Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my child the complete truth

205 replies

Pineapple2023 · 05/02/2023 18:09

People look at me gone out when I say this as if I've just killed their granny but I don't tell lies to my children. They're not taught about santa, Easter bunny etc, we still celebrate but there is no white lies involved.

I believe in monkey see monkey do so if I tell my kids not to lie to me but then in effect lie to them no matter how small would this not make me a hypocrit ?

Anyway , my older children have always been taught the reason they don't see their father often is because he's poorly , the older they're getting the more we are making them aware of their dads mental health condition.(they have a great relationship with his extended family as do i)

With that being said my youngest child has an absolute arsehole of a dad... hasn't seen them for over a year (baring in mind he lived on the same road) and would walk past them in the street.my child's getting to an age where they are going to begin to ask questions.

IMO I shouldn't blinker my child from the truth and suger coat how much of a twat their dad is.obviously I'm not going to tell a 3 year old their dad's a twat but I certainly won't be giving it the old , your daddy just wasn't ready for fatherhood when infact he's got 3 older children he sees and is a good 10years older than I am.the baby was planned and now he even denies that he's even the dad !! ...

My mum thinks I'm wrong and alot of things I've seen on the Internet tell you not to speak bad of the child's other parent but I'm left here thinking , well why ? Why shouldn't they know the truth , their 'dad' is a waste of space down an out, I'm not trying to poison their mind , I wasn't cheated on , I couldn't care less if he had a orgy filmed it and posted it all over social media, but the way he's treat my child is disgusting so why should I suger coat it !!

OP posts:
StarsSand · 06/02/2023 08:45

Honestly I think giving children adult information that they can't do anything productive with is really harmful.

You can give him an age appropriate answer that isn't a lie. And then expand on it as he grows up and is ready to hear more.

'Some families don't have a Dad that spends time with them'

Later:

'In many ways it would be great to have a Dad around but we found that things were very hard with your Dad and decided it was better for you to not see him often.'

Later again:

'You deserve a fantastic dad and it's really sad that your Dad hasn't been that for you. You have a lot of other people who love you, and you are loving in return. All families are different and have their challenges'

Later again

'Your dad hasn't been a good dad. He has a lot of good qualities and he wanted you very much. But He's not good at loving people well and it's been disappointing for all of us. I know that's hard on you. You deserve better. I know you'll be a wonderful dad some day. Do you have any questions about your dad?'

ChampagneLassie · 06/02/2023 08:43

Because that child is 50% their father and they will feel worthless, rejected and potentially unloved if you tell them they way you feel that jumps out from what you write. Read "the book you wish your parents read" for some more discussions around this sort of thing

lowclouds · 06/02/2023 08:42

I don't think this is just about wanting to be honest with your child. It does honestly sound like there are punitive/vengeful motivations on your part.

@rubberduckiee Yes.

You need to think long and hard about your motivations. If there is even an ounce of 'getting back at him' or 'punishing him' then don't do it (and I also strongly feel that there is from your posts).

This cannot be about your needs for revenge, your resentment for the way he treated you. Not even a tiny bit.

Your children's feelings are fragile and they will be more easily broken than you know.

lowclouds · 06/02/2023 08:37

It depends what you mean by telling your child 'the truth'.

'His behaviour is disgusting' - although many would agree - is actually an opinion.

I would not recommend saying anything about your opinion of their dad. This is projecting your own feelings. Your child will make up their own mind when they are older.

You don't have to give them false hope, but you also don't have to be actively cruel by projecting your own.

CPL593H · 06/02/2023 08:16

From the other side, as it's sort of relevant I think, about small children and memory.

I was 3/4 (certainly under 5) when my mother told me that my stepfather wasn't my birth father. Getting on for 60 years later I can remember exactly where we were and that it was a sunny day. Mum wasn't always the most emotionally stable/aware but she got it across in a way that I accepted and understood and although I remember thinking I'd been told something important, I wasn't upset. Probably just as well she did too as I can remember flashes of Mum and Dad (he adopted me) at their wedding when I was 2.5 and would have worked out something from that eventually.

