Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I missing something about US salaries here?

288 replies

Krayvon2 · 05/02/2023 18:27

I work in the UK, colleague works in the US for the same company.

We do a very similar job - Colleague earns around $158k per year. My salary is in £ and still a very good one but considerably less if you look at the exchange rate (probably half of US salary). However, this is a common trend with US vs UK employees in our company due to job market differences, experience etc (the sector we work in commands more of a premium over there).

With my UK salary I still manage to save a decent amount each month and pay all bills and mortgage etc.

Talking to US colleague about how in the UK we get paid on one set day every month (over there salary is paid in two installments each month) and they asked me how on earth I managed to make the money last all month.

They seemed to find it hard to believe it was possible to make a salary last 30 days and implied they struggled to make what they earn last over a couple of weeks! They've also made comments in the past about struggling with a surprise bill or having to put off a purchase.

I know lifestyles are more expensive over there but they spoke as if they earned peanuts so I'm wondering if I'm wrong to think that's a good salary? They get health cover through the company too so that's not an issue. Is there some other tax or something that I'm missing here? They are East Coast but not in most expensive area (not New York or Boston)

OP posts:
MintyFreshOne · 07/02/2023 05:37

And I have to reiterate, I don’t understand why it should be surprising that American salaries are higher, or why British people don’t want to believe it’s true! Sounds like a lot of cope here tbh

The American economy has been the most productive economy for decades now, and the living standards and wages reflect that

MintyFreshOne · 07/02/2023 05:29

IIRC the dems have tried to pass legislation which has been blocked by the reps

The Dems had both chambers for the last two years but did fuck all to fix it because they simply don’t care to.

tbh medical care is fine for the majority of people, I think people fear changing it will make it even worse.

The actual service is amazing compared to anything I’ve experienced elsewhere, hardly anyone in the US would accept NHS style treatment tbh. But there are definitely other systems worth studying and emulating for sure.

nudnikit · 07/02/2023 04:48

@mathanxiety
With all due respect, I think you have some serious rose-tinted glasses on the impact of medical bills on people's lives because your experienes have been positive.
The system as it is is ruining people's lives. As a system, it is possibly the worst possible one out there on nearly every metric on which these systems are evaluated (particularly on equity and efficiency) and the fact is that no other country has emulated the US model because it is a failing one. Of course, I know it works for a lot of people. I know that ACA, expanded medicaid, CHIP and other provisions help but they are plasters on a gushing wound. The core of the problem is the way the system itself is set up.

mathanxiety · 07/02/2023 04:40

@nudnikit

'Asking or begging for charity' consists of filling out a form online, or printing it out and handing it in at the hospital office. I've accompanied a neighbour who was hard of hearing and helped her do this on behalf of an adult family member. It wasn't complicated or in any way embarrassing.

I have personally entered into payment agreements with a dentist when exH neglected to tell me he had dropped dental insurance for the DCs and one of them broke a tooth. This is possible with hospitals too.

I'm not disputing your contention that medical bills are the leading cause of bankruptcy in the US. However, bankruptcy in the US doesn't have the same effects as it has in the UK. Lots of people come out the other end of chapter 11 and move on with their lives.

nudnikit · 07/02/2023 04:33

@mathanxiety
Read these experiences of Americans and tell me that medical debt and bankruptcy is not a major problem and that the hospitals and providers are so charitable
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/01/11/upshot/12up-medicaldebt.html

nudnikit · 07/02/2023 04:19

@knitnerd90
the US also puts relatively little into public health. It's not profitable after all and has to come from gvoernment mainly. Together with the high level of inequality, it's little surpise health outcomes are so poor in the US. The awful health care system (and i mean this as a system - I know individual care can be excellent if you can afford it) is just the icing on the cake

nudnikit · 07/02/2023 04:16

mathanxiety · 07/02/2023 02:10

@nudnikit

I've had a good few different health insurance policies over the course of 30+ years. One of the first things I've done is check what hospitals are in network, and tbh, my experience of taking DCs to emergency rooms is that the ER receptionist has taken my insurance card and verified acceptance before any medical assessment is started.

The No Surprises Act has eliminated the need to wait until you're home from a vacation, etc, before seeking medical help.

