Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
CandleInTheStorm · 07/02/2023 12:57

Newnamenewme23 · 07/02/2023 11:26

Agree.

take the promotion, shove any extra into a private pension until the kids turn 18.

benefit from extra pension, and you won’t lose out longer term when the kids are 18.

plus you also haven’t stepped off the promotion track and slowed your career down.

unless you plan to retire as soon as CB ends, why turn down extra pension and this/future promotions?

madness. And all for £130 a month (2 children). not worth damaging careers for.

I agree too. Bonkers to stall in career for the sake of CB.

There's always going to be a cut-off somewhere where people just on the cusp are going to feel miffed, but that's where long-term thinking comes into play. I felt like that when I lost tax credits because I went for a promotion, but my long term prospects are much better!

I still earn 20k less than the op as a single parent so not quite sure she's griping about this so much. 50k even for a single parent is a good income!

Newnamenewme23 · 07/02/2023 11:26

GoodChat · 07/02/2023 11:08

I have a few friends who are in this exact position and husband didn't go for promotion because it would have tipped them too far.
One set of friends she is on 43k her husband is on 48k so combined is 91k. Scotland the 40% tax bracket kicks in much earlier as well so for them to then lose a chunk of child benefit for 2 children it simply wasn't worth it.

This is such a batshit way of looking at things. The children won't be children forever. It's better to take the promotion and keep increasing your income (even if you don't see any difference) because as soon as the kids turn 18 they're losing that money anyway and will be better off with the promotion money in the long run.

Agree.

take the promotion, shove any extra into a private pension until the kids turn 18.

benefit from extra pension, and you won’t lose out longer term when the kids are 18.

plus you also haven’t stepped off the promotion track and slowed your career down.

unless you plan to retire as soon as CB ends, why turn down extra pension and this/future promotions?

madness. And all for £130 a month (2 children). not worth damaging careers for.

yoyo1234 · 07/02/2023 11:13

Agree go for promotion and could they increase money into a pension fund to come below the cap?

GoodChat · 07/02/2023 11:08

I have a few friends who are in this exact position and husband didn't go for promotion because it would have tipped them too far.
One set of friends she is on 43k her husband is on 48k so combined is 91k. Scotland the 40% tax bracket kicks in much earlier as well so for them to then lose a chunk of child benefit for 2 children it simply wasn't worth it.

This is such a batshit way of looking at things. The children won't be children forever. It's better to take the promotion and keep increasing your income (even if you don't see any difference) because as soon as the kids turn 18 they're losing that money anyway and will be better off with the promotion money in the long run.

pennylanestrawberries · 07/02/2023 11:05

Scottishskifun · 07/02/2023 10:30

I have a few friends who are in this exact position and husband didn't go for promotion because it would have tipped them too far.
One set of friends she is on 43k her husband is on 48k so combined is 91k. Scotland the 40% tax bracket kicks in much earlier as well so for them to then lose a chunk of child benefit for 2 children it simply wasn't worth it.

Yes I’m sure there are some but I feel like I hardly know anyone in this position. That may just be me/my friends perhaps!

Scottishskifun · 07/02/2023 10:30

pennylanestrawberries · 07/02/2023 08:24

I don’t disagree the system isn’t very fair but I’d be interested to know how many families there are where both partners earn £40k to £50k as I don’t know anyone in this situation.

Thinking of all the families I know with kids, it’s either both partners earning low wages, one partner (generally the man) earning more than £50k and the other partner working very little/not at all. Or in a few cases, both partners earning a lot more than £50k.

I just never see this set up everyone talks about where a family earning £99k can claim child benefit.

I have a few friends who are in this exact position and husband didn't go for promotion because it would have tipped them too far.
One set of friends she is on 43k her husband is on 48k so combined is 91k. Scotland the 40% tax bracket kicks in much earlier as well so for them to then lose a chunk of child benefit for 2 children it simply wasn't worth it.

HistoryFanatic · 07/02/2023 10:22

If you need help from the government because you fancy being a SAHP then you obviously can't afford it. Work like many parents do. 🙄

AlwaysLatte · 07/02/2023 10:17

Oh I didn't realise it tapered now, that sounds much more complicated that it was, also as you say, how can people budget for this? It's a terrible system.

fairypeasant · 07/02/2023 09:50

@AlwaysLatte Now, it tapers. And many of us don't know our exact salary that counts until the end of the year. So you don't know how much you get to keep until the end of the year.

And as a single parent, you don't know if you can afford the French exchange trip, or whether that money has to go back. It sucks.

AlwaysLatte · 07/02/2023 08:42

When this first came in we had a choice, to claim it and then pay it back if we wanted to - I really couldn't see the point of that so just stopped claiming it. It should have been made clearer to you.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 07/02/2023 08:32

My point was shouldn’t the government be at least giving parents (and usually it is the Mum who wants to stay at home abit more in the first few years but ofcourse some Dads do aswell) the chance to spend more time with their kids whilst they are young?