My birth father was a git of the first order and I obviously found out much more over the years, but I'm grateful that I was told what I was in an age appropriate way. My advice OP would be to be calm, objective, keep any feelings you have towards this man out of it and concentrate on telling your child that they are loved and much wanted by you. You don't need to make up stories about some fantasy Wonderdad but you should be mindful that your child is more important than your hurt, angry feelings and "need" for truth to be told.

Nutmegger · 06/02/2023 07:53

Thats your child's flesh and blood you're talking about. If you tell your dc that his dad is horrible then the kid will inevitably internalise it and tell himself that he comes from badness or there is a bad part to him

dogdaydown · 06/02/2023 07:50

rubberduckiee · 06/02/2023 07:08

@dogdaydown not referring to OP's older kids, but the second father's own kids

Sorry I misunderstood

LanaCara · 06/02/2023 07:41

There's a time and a place and aged 3 is not it.

Also, YABU not letting them have the fun and excitement of Santa....there's telling lies and then there's just being OTT.

BigMandysBookClub · 06/02/2023 07:41

I think it is better to be honest in an age appropriate way. I have been honest when my son has asked question about what's on TV (political stuff, cost of living). I have told him that much of the time you can't just be a footballer, millionaire or any other well paid job, as you have decreasing social mobility to deal with in the UK, so it is harder for a family like ours and he will have to work harder. I think personal relationships are harder to navigate and you need to be extra sensitive. Something like 'some fathers aren't very good at being a parent as they haven't grown up yet themselves, so they might not be around much'. Don't lie, but don't let your own feelings come across. They have to come to their conclusions themselves.

PaperFun · 06/02/2023 07:39

@Pineapple2023 OP will you teach your child to tell the truth when they receive a gift they don’t like? Or will you tell them to lie and say they like it and are happy with the gift?

Are you grateful for presents you dislike? Or are you one of those ‘I tell it like it is’ sorts?

Intrepidescape · 06/02/2023 07:38

Why are you having children with these men? I think you should speak to a therapist to discuss your issues. What will you tell your children when they ask why you had children with men not fit to be a father?

FancyFanny · 06/02/2023 07:35

Where back in reality, the truth hurts! Every one of us tells small lies and untruths on a daily basis. Without them, we would find it very difficult to negotiate our social and professional lives successfully.

I have a friend who finds lying difficult and seems to pride herself on her ability to speak the truth and not lie. But really, she has a hard time socially and is probably on the autistic spectrum- often offending people and not seeing when the truth would best be spared.

The ability to lie successfully is actually an important developmental milestone in children and although parents find their child's lies difficult to deal with and upset by them, it's not something we should really be punishing them for.

FancyFanny · 06/02/2023 07:27

Yes, lying to children about the Easter Bunny is the root of all evil and those parents that lie to their children definitely bring up children that become pathological liars themselves!

Hobbesmanc · 06/02/2023 07:25

My mum always told us our father was not a nice man and that's why we didn't see him or get cards and presents etc. He was an abusive husband and I'm sure would have been an abusive dad

I met him once after she died and she was right. He is a twat.

WonderingWanda · 06/02/2023 07:17

I think a simple 'He chose not to be involved' would do if and when they ask. I would follow that up with lots of love and comments about how amazing you think they are. I think you need to be careful not to rob your children of a happy foundation with all your truth speaking. Kids are forming their mindsets and thought processes for the rest of their lives. Children who feel unloved by a parent or abandoned by a parent can be more likely to develop mental health problems as they grow up. There's a fine line between not sugar coating it and breaking their hearts op. Most parents tell a few fibs just to protect their children's innocence.

sleephelp2022 · 06/02/2023 07:17

tothelefttotheleft · 05/02/2023 22:02

Why's that so crazy when you see how people blame women for men turning out to be shit husbands and fathers?

