Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
fitzwilliamdarcy · 07/02/2023 19:33

@Hellybelly84 You said:

My point was shouldn’t the government be at least giving parents (and usually it is the Mum who wants to stay at home abit more in the first few years but ofcourse some Dads do aswell) the chance to spend more time with their kids whilst they are young?

That’s what we’re disagreeing with. I’m sure loads of women would find it “impossible” to work if the government started funding them not to - hardly good for equality.

Newnamenewme23 · 07/02/2023 19:21

Where child benefit differs is the original principle that it's for all children

the original principle was to provide a source of income to mums, back in the day when they usually didn’t work, or if they did their finances were controlled by their husbands as it wasn’t so long ago women weren’t allowed their own bank accounts etc.

child benefit was introduced so vulnerable women with irresponsible husbands- financial abuse, alcoholism etc had at least some of their own money for food and other basics.

Newnamenewme23 · 07/02/2023 19:14

Without giving out my Husbands job, it would have been impossible to work around it (we can’t all work jobs around our Husband - for example Army where the Husband is away for many months etc) and lots of Mums have to fit jobs into school hours. As I have done since practically the day my kids were both in.

impossible? I know many forces wives, or wives whose husbands work away, women who’s husbands have long hours, or indeed women who have no husband or partner.

we use nurseries, childminders, breakfast clubs, after school clubs, swap days with other parents.

working school hours is a choice like any other. There is nothing stopping women working, whatever their husband’s jobs is. They just have to utilise paid childcare.

Scottishskifun · 07/02/2023 19:08

Princessglittery · 07/02/2023 18:24

I have hesitated to comment further on this thread but the lack of understanding of average incomes in the UK is surprising.

One benefit of CB not often mentioned is for a SAHP or very low earner is NI credits as long as they claim CB (can decline payment if affected by the tax taper) currently worth about £825 per year. Really important for state pension entitlement.

Child benefit is a state benefits like UC, state pension, maternity allowance etc. and surprise surprise are tax payer funded. Also tax payer funded are the salaries and pay increases of public sector workers including police, NHS workers, fire brigade, teachers & support staff, LA staff and Civil Servants.

In 2022 the median salary was c£33,000, that means 50% of the workforce earn less than this. People who earn £50,000+ are in roughly the top 20% of earners, and those earning £63,000 + are roughly the top 10% of earners.

The question for us as a society is if people who earn £50/63k feel it is wrong to receive less/no child benefit where do you draw the line? and more importantly who should pay more tax to fund it?

I think what most people struggle with is its not based on household income (like how other benefits are calculated) it's based on a single salary which means you get the very real scenario of 1 household with a combined joint income of 80/90k able to claim whilst a single parent just over the threshold it can be a issue.

The govt also has research which shows people are adjusting their working hours/promotions etc so they don't get caught out which means less tax from these people. Its why Truss govt were rumoured to be examining the threshold as less tax means less in the pot.

Where child benefit differs is the original principle that it's for all children hence actually anyone can claim it just over 50k they then need to do a tax return and pay it back which is separate policy to child benefit itself.

It's not fit for purpose but not sure the system could cope with trying to replace it

Princessglittery · 07/02/2023 18:24

I have hesitated to comment further on this thread but the lack of understanding of average incomes in the UK is surprising.

One benefit of CB not often mentioned is for a SAHP or very low earner is NI credits as long as they claim CB (can decline payment if affected by the tax taper) currently worth about £825 per year. Really important for state pension entitlement.

Child benefit is a state benefits like UC, state pension, maternity allowance etc. and surprise surprise are tax payer funded. Also tax payer funded are the salaries and pay increases of public sector workers including police, NHS workers, fire brigade, teachers & support staff, LA staff and Civil Servants.

In 2022 the median salary was c£33,000, that means 50% of the workforce earn less than this. People who earn £50,000+ are in roughly the top 20% of earners, and those earning £63,000 + are roughly the top 10% of earners.

The question for us as a society is if people who earn £50/63k feel it is wrong to receive less/no child benefit where do you draw the line? and more importantly who should pay more tax to fund it?

Hellybelly84 · 07/02/2023 17:47

HistoryFanatic · 07/02/2023 17:19

Nope I have no family nearby and can't afford childcare but also can't afford to quit my job so work round my husband's work. If you were a SAHM due to affordability of childcare I would sympathise but this is someone who just wants to stay at home and get money from the government.

Im not a sahm now (I was for the first few years and beyond grateful I got that time with my kids - you can never get that back so its worth every sacrifice to me).

Without giving out my Husbands job, it would have been impossible to work around it (we can’t all work jobs around our Husband - for example Army where the Husband is away for many months etc) and lots of Mums have to fit jobs into school hours. As I have done since practically the day my kids were both in.

Also not asking for anything, dont claim anything, work school hours, Husband works harder than any other person I know. Im pointing out the waste to give it to people who dont need it. Thats exactly why ive said it should be based on total household income.

