Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 12:24

I have nothing more to add, this is getting a bit silly and childish TBH. I value everyone's opinions but this is getting a but yes it is, no it isn't over and over again. I am always up for a debate but nothing new is being discussed.

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 12:23

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 12:12

Erm, it's never great when people think someone disagreeing with them is awkwardness!

You're obviously not just talking about the OP, and neither is the poster I quoted, because you both referred to circumstances that are different to hers. She's already had her promotion, it's happened, and she hasn't mentioned refusing it or not going for it. But both you and the poster we're responding to here did. And that's fine, the discussion had clearly progressed to the way people in different circumstances might respond to the possibility of CB withdrawal. But let's not pretend that's not what we were doing.

In terms of extra childcare: this will depend, which has always been my point. Some promotions require extra hours. In this respect, they're actually the same as working more hours. The problem is that some of you seem to have substituted your own value judgements, which you can't really do if you're also arguing that there's lots of differences in circumstances.

Ultimately, the problem is with generalisation.

But essentially you aren't actually disagreeing, I feel like you are generalising more than me, i have said that situations vary and you have made similar points to me, but are also insisting that the stepped loss of CB makes you worse off if you earn more, which frankly isn't true in all cases. That is what i am referring to.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 12:12

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 12:00

I just feel like you are going purposely awkward. Yes I have said there might be lots of factors involved, but then again there may not be. I have given examples that I believe to be relevant in different circumstances. I don't understand your problem to be honest.

Why do you need extra childcare for a payrise on the face of it. OP has not mentioned that so it's relevant about looking at just the CB. I also commented that I wouldn't take a promotion as I would have to go into the office so it would cost me more. They are 2 different scenarios so not sure why you keep linking them.

Working extra shifts is something totally different also

Erm, it's never great when people think someone disagreeing with them is awkwardness!

You're obviously not just talking about the OP, and neither is the poster I quoted, because you both referred to circumstances that are different to hers. She's already had her promotion, it's happened, and she hasn't mentioned refusing it or not going for it. But both you and the poster we're responding to here did. And that's fine, the discussion had clearly progressed to the way people in different circumstances might respond to the possibility of CB withdrawal. But let's not pretend that's not what we were doing.

In terms of extra childcare: this will depend, which has always been my point. Some promotions require extra hours. In this respect, they're actually the same as working more hours. The problem is that some of you seem to have substituted your own value judgements, which you can't really do if you're also arguing that there's lots of differences in circumstances.

Ultimately, the problem is with generalisation.

Newnamenewme23 · 15/02/2023 12:04

Surely though if you’re offered a promotion with different working conditions, hours etc then you consider that based on any extra childcare/work life balance, commute etc and decide whether it’s worth it.

£130 child benefit wouldn’t be a dealbreaker or even a consideration.

if you turn down a payrise soley because you’ll lose child benefit as pp’s have suggested then that’s very strange.

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 12:00

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 11:55

Both you and the poster you quote here have engaged in discussion of other factors and examples, making it quite clear that you were talking about the wider population as well as the OP. This insistence that you only mean OP has only come after it's been pointed out that several of the points you've both made (people on NMW, your value judgement on what people 'should' do and on whether it's plausible that they'd think differently to you etc) are irrelevant.

And you actually do yourself down with the insistence that assessing whether a person would be better off purely based on CB withdrawal and no other factor could possibly be relevant, because it's such an obviously silly way to assess the issue. As if anyone is going to say well, I'll still get more in my wage packet and reduced CB in combination so the extra childcare costs are entirely irrelevant to my assessment of whether going for the pay rise/doing the extra shift is worth it.

Second paragraph- fine, but the fact that some people would be better off only furthers the point that circumstances vary far too much for the generalisations made to be correct.

I just feel like you are going purposely awkward. Yes I have said there might be lots of factors involved, but then again there may not be. I have given examples that I believe to be relevant in different circumstances. I don't understand your problem to be honest.

Why do you need extra childcare for a payrise on the face of it. OP has not mentioned that so it's relevant about looking at just the CB. I also commented that I wouldn't take a promotion as I would have to go into the office so it would cost me more. They are 2 different scenarios so not sure why you keep linking them.

Working extra shifts is something totally different also

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 11:55

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 11:36

Its factually not wrong FFS. The OP is not talking about anything else, just CB. Financially you will not be worse off factoring in only CB. It's not an opinion. If you take into account other factors then you may be worse off.

At my organisation most people would be better off with their promotions as only the pay/responsibilities change. Its a professional career so everyone already studying towards qualification already so literally will just be paid more. For me I had some specific work base changes more local to me so I would have to change base hence additional costs to me if I took the next promotion. Loss of child benefit doesn't make me worse off.

Both you and the poster you quote here have engaged in discussion of other factors and examples, making it quite clear that you were talking about the wider population as well as the OP. This insistence that you only mean OP has only come after it's been pointed out that several of the points you've both made (people on NMW, your value judgement on what people 'should' do and on whether it's plausible that they'd think differently to you etc) are irrelevant.

