Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
Sausagemogg · 06/02/2023 08:42

Symposium123 · 05/02/2023 20:36

As others have said, it’s unfair as a family where one parent works might earn £60k per year and receive no child benefit. Another family where both work and earn £98k combined would receive full child benefit.

But in the case of a SAHP in likelihood the one working would earn over the threshold if that's the issue regardless of what the other one earns if they were back at work. As it's a decision people make they shouldn't be treated the same as single parents who are running a household on one wage for reasons largely out of their control, no.

Plbrookes · 06/02/2023 07:45

Dobby123456 · 06/02/2023 07:06

I read it as she's generally fed up with the state of the country - teacher strikes etc. I know how hard teachers have to work to get promoted, so I can kind if understand her being disappointed that she's got a pay rise only to lose it all again.

She hasn't 'lost it all again'. She receives child benefit but at a tapering rate. And if teachers are whining it's a 'shithole' country because teachers are on strike ... isn't there something they could do to solve that?

Dobby123456 · 06/02/2023 07:06

Plbrookes · 06/02/2023 06:47

I'm not arguing for the current system. I'm pointing out that OP is an entitled whiner for describing the UK as a 'shithole country' because well-paid people like her find their state benefits, funded in part by lower earners, tapering off.

I read it as she's generally fed up with the state of the country - teacher strikes etc. I know how hard teachers have to work to get promoted, so I can kind if understand her being disappointed that she's got a pay rise only to lose it all again.

Augend23 · 06/02/2023 06:57

I know it's not a now issue as you have concluded you are still eligible, but if you end up in a situation where you would owe some of the money back, maybe you'd be better off saving the child benefit (rather than not claiming it at all, as you'd be in the same place income wise by saving it) so that when you do pay it back you have the cash there and whatever is leftover forms an emergency fund/reduces the proportion of it you have to save the next year? Would seem a better use of cash than not claiming it at all?

Plbrookes · 06/02/2023 06:47

Dobby123456 · 06/02/2023 06:27

She might be better off than some, but isn't it just objectively unfair that the system favours two-income households? Are the people with a joint income £90K still taking child benefits not the people you should be aiming your ire at?

I'm not arguing for the current system. I'm pointing out that OP is an entitled whiner for describing the UK as a 'shithole country' because well-paid people like her find their state benefits, funded in part by lower earners, tapering off.

Dobby123456 · 06/02/2023 06:27

Plbrookes · 05/02/2023 19:55

Why are people so stupid? OP is an entitled whiner regardless of the past performance of her uterus.

She might be better off than some, but isn't it just objectively unfair that the system favours two-income households? Are the people with a joint income £90K still taking child benefits not the people you should be aiming your ire at?

GCWorkNightmare · 06/02/2023 06:16

speciall · 05/02/2023 20:54

There is specific script that they say you cannot include pension monthly contribution from your employer which gets deducted from your salary. I read again and again

That’s because the taxable pay figure on your P60 has already taken that into account.

Plbrookes · 06/02/2023 05:07

messybutfun · 05/02/2023 22:15

Financially speaking, anyone earning less than £37k (last time I looked) is not a net tax contributor. This is of course based on the average and, on an individual level, entirely dependent on which services you use.

Interesting but irrelevant. Every income-tax payer's tax goes into a pot used to (partly) fund benefits and public services. Anyone paying income tax can rightly say that some of the money they pay is used to fund child benefit payments such as those claimed by the entitled OP.

AllOutofEverything · 06/02/2023 00:35

@TreePorcupine It was introduced by the Conservatives

TreePorcupine · 06/02/2023 00:15

However, the CB income threshold has been frozen since it was introduced ten years ago (by a Labour government)

In 2013?

Correct. The threshold has not been increased in 10 years!

messybutfun · 05/02/2023 22:28

@boatingforthestars Some people will suggest paying more into your pension or other salary sacrifice schemes, in theory it's a good idea but bearing in mind you're in the 40% bracket you'll only be giving back 40% of it.
So if you bumped up your pension payments you'd be paying 2k a year out to save about £500.... the maths don't work.

Of course you are putting the money into your pension, that is something you need to include in your maths.
As for the 40% comment, I don‘t know what you are trying to say.

Circe7 · 05/02/2023 22:19

I don't think people understand quite how financially disadvantaged single parents are by the tax system and how society is set up.

I'm a single parent and make £74k which works out at about £4100 per month. But my childcare costs are £1700 / month. So I'm left with £2400.

This is less than two people on full time minimum wage who would make about £2800 net between them and also generally be entitled to some benefits, help with costs of childcare, child benefit etc.

And my job is far more than full time hours and I have less time available than a two parent family would between them to maintain the house, clean etc. My costs are not all that different to a two parent family. Slightly lower food and clothes costs and 25% council tax discount.

I'm not expecting sympathy or government handouts on my wage but you can be on a very high wage as a single parent and not be particularly well off.

Many single parents also find the child maintenance system ineffective or even if they do manage to claim child maintenance the amount they get in no way reflects the cost of raising a child.

So I understand being annoyed that the one benefit which you thought you might be entitled to may be taken away when a couple who is much better off than you can claim it. It would be easy to tweak the system so that single parents earning up to £100k could claim child benefit but there clearly isn't the political will, in the same way that there isn't the political will to sort out the CMS.

messybutfun · 05/02/2023 22:15

Plbrookes · 05/02/2023 20:04

Yes ... and why is that relevant? She is the beneficiary of transfer payments funded by people on (less than) a quarter of what she earns. Maybe she should spend more time working on stopping her school being a 'shithole' school and less time whining about how she deserves more of lower-paid people's money.

