Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my child the complete truth

205 replies

Pineapple2023 · 05/02/2023 18:09

People look at me gone out when I say this as if I've just killed their granny but I don't tell lies to my children. They're not taught about santa, Easter bunny etc, we still celebrate but there is no white lies involved.

I believe in monkey see monkey do so if I tell my kids not to lie to me but then in effect lie to them no matter how small would this not make me a hypocrit ?

Anyway , my older children have always been taught the reason they don't see their father often is because he's poorly , the older they're getting the more we are making them aware of their dads mental health condition.(they have a great relationship with his extended family as do i)

With that being said my youngest child has an absolute arsehole of a dad... hasn't seen them for over a year (baring in mind he lived on the same road) and would walk past them in the street.my child's getting to an age where they are going to begin to ask questions.

IMO I shouldn't blinker my child from the truth and suger coat how much of a twat their dad is.obviously I'm not going to tell a 3 year old their dad's a twat but I certainly won't be giving it the old , your daddy just wasn't ready for fatherhood when infact he's got 3 older children he sees and is a good 10years older than I am.the baby was planned and now he even denies that he's even the dad !! ...

My mum thinks I'm wrong and alot of things I've seen on the Internet tell you not to speak bad of the child's other parent but I'm left here thinking , well why ? Why shouldn't they know the truth , their 'dad' is a waste of space down an out, I'm not trying to poison their mind , I wasn't cheated on , I couldn't care less if he had a orgy filmed it and posted it all over social media, but the way he's treat my child is disgusting so why should I suger coat it !!

OP posts:
CrescentMoons · 07/02/2023 20:43

I said I loved them enough for two parents. I then said we split up long before she was born (true I was pregnant) they it wasn’t related to her he wasn’t able to be a father to anyone. That he was offered full involvement but chose not to be. That’s he’s an adult and has to take responsibility for his decisions. That decision was not related to her - she didn’t exist at that point.

we had bred our dog the previous year and I pointed out all the puppies were given new loving homes at 8 weeks. That in life sometimes people have one mum, or one dad, or two grandparents etc

in my case this was built into the narrative from birth. It was accepted and not challenged. I never sort to blame her or me - it was his choice.

aged 16 she has no desire whatever to contact him - she says he was the adult, he was able to send birthday cards, find out who she was etc and he chose not to. She doesn’t miss what she has never had.

somoslagente · 07/02/2023 20:33

Wait until the question comes and answer it truthfully. That's how I dealt with a similar issue. NO he didn't live on the same street but he had sod all interest until he hooked up with a new partner a few years down the line.

suddenly i was getting messages from her - not him - he never cared and also denied fatherhood despite the baby being planned.

we had to get DNA tests done so I had to explain that somehow... plus the usual questions of #where's dadddy?

so now she wants nothing to do with him but i tried to keep my opinions on him out of it and just set an example for her and made sure she was provided for - as he certainly didn't

wish you luck!

Curriedpeanuts · 07/02/2023 20:33

If your youngest child doesn't see their father then just don't tell them anything. If they ask where their daddy is, just tell them he went away and maybe they'll see him when they are older.

Don't say anything negative because they will internalise it.

I never breathed a negative word about DC's father until DC was in his 20's, and even then I said very little other than the basics, he works the rest out himself based on his own knowledge of his father. And the reason I didn't was because it wasn't my place to poison the father / child relationship or hurt my DC like that.

I grew up with one parent being put down, and it just made me feel like if any part of me was at all like that parent, my other parent would hate me. It made me feel very insecure and defensive.

Chunkythighss · 07/02/2023 20:16

My husband knew from a young age that his dad didn’t want to see him, wasn’t respectful etc.
He was told a lot of things by his mum that he probably didn’t really need to know. He took up the role of ‘man of the house’.

He has carried this with him to his teenage years and adulthood. He is resentful and cross and had trouble with relationships because of the way his dad was portrayed.

yes, he might not have had the dad he wanted or deserved, but no… he didn’t need to be told ‘the truth’ at such a young age

Hoistupthemainsail · 07/02/2023 20:11

Do what you want as you don't seem particularly interested in hearing other people's opinions.

