Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I missing something about US salaries here?

288 replies

Krayvon2 · 05/02/2023 18:27

I work in the UK, colleague works in the US for the same company.

We do a very similar job - Colleague earns around $158k per year. My salary is in £ and still a very good one but considerably less if you look at the exchange rate (probably half of US salary). However, this is a common trend with US vs UK employees in our company due to job market differences, experience etc (the sector we work in commands more of a premium over there).

With my UK salary I still manage to save a decent amount each month and pay all bills and mortgage etc.

Talking to US colleague about how in the UK we get paid on one set day every month (over there salary is paid in two installments each month) and they asked me how on earth I managed to make the money last all month.

They seemed to find it hard to believe it was possible to make a salary last 30 days and implied they struggled to make what they earn last over a couple of weeks! They've also made comments in the past about struggling with a surprise bill or having to put off a purchase.

I know lifestyles are more expensive over there but they spoke as if they earned peanuts so I'm wondering if I'm wrong to think that's a good salary? They get health cover through the company too so that's not an issue. Is there some other tax or something that I'm missing here? They are East Coast but not in most expensive area (not New York or Boston)

OP posts:
LemonSwan · 07/02/2023 00:47

AliceOlive · 07/02/2023 00:42

What?! No. Sheesh.

Well just googling now and in big cities it seems not. But I swear I remember watching something where the neighbours hadn’t paid their subscription and their house was on fire but the fire service turned up to wait for the fire to jump to the next house who had paid so they could put those specific flames only out. Mind boggling.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/02/2023 00:47

LemonSwan · 07/02/2023 00:41

Dont you even have to pay to subscribe to the fire engine?

It’s a mad world.

Some very rural people do, it’s because they don’t pay for it their property taxes. If they don’t pay the subscription they will be charged for the response. It is not the norm. In these areas the typical fire department is volunteer and the fee goes toward equipment

AliceOlive · 07/02/2023 00:42

LemonSwan · 07/02/2023 00:41

Dont you even have to pay to subscribe to the fire engine?

It’s a mad world.

What?! No. Sheesh.

LemonSwan · 07/02/2023 00:41

Dont you even have to pay to subscribe to the fire engine?

It’s a mad world.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/02/2023 00:37

knitnerd90 · 07/02/2023 00:21

This is related to what I do for work (so I really should not have made that typo about Medicaid! I shall blame autocorrect). The US system is a giant set of kludges. It's not something anyone would intentionally design, but it was set up piecemeal, and once a block is in place, it becomes very difficult to dislodge.

It is true that our relatively poor outcomes don't necessarily reflect the quality of care, though it's doubtful that obesity is as big a contributor, because obesity maps strongly onto other social determinants of health such as poverty and race; obesity itself may be causing a lot less than we think. The US invests relatively little into closing social gaps and that winds up on the back of the healthcare system. There's issues such as the "deaths of despair" amongst working class whites, especially men. We wind up with a system where some people get too much healthcare and others don't get enough. Here near a major city, the health care is world class. Not only does DC have several excellent hospitals, I'm an hour from Baltimore, which has two more, including Johns Hopkins which is one of the best in the world. Now go to the Mississippi Delta and it's like being in an entirely different country. The gaps in health insurance snowball: when a woman only gets proper medical care during and for a short period after pregnancy, chronic health conditions aren't properly treated. There's no real system for resource allocation other than the market. Because Medicare pays less than private insurance and Medicaid least of all, hospitals in poor areas (and often in rural areas) struggle to stay open. There is a crisis in rural healthcare that people in cities don't really hear about. A work friend of mine worked on the rez for IHS and her stories were heartbreaking.

In an ideal world, we would spend less than we do, but more than the UK does. Administration and insurance profits aren't as huge as some politicians would have you think. What drives up costs is that Americans pay far more for identical products and services and there is little to no cost control. It's good that nurses here are properly paid, but look at device and drug costs: A Mirena coil costs the NHS about £90 last I checked whereas the US cost is nearly $1,000.

It's good that nurses here are properly paid, but look at device and drug costs: A Mirena coil costs the NHS about £90 last I checked whereas the US cost is nearly $1,000.

