Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
Dobby123456 · 08/02/2023 03:59

BanjoKnockers · 08/02/2023 00:23

@Zax I like the cut of your gib!

There's something not right about people moaning about being given public money to overpopulate an overpopulated planet with children they can't afford to raise.

Why are there so many people who had mums and children on mumsnet? They should set up another site like 'Misanthropic Planetnet' or something! 😂

Dobby123456 · 08/02/2023 03:55

Zax · 07/02/2023 22:41

Rishi and Hunt should launch a 'pay you to breed' campaign, then you'd all be happy and stop searching for ways to 'reduce' your income in order to receive handouts. I mean, £50k is well above national average so budget and deal with it or accept the promotions that have so often been referred to on here as rejected. This thread has been an eye opener. I'm going to send it to Jeremy Hunt with a detailed narrative to hopefully get some cost savings underway. He needs to calculate child benefits payments on gross salary with no allowance for creative reductions such as paying into pension scheme. To me this is a form of benefit fraud or will be when the government wakes up and smells the coffee.

The eye- opener for me is the number of people resentful at the OP for having gained promotion and a better salary, but not at all bothered that double income households can continue to claim way beyond the thresthold.

MintJulia · 08/02/2023 01:03

@BanjoKnockers The thing is all those people on £52k - including myself, aren't milking the system and haven't chosen to manipulate anything.

My employer chooses to pay me £52k. (I'd rather they paid me more).
The govt set the point at which child benefit reduces, at £50k
The govt created auto enrollment of pensions.
The govt set standard employee contributions at 5%.
The govt made pensions tax deductible.
5% of £52k is £2,600, so the taxable part of my income is £49,400.

PAYE means I don't claim tax back, it just happens. I and those like me, haven't manipulated anything.

And on that salary, I have one child, who I can afford to raise.

So I think your beef is with government tax policy, not with me.

BanjoKnockers · 08/02/2023 00:23

@Zax I like the cut of your gib!

There's something not right about people moaning about being given public money to overpopulate an overpopulated planet with children they can't afford to raise.

Princessglittery · 08/02/2023 00:14

@hourbyhour101 Flowers for your friend. Make sure she has claimed bereavement allowance etc.

Zax · 08/02/2023 00:08

Circe7 · 07/02/2023 23:54

@Zax
Reducing net income by making pension contributions is about the least “creative” tax mitigation there is. Everyone who saves into a pension does it. There is specific law which allows this. It is a policy choice that pension contributions should reduce taxable income in order to incentivise saving into pensions. Are you saying that you want tax relief on pensions to be scrapped altogether or for the way in which pension contributions are taken into account to be changed in the one specific case of child benefit but otherwise left alone?

No, having read the extent that some here manipulate their income to obtain it, I am going to heavily canvas for the abolition of child benefit. I didn't realise until this thread came alive that there were so many £50k+ earners bleeding the system with 'legal' manipulation. To coin a phrase it seems like very well paid employees are 'milking the system' just like those on long term sick who often are branded as scroungers even though they are ill and simply unable to work. That's irony I believe.

Circe7 · 07/02/2023 23:54

@Zax
Reducing net income by making pension contributions is about the least “creative” tax mitigation there is. Everyone who saves into a pension does it. There is specific law which allows this. It is a policy choice that pension contributions should reduce taxable income in order to incentivise saving into pensions. Are you saying that you want tax relief on pensions to be scrapped altogether or for the way in which pension contributions are taken into account to be changed in the one specific case of child benefit but otherwise left alone?

Zax · 07/02/2023 23:43

EasterIssland · 07/02/2023 23:37

Can’t wait to hear from you.

You'll hear it from the government, not me. Just be patient!

EasterIssland · 07/02/2023 23:37

Zax · 07/02/2023 23:31

I have a very sound understanding of economics and that will be reflected in my report to Sunak/Hunt. Watch this space, things will change. I know how to do it as have been successful on a previous issue.

Can’t wait to hear from you.