And you actually do yourself down with the insistence that assessing whether a person would be better off purely based on CB withdrawal and no other factor could possibly be relevant, because it's such an obviously silly way to assess the issue. As if anyone is going to say well, I'll still get more in my wage packet and reduced CB in combination so the extra childcare costs are entirely irrelevant to my assessment of whether going for the pay rise/doing the extra shift is worth it.

Second paragraph- fine, but the fact that some people would be better off only furthers the point that circumstances vary far too much for the generalisations made to be correct.

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 11:36

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 06:55

And it's wrong.

Its factually not wrong FFS. The OP is not talking about anything else, just CB. Financially you will not be worse off factoring in only CB. It's not an opinion. If you take into account other factors then you may be worse off.

At my organisation most people would be better off with their promotions as only the pay/responsibilities change. Its a professional career so everyone already studying towards qualification already so literally will just be paid more. For me I had some specific work base changes more local to me so I would have to change base hence additional costs to me if I took the next promotion. Loss of child benefit doesn't make me worse off.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 06:55

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 22:28

'still be better off financially' - in regard to CB! That is what this thread is about.

And it's wrong.

Ilikepinacoladass · 15/02/2023 06:23

TheLostGiraffe · 15/02/2023 01:57

A promotion doesn't always mean more childcare costs? In the OP they were just getting a payrise, not working more hours

Try reading the post I responded to.

Huh?

'Some people take a promotion without all these additional costs, if they are at the same office, same hours.'

'Ah yes of course they do. The ones who don't have to pay additional childcare costs because there is a SAHP taking care of "all of that". I.e. 98% men. Ok then.'

The post you responded to was talking about cases where a promotion didn't mean more hours or different office, that's why they are not paying additional childcare, not because there's a SAHP..

TheLostGiraffe · 15/02/2023 01:57

A promotion doesn't always mean more childcare costs? In the OP they were just getting a payrise, not working more hours

Try reading the post I responded to.

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 22:28

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 20:12

And once again, that's a bad point.

There's no 'you will be better off financially' about it, because the things that some people will need to do in order to get into that position will financially outweigh the increase in salary.

Your view on whether the loss of child benefit isn't a big factor is also not the determinative one. There are going to be some people for whom the amount they'd get after the higher rate tax etc would still make it worthwhile for them but their value judgement is that the CB loss is the point at which the effort outweighs the reward. They'll act based on their value judgement, not yours. It isn't for you to decide that someone else is short sighted.

'still be better off financially' - in regard to CB! That is what this thread is about.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 20:12

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 19:57

There are lots of considerations whether to take a promotion/ work more. Financial, family, career etc etc . My point, and topic of this thread, is that child benefit decreasing isn't a big factor because the financial difference is negligible as it tapers off the more you earn, and you will still be better of financially than if you didn't take earn more.

And once again, that's a bad point.

There's no 'you will be better off financially' about it, because the things that some people will need to do in order to get into that position will financially outweigh the increase in salary.

Your view on whether the loss of child benefit isn't a big factor is also not the determinative one. There are going to be some people for whom the amount they'd get after the higher rate tax etc would still make it worthwhile for them but their value judgement is that the CB loss is the point at which the effort outweighs the reward. They'll act based on their value judgement, not yours. It isn't for you to decide that someone else is short sighted.

PugInTheHouse · 14/02/2023 20:07

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 19:41

Ah yes of course they do. The ones who don't have to pay additional childcare costs because there is a SAHP taking care of "all of that". I.e. 98% men. Ok then.

This makes no sense at all TBH. I've given my opinion, which is what MN is all about, I don't need to argue over and over again about irrelevant points.

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 20:00

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 19:41

Ah yes of course they do. The ones who don't have to pay additional childcare costs because there is a SAHP taking care of "all of that". I.e. 98% men. Ok then.

A promotion doesn't always mean more childcare costs? In the OP they were just getting a payrise, not working more hours

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 19:57

There are lots of considerations whether to take a promotion/ work more. Financial, family, career etc etc . My point, and topic of this thread, is that child benefit decreasing isn't a big factor because the financial difference is negligible as it tapers off the more you earn, and you will still be better of financially than if you didn't take earn more.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 19:41

PugInTheHouse · 14/02/2023 19:06

The original post was talking about purely the loss of child benefit being over £50k so it is relevant. The increase in salary IS higher than the loss of child benefit, the increase in other costs relating to a potential promotion are a separate discussion. Some people take a promotion without all these additional costs, if they are at the same office, same hours. That's not particularly unusual.

Ah yes of course they do. The ones who don't have to pay additional childcare costs because there is a SAHP taking care of "all of that". I.e. 98% men. Ok then.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 19:31

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 19:21

And whether that means people will be a factor in people deciding not to not work more / take promotions.