The thread is talking about the unfairness of a single Mum having it reduced or losing it altogether if she earns abit more, whilst a couple can be earning nearly double the amount she currently gets and still get it.

Is she right to be pissed off at that? Yes!

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 07/02/2023 17:29

GoodChat · 07/02/2023 14:56

Yeah if you're making other sacrifices too you have to weigh up pros and cons but we're talking about someone turning down a promotion on the basis of solely losing their child benefit.

Well, the 40% tax bracket is also applicable at that point too. I know it starts lower in Scotland so the person was on it anyway, but it's obviously going to form part of the calculations about whether the benefits are worth the effort.

HistoryFanatic · 07/02/2023 17:19

Hellybelly84 · 07/02/2023 15:23

Do you have family help?
Does your Husband work away and work extremely long hours?
Do you have a nursery nearby?

There’s lot’s of reasons people have to stay at home in the early years (other than just wanting to). I loved being able to work when it became possible when mine went to pre-school/school.

I also hear from friends how exhausted they are when the grandparents are away and they have to ‘do it all’ and have to laugh. Plenty of people out there get given alot of free extra help (that would cost thousands if they were paying for it) that others dont have, so a blanket statement of ‘just work’ is rubbish.

Nope I have no family nearby and can't afford childcare but also can't afford to quit my job so work round my husband's work. If you were a SAHM due to affordability of childcare I would sympathise but this is someone who just wants to stay at home and get money from the government.

Dobby123456 · 07/02/2023 17:05

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 07/02/2023 14:02

Yep. The fact is that there's a bottleneck. Parents in particular can be in a position where the marginal costs just aren't worth it.

If it's a wage increase requiring nothing of you and you don't mind a bit of admin sure, take it and increase pension contributions. If it involves another shift, a different job, you might incur more work associated costs, for some people it's not going to be worth the effort in their circumstances. It all depends. People react differently, have different priorities, and one person's career advancement no brainer is another person's mugs game.

I think this is the nit that people don't understand. There's no such thing as a free lunch. Employers don't go 'oh, you've been working for us for a few years, why don't we give you a nice pay rise.' Most organisations will have a whole list of hurdles you have to jump through meaning more time away from the kids, more late nights, more childcare at the weekends.

CandleInTheStorm · 07/02/2023 17:04

Zax · 07/02/2023 16:53

Child benefit is archaic and in desperate need of overhaul or better still scrapping all together. A drain on the country's finances to fund people who choose to have kids but haven't budgeted properly. Divert the money to our pensioners who have given a lifetime of contributions in return for a pittance that they call a state pension. I know that I'll get slated for this but it's my view and I don't care about the impending responses l.

I agree, they need to scrap it altogether and put the money elsewhere for the most vulnerable. When you've got people on higher incomes complaining about not getting it (I don't get mean op), people trying to claim it could make or break their monthly finances as though they are somehow on the breadline, and not going for promotions to keep cb... you know it has to go.

Zax · 07/02/2023 16:53

Child benefit is archaic and in desperate need of overhaul or better still scrapping all together. A drain on the country's finances to fund people who choose to have kids but haven't budgeted properly. Divert the money to our pensioners who have given a lifetime of contributions in return for a pittance that they call a state pension. I know that I'll get slated for this but it's my view and I don't care about the impending responses l.

Hellybelly84 · 07/02/2023 16:52

fitzwilliamdarcy · 07/02/2023 16:22

@Hellybelly84 None of that is the responsibility of the government to sort out, though, which was the point.

Hence why we get on with our life, both work, have no help, pay for childcare all through the holidays, dont ask for anything etc.

I am allowed to think its incredibly unfair/ridiculous to give it to households where both earn upto £49k and households on half of that (the OP) as a single Mum (getting nothing from the Dad) doesn’t get it. Or where there is a situation when one parent doesn’t have the option/not financially viable to work - we do actually need to have kids to fund us in old age! It is the responsibility of the government to not make ridiculous rules.

As child benefit was introduced specifically to be spent on the kids, there really isnt any argument against looking at total household income and deciding who gets it based on that. If they changed it tomorrow and said only households earning under say 40k got it, that would be a fairer system than we have now.

fairypeasant · 07/02/2023 16:44

GoodChat · 07/02/2023 15:01

It's the same with Tax Free Childcare allowance. You can claim if you have two parents on £99,999 but not if you have one parent on £100,000

I'm not convinced the balance of the budget is quite so precarious at 100k as it is at 50k, even in areas like the South East/London. No one is struggling on 100k, even as a single parent. Tax free childcare is a totally separate issue.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 07/02/2023 16:22

@Hellybelly84 None of that is the responsibility of the government to sort out, though, which was the point.

Hellybelly84 · 07/02/2023 15:23

HistoryFanatic · 07/02/2023 10:22

If you need help from the government because you fancy being a SAHP then you obviously can't afford it. Work like many parents do. 🙄

Do you have family help?
Does your Husband work away and work extremely long hours?
Do you have a nursery nearby?