Zax · 07/02/2023 23:31

EasterIssland · 07/02/2023 23:25

Wishful thinking if you think this countries main problem is paying 1000/year to those earning between 50 and 60k

I have a very sound understanding of economics and that will be reflected in my report to Sunak/Hunt. Watch this space, things will change. I know how to do it as have been successful on a previous issue.

EasterIssland · 07/02/2023 23:25

Zax · 07/02/2023 23:21

@Princessglittery If you dislike legal tax avoidance start with making everyone have their salary/pay paid via PAYE, this includes all company directors, self employed etc. People who are paid all/most of their income via PAYE probably pay the most accurate tax. Then you can remove tax relief on the first £1,000 of savings interest, pension contributions, ISAs, tax free childcare etc.

I totally agree with you about IR35 and other such tax avoidance measures. Tighten the lot of them up including the abolition of child benefit and child minder fees then watch the government's books balance quickly.

Wishful thinking if you think this countries main problem is paying 1000/year to those earning between 50 and 60k

Zax · 07/02/2023 23:25

EasterIssland · 07/02/2023 22:54

What a stupid comment

so tell me which family will be better off. A couple earning 30k each with cb allowed or a single mum with 50k and having to return part of her cb money and paying bills on her own.

make sure you mention this on your letter to Sunak

I don't care which ones would be better or worse off. This is a bleed on the UK's finances when every penny counts. Have kids if you can afford them otherwise wait until/if you can, just like any other major expenditure.

Zax · 07/02/2023 23:21

Princessglittery · 07/02/2023 23:02

@hourbyhour101 no idea where your friend got that duff advice. Reducing hours reduces income. Unless her DH/DP also earns over the limit.

@Zax If you dislike legal tax avoidance start with making everyone have their salary/pay paid via PAYE, this includes all company directors, self employed etc. People who are paid all/most of their income via PAYE probably pay the most accurate tax. Then you can remove tax relief on the first £1,000 of savings interest, pension contributions, ISAs, tax free childcare etc.😂

@Princessglittery If you dislike legal tax avoidance start with making everyone have their salary/pay paid via PAYE, this includes all company directors, self employed etc. People who are paid all/most of their income via PAYE probably pay the most accurate tax. Then you can remove tax relief on the first £1,000 of savings interest, pension contributions, ISAs, tax free childcare etc.

I totally agree with you about IR35 and other such tax avoidance measures. Tighten the lot of them up including the abolition of child benefit and child minder fees then watch the government's books balance quickly.

NameInUseAlreadyAgain · 07/02/2023 23:14

Princessglittery · 05/02/2023 17:57

@pinotnow

  1. Tax year is 6 April to 5 April
  2. Its gross earnings for the year so very basic maths - 3 months at £49k/12 x3 (£12,250) and 9 months at £52k i12 x 9 (39k) = £51,250
  3. Deduct pension contributions 10.2% x £51,250 = £5,227 from gross pay = £46k so well under the £50k limit. Note you are taxed on £46k not £51,250.
  4. Your employer pays 23.68% = £12,136 in pension contributions. compared to the legal minimum of 3%.
  5. you will have banked 1/57th c£900 as a DB pension this is revalorised from April 2024 and every year after that by I think CPI.
  6. You may find you pay slightly more pension contributions because the pay award was delayed. Far to complex for me to explain on a Sunday night.
You may think it’s a shithole country but when you ask what % employer pension contributions other non-public sector workers get and what their DC pension scheme will pay out compared to your DB scheme you may be surprised.

This is a classic example of why I believe personal/family finance and basic maths should be taught in schools.

23.68% employer contributions ! Wow! Never knew it was so high.

OP youve had a pay rise so just think of it that you’ve had 20% of the years child benefit less as a pay rise. It’s not hard to see you are still better off than you were before the pay rise. 20% of the child benefit isn’t a lot …..

EasterIssland · 07/02/2023 23:12

There is this calculator that it might be helpful
she just needs to input the data she believes she’ll have paid by April and also if she was to reduce her hours how much would that be
www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-calculator

hourbyhour101 · 07/02/2023 23:09

@EasterIssland thank you I will let her know. Her head a mess atm and since I'm not the strongest in finance I though I best ask Mn !