Financially speaking, anyone earning less than £37k (last time I looked) is not a net tax contributor. This is of course based on the average and, on an individual level, entirely dependent on which services you use.

piedbeauty · 05/02/2023 22:02

Thatsnotmybee · 05/02/2023 17:02

I do think it's mad that a couple earning £49k each can claim it, but a lone parent has to pay it back. It should be based on household income.

This. Totally stupid, totally unfair.

Whenharrymetsmelly · 05/02/2023 21:52

fitzwilliamdarcy · 05/02/2023 21:03

I’d do away with child benefit altogether. If childcare is the problem, tackle that. If wages are too low, tackle that. If housing costs are too high. tackle that. Giving households with a child in them money just because there’s a child in them is bonkers.

Agree

CandleInTheStorm · 05/02/2023 21:35

Plbrookes · 05/02/2023 21:27

It is means tested! You get it up to £50k then it tapers down to zero at £60k.

I meant in the same way universal credit is via household, etc. Child benefit entitlement is set far too high. They should lump it in with universal credit for low earners and make it based on household income.

Plbrookes · 05/02/2023 21:27

CandleInTheStorm · 05/02/2023 21:09

It is strange how every other child related benefit is means tested, but child benefit gets paid to individuals, whether they are single or not, to people earning salaries of 50k plus! It should be scrapped and become part of the Universal credit element.

It is means tested! You get it up to £50k then it tapers down to zero at £60k.

Hellybelly84 · 05/02/2023 21:11

WulyJmpr · 05/02/2023 20:55

The single parent argument aside (as in, it is going to be fundamentally more difficult to raise children on one income rather than two), I am slightly horrified at the level of comments wanting household income to be assessed rather than on an individual basis. If we want equal rights and equal opportunities for women we should not be encouraging or even bringing up this idea.

The fact is that men tend to be the higher earners still to this day, so assessing child benefit entitlement based on household income would incentivise women to leave/stay out of the workplace, or take less senior positions. It would increase the gender pay gap when this has been reducing.

As a household with 2 high earners it would feel to me like a slippery slope anything to do with my finances being affected by my husband's earnings. It smacks of the 50s when wives would be asked by banks for their husband's permission to take out mortgages etc.

Child benefit should be universal. Or even better child care should be free or heavily subsidised then we would not need child benefit. It should also have increased with inflation but has instead stagnated in real terms for years. Let's not fall into the Tory trap of pitting people against one another and instead see the bigger picture- that raising children is far too expensive in this country.

What about wanting to see your kids in the early years and not be punished for raising them? Isnt that something we should encourage aswell as supporting women who want to get straight back to work? It shouldn’t be one or the other.

My Husband worked extra (taking overtime when he could) so I had the option to do that. We have no family near us to help either, so it would have been off to nursery at 9 months and my salary really wouldn’t have been worth it with that. I think most people would at least choose to spend more time with their kids in the early years if possible. I went back to work as soon as mine were both in pre-school/school and I dont intend to stop working until I imagine mid 60’s/70! My Husband earning over the threshold, meant no CB even though I wasn’t earning and looking after a baby and a pre-schooler.

Why dont they at least not punish women who stay at home for the early years and say every family gets child benefit whilst the child is under school age?

CandleInTheStorm · 05/02/2023 21:09

fitzwilliamdarcy · 05/02/2023 21:03

I’d do away with child benefit altogether. If childcare is the problem, tackle that. If wages are too low, tackle that. If housing costs are too high. tackle that. Giving households with a child in them money just because there’s a child in them is bonkers.

It is strange how every other child related benefit is means tested, but child benefit gets paid to individuals, whether they are single or not, to people earning salaries of 50k plus! It should be scrapped and become part of the Universal credit element.

TheHateIsNotGood · 05/02/2023 21:04

Maybe you could explain your dilemma to all the teachers that feel underpaid? So, what you're saying is, that as a Teacher you're paid too much to claim child benefit?

That somewhat contradicts the 'poor teachers' message pumped out by the media.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 05/02/2023 21:03

I’d do away with child benefit altogether. If childcare is the problem, tackle that. If wages are too low, tackle that. If housing costs are too high. tackle that. Giving households with a child in them money just because there’s a child in them is bonkers.

Sumlove · 05/02/2023 21:01

Love that people think that because you earn £50k, you should not feel aggrieved at households with twice the income receiving CB when you can't or it is reduced. Either make it fair - ie £50k whether it is a single parent or household, or universal for everyone. Current system is blatantly unfair!

speciall · 05/02/2023 20:58

Sorry meant to be writing Pension contribution by you to employer's pension scheme

Hellybelly84 · 05/02/2023 20:58

AllOutofEverything · 05/02/2023 20:49

@Hellybelly84 It is above average household income.

The average salary is over 30k. She is a single parent paying for everything. I agree shes not earning pittance, but surely the system is totally flawed if 2 people earning almost 100k can still get it.

If 52k is a brilliant household income, then why dont the government cap CB when your whole household earns over 50k?

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 05/02/2023 20:56

ditalini · 05/02/2023 17:32

1st April to 31st March.

Sorry, it's actually 6th April to 5th April following year.