Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
Weedoormatnomore · 05/02/2023 20:08

Someone else may have said it already as not read all the reply. The £50k is based on your gross pay less pension payments. The tax is not paid till the following year ! So income earned 6th April 22 to 5th April 23 is paid by 31st Jan 24 unless a sole trader with a different year end.

Fireingrate · 05/02/2023 20:07

YANBU and disgusted that two thirds of voters here think you are.

A couple with an income of £90k would get full CB but you don’t. The poorly handled changes to CB are an utter example of political cowardice.

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 20:06

I'm really grateful for all the detailed replies setting out what my next steps need to be Thanks.

I've gone on the government calculator and put in my new gross pay as if it were my pay for the whole year and it says I would owe about £450 now. So ok less than a third (ish) of my total and but not something I can afford to just pay out so means I'd be better off just not having it. And the site says pension paid before tax can't be deducted so my teachers' pension contributions won't count. Bit sickening to say the least.

To everyone who thinks I'm a loaded whiner or something, I may be the latter but justifiably I think and I'm definitely not the former. To think I've worked my arse off to get a promotion and finally got a piddly pay rise after years of a freeze and I'm going to be losing out is absolutely gut-wrenching. Hopefully my standard of living might just about stay where it is rather than falling despite what looks like on paper a decent rise. Fucking great.

OP posts:
youshouldnthaveasked · 05/02/2023 20:04

How much do you think you’ll have to pay back? We’re currently paying back child tax credits and have a payment plan

Plbrookes · 05/02/2023 20:04

minihitch · 05/02/2023 19:58

So OP is whining that they got a payrise which means that she, on a relatively high salary, gets a little less of the money we pay in tax. And has the sense of entitlement to blame this on it being a 'shithole country'. I guess something, or someone, is full of shit, and it's not the UK

the op pays tax too....

Yes ... and why is that relevant? She is the beneficiary of transfer payments funded by people on (less than) a quarter of what she earns. Maybe she should spend more time working on stopping her school being a 'shithole' school and less time whining about how she deserves more of lower-paid people's money.

Madreb · 05/02/2023 20:04

I'm exactly the same. UPS3 plus tlr, extra duties and i did some examining. But pension keeps me well under the threshold for higher rate and CBenefit deductions.

LittleOwl153 · 05/02/2023 20:02

You can log o to the hmrc system if you have your p60/payslip to hand and it will tell you what is classed as income each month the payroll has been run/reported.

Reigateforever · 05/02/2023 20:01

This is the new hidden tax trap, wages have gone up but not the tax levels.

DividedHouses · 05/02/2023 20:01

I know this is missing the point of the thread and I am sorry but to me, it sounds like you must be super-busy and super-stressed right now OP. You're a teacher, so you're obviously well-educated and likely you have to be better organized than the rest of us. So I think you must be overwhelmed at the moment to have to post on mumsnet that you can't work this out by putting your salary into the online calculator and understanding you don't include the portion of your salary that you pay to pension. I am also completely shit at understanding money (it panics me how much I don't understand) and if I can understand these things and you can't, I wonder if you're overwhelmed and tired and I just wanted to give you flowers and hope you can get a break and a cup of tea.

I agree with everyone else the stupid 49k per person is outrageously discriminatory against single parents and also stupid

[as you were, off-topic post that expresses sympathy to OP concluded]

ThinWomansBrain · 05/02/2023 19:58

@madamovaries if you pension is under a salary sacrifice scheme, you will have consented to that, so you should have received the relevant documentation and explanations.

To simplify numbers - you gross pay before pension and salary sacrifice, is £60k, and the pension deduction is 10%.
Instead of your gross salary being shown as £5k per month, with a £500 pension deduction, your payslip shows gross earnings of £4.5k, so the amount to be considered for CB threshold purposes is £4.5k x 12, not £60k.

minihitch · 05/02/2023 19:58

So OP is whining that they got a payrise which means that she, on a relatively high salary, gets a little less of the money we pay in tax. And has the sense of entitlement to blame this on it being a 'shithole country'. I guess something, or someone, is full of shit, and it's not the UK

the op pays tax too....

