Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 16:21

I'm not convinced the balance of the budget is quite so precarious at 100k as it is at 50k, even in areas like the South East/London. No one is struggling on 100k, even as a single parent. Tax free childcare is a totally separate issue.

Of course a single parent on £100k can struggle! 🙄 That salary means net pay of £5564 if you make zero pension contributions. Rent/ mortgage in many parts of SE on a modest property suitable for a family can easily be £2500+. Childcare for two children can be £2000+. Leaving £1000 if you are lucky for all bills, food, car/ trains, clothes, etc. In many parts of SE the rent and childcare would be even higher than that. Some people seem to have no idea that to earn the higher salaries obviously people usually have to live in areas where the cost of living is also much higher.

Why should a single parent in that position get no tax free childcare, not get the subsidised nursery hours, and be paying way more tax than a household with the same income but two parents to share earning/ childcare so far lower expenses? It's clearly grossly unfair for any of these thresholds to be set on a single income basis rather than a household basis at every level in the system, whether it's the tax free allowance, higher rate tax threshold, child benefit threshold or whatever. It's completely illogical and very deliberately discriminatory to single people a in particular single parents.

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 16:11

fairycakes1234 · 07/02/2023 14:35

In Ireland everyone gets child benefit regardless of their income. Not sure if its fair or not but thats how its done.

That is fair and far more sensible, given the purpose of it. And also the fact that means testing it costs more than providing it for all children, so is utterly pointless.

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:10

Women campaigned for years to be taxed as individuals, it used to be by household. It allows women financial independence. We should have the same with all welfare benefits.

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 16:07

Ukrainebaby23 · 06/02/2023 22:05

Also discriminates where one parent is a high earner and one a low earner, Dh is a locum and rarely gets above 20k pa while we are fortunate to have 2 incomes, can't see why we have to repay CB when others earn more jointly.

This is why income tax allowances and all of these thresholds need to be changed to be on a household basis as they are in many civilised countries.

fairypeasant · 13/02/2023 13:53

@messybutfun No, @Zax doesn't 'get it.' They don't want to 'get it'. They don't sound the most, urm, mainstream in their thinking. I wouldn't engage.

messybutfun · 13/02/2023 13:19

@zax You really don‘t get it, do you? Free nursery places should be considered as a benefit to children NOT ADULTS. The adults (and their income for that matter) should be left out of the equation.

Zax · 13/02/2023 11:39

messybutfun · 13/02/2023 08:27

Let me say it again:

The country has no viable economic future if it doesn’t invest in its children.

'Investing in children' is on no way connected with artificially adjusting one's income to obtain a state benefit. There, I've said it again also.

messybutfun · 13/02/2023 08:27

Let me say it again:

The country has no viable economic future if it doesn’t invest in its children.

Zax · 12/02/2023 22:31

WulyJmpr · 12/02/2023 19:15

Certain people are going to be furious if/when the government increases free nursery hours

www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/feb/10/treasury-considering-huge-expansion-free-childcare-england

Some people are going to be even more furious when the government runs out of funds and the country goes bankrupt due to becoming a charitable organisation with no understanding of its pocket depths.

WulyJmpr · 12/02/2023 19:15

Certain people are going to be furious if/when the government increases free nursery hours

www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/feb/10/treasury-considering-huge-expansion-free-childcare-england

Dobby123456 · 12/02/2023 16:20

Newnamenewme23 · 12/02/2023 11:04

What I earned after tax wouldn't cover the childcare costs, so what's the point?

childcare is only 3-4 years. the point is you continue with your pension, and you don’t step of the work ladder- it can be difficult to get back to the level you were at, you are now used to talking on all the household work which is a difficult adjustment if you do go back. Long term you will be better off staying in work.

also why is childcare costs only yours? Surely you are only paying half, your dh pays the other.

If I wasn't working, would look after the children myself. I'm just giving examples of things that would put me off working in the hypothetical situation that everything I earned was taxed at the same level as my husband. Some of this might be psychological, some of it might be short-term thinking. You need to factor in that people don't want to miss their children growing up, and that working while looking after small children is stressful - so it's got to be worthwhile financially.

Newnamenewme23 · 12/02/2023 11:04

What I earned after tax wouldn't cover the childcare costs, so what's the point?

childcare is only 3-4 years. the point is you continue with your pension, and you don’t step of the work ladder- it can be difficult to get back to the level you were at, you are now used to talking on all the household work which is a difficult adjustment if you do go back. Long term you will be better off staying in work.

also why is childcare costs only yours? Surely you are only paying half, your dh pays the other.

Dobby123456 · 12/02/2023 10:21

TheLostGiraffe · 11/02/2023 23:29

I agree with this at some level (I'm against penalising single-income families). On the other hand, if everything I earned was taxed at the level my partner is taxed it would be so depressing I don't think I would bother!

Well that is the situation the single parent is in by working harder. And there is only one of them with additional childcare costs for every hour they work. So you see the issue: the unfairness you perceive it would be for you, is doubly compounded for them and yet that is not a hypothetical situation but their reality.

I wasn't saying it works be unfair if I was taxed at my partner's level, but it would put me off working. What I earned after tax wouldn't cover the childcare costs, so what's the point?
That must be how single parents feel about putting in the extra hours to get the pay rise, so I definitely sympathise there. I think single parents should get priority on child benefit, but not sure how that would work in practice.

TifT · 11/02/2023 23:50

Personally I think it’s an outdated benefit and certainly shouldn’t be given to people who don’t actually need benefits. The lack of money from your ex is a bigger issue

TheLostGiraffe · 11/02/2023 23:29

I agree with this at some level (I'm against penalising single-income families). On the other hand, if everything I earned was taxed at the level my partner is taxed it would be so depressing I don't think I would bother!

Well that is the situation the single parent is in by working harder. And there is only one of them with additional childcare costs for every hour they work. So you see the issue: the unfairness you perceive it would be for you, is doubly compounded for them and yet that is not a hypothetical situation but their reality.

Donkeyotey · 11/02/2023 23:05

ReamsOfCheese · 05/02/2023 17:01

YABU to call it a shithole country when it's given you free money for years and years. It's not child benefit's fault that you're a lone parent or that your ex doesn't pay CMS. Also if you were on 49k surely you saw it coming that you'd be over the 50k soon-ish?
First Google result for "child benefit over £50,000" explains it: www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-charge
The link at the bottom of the page sets out exactly how you sort it out: www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-charge/pay-the-charge

I agree.

Dobby123456 · 11/02/2023 22:49

TheLostGiraffe · 11/02/2023 22:25

Yep. As with all tax thresholds: the tax free allowance, 20% tax, 40% tax, the thresholds for tax free childcare/ 30 hrs etc. All of it should be based on household income. It massively penalises single people and single parents in particular (almost all of whom are women).

I agree with this at some level (I'm against penalising single-income families). On the other hand, if everything I earned was taxed at the level my partner is taxed it would be so depressing I don't think I would bother!

TheLostGiraffe · 11/02/2023 22:49

Maybe go to a country where it really is a shithole. Line up for food and receive scant medical treatment.

Lol. Seems many areas of the UK are now what you are describing here.

TheLostGiraffe · 11/02/2023 22:47

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 06/02/2023 09:27

It does become prohibitive and research suggests some decline career progressions because of it as you have to be paid well over the rate for it not to cause a impact.

Yes, there are certainly some people who make choices to work less or not go for a new role because of the child benefit withdrawal. There's a bottleneck for people earning 50-60k, particularly if they have dependent DC, and tax bottlenecks aren't a good thing in general. There's always going to be some issues at the point where people move threshold, that's inevitable, but child benefit entitlement exacerbates this one.

Yes. The same as the withdrawal of the tax free allowance, 30 hours of childcare and tax free childcare at £100k creates another one that's even worse, resulting in an effective tax rate of almost 80%. Not for a family with that same income split between two people though, only for those earning it on their own. It's absurd.

TheLostGiraffe · 11/02/2023 22:45

But in the case of a SAHP in likelihood the one working would earn over the threshold if that's the issue regardless of what the other one earns if they were back at work. As it's a decision people make they shouldn't be treated the same as single parents who are running a household on one wage for reasons largely out of their control, no.

Indeed. And also obviously as well as being penalised by the tax system they will have much higher childcare costs because they have to provide financially and look after their children. Comparing the situation of a lone parent to a family with two adults who have 48 hours per day to choose to work or look after their children themselves, so can have zero childcare costs, is laughable.

TheLostGiraffe · 11/02/2023 22:42

I'm not arguing for the current system. I'm pointing out that OP is an entitled whiner for describing the UK as a 'shithole country' because well-paid people like her find their state benefits, funded in part by lower earners, tapering off.

It's not funded by lower earners. Low income people do not even fund themselves: their taxes do not cover their state services. A very small proportion of high earners only are net contributors to the tax system so you can wind your neck in, nobody on a low income is funding anything towards anybody else at all. They are receiving a subsidy from the higher earners that you clearly resent, despite them supporting everyone else.

TheLostGiraffe · 11/02/2023 22:33

AllOutofEverything · 05/02/2023 19:03

So you are complaining because you are on a high wage and so are no longer entitled to an income related benefit?
YABVU.

She isn't on a high wage.

The whole point is that it should not be an income related benefit. And even if it were, it should be based on household income like all benefits and tax should be.

TheLostGiraffe · 11/02/2023 22:25

Thatsnotmybee · 05/02/2023 17:02

I do think it's mad that a couple earning £49k each can claim it, but a lone parent has to pay it back. It should be based on household income.

Yep. As with all tax thresholds: the tax free allowance, 20% tax, 40% tax, the thresholds for tax free childcare/ 30 hrs etc. All of it should be based on household income. It massively penalises single people and single parents in particular (almost all of whom are women).

Blablablablaba · 11/02/2023 19:39

It is shit especially as ur one income a family on £49k still get it all 🤷🏻‍♀️

Stick the £2k in ur pensions as additional contribution and then u won't need to pay it back in future.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 11/02/2023 17:27

Ok if it's 30p Lee I'm not even joking about the livestream.