There are a myriad of considerations for taking a promotion.

My point is that the CB tapering off isn't a big one of them.

It's a bad point. Because what you actually mean is that it wouldn't be for you and you don't think it should be for others. You can't substitute your own value judgement for the ones other people might make.

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 19:21

And whether that means people will be a factor in people deciding not to not work more / take promotions.

There are a myriad of considerations for taking a promotion.

My point is that the CB tapering off isn't a big one of them.

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 19:19

Those comments were in the context of a thread about child benefit decreasing after 50k

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 19:16

The direct quotes that I take issue with from both of you are here:

Also as it tapers off from 50-60k surely you're still better off with the pay increase, even if you do miss out on part or all of the child benefit

It makes no sense to not take a job that goes over the £50k though as it is stepped from 50-60k (1% of the child benefit for every £100 over £50k I think).

Both of these are wrong because they're based on generalisations and only half of the picture. You cannot say that you're better off with the pay increase because even assuming you mean financially only, that leaves out any extra costs that might need to be incurred to get it. Nor can you say it makes no sense not to take the job because the withdrawal is incremental, for the same reasons.

It's absolutely not a generalised conversation about working in general being worthwhile, it's a conversation about whether it will be for some people who are going to lose child benefit. That isn't the same thing. There's a bottleneck at 50-60k, particularly for those with dependent children, and the existence of that bottleneck makes it different to other decisions people might make where there's no bottleneck.

Nor does the fact that some people can get a promotion (or a wage increase without a promotion) without any extra costs negate the fact that others can't. It's not either/or.

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 19:07

Of course it is a separate consideration, you're turning it into a more generalised conversation about working more being worth it or not, when the original thread was about benefits (child benefit to be specific)

PugInTheHouse · 14/02/2023 19:06

The original post was talking about purely the loss of child benefit being over £50k so it is relevant. The increase in salary IS higher than the loss of child benefit, the increase in other costs relating to a potential promotion are a separate discussion. Some people take a promotion without all these additional costs, if they are at the same office, same hours. That's not particularly unusual.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 18:56

PugInTheHouse · 14/02/2023 18:51

No my view isn't that at all. I said child benefit on its on shouldn't be an issue, piled on top of other things is different. But let's not forget we are talking £50k+ salaries here, not minimum wage.

I haven't said you are always better off taking the promotion, I said taking into account paying back child benefit you would be. I have said I wouldn't take promotion due to all the other factors which would make me worse off, these things aren't stepped they are literally just paying out more expenses to take a promotion.

It sounds here like you're saying that the increase in salary will be higher than the decrease in child benefit? If that's all you're looking at, you're doing it wrong. Half the picture and completely pointless. @Ilikepinacoladass is wrong to say they're a separate consideration.

I'm not sure where this 'should' has come from either. Who decided that, and why are the people for whom it would be an issue in the wrong about their priorities? The fact that we're not talking about people on NMW is irrelevant: you presumably don't think people who aren't on NMW don't weigh up whether they think a particular course of action is financially worthwhile for them or not.

Ultimately, some of you seem to be attributing far too much weight to your own personal calls about what's sensible and worth it.

Ilikepinacoladass · 14/02/2023 18:53

PugInTheHouse · 14/02/2023 18:37

Child benefit is unlikely to be the only factor in making this decision though. If it was then any increase in salary is worth it. People often say the same about going into 40% tax bracket but obviously as this is only on the bit above the limit you're still better off in most situations.

I haven't gone for promotions at my work because I would have to travel into the office more, plus would have to pay for daycare. I would be earning less based on these things, the child benefit being a sliding scale makes little difference really.

It's everyone's own decision surely but I don't really believe that people wouldn't take a promotion for having to pay back child benefit which would be below the payrise amount as it is on a sliding scale.

Exactly this! The extra expenses for working more (travel / childcare etc) would exist with or without the benefit and are a separate consideration.

They would be the much bigger factor I think than the slight reduction of benefits

PugInTheHouse · 14/02/2023 18:51

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 18:42

It isn't the only factor no, as there's the 40% tax bracket too except in Scotland where it's lower. But why do you think that means the tapered withdrawal of CB couldn't be the straw that breaks the camel's back? Your view seems to be that you don't think that so nobody could.

Ultimately, it's just not correct to generalise that people will always be better off taking the promotion. People have said that several times in the thread and it doesn't get any more true with repetition.

No my view isn't that at all. I said child benefit on its on shouldn't be an issue, piled on top of other things is different. But let's not forget we are talking £50k+ salaries here, not minimum wage.

I haven't said you are always better off taking the promotion, I said taking into account paying back child benefit you would be. I have said I wouldn't take promotion due to all the other factors which would make me worse off, these things aren't stepped they are literally just paying out more expenses to take a promotion.

Swipe left for the next trending thread