So in other words Americans are subsidizing the NHS. You’re welcome ☺️

That’s the other part of the equation that doesn’t ever seem to get discussed. All of those fancy new drugs that are developed by US drug companies… Get paid for by US health insurance companies>consumers but sold at a discount to other health care systems. I haven’t seen the NHS develop a life changing drug in awhile. Why is that?

knitnerd90 · 07/02/2023 00:21

This is related to what I do for work (so I really should not have made that typo about Medicaid! I shall blame autocorrect). The US system is a giant set of kludges. It's not something anyone would intentionally design, but it was set up piecemeal, and once a block is in place, it becomes very difficult to dislodge.

It is true that our relatively poor outcomes don't necessarily reflect the quality of care, though it's doubtful that obesity is as big a contributor, because obesity maps strongly onto other social determinants of health such as poverty and race; obesity itself may be causing a lot less than we think. The US invests relatively little into closing social gaps and that winds up on the back of the healthcare system. There's issues such as the "deaths of despair" amongst working class whites, especially men. We wind up with a system where some people get too much healthcare and others don't get enough. Here near a major city, the health care is world class. Not only does DC have several excellent hospitals, I'm an hour from Baltimore, which has two more, including Johns Hopkins which is one of the best in the world. Now go to the Mississippi Delta and it's like being in an entirely different country. The gaps in health insurance snowball: when a woman only gets proper medical care during and for a short period after pregnancy, chronic health conditions aren't properly treated. There's no real system for resource allocation other than the market. Because Medicare pays less than private insurance and Medicaid least of all, hospitals in poor areas (and often in rural areas) struggle to stay open. There is a crisis in rural healthcare that people in cities don't really hear about. A work friend of mine worked on the rez for IHS and her stories were heartbreaking.

In an ideal world, we would spend less than we do, but more than the UK does. Administration and insurance profits aren't as huge as some politicians would have you think. What drives up costs is that Americans pay far more for identical products and services and there is little to no cost control. It's good that nurses here are properly paid, but look at device and drug costs: A Mirena coil costs the NHS about £90 last I checked whereas the US cost is nearly $1,000.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/02/2023 00:14

nudnikit · 06/02/2023 23:11

This is also the interesting thing about the US. With medicaid, medicare, CHIP, the different state subsidies (expanded medicaid etc) , veterans' care and support to government hospitals, the public spending (as % of GDP) is about the same as the UK. So Americans pay about the same in taxes for health as they do in the UK. But then they have all the private spending on top (employer and out of pocket) which mean that they spend more than double but still have significant numbers uninsured and poorer health outcomes on many indicators - not to mention medical expenses being the number one cause of bankruptcy (which can happen even with insurance). The US health system is probably (as a system) the worst possible.

And yet we don’t have to spend our hospital stays in a 4-8 bed ward eating soggy sandwiches. or worse in a hallway. We can see any doctor we want in a reasonable timeframe. And our parents aren’t left for over 24 hours on the floor waiting for an ambulance after a fall.

Pssst…here’s the big secret in the US…most people are ok with what they spend for the services they receive.

Women see gynecologist yearly, their children see pediatricians as the norm, if I know I have a specialist need I call that specialist for an appointment. I don’t wait for a GP to tell me my problem is worthy. The poorest among us give birth in the same private rooms as the the well to do. My mom…on Medicare had a 24 hour 1 to 1 aide assigned to her in the hospital.

Oh and if I call for an ambulance, be it a stubbed toe or a heart attack. The response time is 4-6 minutes.

All of the above is an average experience of an American in our system.

The difference between the poor and those with insurance is how much is written off by the the providers… and yes I’d rather be bankrupt than in pain or dead.

If you’re enrolled in some of the medical assistance programs you may have a few more hoops to jump through. But they are out there.

nudnikit · 07/02/2023 00:09

Of course it's not fair to evaluate the US healthcare system on outcomes like life expectancy and infant mortality due to the impact of social and evironmental factors.

And things definitely got better under ACA

I'm not bashing American but, nonetheless, as a SYSTEM, the US healthcare system is the worst possible model. Tying healthcare to your employer is a terrible idea (it only happened due to caps on salaries in WW2 when there was a labour shortage and employers started to offer extra perks). Massive amounts of money are spent on administration (someone has to decide what's covered and what isn't and deal with all the back and forth). The system is terribly fragmented between different suppliers. Even with ACA there are still many who are not covered or who do not have sufficient coverage. And the pricing is insane with costs off the charts (especially prescription costs, even for things like insulin), it's not even like a marketplace where you can shop around for the best deal.

Mamanyt · 07/02/2023 00:04

Partyandbullshit · 06/02/2023 15:37

Off-topic: I've never understood how "bi-weekly" means every two weeks, but "bi-monthly" doesn't mean every two months, but twice a month. Grrrr.