Wingingit11 · 05/02/2023 19:58

WulyJmpr · 05/02/2023 19:55

Also, people saying that CB should be based on household income...

  1. households with 2 workers approaching £100k household income are just as in need of child benefit as we are paying through the nose for full time childcare. We also pay an awful lot through taxation so not exactly sponging.

  2. This assumes households share finances which is not necessarily true.

Child benefit should be universal as it's fundamentally unaffordable to raise kids before primary school age (NB assumes the government would like this country to continue existing)

I also had to pay through the nose for nursery as a single parent 🙄

Plbrookes · 05/02/2023 19:55

Dobby123456 · 05/02/2023 19:28

Why are people so nasty! This is fecking mumsnet, where mums (you know, those people who produce and raise children!) look for advice. They would give her 'free money' if she was living with another lower earner, even if their net income was well over the threshold, so why discriminate against one-income households?

Why are people so stupid? OP is an entitled whiner regardless of the past performance of her uterus.

Rollonspring23 · 05/02/2023 19:55

Drives me absolutely nuts that it’s not based on household income and that households with an income of £99k can still claim it. Also drives me mad that the ‘tax’ on the between £50k and £60k can’t be sorted out without having to do a tax return. We’ve just realised we need to pay back 100 percent of this last years due to an unforeseen bonus. It acts like an extra tax on that 50k to 60k bracket which wouldn’t grate do much if households earning 99k across two earners weren’t still getting to claim full child benefit. It’s maddening!!

WulyJmpr · 05/02/2023 19:55

Also, people saying that CB should be based on household income...

  1. households with 2 workers approaching £100k household income are just as in need of child benefit as we are paying through the nose for full time childcare. We also pay an awful lot through taxation so not exactly sponging.

  2. This assumes households share finances which is not necessarily true.

Child benefit should be universal as it's fundamentally unaffordable to raise kids before primary school age (NB assumes the government would like this country to continue existing)

WishingMyLifeAway · 05/02/2023 19:54

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 17:25

So it doesn't look like I owe anything at the moment as a result of the pension contributions. But when does the tax year run from? I thought it was April-April but seeing references to October? Also, I do exam marking so I suppose that is no longer as lucrative as will have to watch that it doesn't take me over, which is difficult as you don't actually know how much you have earnt until you get it. In addition, I have just been promoted. I think my new pay will not come into force until the March payslip, or even if it does make February it won't be the full month. It just feels like as soon as I have done something to improve my situation, it starts being taken away...

Sympathy to anyone else in similar position!

Just pay any income that takes you over £50,000 into your pension (if you can increase the amount that is paid into your work's pension to cover the amount as that means you'll pay less NI - assuming your pension is salary sacrifice) before the end of the tax year (5th April).

You'll then keep your child benefit and the contributions into your pension will receive tax relief. Win win.

ThinWomansBrain · 05/02/2023 19:49

So, the amount I quoted is before any deductions, which is gross income isnt it? So is it as simple as adding all my pension contributions up and if they bring my take home pay below £50k (they will) then I don't have to do anything?
One of the first responses gave links to the govt website - explaining that it's based on gross taxable income. That is very different to take home pay
"Your adjusted net income is your total taxable income before any allowances" the govt website also includes a tax calculator.

And yes, the tax year runs from April to March - So if your increase was in October, that's 6 months of 49k and 6 months at £52k pro rata - so £50.5k across the year, gross before your pension contribution. If your employee contribution is 10%, that's £5,050, so will put you well below the threshold, and probably will next year, depending on the 2023 pay award.