Well I don't know what decade you are living I because that doesn't happen in my world!

The world is changing, women aren't always to blame for everything but good to know you still think they are and are encouraging that narrative.

TheBadLuckOfTeelaBrown · 06/02/2023 07:14

If the father is that much of a twat then they will find out themselves anyway.
I remember my son thanking me when he was an adult for never bad mouthing his dad He found out for himself and was impressed that I had held back and let him build his own relationship or non-relationship with him. We had a very open and long conversation about all the things and he said how incredibly grateful he was for me not being an arsehole and letting the actual arsehole speak for himself.
You don't need to sugarcoat things but keep your darkest thoughts to yourself. It is not necessary to be brutal about a person's parent unless they're Charles Manson or something...and that I doubt.

rubberduckiee · 06/02/2023 07:08

@dogdaydown not referring to OP's older kids, but the second father's own kids

rubberduckiee · 06/02/2023 07:04

That said, I also understand why you think it's unfair to "cover" for a deadbeat dad. I would tell the child when their brains and emotions are more developed. Ideally they would be able to process and understand simultaneous truths (dad doesn't want me and only wants his own kids, BUT that doesn't mean I am fundamentally unloveable), maybe as an older teen or adult.

rubberduckiee · 06/02/2023 07:02

Also, here is another harsh truth OP. I promise I'm not just saying this to be nasty – it's relevant and you're an adult able to process it.

If you tell your child all these horrible details now, they have a higher likelihood of ending up like you down the road (multiple poor relationship choices, and possibly limited life options). Growing up knowing in great detail that you're unlovable and unwanted by your parent, especially from the age of 3 (!), is a surefire way to guarantee you jump into bed with trash. You can break the generational cycle now. If you want to get all the horrible emotions off your chest, vent on MN or to someone else, not to your 3 year old.

dogdaydown · 06/02/2023 07:00

rubberduckiee · 06/02/2023 06:07

You're going to tell a 3 year old his/her father wants the 3 older children, but not him/her?

I don't think this is just about wanting to be honest with your child. It does honestly sound like there are punitive/vengeful motivations on your part.

I totally get not giving your child false hope, and giving them a neutral or even slightly harsh answer, but to rub it in to that extent does suggest some other motivations.

I think it's two different fathers?

jeaux90 · 06/02/2023 06:55

My DD13 hasn't seen or heard from her dad since she was 3. She has occasionally asked. I tell her he is not very good at caring about other people.

The fact he is an abusive, sociopathic narcissist and is in prison is not something she needs to know yet.

There is truth, then there is another way of telling the truth.

AsItWasInAnOwlsTree · 06/02/2023 06:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster

LoekMa · 06/02/2023 06:43

KickAssMumma · 05/02/2023 18:14

Difficult one. I’m going to be in same position though I’m a fair way off it yet- baby due in may and his dad is an utterly useless piece of shit. Total wanker. Has done nothing for this baby at all- I have to scrimp and fight for every single thing. To make sure baby has all he needs and it’s killing me off in the process. It’s hard. But what would I tell mine, if this continues? It’s hard to say. It’s a hard balance to strike between honesty and too much information for the child. I’m sorry I have no real answer!

Not to denigrate your experience , but I am sure "keeping it real" begins with telling the child why/how you let yourself get knocked up by someone so useless , no?

Unsurewhattodo1995 · 06/02/2023 06:32

Pineapple2023 · 05/02/2023 18:21

Like I said I'm not going to turn round and call their dad a twat, it will be age related as I have done with the older 2 kids , I hate the fact that this is the situation and trust me when I say I've tried resolving it many times. But I just don't see why I should be nice about someone who doesn't give a fuck about them or their feelings 🤷

But you should give a fuck about your child’s feelings

Swipe left for the next trending thread