EasterIssland · 07/02/2023 23:06

hourbyhour101 · 07/02/2023 22:46

Daft question but one my friend was asking she's recently got a pay-rise of the similar amount to op and in similar situation re line income.

I suggested she dropped her hours (she's always complaining she doesn't have enough work life balance) but she said that wouldn't effected it and she would still lose CB ? Is that right ? If you can up your pension and make gift aid amount to lower your overall income ? Surely reducing your hours would also do it ?

Sorry 😵‍💫 I'm clearly being a bit thick or missing something (having never been entitled to CB) I don't know the inns and out but she says it's really screwed her !

Op I'm so sorry 💐

If she’s paid per hours or days then as long as she gets less than 52k then she’ll be better off doing that If she can afford it. It’s at the end of the financial year how much cash has she been paid and after that you do self assessment and pay it back. So if in April she’s earning over 51k then she’ll have to return some back(not much if it’s close to that figure)

There is a range around 52-55k in my opinion that is a crap range , you’ve to pay more taxes and also send some cb back. It’s better earning less 50k or so, pay less taxes and not returning cb but you take home at the end of the year similar money

hourbyhour101 · 07/02/2023 23:05

@Princessglittery tbf her husband passed a little while ago and he was in finance and sorted it all out. Quite literally. She's just a bit muddled at the mo

I'm glad I wasn't wrong I will go back and tell her ! Having had no experience with it I though she must have gotten it wrong.

Thank you for coming back to me. I almost didn't post as I thought someone would start spouting off about her claiming CB as fraud 😵‍💫 and my baby is teething so I just don't have the energy for that nuttery tonight

Princessglittery · 07/02/2023 23:02

hourbyhour101 · 07/02/2023 22:46

Daft question but one my friend was asking she's recently got a pay-rise of the similar amount to op and in similar situation re line income.

I suggested she dropped her hours (she's always complaining she doesn't have enough work life balance) but she said that wouldn't effected it and she would still lose CB ? Is that right ? If you can up your pension and make gift aid amount to lower your overall income ? Surely reducing your hours would also do it ?

Sorry 😵‍💫 I'm clearly being a bit thick or missing something (having never been entitled to CB) I don't know the inns and out but she says it's really screwed her !

Op I'm so sorry 💐

@hourbyhour101 no idea where your friend got that duff advice. Reducing hours reduces income. Unless her DH/DP also earns over the limit.

@Zax If you dislike legal tax avoidance start with making everyone have their salary/pay paid via PAYE, this includes all company directors, self employed etc. People who are paid all/most of their income via PAYE probably pay the most accurate tax. Then you can remove tax relief on the first £1,000 of savings interest, pension contributions, ISAs, tax free childcare etc.😂

EasterIssland · 07/02/2023 22:58

Zax · 07/02/2023 22:41

Rishi and Hunt should launch a 'pay you to breed' campaign, then you'd all be happy and stop searching for ways to 'reduce' your income in order to receive handouts. I mean, £50k is well above national average so budget and deal with it or accept the promotions that have so often been referred to on here as rejected. This thread has been an eye opener. I'm going to send it to Jeremy Hunt with a detailed narrative to hopefully get some cost savings underway. He needs to calculate child benefits payments on gross salary with no allowance for creative reductions such as paying into pension scheme. To me this is a form of benefit fraud or will be when the government wakes up and smells the coffee.

Also it’s not benefit fraud. It’s allowed hence why people do it. It’d be fraud if it wasn’t allowed

last year I was earning myself around 60k. Paying loads of taxes (nearly 1k a month). And I had to return part of the cb back to the government. The same government won’t give me a single penny if I ever need it because I’m rich. Ha. But if I put part of my money in my pension I’m not only keeping that money and the corresponding taxes but I also have to pay less back? And if I ever need the money as the government won’t help me then I’ll be able to use my pension pot.

