Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I missing something about US salaries here?

288 replies

Krayvon2 · 05/02/2023 18:27

I work in the UK, colleague works in the US for the same company.

We do a very similar job - Colleague earns around $158k per year. My salary is in £ and still a very good one but considerably less if you look at the exchange rate (probably half of US salary). However, this is a common trend with US vs UK employees in our company due to job market differences, experience etc (the sector we work in commands more of a premium over there).

With my UK salary I still manage to save a decent amount each month and pay all bills and mortgage etc.

Talking to US colleague about how in the UK we get paid on one set day every month (over there salary is paid in two installments each month) and they asked me how on earth I managed to make the money last all month.

They seemed to find it hard to believe it was possible to make a salary last 30 days and implied they struggled to make what they earn last over a couple of weeks! They've also made comments in the past about struggling with a surprise bill or having to put off a purchase.

I know lifestyles are more expensive over there but they spoke as if they earned peanuts so I'm wondering if I'm wrong to think that's a good salary? They get health cover through the company too so that's not an issue. Is there some other tax or something that I'm missing here? They are East Coast but not in most expensive area (not New York or Boston)

OP posts:
onlylarkin · 10/02/2023 18:02

I love being able to see my records. Had a mammo last month and they sent me the images. I cant make heads or tails of it obviously, but I am a nerd when it comes to seeing those things.

I had surgery on my wrist once and was just under twilight sleep. I asked the doctor to show me the incision because I wanted to see how it all works. 😆

SenecaFallsRedux · 10/02/2023 15:01

I have access to all my medical records.

Same here. And I get an email alert every time something is added to the record.

Liorae · 10/02/2023 14:24

MissConductUS · 10/02/2023 14:02

That was probably true 20 years ago, but not now. The ACA funded the creation of regional health data exchanges. Any hospital my family or I might go to has electronic access to our medical records.

www.nyehealth.org/

In addition, I have access to all my medical records. If I get a mammogram in the morning, the result is online by the afternoon. I know when I had my last gyn exam. It's all at my fingertips. I can schedule any kind of medical appointment through the same app.

MissConductUS · 10/02/2023 14:02

Liorae · 09/02/2023 23:43

It's like that where I live too.

That was probably true 20 years ago, but not now. The ACA funded the creation of regional health data exchanges. Any hospital my family or I might go to has electronic access to our medical records.

www.nyehealth.org/

Liorae · 09/02/2023 23:43

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 09/02/2023 21:59

When my child was struggling with a chronic illness and we had to call an ambulance and ended up in A&E we were seen immediately with the ambulance sending DC's number ahead to hospital so their file had already been reviewed by the time we had got there and a doctor was ready and waiting to treat on arrival without us having to explain the illness. Amazing service and this with an NHS style model. This would NEVER happen in the US, healthcare is very fragmented (another issue)!!

That's actually also how it happens where I live in the US. We arrive at Maine Med or one of the other hospitals in Maine that are part of MaineHealth, they open up MyChart, they see our records. MaineHealth treats 1.1 million of Maine's 1.3 million residents BTW.

It's like that where I live too.

mathanxiety · 09/02/2023 22:52

@drspouse

How would the doctor have known the seizure wasn't caused by a brain injury without the CT scan?

It's possible to have epilepsy and also sustain a brain injury from some other cause.

onlylarkin · 09/02/2023 22:23

Any medical system under the hospital system can "talk" to each other. Need an Xray? Go get it and the doctor can pull it up from his office. Need a mammogram? Need to go-to the ER? Doc can see any medical records from within that system.

The problem arises when the hospital systems don't talk to each other.

As for expenses in the US, my car payment is $800 a month, mortgage is $1900. We are comfortable. Have retirement and savings. That is with 25 years experience and multiple moves around the country early on. But I recognize that not everyone has the same opportunities we have. I live in a high cost of living area.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 09/02/2023 22:05

MissConductUS · 06/02/2023 22:56

Americans often mix up the two programs because the names are so similar. And because Medicaid is administered by the states, some rebrand the programs. In California, for example, Medicaid is called Medi-Cal.

seniors.insurance.ca.gov/hc/medicare-and-medical.cfm

Yes, when I first arrived I was very confused by the fact that Maine brands both Medicare and Medicaid as Mainecare.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 09/02/2023 21:59

When my child was struggling with a chronic illness and we had to call an ambulance and ended up in A&E we were seen immediately with the ambulance sending DC's number ahead to hospital so their file had already been reviewed by the time we had got there and a doctor was ready and waiting to treat on arrival without us having to explain the illness. Amazing service and this with an NHS style model. This would NEVER happen in the US, healthcare is very fragmented (another issue)!!

That's actually also how it happens where I live in the US. We arrive at Maine Med or one of the other hospitals in Maine that are part of MaineHealth, they open up MyChart, they see our records. MaineHealth treats 1.1 million of Maine's 1.3 million residents BTW.

MissConductUS · 09/02/2023 14:02

Posts about the US just descend into a shit show in MN.

You said it, sister.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 08/02/2023 23:08

Krayvon2 · 05/02/2023 19:23

Thanks all for your responses. I mistakenly assumed 6 figure salaries were big money (as they often are in UK) but I guess its all relative. I also assumed taxes were less/ lower over there as there's no state healthcare etc but seem to be wrong on that too. I'm quite surprised at how much more expensive thjngs can be too - think I always thought they were cheaper in US. Basically all my ideas about US living seem to be wildly off or out of date!

So @Krayvon2 did you get your answer? Lol

Posts about the US just descend into a shit show in MN.

knitnerd90 · 08/02/2023 20:23

This is the standard "but it's all about the Benjamins!" argument, and it's rarely that simple--in this case, the neurologists themselves don't make money from extra scans. (Radiology does.)

It's more complicated than that. When technology is available to use, there's a tendency to use it, for good or bad. (Bad would be overuse of DaVinci robotic surgery, but that's another essay.) Once you have paid for the CT scanner and the technician, the cost of each scan actually drops, because those costs are fixed.

I don't have current stats on availability of CT scans on the NHS, but in the 2000s, which is when that AAN recommendation came out (2007, to be precise) not all NHS hospitals had CT available at all times. The American system, again in both good and bad ways, effectively encourages hospitals to invest in expensive technology to "compete" with other facilities. So what often happens is that a hospital has whatever new tech is available and the staff responds to that availability and uses it more.

You can calculate how many scans you need to do to find a problem (aka Number Needed To Treat, or NNT) and work out, financially, the cost per problem found and decide if it's "worth it"; this is what NICE does when it develops guidelines. American medical groups tend to downplay cost over safety when they develop guidelines. This doesn't mean they are directly profiting from it, or even that they're helping colleagues profit. They downplay resource scarcity in ways that other systems do not. They are trained to assume that CT scans are easily available and not in need of rationing or prioritizing. It's also partly a response to the medico-legal climate and the fear of the risk, or perceived risk, of being sued. You will be sued for not doing a CT. You won't be sued for doing one, especially if the procedure was in line with accepted practice. You can argue that this leads to unnecessary scans, and sometimes it does, but there's a great deal of grey area and it's not always clear cut. At some point, the question is going to be risk tolerance and that cannot be perfectly quantified.

Now, there is also a lot of interesting research on how clinicians respond to the availability of new and more expensive technology and subconscious bias, but most of it isn't direct. This is yet another reason cost control needs to be top down and coordinated.

AliceOlive · 08/02/2023 20:01

drspouse · 08/02/2023 19:13

Funny how the AAN recommends something expensive that isn't used in the UK.

Your comment can be taken at least two ways.

Is it “funny” to you that a standard tool for assessment in the US is not available in UK?

Or do you believe that because of the expense and it’s lack of availability in the UK that it’s not a valid tool?

drspouse · 08/02/2023 19:13

knitnerd90 · 08/02/2023 08:26

It's not necessary for epilepsy, but what they're looking for is to see if the seizure was caused by brain injury. It is the recommendation of the American Academy of Neurology, so an ER doctor who insists on a CT is practicing within the accepted standard of care.

Funny how the AAN recommends something expensive that isn't used in the UK.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 08/02/2023 17:03

@MissConductUS I saw a journalism assistant role advertised at $65k over there last week.

Assistants in the UK for journalism are paid between £19k and £25k Blush

MissConductUS · 08/02/2023 16:50

IDontWantToBeAPie · 08/02/2023 16:46

Food costs a lot more over there tbf as does healthcare.

But yes generally they're paid a bomb more than us over here

Nursing salaries are at least double here vs the UK. A good hospital nurse here with five years of experience will make $100k per year with no problem and with great benefits.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 08/02/2023 16:46

Food costs a lot more over there tbf as does healthcare.

But yes generally they're paid a bomb more than us over here

AliceOlive · 08/02/2023 16:44

SenecaFallsRedux · 08/02/2023 15:21

I think any supporters of the US healthcare system are more ideologically driven than any evidence-based analysis.

Like so much else in the US, I think that support is not so much ideologically driven as vested-interest (at many different points in the "system") driven. I despair that we will ever achieve anything close to health equity in this country.

I don't think we will - because so much of health comes down to genetics, family culture and socio-economic levels.

If being ideologically driven means I don't believe we should sacrifice excellent healthcare for most in order to achieve equal but subpar, government-controlled care for all, count me in. I have 0% faith in any government, particularly the current US government doing anything well, fairly or efficiently.

In the US people also frequently use the words health, healthcare and health insurance interchangeably. These are not even remotely the same concepts.

SenecaFallsRedux · 08/02/2023 15:21

I think any supporters of the US healthcare system are more ideologically driven than any evidence-based analysis.

Like so much else in the US, I think that support is not so much ideologically driven as vested-interest (at many different points in the "system") driven. I despair that we will ever achieve anything close to health equity in this country.

Caterina99 · 08/02/2023 09:03

Our healthcare experience in the US was excellent. We had good insurance and lived in a suburban area just outside a major city, so there everything you could possibly need and lots of choice of providers

I could ring my gp, ob, pediatrician, dermatologist, kids neurologist etc and have an appointment usually at a convenient time for me in their lovely office. or go to the walk in center when my DC got stitches. Prescriptions were quick, 24 hour pharmacy open near me! We were happy to pay because the service was great and we had the salary to match.

BUT the stories of people with no/wrong type of insurance! It was just heartbreaking. ACA has helped that a lot, but still people would refuse ambulances, only go to certain hospitals, not go to the doctor or get their prescriptions because they can’t afford them! Medicare kicks in at 65 so many people cannot afford to retire before then as they can’t self fund insurance.

Agreed, the best system is probably a mix where those that can, pay something for healthcare, but we don’t end up with the huge US style inequality.

nudnikit · 08/02/2023 08:46

knitnerd90 · 08/02/2023 07:19

Yes, my master's degree is in a related area. None of the experts in my program thought the US has a good system. They don't agree on precisely what the "best" system is as different models have different strong points (so it also becomes a question of values and priorities) but I've yet to meet one who says the US is good, as a system.

you'll find some economists who love the free market but not one of them can point to a working example on any kind of scale. The free marketeers also love the consumer directed model but as we can see, shoving increasing costs onto consumers in the form of cost shares doesn't actually slow spending and patients don't actually have the information (and frequently not the time) to make cost directed decisions the way they envision. The most successful cost controls come from the top down.

Exactly. I think any supporters of the US healthcare system are more ideologically driven than any evidence-based analysis.
I recognise that there are excellent treatmeants and interventions in the US and if I had a rare serious disease (and good insurance) I would rather be there than most other places but, at the end of the day, far far more people would benefit from, say, good diabetes care which is much less lucrative and more common among poorer people. If I were a low income diabetic, I would rather be in any developed country than the US for healthcare.

knitnerd90 · 08/02/2023 08:26

drspouse · 08/02/2023 07:26

@MissConductUS A CT is neither necessary nor standard to diagnose epilepsy. DS now has a diagnosis and I know of no child in the UK with his diagnosis who had a CT following a toddler seizure. An EEG is diagnostic.

It's not necessary for epilepsy, but what they're looking for is to see if the seizure was caused by brain injury. It is the recommendation of the American Academy of Neurology, so an ER doctor who insists on a CT is practicing within the accepted standard of care.

drspouse · 08/02/2023 07:30

@onlylarkin that's why we have global antibiotic resistance.

drspouse · 08/02/2023 07:26

@MissConductUS A CT is neither necessary nor standard to diagnose epilepsy. DS now has a diagnosis and I know of no child in the UK with his diagnosis who had a CT following a toddler seizure. An EEG is diagnostic.