On topic: people have raised entire families for generations off the income generated by working through the confusion of personal taxes, healthcare, pensions provisions etc in the US. The misinformation in this country is partly down to organic growth of various systems, and there's no impetus to clear up confusion because working through the confusion/working the confusion to your advantage is an entire industry. No wonder foreigners find it difficult to comprehend!

And, it seems, the more you make here in the USA, the less you pay in taxes. For a few years, I had about $2,000-$3,000 taxable income (Social Security is not normally taxed) annually. Not enough to have to file for. One year I did have to file in order to get a stimulus check (during the early part of the pandemic). My taxes were less than $200. I found, to my horror, that I paid MORE in taxes on my little income that year than then-"President" Trump paid.

MissConductUS · 06/02/2023 23:48

The quality and availability of medical care is not the only determinant of health outcomes. What drags the numbers down in the US is obesity and substance abuse.

Medical expenses were a much more common cause for bankruptcy before the ACA, which caps annual out-of-pocket expenses for insured patients.

www.healthcare.gov/glossary/out-of-pocket-maximum-limit/

In the last census, I recall 92% of the population had medical coverage, either private or public. The system is bonkers but does have some redeeming characteristics.

nudnikit · 06/02/2023 23:11

This is also the interesting thing about the US. With medicaid, medicare, CHIP, the different state subsidies (expanded medicaid etc) , veterans' care and support to government hospitals, the public spending (as % of GDP) is about the same as the UK. So Americans pay about the same in taxes for health as they do in the UK. But then they have all the private spending on top (employer and out of pocket) which mean that they spend more than double but still have significant numbers uninsured and poorer health outcomes on many indicators - not to mention medical expenses being the number one cause of bankruptcy (which can happen even with insurance). The US health system is probably (as a system) the worst possible.

MissConductUS · 06/02/2023 22:56

Americans often mix up the two programs because the names are so similar. And because Medicaid is administered by the states, some rebrand the programs. In California, for example, Medicaid is called Medi-Cal.

seniors.insurance.ca.gov/hc/medicare-and-medical.cfm

knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 22:34

EffortlessDesmond · 06/02/2023 22:15

Medicare doesn't cover maternity. Very few over 65s give birth.

It's possible if you're disabled, since disabled people are also on Medicare. But yes, for the 40%, I meant Medicaid.

nudnikit · 06/02/2023 22:34

@gwenneh It was a few years ago. Good they fixed it (finally) because it really was ridiculous to be in hospital and the onus was on you to check a doctor's network status even when ill and hospitalized.

SenecaFallsRedux · 06/02/2023 22:24

I spent some time in the emergency room with a family member this weekend. The No Surprises notices are very prominently posted.

EffortlessDesmond · 06/02/2023 22:15

Medicare doesn't cover maternity. Very few over 65s give birth.

gwenneh · 06/02/2023 22:11

Guess that's why the insurance denied my claim and i was on the hook for thousands of dollars.

That must have been prior to the No Surprises Act, which made that sort of situation illegal.

And I'm pretty sure the PP means Medicaid, not Medicare. In 2020 Medicaid covered 42% of US births.

knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 22:10

Yes, I meant Medicaid! I do know the difference and don't know why I typed that.

There's now a bill to prevent surprise out of network billing for emergency services. The doctor and insurance have to go sort it out and you're not liable. It doesn't take away half the hassle of dealing with insurance, but it does protect you in that particular case, as it should since you don't get much choice!

nudnikit · 06/02/2023 21:40

knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 21:21

I saw that and it was ridiculous! They picked a gourmet market in the most expensive part of Manhattan. Basically the most expensive eggs possible!

You do generally pay some of the cost for birth as with everything (though 40% of US births are on Medicare). It all depends on your health insurance. It is wrong that your employer has such a big role in deciding whether you get good insurance or not, but $30K is not what people pay, and for child birth specifically a lot of the gaps have been closed.

People do sometimes make short sighted budgeting decisions with health insurance, though. Especially younger, healthier people: they decide to have a lower premium now but don't budget to pay the deductible because they think they won't need it. Many employers, especially larger ones, offer a choice of plans. After the ACA passed there were some people screaming about how they didn't want to buy insurance at all. I doubt they would have wanted to be left bleeding to death in an emergency, though.