Soopermum1 · 07/02/2023 20:08

I didn't mouth ex to DS, conversely but ex absolutely did a number on DS. Now DS hates me and lives with his dad. It's hard to judge what to do for the best.

LauraIAm · 07/02/2023 20:04

I think the point is your child needs the space to make his own assessment of his own father as he gets older. If you force ‘your truth’ on him he may feel he has to think that too to keep your love or whatever. You don’t have to lie, just keep it neutral - ‘Daddy and I didn’t get on very well when we lived together so we decided it would be nicer for you if we lived apart’. If he asks you as an adult you can consider sharing warts and all then.

sianiboo · 07/02/2023 20:00

@Awakeallnight Couldn't agree with your post more.

My parents split, nastily, when I was 21. My mother emotionally blackmailed myself and my two brothers into cutting all contact with our father. That was 34 years ago and she's done nothing but slag him off to us ever since.

I accepted her 'truth' for a while, until I discovered, through reading her own diary, that she was fucking lying her head off about certain events/decisions made...huge decisions that to this day still affect my life (and my two brothers). She tried blaming my father for all of it, when her own words showed that she was the driving force. Not that I really needed the diary, as I was 9 when the decisions were made and obviously as it was so major that time is indelibly recorded in my memories...

I've never trusted her 'truth' since, and as I've got older I've understood more about why my father left. I would have done the same, but would have done it differently. Yes, my father is a twat...and so is my mother for the way she's acted since. You don't burden your children with your marriage crap, especially if they haven't even asked anything about it. Find help elsewhere.

Mrsgreen100 · 07/02/2023 20:00

After 25 years I found that my ex was a covert narcissist, he had been stealing from me and had another family for 20 of them , very plausible totally believed by everyone when I discovered what an evil person he is , and realised even though my friends and family thought I was a strong woman etc etc I had been the victim of coercive control fraud and so much more . Honestly feel like we have been living in a bloody Netflix movie it’s all so unbelievable awful.
I asked close friends what to tell my daughter
they all said tell her the truth the stealing and manipulation of assets, including savings, put away for her, but keep it simple and keep your feelings back.
A year on I regret telling her she’s a mess nearly 20 now and it’s shattered her whole world to know that her father is a liar, cheat and fraudster.
I thought it would protect her going forward, in the horrible mess it’s to much to bear for a young person in the face of her whole life being a lie and in chaos.
think very carefully about the long term affects of the truth .

Messyhair321 · 07/02/2023 19:53

Your child will take it personally, they may feel rejected if you say the dad doesn't want to know.
I was in this position some years ago - I just used to really emphasise to my DD that I really wanted & really loved her no matter what. I said, when she asked lots of questions about her dad that he "wasn't very good at sharing " - I tried not to slate him because I knew she would feel bad about herself.
Tell your DD you love her & wouldn't be without her.
I get that you'd be angry anyone would be, but your DD doesn't need to be involved with adult stuff.

DeeDoyle · 07/02/2023 19:48

Because their minds are not mature enough to understand. You dont have to sugar coat it but I dont see a need to cause harm to your childs mental health either.

LeHamelRenard · 07/02/2023 19:42

Your child is 50% you and 50% your ex-partner. If you criticise your ex your child will feel they’re bad too.

Jojojojojowhat · 07/02/2023 19:39

What would you tell them if they weee conceived via sperm donor? Because he’s basically that…

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/02/2023 19:31

ancientgran · 05/02/2023 19:04

When I got divorced someone said this to me, "If you tell your kids there dad is rubbish remember they are half him, if he does the same remember they are half you. That makes them rubbish." I never said a bad word about him and as far as I know he never said anything bad about me.

This. This was said to me more or less word for word by a friend whose dad was an alcoholic. His mum divorced him and he drank himself to death within a few years.

I have had a similar dilemma with my DD who is now 12. We separated when she was four after years of (mainly) emotional abuse. He continued the abuse for several years and still drinks heavily and has recurrent depression.

