Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 18:42

PugInTheHouse · 14/02/2023 18:37

Child benefit is unlikely to be the only factor in making this decision though. If it was then any increase in salary is worth it. People often say the same about going into 40% tax bracket but obviously as this is only on the bit above the limit you're still better off in most situations.

I haven't gone for promotions at my work because I would have to travel into the office more, plus would have to pay for daycare. I would be earning less based on these things, the child benefit being a sliding scale makes little difference really.

It's everyone's own decision surely but I don't really believe that people wouldn't take a promotion for having to pay back child benefit which would be below the payrise amount as it is on a sliding scale.

It isn't the only factor no, as there's the 40% tax bracket too except in Scotland where it's lower. But why do you think that means the tapered withdrawal of CB couldn't be the straw that breaks the camel's back? Your view seems to be that you don't think that so nobody could.

Ultimately, it's just not correct to generalise that people will always be better off taking the promotion. People have said that several times in the thread and it doesn't get any more true with repetition.

PugInTheHouse · 14/02/2023 18:37

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 18:13

Not only is it a generalisation that most promotions are a stepping stone, but also the financial side will depend entirely on what a person would need to do in order to get that promotion. In some cases this will include extra costs of working such as more childcare. It's certainly possible that these extra costs would be higher than the extra pay rise less 40% tax less tapered CB withdrawal.
So even if you're basing your assessment purely on finances and not factoring in the value a person ascribes to their time, which you shouldn't because people's mileage on that one varies, it's still just not correct.

Child benefit is unlikely to be the only factor in making this decision though. If it was then any increase in salary is worth it. People often say the same about going into 40% tax bracket but obviously as this is only on the bit above the limit you're still better off in most situations.

I haven't gone for promotions at my work because I would have to travel into the office more, plus would have to pay for daycare. I would be earning less based on these things, the child benefit being a sliding scale makes little difference really.

It's everyone's own decision surely but I don't really believe that people wouldn't take a promotion for having to pay back child benefit which would be below the payrise amount as it is on a sliding scale.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 18:13

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 17:44

It would be a bit short sighted to not go for a promotion just because it put you above the 50k threshold, seeing as that in another few years you're likely to be able to go to the next level up, most promotions being a stepping stone in a career. Also as it tapers off from 50-60k surely you're still better off with the pay increase, even if you do miss out on part or all of the child benefit

Not only is it a generalisation that most promotions are a stepping stone, but also the financial side will depend entirely on what a person would need to do in order to get that promotion. In some cases this will include extra costs of working such as more childcare. It's certainly possible that these extra costs would be higher than the extra pay rise less 40% tax less tapered CB withdrawal.
So even if you're basing your assessment purely on finances and not factoring in the value a person ascribes to their time, which you shouldn't because people's mileage on that one varies, it's still just not correct.

PugInTheHouse · 14/02/2023 18:13

That was worded badly, everyone earning the same household income should be able to claim it under the current system. It was only a hit for those earning over £50k when the new rule was brought in really, esp a £60k one parent family but anyone now going over the limit isn't really affected.

In reality there is no need for any benefits for people earning over £50k.

PugInTheHouse · 14/02/2023 18:10

It makes no sense to not take a job that goes over the £50k though as it is stepped from 50-60k (1% of the child benefit for every £100 over £50k I think). What seems wrong is that single parent families lose out when a household earning double still gets it, however I feel that everyone who wants to claim it should be able to regardless. It was never supposed to be a means tested benefit. It should probably be reviewed in full, doing it this way is a half arsed effort really.

Zax · 14/02/2023 18:06

JudesBiggestFan · 14/02/2023 11:27

Give me strength. Why should we all pay for your kids if your husband won't? I'm tired of the sense of entitlement. Pick better partners or if you can't do that, pursue them through the courts to make them pay. If you're earning over 50k, you don't need handouts.

Couldn't agree with you more. It's a thought process that exists widely in our society, especially amongst those with no sense of commerce, such as civil servants.

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 17:44

It would be a bit short sighted to not go for a promotion just because it put you above the 50k threshold, seeing as that in another few years you're likely to be able to go to the next level up, most promotions being a stepping stone in a career. Also as it tapers off from 50-60k surely you're still better off with the pay increase, even if you do miss out on part or all of the child benefit

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 11:52

The problem with that argument is that one of the logical consequences is some people ensuring they don't earn over 50k. Basing policy is matters like this on one's feelings about entitlement isn't particularly sensible. The question needs to be how much of a difference perverse incentives like this make, and whether we'd be objectively better off removing them or not.

It isn't such an issue when people respond by just paying extra into their pensions, indeed its arguably a net positive. When they respond by working less or not going for a promotion, however, that's when it becomes a problem.

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 11:51

@BarbaraofSeville
The arts are pretty vital to this countries economy and long term prosperity, and indirectly some of the roles save lives, through communication in the public and charity sectors.

JudesBiggestFan · 14/02/2023 11:27

Give me strength. Why should we all pay for your kids if your husband won't? I'm tired of the sense of entitlement. Pick better partners or if you can't do that, pursue them through the courts to make them pay. If you're earning over 50k, you don't need handouts.

Zax · 14/02/2023 11:20

messybutfun · 14/02/2023 08:11

@usernamealreadytaken Specifically, I was talking about nurses. Pay them to study. It‘s a nonsense that we have 150,000 vacancies yet we are not training enough. And about 30% of those that start training drop out. Why is that? It needs addressing now.

Secondly, we have a recently opened training facility for new doctors which has placements only for overseas students. Not a single place has been funded for domestic students. All the while we are short of doctors.