Your hostpital may be in network but your provider might not be. I never had a ER receptionist decide which doctors would be providing service or checking who is in which network. But hopefully this has changed with the new legislation. Thankfully I didn't have a mjaor medical issues when I lived in the US, I shudder to think of dealing with all the bills if I did.

nudnikit · 07/02/2023 04:11

Yes, you can ask and beg for charity. But if they know you have assets, you can bet your life that they are coming to come after you. That's why medical expenses are the number one cause of bankruptcy in the US. It's a disgrace.

nudnikit · 07/02/2023 04:10

The US isn't subsidizing the NHS with meds, at least not intentionally. Any normal healthcare system as in most developed countries has purchasing power and can negotiate prices down. The US can't do that because it's too fragmented so the pharma companies can make all their profits off their backs and there's no regulation to prevent it - even insulin is ridiculously expensive. They do it because they can and the US system does nothing to protect the patients, even for life saving drugs. IIRC the dems have tried to pass legislation which has been blocked by the reps.

nudnikit · 07/02/2023 04:05

My experience, living in a US suburb, was totally different to yours clearly. I found public transport woefully lacking. And I was in between two major metropolitan areas, just an hour from each, most certainly not rural or far flung.

mathanxiety · 07/02/2023 04:03

YY, @saltinesandcoffeecups

And patients can also apply to the hospital financial assistance office if a bill is going to cause financial hardship or isn't affordable at all.

nudnikit · 07/02/2023 04:00

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/02/2023 02:42

There is a big sign in every ER in the country that says all patients will be treated and stabilized regardless of ability to pay. If you don’t have insurance a social worker will come to you to help you apply for assistance if applicable otherwise you will receive a bill and can work out payment arrangements with the business office. No one is turned away for emergency care.

Yes, I know that but has nothing to do with what I wrote.

Of course you'll be treated in the ER but that doesn't mean it's free. You WILL be chased to pay the ER bills if you don't have insurance. You MIGHT be able to negotiate them down but that's up to the hospital and providers (don't forget you don't JUST get a bill from the hospital). Worst case, you'll have huge medical debt and end up in bankruptcy as a result including losing your own house.

Also note that stabilized does not mean treated. You can still be very ill but you won't be treated if you're stable (and can't pay).

onlylarkin · 07/02/2023 03:47

@saltinesandcoffeecups that is a great example. Thanks for sharing that.

SmilesThroughGrittedTeeth · 07/02/2023 03:29

The days off I mentioned above are all paid.

SmilesThroughGrittedTeeth · 07/02/2023 03:08

MissConductUS · 06/02/2023 15:54

I get ten paid holidays and five weeks of annual leave. Perhaps that's "very little" by UK standards.

The amount of leave you get is tied to your job level and is negotiable.

I'm in the US and I get 6 weeks vacation a year, 10 sick days, my birthday off, 14 holidays and what we call 4 recharge days. I can also take off 4 days a year to volunteer.

I have been with the same company for 25 years. I work in the software industry.

My husband is in the manufacturing industry. He has been with the same company for 5 years and gets 3 weeks vacation a year along with 10 holidays.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/02/2023 02:50

onlylarkin · 07/02/2023 01:56

Fire and rescue, and police, are paid through property taxes. I have never heard of a subscription service for these and have lived in 5 different states in all areas of the country. Though maybe it does happen in very rural areas.

My mom lives in small town that has a volunteer fire department. Still funded through property taxes (they usually have 1 paid employee plus the cost of keeping the equipment). Though they do bill you for mileage if they have to drive you into the next biggest city.

On another note, it is helpful to remember when talking about medical costs in the US, the Health and Pharmaceutical industries are the #1 contributors (higher even then the NRA) to campaign finance and their lobbyists are very successful. Both Democrats and Republicans take campaign donations. That is why our healthcare system is the way it is. But guess who has to change it? The very people who benefit from it.

Here is an example… Guthrie OK, population 10K. (Located in the middle of OK…and found through a quick google search)

It is really not common and the vast majority of people in the US are covered by fire departments paid for by local property taxes, even if staffed by volunteers.

www.cityofguthrie.com/261/Rural-Fire-Subscription-Program

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/02/2023 02:42

mathanxiety · 07/02/2023 02:10

@nudnikit

I've had a good few different health insurance policies over the course of 30+ years. One of the first things I've done is check what hospitals are in network, and tbh, my experience of taking DCs to emergency rooms is that the ER receptionist has taken my insurance card and verified acceptance before any medical assessment is started.

The No Surprises Act has eliminated the need to wait until you're home from a vacation, etc, before seeking medical help.

There is a big sign in every ER in the country that says all patients will be treated and stabilized regardless of ability to pay. If you don’t have insurance a social worker will come to you to help you apply for assistance if applicable otherwise you will receive a bill and can work out payment arrangements with the business office. No one is turned away for emergency care.

mathanxiety · 07/02/2023 02:10

@nudnikit

I've had a good few different health insurance policies over the course of 30+ years. One of the first things I've done is check what hospitals are in network, and tbh, my experience of taking DCs to emergency rooms is that the ER receptionist has taken my insurance card and verified acceptance before any medical assessment is started.

The No Surprises Act has eliminated the need to wait until you're home from a vacation, etc, before seeking medical help.

mathanxiety · 07/02/2023 01:57

You also don't need to be far flung to require a car, you just need to be out of the city centre

That's not true at all.

Most larger metropolitan areas have decent public transport networks. Suburbs that were developed before WW2 - a huge number of communities, which are home to millions - enjoy the benefit of the networks that were built before the car culture of the 50s and 60s.

If you move to a smaller city, your options may be limited. Similarly, moving to a rural or semi rural area will limit your public transport options in the UK.

onlylarkin · 07/02/2023 01:56

Fire and rescue, and police, are paid through property taxes. I have never heard of a subscription service for these and have lived in 5 different states in all areas of the country. Though maybe it does happen in very rural areas.

My mom lives in small town that has a volunteer fire department. Still funded through property taxes (they usually have 1 paid employee plus the cost of keeping the equipment). Though they do bill you for mileage if they have to drive you into the next biggest city.

On another note, it is helpful to remember when talking about medical costs in the US, the Health and Pharmaceutical industries are the #1 contributors (higher even then the NRA) to campaign finance and their lobbyists are very successful. Both Democrats and Republicans take campaign donations. That is why our healthcare system is the way it is. But guess who has to change it? The very people who benefit from it.

onlylarkin · 07/02/2023 01:46

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/02/2023 00:37

It's good that nurses here are properly paid, but look at device and drug costs: A Mirena coil costs the NHS about £90 last I checked whereas the US cost is nearly $1,000.

So in other words Americans are subsidizing the NHS. You’re welcome ☺️

That’s the other part of the equation that doesn’t ever seem to get discussed. All of those fancy new drugs that are developed by US drug companies… Get paid for by US health insurance companies>consumers but sold at a discount to other health care systems. I haven’t seen the NHS develop a life changing drug in awhile. Why is that?

This and @knitnerd90 are both correct.

We pay the highest prescription costs in any country, I think. I am no expert. But all these US companies are doing all the research and then charging us high prices, while we get to watch other countries pay much less for the same drugs. Plus, the US Government may have helped with funding those projects through research grants and tax breaks.

So basically, we are paying for the research and then paying again to use it.

My family is lucky as we have excellent healthcare because it is a global company not based in the US, but has offices in nearly every large city, our health insurance costs are fairly low.

I can be seen same day in many cases for acute illnesses and surgery schedule happens within a month. I can see a specialist without a referral for anything. Our insurance pays for mental health treatment (ACA law iirc) the same as medical appointments. $25 or $40 co-pay to see a therapist or Psychologist.

Canadian's come across the border all the time for quicker healthcare.

I think the idea of the NHS is good, but I prefer our system. Best would be to somehow figure out the mix of the two. I cant not imagine calling an ambulance and having to wait 24 hours.

Also, I have a relative on Medicaid who has an autoimmune disorder and gets the same treatment I do with the same doctors. She pay 0 for her Medicaid and 0 for any visits, including the infusions she needs.

knitnerd90 · 07/02/2023 01:17

It happens but it's extremely rare. My county doesn't charge residents for ambulances either. There are some parts of the US that are extremely rural and have almost no public services.

the data suggests that in most cases the US isn't subsidising the NHS. It's just pure profit. See, for example, how insulin prices have risen since 2006 despite the product not changing.

pharmaceutical companies are international, not just American (eg GSK is British, Novartis is Swiss, etc). The NHS doesn't really develop its own drugs, though research is certainly done at NHS hospitals and facilities. American pharmaceutical companies do benefit from the government sponsored research at the NIH and universities. This is why Boston is such a biotech hub.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/02/2023 01:14

To add the taxpayers of those rural cities could vote to fund a fire department through taxes, but choose not to. So they pay the fee as a subscription or gamble they won’t need the service. Really their choice all around at the end of of the day.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/02/2023 01:08

It really does happen but think ass end of Montana or North Dakota. Not NYC or Cleveland suburb

2013isback · 07/02/2023 01:01

LemonSwan · 07/02/2023 00:47

Well just googling now and in big cities it seems not. But I swear I remember watching something where the neighbours hadn’t paid their subscription and their house was on fire but the fire service turned up to wait for the fire to jump to the next house who had paid so they could put those specific flames only out. Mind boggling.

Mind-boggling indeed. It's completely obvious that this makes no sense and did not happen.