I have decided to be polite and respectful to a fault when I speak to my daughter about him. She has asked me why I didn’t want to stay with him and I just said we got on better as friends. She still sees him and loves him but she absolutely knows I am the parent she relies on and the one who has done all the heavy lifting. Me telling her her dad was an abusive shit to me and has a drink problem serves no purpose except to make her feel shit about him and potentially about herself. No one wins, least of all her.

Thankfully he has had something of an epiphany since we separated and had to some degree turned himself around so my relationship with him is fairly cordial and we do things “as a family” sometimes. Hell would freeze over before I reinstated him into our lives in a permanent way and I will never trust or respect him but I am quite content to fake things in front of her to keep her happy.

I think you should be honest with yourself about why you would be being “honest” with your kids about him. It may be cathartic for you but it’s unlikely to help them.

TheAllButterBiscuit · 07/02/2023 19:21

I wouldn’t go down the route of making an overt judgement on their dad in a positive or negative light, but I would explain that in your household you have a certain set of values, and their dad has different ones. I think you could say that as a family you do/don’t like something, but their dad has the right to choose how he lives. If they say ‘but that’s not kind etc’ you can say ‘yes I agree with you, which is why in our household we don’t behave that way’.

Obviously this implies a certain degree of bad behaviour on the dad’s part, but it also means that you are stating the facts to your children without bringing ‘trash talking’ into it. It also leaves them free to make up their own minds in future.

For context, when my parents divorced, my mum took the above tactic whereas my dad slates my mum openly. I respect my mums actions and learned from the far more.

Also for context I don’t personally believe that it’s always helpful to actively talk well of someone, just because they are your child’s parent. But that’s not the same as saying negative things about them to young children.

Oodiks · 07/02/2023 19:18

I don't think you're being unreasonable, but you've got a fine line to walk. You can't sugar coat it and pretend his dad is a great guy, but you can't demonize him either. Be honest, but be kind.
I'm in a similar scenario, but with my 17yo. I asked her dad to move out, he moved away and has given up contacting her.

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 07/02/2023 19:13

Pinkyxx · 05/02/2023 20:00

I don't lie to my child either.

I allowed her to experience the magic of childhood by indulging in the fantasy of Father Christmas, the Easter Bunny and the tooth fairy. I taught her the importance of truth, honesty and integrity. Net result I have a teenager who does not lie to me.

She also happens to have a Father who I consider to be an arsehole. He was violent, emotionally and the whole spectrum of abusive. He then left to join his mistress to live their ''best life'' and spent vast amounts of money dragging me through court for years for contact. Contact he's failed to ever take in full. He has played no parental role, be it school, health, or other. I have raised her single handedly. Even now over a decade later he still tries at every given opportunity to control my life.

Nevertheless, he is her father. To bad mouth him hurts her. To tell her he doesn't care, can't be bothered, didn't turn up because he had something better to do etc hurts her. Ask yourself what child benefits from hearing - your parent doesn't care about you. The message this sends to a child is you are worthless. I love my daughter and do not wish to cause her pain. My love for her outweighs my distain for him. I have enabled and supported a relationship with him, free of any emotional bias that would interfere with her developing that relationship. That is my role as her Mum, every child deserves a relationship with both their parents. Every child has an intrinsic drive to have a relationship with their parents. This drive goes beyond the rationale or conscious mind.

The quality of that relationship falls outside of the realms of my control and within her Father's purview. I have no control or influence over how he chooses to parent and what kind of relationship he develops with our daughter.

As it happens, as the years passed, she started to see him as he is. I supported her through many painful, heartbreaking years of he feeling grossly inadequate, rejected and lost questioning what she could do differently or what was 'wrong' with her. Of her hoping that this time, it would be different. And the disappointment when it wasn't. At around age 10 after yet another instance of his causing her pain, she said to me quite out of the blue - ''Thank you Mummy for never making it difficult for me with Daddy. I don't think I could cope with everything he does if you made it hard too''.

