospital services
  • Little things (again depending on location)
  • School transportation, home garbage pickup, leaf/snow removal, etc

I think everyone needs to use a little common sense here… is it really plausible that everyone is paying $18K-$30K out of pocket per baby? Do you really think that there isn’t a government retirement plan? Do you think the government wouldn’t have a way to collect taxes from payroll?

Yes we have tent cities but look at who lives in them, mostly drug addicts and mentally unwell people. Yes some people can’t afford health insurance, but the vast majority can. Yes, some people live far beyond their means and don’t prioritize intelligently. And yes some people are poor through no fault of their own, but they do have safety nets available to them.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 06/02/2023 14:39

knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 14:28

The safety net in the US has massive holes in it, but I do think Brits don't know what is available as the programs are so patchwork. What the US doesn't really have, thanks to "welfare reform," is cash welfare (it technically exists, but is time limited and very difficult to access). If you are not working and not disabled, there's really nothing for you. If you fall into one of those categories, there is something.

Housing vouchers (Section 8) do exist but are capped and getting one is very difficult in most of the country. The biggest issue the US is having with housing right now is that there isn't enough of it. People are priced out of the market because of demand, even in traditionally cheaper cities. No one seems to have an idea of how to deal with it.

There is no child benefit (the experiment with the prepaid Child Tax Credit would have effectively created that) but there is a significant child tax credit and earned income tax credit, and they are refundable credits--that is, you can get back more than you pay in income tax.

That’s not true about disability, social security benefits cover disability payments as well.

I do agree with you about they fact there are holes and it’s not perfect but neither is the Uk benefit system, there are big holes there as well. Are you telling me it’s easy to walk into a council house in the UK?

Re child benefit yes it’s a tax credit which you claim back which they made advanced last year, it sure if it continues to be advanced payment or back to normal.

Irrespective I do not think the UK benefit system is that amazing once you go past a certain I cor level, so I would rather be in a position to earn and save more than limit myself to a low income to get low benefits.

So yes I agree there are holes and it’s not perfect but its also not the UK narrative of no benefits.

knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 14:28

The safety net in the US has massive holes in it, but I do think Brits don't know what is available as the programs are so patchwork. What the US doesn't really have, thanks to "welfare reform," is cash welfare (it technically exists, but is time limited and very difficult to access). If you are not working and not disabled, there's really nothing for you. If you fall into one of those categories, there is something.

Housing vouchers (Section 8) do exist but are capped and getting one is very difficult in most of the country. The biggest issue the US is having with housing right now is that there isn't enough of it. People are priced out of the market because of demand, even in traditionally cheaper cities. No one seems to have an idea of how to deal with it.

There is no child benefit (the experiment with the prepaid Child Tax Credit would have effectively created that) but there is a significant child tax credit and earned income tax credit, and they are refundable credits--that is, you can get back more than you pay in income tax.

MissConductUS · 06/02/2023 13:44

And you have to fund your entire health insurance payments, including the (much larger) proportion that would previously have been paid by the employer. It's called COBRA, and most people who lose their jobs cannot afford it.

If your only income is unemployment insurance, you will meet the threshold for free or heavily subsidized care under the ACA. And you can apply right away as the loss of a job with private coverage qualifies as a "life event".

If you were laid off and are getting a severance package many employers will continue your coverage for three to six months as part of the package.

BeetlesForever · 06/02/2023 13:29

ACA, sorry - affordable care act. AKA Obamacare.