Think on your letter to sunak, you should be thinking who is your enemy … those earning 60k and paying their taxes or those earning millions like sunaks wife or the previous health minister that are evading taxes? Make sure you attack the enemy and not the vulnerable one just because they earn above average wages

EasterIssland · 07/02/2023 22:54

Zax · 07/02/2023 22:41

Rishi and Hunt should launch a 'pay you to breed' campaign, then you'd all be happy and stop searching for ways to 'reduce' your income in order to receive handouts. I mean, £50k is well above national average so budget and deal with it or accept the promotions that have so often been referred to on here as rejected. This thread has been an eye opener. I'm going to send it to Jeremy Hunt with a detailed narrative to hopefully get some cost savings underway. He needs to calculate child benefits payments on gross salary with no allowance for creative reductions such as paying into pension scheme. To me this is a form of benefit fraud or will be when the government wakes up and smells the coffee.

What a stupid comment

so tell me which family will be better off. A couple earning 30k each with cb allowed or a single mum with 50k and having to return part of her cb money and paying bills on her own.

make sure you mention this on your letter to Sunak

hourbyhour101 · 07/02/2023 22:46

Daft question but one my friend was asking she's recently got a pay-rise of the similar amount to op and in similar situation re line income.

I suggested she dropped her hours (she's always complaining she doesn't have enough work life balance) but she said that wouldn't effected it and she would still lose CB ? Is that right ? If you can up your pension and make gift aid amount to lower your overall income ? Surely reducing your hours would also do it ?

Sorry 😵‍💫 I'm clearly being a bit thick or missing something (having never been entitled to CB) I don't know the inns and out but she says it's really screwed her !

Op I'm so sorry 💐

Zax · 07/02/2023 22:41

Rishi and Hunt should launch a 'pay you to breed' campaign, then you'd all be happy and stop searching for ways to 'reduce' your income in order to receive handouts. I mean, £50k is well above national average so budget and deal with it or accept the promotions that have so often been referred to on here as rejected. This thread has been an eye opener. I'm going to send it to Jeremy Hunt with a detailed narrative to hopefully get some cost savings underway. He needs to calculate child benefits payments on gross salary with no allowance for creative reductions such as paying into pension scheme. To me this is a form of benefit fraud or will be when the government wakes up and smells the coffee.

fairypeasant · 07/02/2023 22:12

Princessglittery · 07/02/2023 18:24

I have hesitated to comment further on this thread but the lack of understanding of average incomes in the UK is surprising.

One benefit of CB not often mentioned is for a SAHP or very low earner is NI credits as long as they claim CB (can decline payment if affected by the tax taper) currently worth about £825 per year. Really important for state pension entitlement.

Child benefit is a state benefits like UC, state pension, maternity allowance etc. and surprise surprise are tax payer funded. Also tax payer funded are the salaries and pay increases of public sector workers including police, NHS workers, fire brigade, teachers & support staff, LA staff and Civil Servants.

In 2022 the median salary was c£33,000, that means 50% of the workforce earn less than this. People who earn £50,000+ are in roughly the top 20% of earners, and those earning £63,000 + are roughly the top 10% of earners.

The question for us as a society is if people who earn £50/63k feel it is wrong to receive less/no child benefit where do you draw the line? and more importantly who should pay more tax to fund it?

It costs more to administrate this as a tapering benefit than it did as a universal benefit. Plus I (and likely others) cut my hours because CB tipped me from "worth it" to "not worth it- the state has lost my work (I work in the public sector) and my taxes. Overall, the state has lost money. So no tax rises needed.

CandleInTheStorm · 07/02/2023 20:39

Newnamenewme23 · 07/02/2023 19:21

Where child benefit differs is the original principle that it's for all children

the original principle was to provide a source of income to mums, back in the day when they usually didn’t work, or if they did their finances were controlled by their husbands as it wasn’t so long ago women weren’t allowed their own bank accounts etc.

child benefit was introduced so vulnerable women with irresponsible husbands- financial abuse, alcoholism etc had at least some of their own money for food and other basics.

Yes back when their husband had spent half of it in the pub before he got home!

Swipe left for the next trending thread