This is just the tip of the iceberg - it goes for pretty much any industry with a skill shortage. It’s really not about jobs the British don‘t want to do - the British need to be skilled up to do them. And they can‘t be expected to pay for it.

I take it that you're a supporter of printing more money to satisfy the nurses 20% salary increase demands?

Dobby123456 · 14/02/2023 09:37

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 09:08

But if you start paying people to study medicine / nursing where do you stop? Do people only get paid to study for 'worthy' careers?

What about the arts, could people get paid to study those too?

Seems fair enough to me. If you train to be a maths teacher, you get the fees covered, because the country is short of maths teachers. Wouldn't bother me in the least if they introduced similar incentives for nursing. Where do you stop? With the jobs that aren't short of trained applicants, of course.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 09:30

It's not like paying bursaries to people so they can study for healthcare roles, more than they'd get for doing eg English is some new untested thing we've never tried either.

BarbaraofSeville · 14/02/2023 09:15

Don't be ridiculous. The country needs medical staff and there's currently a huge shortage and for many, pay is relatively low for a graduate profession. Something has to change.

No-one's going to die if we don't have enough people studying the arts. It's a nice to have after we've satisfactorily provided a decent basic standard of living for the country's citizens.

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 09:08

But if you start paying people to study medicine / nursing where do you stop? Do people only get paid to study for 'worthy' careers?

What about the arts, could people get paid to study those too?

messybutfun · 14/02/2023 08:11

@usernamealreadytaken Specifically, I was talking about nurses. Pay them to study. It‘s a nonsense that we have 150,000 vacancies yet we are not training enough. And about 30% of those that start training drop out. Why is that? It needs addressing now.

Secondly, we have a recently opened training facility for new doctors which has placements only for overseas students. Not a single place has been funded for domestic students. All the while we are short of doctors.

This is just the tip of the iceberg - it goes for pretty much any industry with a skill shortage. It’s really not about jobs the British don‘t want to do - the British need to be skilled up to do them. And they can‘t be expected to pay for it.

usernamealreadytaken · 13/02/2023 23:04

@messybutfun
"A civilised society is one that invests in its people, especially its children. You can see where not investing in skills and charging youngsters to learn a job like nursing has got us.

We now need to import these skills at a rate of half a million a year without getting anywhere near sufficient levels. Child benefit doesn‘t even scratch the surface. It will take a whole lot more spending than £20 a week on a child to rectify the neglect and managed decline of the last 13 years."

The majority of the "skills" we have to import every year are workers in tertiary industries; jobs which domestic workers don't want to do. How do you suggest we "invest" in our young people and encourage them to do the jobs they consider too shit to bother with?

It would be fabulous to give all young people a "free" university education, but won't that just compound the problem of them not wanting to do jobs which are beneath them? Do you think we should just keep importing people from poorer countries to do the jobs we're above doing? Do you really not see a problem with this? Perhaps you'd prefer all young people to get a university education, and then for all jobs to be degree entry?

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 22:56

Yes definitely worth it if you don't have to pay it all back, of course.

Just such a stupid system and massive waste of money because effectively - given that administering the means testing costs more than paying it universally - what they have done is taken money from children and spent it on admin staff instead.

PorePatrol · 13/02/2023 22:10

Yes, if he was earning £60k I wouldn't bother. He probably will be next tax year (and I'll be FT then) at which point it will be a waste of time. The point I was trying to make (although appreciate not so clearly) is that I find it bizarre the amount of people on here saying they don't claim because their oh's earn over £50k. A tax return takes 20ish mins so unless the OH is earning £60K and not making pension contributions it is still worth claiming because you'll receive something. I think one year we repaid all but £400 but £400 for 20 min form filling is worth it for me.

Ilikepinacoladass · 13/02/2023 21:33

Well either way considering we are helping them out by producing more people I think they should help us with the financial burden.

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 21:33

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 20:21

Also there's absolutely no point in doing that. You're just making extra work for yourselves. Just tick the box to say you don't want it paid to you and then make the pension contributions for you from his salary, then you won't have to claim it and file a tax return and pay it back again, that's completely pointless.

Sorry with this I had misread and missed the part where you said he is earning under £60k so you don't pay it all back. I thought you had said he was earning £60k.

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 21:03

It really does not. Government support improves the life of children, but it makes no real difference to whether they are born or not.

Ilikepinacoladass · 13/02/2023 20:47

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 13/02/2023 20:11

I don't think child benefit raises birth rates, but the withdrawal of it incentivises some people to lower their work rate.

Not on its own no, but doing things like making it financially easier to have children in general does. And the government benefits from people having children (as previously said we are facing an aging population!)

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 20:30

I thought I was reasonably well up on this stuff, but the bit about expense refunds being considered income for UC purposes is new to me. And one of the stupidest things I've ever heard. If we weren't so desperately short of carers it'd be funny.

It's a good point about freezing thresholds. Cowardice, really. Because inflation was quite low for a long time, it didn't matter much, but now all of a sudden a lot of people, perhaps a critical mass, are feeling the impact. Some of them will tailor their decision making process accordingly.

Agreed on both counts @BashirWithTheGoodBeard , complete madness. And yet they stand there wringinf their hands saying "why is our productivity so low, why aren't people working more?". Fix the tax system and so many of the issues would go away. 🤷🏻‍♀️

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 20:21

Also there's absolutely no point in doing that. You're just making extra work for yourselves. Just tick the box to say you don't want it paid to you and then make the pension contributions for you from his salary, then you won't have to claim it and file a tax return and pay it back again, that's completely pointless.

Swipe left for the next trending thread