Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
Zax · 11/02/2023 17:19

messybutfun · 11/02/2023 17:10

30p Lee?

A civilised society is one that invests in its people, especially its children. You can see where not investing in skills and charging youngsters to learn a job like nursing has got us.

We now need to import these skills at a rate of half a million a year without getting anywhere near sufficient levels. Child benefit doesn‘t even scratch the surface. It will take a whole lot more spending than £20 a week on a child to rectify the neglect and managed decline of the last 13 years.

And 'civilised' people don't work the system.

messybutfun · 11/02/2023 17:10

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:28

A touch of sarcasm I sense, but I'll rise above that and answer the question honestly nevertheless; I have an appointment with my MP next week who is very interested in talking to me and taking it to Westminster.

30p Lee?

A civilised society is one that invests in its people, especially its children. You can see where not investing in skills and charging youngsters to learn a job like nursing has got us.

We now need to import these skills at a rate of half a million a year without getting anywhere near sufficient levels. Child benefit doesn‘t even scratch the surface. It will take a whole lot more spending than £20 a week on a child to rectify the neglect and managed decline of the last 13 years.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 11/02/2023 16:00

fitzwilliamdarcy · 11/02/2023 15:58

Entirely genuine. Full disclosure - I don’t agree with CB (think child poverty needs tackling elsewhere) but I was genuinely asking what the difference was.

Yep, you were the one I thought was real!

fitzwilliamdarcy · 11/02/2023 15:58

Entirely genuine. Full disclosure - I don’t agree with CB (think child poverty needs tackling elsewhere) but I was genuinely asking what the difference was.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 11/02/2023 15:55

It is quite interesting that we've now had a couple of posters, one of whom at least appeared to be genuine, has asked what the difference is between ensuring continued eligibility for CB and doing the same for other, lower income benefits. And the answer, fundamentally, is nothing. Where there are bottlenecks like the ones we have at 50k, 100k and at various lower points for people on top up benefits depending on circumstances, some people respond to that. Which is why the existence of these bottlenecks isn't a good thing.

GCWorkNightmare · 11/02/2023 15:47

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:37

Talk about hypocrisy! My word the effluent posts here in support of obtaining child benefit by deception are a fine example. Let's take this to the other end of the scale, that's assuming that some of you here are in touch with the reality of those well beneath them. So, someone is offered extra work hours but refuses them because they would lose their Universal Credit. That's wrong too, but on a different level. Both are bleeding the system deceptively. Tighten up a load of these rules and there would be more funds in the pot for our NHS etc..

Cabinet members evading millions in tax is fine but someone investing in their pension (thus reducing burden on the state later) and taking £20
a week child benefits is wrong? Okay.

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:37

hourbyhour101 · 11/02/2023 15:26

@Zax May be legal but it's immoral

Interesting your calling others immoral from someone that calls people who have kids "breeders".

You realise since you were once a kid, your parents were "breeders" 😏

The more you talk the more I feel sorry for the person on the receiving end of your letter. Poor person will want to scratch their eyes out from the hypocritical bullshit that comes from your mouth.

Talk about hypocrisy! My word the effluent posts here in support of obtaining child benefit by deception are a fine example. Let's take this to the other end of the scale, that's assuming that some of you here are in touch with the reality of those well beneath them. So, someone is offered extra work hours but refuses them because they would lose their Universal Credit. That's wrong too, but on a different level. Both are bleeding the system deceptively. Tighten up a load of these rules and there would be more funds in the pot for our NHS etc..

GCWorkNightmare · 11/02/2023 15:34

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:28

A touch of sarcasm I sense, but I'll rise above that and answer the question honestly nevertheless; I have an appointment with my MP next week who is very interested in talking to me and taking it to Westminster.

Presumably your MP is up front about all of their income and don’t have any offshore —tax avoiding— accounts.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 11/02/2023 15:32

hourbyhour101 · 11/02/2023 15:30

I don't often feel sorry for Tory mps - but my god if there's even a slight chance this poster has a meeting with one of them.

I hope they don't die of boredom

I think it'll be great entertainment! We should crowdfund a livestream.

EasterIssland · 11/02/2023 15:30

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:28

A touch of sarcasm I sense, but I'll rise above that and answer the question honestly nevertheless; I have an appointment with my MP next week who is very interested in talking to me and taking it to Westminster.

Glad to hear the mp is willing to help you! I’m now earning over 60k so not even allowed to earn the cb so I’m glad all these rich people will stop stealing money from the government! I support your case.

hourbyhour101 · 11/02/2023 15:30

I don't often feel sorry for Tory mps - but my god if there's even a slight chance this poster has a meeting with one of them.

I hope they don't die of boredom

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 11/02/2023 15:28

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:24

Well, truly I'm not bothered whether you're interested in my views and ethics, you will not silence me. If you think that the government wishes to encourage deceptive methods of obtaining benefits when your salary is £50k+ then you're living in a parallel universe.