Now a teenager, she has reached the conclusion she does not wish to have a relationship with him anymore. She knows in her heart and mind that she did everything in her power to have a relationship and he simply can't or won't meet her half way. She has been free to make this journey herself, lived her reality free of influence from me or others. The hard raw reality is tastes bitter but far less so than the poison of living someone else's narrative. Children who listen to their mother denigrate their father for years become adults who one day question whose reality was I living mine or my mothers?

Allow your child to be free to live their own reality and make their own choices.

Nailed it!

supersop60 · 07/02/2023 19:11

There's a difference between telling someone the truth and telling them EVERYTHING. Saying 'your dad is a twat' is your opinion (may or may not be the truth for someone else.
There are some good suggestions in pp

Unsure33 · 07/02/2023 18:47

Sux2buthen · 05/02/2023 19:09

I've told mine (between 3 and 6) that sometimes grown ups don't always make good choices. And that right now daddy has been making bad choices and that's why he doesn't see them. I say it doesn't mean they're not loved, just that even grown ups can be very wrong and in the end it is him that misses out

That is a good way of putting it . I don’t think you should lie but also you should never be judgemental about the other parent . When the child is old enough they can make up their own mind . You never know things may change .

Watchamocauli · 07/02/2023 18:46

You are better off asking a professional person than a random bunch of strangers pretending to child psychologist.

HappyBunnyNow · 07/02/2023 18:41

As previous poster said children feel that they are 50% each parent and if you say negative things about their father that will cause them emotional harm. I don't tell "lies" to my kid about Santa etc.. either but I protect them from additional harm by always being respectful in the way I speak about their father despite his behaviour... I don't pretend he's better than he is but it's not my job to point out his flaws. They will only resent you for doing this if you insist on it. I think what was written above is the kindest option.

"Because it's for their benefit, they are half of that person. Tell them that you don't know why he doesn't see them, but say that he is missing out hugely and that you are so lucky to have them. Telling them he is no good will lead to them thinking they must be not much good either. Turn it round into a positive every time about how lucky you are and how great they are, don't make it a negative for them."

buttermymuffins · 07/02/2023 18:32

My thoughts for what it is worth. My parents divorced acrimoniously when I was 2. I lived with my mum & saw my dad usually once at the weekend a 2 week holiday in the summer. They hated each other. My mum slagged my dad off when I was with her & he’d do the same when I was with him. Not constantly but it was always there. So when I was a kid I came to the conclusion that as I was 50% each of them they must both also hate that half of me. I also hated it so much when I had to listen to them slagging the person who they brought me into the world with. Therefore 100% of me was bad. This needed some therapy to sort out & made it difficult for me to believe people could actually like me. And I have had imposter syndrome for most of my life. So careful how you word it.

Inwiththenew · 07/02/2023 18:30

From friends of mine who have been in similar situations, it’s best to do what you can to encourage the father to have an interest. I appreciate that it may seem totally futile but this is the best way to support your child. I mean, I’m not saying bust a gut to try to make him come around but just try to keep things open. Suggest a dna test. And you could tell your child that daddy just finds it difficult to be friends at the moment and you don’t really know why.

gemloving · 07/02/2023 18:28

Has your child ever asked a question about his dad? Unless the question is being asked, I wouldn't not start the conversation given his age.

RinklyRomaine · 07/02/2023 18:23

Three is too young to say much other than 'I'm not sure, we will ask him if we see him'. That's not about lying or sugar coating, it's just common sense because any real answer would be too much to comprehend and a lie is not going to help. My older DC, however, I have been reasonably honest with since she was around ten. 'Of course he loves you, but sometimes he is selfish or unable to to put you first. It's not your fault, you've done nothing wrong, it's just who he is'. Because, and I worry about this a lot, she was learning to try and keep pleasing him, accepting crumbs of attention and blaming herself when it didn't happen. She needed to know, not have me either lie for him or affirm her worst fears. Not learn that she needs to constantly accept being picked up and dropped, be a good girl or whatever. But that's age appropriate. Not at 3.