As a pp says, you'll get full year figures on your P60 - likely to be April or May. You can also look at the Year to date figures on you January payslip and add on two months (for Feb and March) to see what the full year will be.

madamovaries · 05/02/2023 19:49

I think it’s incredibly unfair that it’s not based on household income. But have always thought there’s a second problem too. Imagine the women in abusive relationships where their partner earns a lot but the woman has no access to it - the whole point of giving it to all mothers was that they had some money in their pocket. I don’t actually think it should be means tested at all for this reason.

anyway, as for your situation, it is rubbish and I am hugely sympathetic. You haven’t missed a deadline though - it’ll be the next tax year where you’ll have to pay some of it back.
I’ve had to do this because I had a mat leave so qualified, then earned too much in a full year of working when I went back so had to pay some back, but there is a time lag, so you’ll be ok

best of luck x

WulyJmpr · 05/02/2023 19:49

BugsyDrakeTableScape · 05/02/2023 17:05

It's a sliding scale from £50k to £60k on terms of tax. You need to earn the money in the tax year you're claiming in so if you got the rise in November then you won"t earn the £52k in full until the next tax year, and then you need to file a self assessment on the October afterwards. There is an online calculator where you can put your details in and it tells you approx how much tax you'll pay and when you need to do it.

There are ways to bring your calculated earnings down - for example looking at gift aid contributions or pension contributions - but just be careful as if you're already claiming a tax break on them (for example salary sacrifice pension) then you won't be able to claim it for CB purposes.

We've just been through the same process and it is a minefield

Hi there,

Can you link to any evidence on salary sacrificed pension payments not counting towards reducing Adjusted Net Income for child benefit purposes?

Thanks

Ariautec · 05/02/2023 19:47

Stupid system with many pitfalls.

I claimed CB as a single parent earning less than the threshold, then my partner moved in. He earned just over the threshold, taking him into the self assessment system - not their DF who paid very little CM, just a man that wasn't responsible for my teens.

The self assessment was a nightmare to sort, including getting out of it, when my CB stopped. I didn't get any money and partner was still receiving tax demands.

JoKy · 05/02/2023 19:43

Try and speak to HMRC. They are usually very helpful. As soon as I reached the 52k in salary I got sent a self assessment letter for the relevant tax year.
It is unfair they way that this is calculated and I empathise. Hopefully your pension will help with keeping you below the threshold. Mine actually did but I do pay a fair bit in.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 05/02/2023 19:33

However, the CB income threshold has been frozen since it was introduced ten years ago (by a Labour government)

In 2013?

TreePorcupine · 05/02/2023 19:32

Following the introduction of independent taxation in 1990 it was no longer possible to include joint income assessments for the likes of child benefit and therefore the situation of apparent inequity highlighted by the OP was established.

www.europeantax.blog/post/102fv8r/what-does-independent-taxation-mean

There are obviously pros and cons to this change of tax status but the removal of universal child benefit in 2013 and the introduction of a salary ceiling in conjunction with independent taxation has caused situations like this.

Don't forget that the average full time salary in the UK is around £38,500 and CB is fully available up to £50k so that ought to cover higher than average incomes.

However, the CB income threshold has been frozen since it was introduced ten years ago (by a Labour government) when the average UK salary was less than £30,000. Consequently, CB is no longer as widely available to the population.

Whether the threshold is right is clearly debatable, especially now when personal tax thresholds are frozen for five years during a cost of living crisis. It is very large stealth tax for some people and a large increase in some people's personal marginal tax rate which is hard to stomach.

It's obviously also a disincentive to developing a career and earning more money if a disproportionate level of a salary increase is absorbed by higher taxation/reduced benefits.

EasterIssland · 05/02/2023 19:32

Can you pay money on your pension. So that it doesn’t increase by much. As the money that is taken into account is without this
also last year I earnt 52k and I had to return 110. It’s more the hassle of having to do self assessment that is a pain

Oochiewalla · 05/02/2023 19:32

As far as I’m aware pension contributions only count if they are not taken directly from wages, as they already have tax relief applied. The system is deeply flawed. We have a total household income of 70k and had to pay £844 back. I’ve since cancelled receiving child benefit as the extra £140 a month isn’t worth paying a lump sum in January.

Swipe left for the next trending thread