Medicare is for the elderly so unlikely that there are births being covered by it!
www.medicare.gov/what-medicare-covers/your-medicare-coverage-choices/whats-medicare

nudnikit · 06/02/2023 21:35

mathanxiety · 06/02/2023 16:02

Rent varies enormously even within the same zip code.

You can eat very well in the US without breaking the bank. Cooking ability makes a difference.

If you don't want to live in a place where there is reliable public transport, then you have to take practicalities into account. Yes, this means running cars in far flung suburbs, which is what people living in rural areas of the UK have to do too.

It doesn't take a lot of effort to locate a doctor who takes your insurance, and to have this sort of info to hand in case of emergency.

Low paid workers provide essential services in the UK. Hence the current strikes.

Rents everyhwere vary enormously. My experience living in both suburban east coast adn NYC is that like for like it's more expensive in the US. You also don't need to be far flung to require a car, you just need to be out of the city centre. When we lived in the suburbs we lived in a town which was in between two major cities, an hour to each .Apart from a train to these cities you needed a car (including to drive to the train station). The UK has much better public transport provision, no one could possibly argue with that - even just for the fact that the urban geography is vastly different. In fact there are few cities in the US with the exception perhaps of the main east coast ones where you can manage without a car. Good luck in Houston or Los Angeles. They are built for cars par excellence.

Interesting about the in an out of network doctors Glad you've told me how easy it should have been @mathanxiety . When I was in the ER ,writhing in pain with suspected appendicitis (aka emergency), I needed to check with which insurance the doctor was in network and then insisted they find me a new doctor when she was out of network. Shame I didn't realise then how easy it was meant to have been. Guess that's why the insurance denied my claim and i was on the hook for thousands of dollars.

If I had to be a low paid worker, I would a million times choose the UK over the US. The fact that workers don't strike in the US is more telling about how they've managed to destroy the unions and organized labour for these workers than anything to do with a higher standard of living.

I am talking from my own experience of having lived the better part of a decade in the US as well as in the UK. The US is a big place and others may have had different experiences.

EffortlessDesmond · 06/02/2023 21:27

I think it would be sensible to time-limit claims for unemployment in the UK too. Six months? Eight? Except for real disability issues. Can you drive? Do deliveries. Otherwise, learn a new skill, and no I don't mean macrame!

knitnerd90 · 06/02/2023 21:21

Girasoli · 06/02/2023 18:09

Sorry I was misremembering where I read about the $18 eggs, it was this Guardian article:

amp.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jan/25/18-a-dozen-how-did-americas-eggs-get-absurdly-expensive

The homesteaders must have been complaining another food was really expensive!

I saw that and it was ridiculous! They picked a gourmet market in the most expensive part of Manhattan. Basically the most expensive eggs possible!

You do generally pay some of the cost for birth as with everything (though 40% of US births are on Medicare). It all depends on your health insurance. It is wrong that your employer has such a big role in deciding whether you get good insurance or not, but $30K is not what people pay, and for child birth specifically a lot of the gaps have been closed.

People do sometimes make short sighted budgeting decisions with health insurance, though. Especially younger, healthier people: they decide to have a lower premium now but don't budget to pay the deductible because they think they won't need it. Many employers, especially larger ones, offer a choice of plans. After the ACA passed there were some people screaming about how they didn't want to buy insurance at all. I doubt they would have wanted to be left bleeding to death in an emergency, though.

nonheme · 06/02/2023 20:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

AliceOlive · 06/02/2023 19:30

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/02/2023 18:29

So far we’ve mythbusted

  • the $30K baby price tag
  • the $18 eggs
  • the no taxes being deducted
  • the no housing assistance
  • the no unemployment assistance
  • the pay period variation
  • the no paid vacation

What else was there?

That people don't care about one another. Today my 90+ year old neighbor brought over eggs to share with me, since the prices in the local store are high. She found some for $6.50 for 2 dozen so we split them. Wouldn't hear of me coming over to pick them up myself. A few days ago I took lasagna and oranges to another neighbor and left with a package of blueberries.

When we moved in, someone threw actually threw us a "get to know the neighbors" party and people brought all kinds of cards and presents to my house for weeks. Bread & Honey, Fresh Flowers, Vegetable, etc. This is the norm for us.

Citygirlrurallife · 06/02/2023 18:38

In fairness it does actually cost minimum $30K to have a baby but insurance usually covers that. Everyone I know who has had a straight forward hospital birth + epidural has had to pay out about $2-4K