Oh, I've just realised you were the wind up merchant/crackhead I warned people about earlier in the thread. Mea culpa, but we might as well have some fun since you're still here. Have you managed to get hold of Rishi yet?

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:28

EasterIssland · 11/02/2023 15:24

How is your talk with the government going ?

A touch of sarcasm I sense, but I'll rise above that and answer the question honestly nevertheless; I have an appointment with my MP next week who is very interested in talking to me and taking it to Westminster.

hourbyhour101 · 11/02/2023 15:26

@Zax May be legal but it's immoral

Interesting your calling others immoral from someone that calls people who have kids "breeders".

You realise since you were once a kid, your parents were "breeders" 😏

The more you talk the more I feel sorry for the person on the receiving end of your letter. Poor person will want to scratch their eyes out from the hypocritical bullshit that comes from your mouth.

EasterIssland · 11/02/2023 15:26

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:24

Well, truly I'm not bothered whether you're interested in my views and ethics, you will not silence me. If you think that the government wishes to encourage deceptive methods of obtaining benefits when your salary is £50k+ then you're living in a parallel universe.

They clearly are when they’re the ones that have set up the rules that allow it.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 11/02/2023 15:25

fitzwilliamdarcy · 11/02/2023 15:13

I am struggling with this as it used to be the case (possibly still is) that if it looked like you’d reduced your savings on purpose to entitle yourself to pension credit, your claim would be denied. I assume the same would be true for any means tested benefit, actually.

How is reducing your income (in whatever way) in order to receive CB different?

Because savings and ongoing earnings are two very different things and a system treating the two the same way would be unworkable.

A person's savings already exist and, unless they're in cash under the bed or whatever, are quite simple to document. Whereas your wages for next month don't exist yet and you have to actively do something to get them. There are many more ways why people's income might be vary: overtime, self employment, illness, bonuses, having to move job for a lesser paid one because the bus you got to the old job has stopped running, seasonal work, needing to drop a shift a week for a bit while you look after your mum following her operation. Imagine trying to come up with a set of rules as to when this was ok and when it wasn't, then enforcing it.

Additionally, as discussed already, there's the fact that the government want and need people to save more for their retirement. They're not going to be unhappy about people paying more into their pensions to keep child benefit, particularly not when the alternative in at least some cases would be the person working less or not taking a promotion.

EasterIssland · 11/02/2023 15:25

boboshmobo · 11/02/2023 15:19

Yep! You are penalised for being successful .. standard ! 🙄

Would like to know whether zax is thinking about letting the government know that they should stop paying tax to those parents that only work 15h so they can get more cash or is it only those parents that earn 50-60k that she’s worried about.

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:24

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 11/02/2023 15:18

I'm completely uninterested in your moral take, my only interest was in pointing out that the reduction through pension contributions isn't going to change because it's a nudge towards the behaviour that the government want people to engage in.

Well, truly I'm not bothered whether you're interested in my views and ethics, you will not silence me. If you think that the government wishes to encourage deceptive methods of obtaining benefits when your salary is £50k+ then you're living in a parallel universe.

EasterIssland · 11/02/2023 15:24

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:01

You're all missing the salient point. There have been all sorts of 'creative' suggestions of how one should effectively reduce one's income in order to receive a state benefit. May be legal but it's immoral and a drain on society.

How is your talk with the government going ?

boboshmobo · 11/02/2023 15:19

Yep! You are penalised for being successful .. standard ! 🙄

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 11/02/2023 15:18

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:01

You're all missing the salient point. There have been all sorts of 'creative' suggestions of how one should effectively reduce one's income in order to receive a state benefit. May be legal but it's immoral and a drain on society.

I'm completely uninterested in your moral take, my only interest was in pointing out that the reduction through pension contributions isn't going to change because it's a nudge towards the behaviour that the government want people to engage in.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 11/02/2023 15:16

(I’m not agreeing with @Zax or their campaign - just trying to understand the logic behind this.)

fitzwilliamdarcy · 11/02/2023 15:13

I am struggling with this as it used to be the case (possibly still is) that if it looked like you’d reduced your savings on purpose to entitle yourself to pension credit, your claim would be denied. I assume the same would be true for any means tested benefit, actually.

How is reducing your income (in whatever way) in order to receive CB different?

Zax · 11/02/2023 15:01

Motheranddaughter · 11/02/2023 10:28

Tax avoidance is arranging your personal affairs to benefit from the tax laws
Tax evasion is not paying tax that is due
Tax avoidance is legal
Tax evasion is not

You're all missing the salient point. There have been all sorts of 'creative' suggestions of how one should effectively reduce one's income in order to receive a state benefit. May be legal but it's immoral and a drain on society.

Lapland123 · 11/02/2023 12:37

Zax

of course there should be incentives for people to take responsibility for their pensions. Otherwise everyone is trying to claim pension credit. Who do you think will pay for all this?

there has to be some benefits to working and providing for yourself. It doesn’t make any sense to resent society’s net contributors

Swipe left for the next trending thread