There’s lot’s of reasons people have to stay at home in the early years (other than just wanting to). I loved being able to work when it became possible when mine went to pre-school/school.

I also hear from friends how exhausted they are when the grandparents are away and they have to ‘do it all’ and have to laugh. Plenty of people out there get given alot of free extra help (that would cost thousands if they were paying for it) that others dont have, so a blanket statement of ‘just work’ is rubbish.

Scottishskifun · 07/02/2023 15:14

Newnamenewme23 · 07/02/2023 11:26

Agree.

take the promotion, shove any extra into a private pension until the kids turn 18.

benefit from extra pension, and you won’t lose out longer term when the kids are 18.

plus you also haven’t stepped off the promotion track and slowed your career down.

unless you plan to retire as soon as CB ends, why turn down extra pension and this/future promotions?

madness. And all for £130 a month (2 children). not worth damaging careers for.

Because they have 2 children in nursery which is expensive and £130 a month is more then they would receive from the promotion so wasn't worth the extra stress for what they would lose. It doesn't seem to have damaged his career as it was a application process anyway he just didn't apply.

It's more common then people realise because the threshold hasn't changed for so long and often people have to be short sighted because their finances are finely balanced.

GoodChat · 07/02/2023 15:01

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/02/2023 14:47

Used to be that everyone got it. But was made means tested for optics of the govt wanting to look tough, even though costs more to administer.

Also it’s criminal that it’s done on if one person earns over the threshold and not on household income. Single parents treated worse than couples as usual.

It's the same with Tax Free Childcare allowance. You can claim if you have two parents on £99,999 but not if you have one parent on £100,000

GoodChat · 07/02/2023 14:56

fairypeasant · 07/02/2023 13:35

It's not bonkers to stall in your career, when not only do you lose CB, but you may have to pay more childcare/have less time at home. Everything comes at a cost, and losing CB, plus that extra income being in the 40% bracket, minus childcare... why would you? Extra responsibility, or extra hours, or extra stress, or all three, for a few pounds a week you actually get to keep? No thanks. The CB can be the final straw in making something just not worth it.

Yeah if you're making other sacrifices too you have to weigh up pros and cons but we're talking about someone turning down a promotion on the basis of solely losing their child benefit.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/02/2023 14:47

Used to be that everyone got it. But was made means tested for optics of the govt wanting to look tough, even though costs more to administer.

Also it’s criminal that it’s done on if one person earns over the threshold and not on household income. Single parents treated worse than couples as usual.

fairypeasant · 07/02/2023 14:44

@fairycakes1234 It actually costs the taxpayer less in admin to give it to everyone. It was a nonsensical piece of unfair shit what they've done here.

fairycakes1234 · 07/02/2023 14:35

In Ireland everyone gets child benefit regardless of their income. Not sure if its fair or not but thats how its done.

fairypeasant · 07/02/2023 14:16

As I said, not a muppet- there are thresholds for all sorts of expenses. Tax, pension contribution thresholds, need for more childcare, more travel. And promotion isn't free money with no strings. It has to be worth it. And yeah, £140/month can be the difference between worth it, and not worth it.

bellswithwhistles · 07/02/2023 14:12

Scottishskifun · 07/02/2023 10:30

I have a few friends who are in this exact position and husband didn't go for promotion because it would have tipped them too far.
One set of friends she is on 43k her husband is on 48k so combined is 91k. Scotland the 40% tax bracket kicks in much earlier as well so for them to then lose a chunk of child benefit for 2 children it simply wasn't worth it.

her husband didn't go for a promotion because they would have lost £136 a month?! Don't be ridiculous! If this is true, what a muppet.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 07/02/2023 14:02

fairypeasant · 07/02/2023 13:35

It's not bonkers to stall in your career, when not only do you lose CB, but you may have to pay more childcare/have less time at home. Everything comes at a cost, and losing CB, plus that extra income being in the 40% bracket, minus childcare... why would you? Extra responsibility, or extra hours, or extra stress, or all three, for a few pounds a week you actually get to keep? No thanks. The CB can be the final straw in making something just not worth it.

Yep. The fact is that there's a bottleneck. Parents in particular can be in a position where the marginal costs just aren't worth it.

If it's a wage increase requiring nothing of you and you don't mind a bit of admin sure, take it and increase pension contributions. If it involves another shift, a different job, you might incur more work associated costs, for some people it's not going to be worth the effort in their circumstances. It all depends. People react differently, have different priorities, and one person's career advancement no brainer is another person's mugs game.

fairypeasant · 07/02/2023 13:35

It's not bonkers to stall in your career, when not only do you lose CB, but you may have to pay more childcare/have less time at home. Everything comes at a cost, and losing CB, plus that extra income being in the 40% bracket, minus childcare... why would you? Extra responsibility, or extra hours, or extra stress, or all three, for a few pounds a week you actually get to keep? No thanks. The CB can be the final straw in making something just not worth it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread