Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 20:19

I view this differently. My DP earns over £50k. We claim the CB and pay it into my pension to make up for me working PT and we then pay the CB back in his tax return (not all of it as he's under £60k and pays pension contributions)

You could make those exact same pension contributions into your pension from his salary whether CB was withdrawn or not so I don't really understand why this is relevant?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/02/2023 20:11

I don't think child benefit raises birth rates, but the withdrawal of it incentivises some people to lower their work rate.

Ilikepinacoladass · 13/02/2023 20:04

@EasterIssland
Hmm no but as a single parent it does help.

And if there was more support like that (especially for single parents) then I believe it would help the birth rate.

Also to say 'the country owes you nothing for deciding to have a baby', as if you're purely doing it for the fun of it and having children has no benefit for the country is a bit of a piss take

EasterIssland · 13/02/2023 19:58

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 19:46

I believe in child benefit but it does nothing to raise birthrates.

You can’t raise a child with £20/week. That barely pays for nappies and wipes

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/02/2023 19:53

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 19:46

I believe in child benefit but it does nothing to raise birthrates.

No, although I think there was some indication the child tax credit system might have had an impact, a while back?

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 19:46

I believe in child benefit but it does nothing to raise birthrates.

Ilikepinacoladass · 13/02/2023 19:43

daffodilday · 05/02/2023 17:27

To call the UK a shit hole for giving you free money for producing a child is laughable. The country does not owe you money because you decided to have a child.

Producing children does actually help the country though and is very much needed at the mo as we face a declining birth rate! Look at what's happening to China, a declining birth rate, aging population and a massive problem..

PorePatrol · 13/02/2023 19:39

Wibblewibble1 · 05/02/2023 16:58

I can’t claim child benefit, as my partner Earle’s over 50k and we have to pay the tax on it - this makes it not worth while at all as I pay most of it back. It’s ridiculous. We both work but I am not in high paid employment and we struggle on by paying our mortgage and taxes , then can’t claim child benefitS the system is laughable and rubbish. I get why you are upset.

I view this differently. My DP earns over £50k. We claim the CB and pay it into my pension to make up for me working PT and we then pay the CB back in his tax return (not all of it as he's under £60k and pays pension contributions)

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/02/2023 19:35

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 19:21

@BashirWithTheGoodBeard that article is absolutely spot on, about how these disincentives penalise people at every level of the tax system.

Refund of expenses being considered "income" and resulting in a reduction in universal credit is completely bonkers. As are all of these artificial bottlenecks at all levels of earning. The last one in the article talking about the 62% tax rate also shows one of the worst ones. And that's without a student loan, or childcare allowances being lost. If you add those in then you will be looking at an effective tax rate of between 75% and 85%. Why would anybody bother? Totally barmy as it is the treasury who loses out in the long term by creating these disincentives. Fixing this should be their number one focus if they had any sense but they don't, obviously.

I thought I was reasonably well up on this stuff, but the bit about expense refunds being considered income for UC purposes is new to me. And one of the stupidest things I've ever heard. If we weren't so desperately short of carers it'd be funny.

It's a good point about freezing thresholds. Cowardice, really. Because inflation was quite low for a long time, it didn't matter much, but now all of a sudden a lot of people, perhaps a critical mass, are feeling the impact. Some of them will tailor their decision making process accordingly.

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 19:31

They also need to stop this fiscal drag nonsense. They must think we are all so stupid if they think we don't realise that freezing thresholds costs us way more than adding a couple of % to the headline rate, it's insulting how dumb they believe we all are. If it had kept up with inflation higher rate tax would start at around £90k. It needs to be put into law that thresholds are automatically uprated by inflation every year by default unless a specific additional law is passed to negate this, which would ensure a proper debate by our elected representatives (such as they are) was had about it and at least the way people were being ripped off had to be publicly declared each time they decided to make it worse.

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 19:21

@BashirWithTheGoodBeard that article is absolutely spot on, about how these disincentives penalise people at every level of the tax system.

Refund of expenses being considered "income" and resulting in a reduction in universal credit is completely bonkers. As are all of these artificial bottlenecks at all levels of earning. The last one in the article talking about the 62% tax rate also shows one of the worst ones. And that's without a student loan, or childcare allowances being lost. If you add those in then you will be looking at an effective tax rate of between 75% and 85%. Why would anybody bother? Totally barmy as it is the treasury who loses out in the long term by creating these disincentives. Fixing this should be their number one focus if they had any sense but they don't, obviously.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/02/2023 18:22

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 16:36

WulyJmpr
Certain people are going to be furious if/when the government increases free nursery hours

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/feb/10/treasury-considering-huge-expansion-free-childcare-england

Yes it's about time that happened as well. It's a no brainer. It pays for itself in the long term because you do not lose women (taxpayers) from the workplace who end up with such huge employment gaps that even if/ when they do rejoin many do not reach their earning (and therefore taxpaying) potential, and therefore also require more state support later in life, as well as during child-rearing years.

Countries (almost all developed ones) that heavily subsidise childcare so that it costs a maximum of a couple of hundred pounds per month don't do this out of the goodness of their hearts. They do it because it's been proved to be good economic sense.

On that subject, some of the examples in this article are relevant.

www.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/13/full-time-part-time-work-no-longer-pays-uk-economy

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 17:40

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 17:03

But you do not know what the allowance is without accurate sharing of earnings and income. And why should a woman earning less have to pay more tax proportionately than her higher earning husband because he is in a higher tax bracket? That only works if they share all earnings and lots of threads on here show it is common not to.

And no, sharing of detail would not be necessary in couples if they don't wish to. It would simply be that the tax free allowance, the amount that you can earn before higher rate tax kicks in etc is set per household. Therefore a oart of a couple your share of whatever level that is set as is half of it - regardless of what the other person earns - unless you agree otherwise to sign a form to split it differently because you decide that would be more beneficial. It would simply mean that each household gets a fair share of earnings without tax applied or at lower thresholds. It would not mean that people have to share their finances or details of them in a couple if they don't wish to, it would simply remove the unfairness of them being taxed less on the same overall income.

EasterIssland · 13/02/2023 17:36

BobSacamono · 13/02/2023 17:06

Wait wait wait. If my net salary is over 50k but pension contributions leave my gross salary under 50k pa does that mean the child benefit tax doesn’t apply?

Also money you donate

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 17:34

BobSacamono · 13/02/2023 17:06

Wait wait wait. If my net salary is over 50k but pension contributions leave my gross salary under 50k pa does that mean the child benefit tax doesn’t apply?

Yes.

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 17:33

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 17:03

But you do not know what the allowance is without accurate sharing of earnings and income. And why should a woman earning less have to pay more tax proportionately than her higher earning husband because he is in a higher tax bracket? That only works if they share all earnings and lots of threads on here show it is common not to.

She won't. She can keep her share of the household's allowance as will he. The difference will be that a lone parent isn't paying additional tax to compensate for the higher earning partner in the couple (husband in your example) paying less.

Scottishskifun · 13/02/2023 17:15

BobSacamono · 13/02/2023 17:06

Wait wait wait. If my net salary is over 50k but pension contributions leave my gross salary under 50k pa does that mean the child benefit tax doesn’t apply?

Correct it's based on your P60 which doesn't factor in pension contributions

BobSacamono · 13/02/2023 17:06

Wait wait wait. If my net salary is over 50k but pension contributions leave my gross salary under 50k pa does that mean the child benefit tax doesn’t apply?

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 17:03

But you do not know what the allowance is without accurate sharing of earnings and income. And why should a woman earning less have to pay more tax proportionately than her higher earning husband because he is in a higher tax bracket? That only works if they share all earnings and lots of threads on here show it is common not to.

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 16:50

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:46

It is not obtuse. It gives women more financial independence.

I've just explained to you why it doesn't. It actively inhibits women from being able to leave unhappy or abusive relationships.

I also explained how it could function within a relationship so that each partner by default was allocated 50% of the household allowances unless they decide to sign a document specifying a choice to the contrary. So it would not result in any loss of financial independence. It would simply remove the inequality whereby single people are taxed far more on the same household income.

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:46

It is not obtuse. It gives women more financial independence.

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 16:41

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:10

Women campaigned for years to be taxed as individuals, it used to be by household. It allows women financial independence. We should have the same with all welfare benefits.

This is also just such an obtuse comment I cannot get my head around it. If your idea was implemented then someone married to a billionnaire who decided to be a SAHP could claim universal credit. 🤣 It's very obvious that what matters is the overall household income.

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 16:36

WulyJmpr
Certain people are going to be furious if/when the government increases free nursery hours

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/feb/10/treasury-considering-huge-expansion-free-childcare-england

Yes it's about time that happened as well. It's a no brainer. It pays for itself in the long term because you do not lose women (taxpayers) from the workplace who end up with such huge employment gaps that even if/ when they do rejoin many do not reach their earning (and therefore taxpaying) potential, and therefore also require more state support later in life, as well as during child-rearing years.

Countries (almost all developed ones) that heavily subsidise childcare so that it costs a maximum of a couple of hundred pounds per month don't do this out of the goodness of their hearts. They do it because it's been proved to be good economic sense.

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 16:32

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:10

Women campaigned for years to be taxed as individuals, it used to be by household. It allows women financial independence. We should have the same with all welfare benefits.

They did but the situation was very different then: women could not own property in their own right, were very restricted with careers, had few avenues to leave abusive relationships because they could not have bank accounts or mortgages in their own names.

Things have changed and the tax system needs to reflect that. The current situation massively penalises single parents (almost all women) and actually makes it much harder for people to leave abusive relationships. It is also one of the main contributors to our very high levels of child poverty, much of which unsurprisingly occurs in the single parent households almost all headed by women who are penalised by this tax system.

The quickest and easiest way to make a huge difference to these problems would be to equalise the tax system so that income tax and all of these other thresolds are set on a household basis as they are in France, Denmark and many other countries.

Within a household with two earners it would obviously be up to them to agree how they split the allowances between them if they have separate finances, with the default being that 50% is applied to each unless they both agree otherwise. But there is no rational argument for them having double the allowances that a lone parent has, who is already doing twice the work and will therefore inevitably have higher costs.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/02/2023 16:22

WulyJmpr · 12/02/2023 19:15

Certain people are going to be furious if/when the government increases free nursery hours

www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/feb/10/treasury-considering-huge-expansion-free-childcare-england

Leaving aside the windups and shit stirring for a moment, that's a very interesting policy proposal.