No - it's not the government's job to sort out the financial planning of every set of young parents in the country. It absolutely should be tackling high housing/childcare costs, but not giving people money to stay at home for years because they fancy being a SAHP.

Sunshine275 · 07/02/2023 08:26

Between £50-£60k you’ll only pay a percentage every year of the £2k you’re over, it won’t be a case of not being completely unenrolled, you’ll just have to complete a tax return. But as people say they’ll take into account works pension payments so you’ll prob have nothing to pay.

pennylanestrawberries · 07/02/2023 08:24

I don’t disagree the system isn’t very fair but I’d be interested to know how many families there are where both partners earn £40k to £50k as I don’t know anyone in this situation.

Thinking of all the families I know with kids, it’s either both partners earning low wages, one partner (generally the man) earning more than £50k and the other partner working very little/not at all. Or in a few cases, both partners earning a lot more than £50k.

I just never see this set up everyone talks about where a family earning £99k can claim child benefit.

Ukrainebaby23 · 07/02/2023 08:21

He does, apart from the money, he gets the Ni credit which is useful but then I will have to payit back in the tax as my earnings will tipover 50k this year.
That's main point of the thread; if one of you, or a single parent earns over 50k you have to pay it back, if 2 parents earn up to 49k each, they don't .

Glittertrauma · 07/02/2023 08:13

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 17:05

@ Reamsofcheese It's a total shithole and has had plenty of free labour off me over the years so I'll call it what it is. And it is a totally unfair decision that a single income family on £50k has to start paying it back while a double income family can earn nearly double that and not have to. Total shithole, yes.

I can't work out the pension thing at all and whether it applies to me.

Totally agree that its unfairly done - and I say that as someone on the other side of it.

My advice would be to up your pension contributions as much as possible to lower your taxable income. We've done this with several pay rises to avoid triggering things over certain income thresholds. It's annoying as all your extra is for future benefit and doesn't help in the here and now. And it only works up to a certain amount but as someone just on the threshold it could help.

Neededanewuserhandle · 07/02/2023 08:09

Ukrainebaby23 · 06/02/2023 22:05

Also discriminates where one parent is a high earner and one a low earner, Dh is a locum and rarely gets above 20k pa while we are fortunate to have 2 incomes, can't see why we have to repay CB when others earn more jointly.

I may be missing something but it sounds as if your DH should claim Child benefit surely?

Wrongun1999 · 07/02/2023 07:59

Don’t forget you can make additional payments to your pension (faster accrual or purchase additional pension) to get it under 50k

CBG34 · 07/02/2023 06:58

How annoying for you! If you want to talk it through with someone then Citizens Advice can offer guidance on this kind of thing. HMRC will tell you processes, but they don't advocate for you as they have to be impartial/unbiased

Might be worth chatting it through with a specialist advisor as there must be some options to work this out

Justellingthetruth · 07/02/2023 06:14

@pinotnow

why should any country pay you for having kids?
yes the rules on it are stupid I agree.

have you stood for election?
have you wrote to you MP?
why not if you are so upset about it?
do you vote at every election?

Dobby123456 · 07/02/2023 00:46

Hellybelly84 · 07/02/2023 00:19

Agree! That was our situation before pre-school/school, it would have been pointless working to bring home a few quid.

Im not even asking for CB for us - just asking for a fair system. People with a much higher household income than us (say by 30k) get given it, whilst we dont. Bonkers!

Where you are in the country also makes a difference. When I was living in London my health visitor told me that the mothers she worked with who were on child number two under school age couldn't go back to work because of the childcare costs. It was around the time when Cherie Blair made that shockingly out-of-touch comment about 'yummy mummys'. I think she lived in a different part of London from me because I didn't know any 'yummy mummys', just hard-working mums.

Hellybelly84 · 07/02/2023 00:19

Dobby123456 · 07/02/2023 00:02

Also some women (and men!) stay at home to look after their children because they couldn't earn enough to pay for the childcare. Especially if they've got a few children. Basically, the government doesn't want people to have more than one or two children or stay out of work too long (not paying taxes), so they've come up with a system to make that kind of family life impossible for most.

Agree! That was our situation before pre-school/school, it would have been pointless working to bring home a few quid.

Im not even asking for CB for us - just asking for a fair system. People with a much higher household income than us (say by 30k) get given it, whilst we dont. Bonkers!

Dobby123456 · 07/02/2023 00:02

Hellybelly84 · 06/02/2023 23:27

I work too and plan to for at least 40+ years of my life. Other than the first few years of my kids lives, ive never been out of work. My Husband loved that I stayed at home (ofcourse had to accept a massive income hit for this but worth it). My point was shouldn’t the government be at least giving parents (and usually it is the Mum who wants to stay at home abit more in the first few years but ofcourse some Dads do aswell) the chance to spend more time with their kids whilst they are young? Why take child benefit away from a family where a parent stays at home in the early years, yet give it to a household earning nearly £100k for 18 years of their kids lives. Thats what everyone should be questioning!

As ive said before, just basing it on total household income would make it a much fairer system. You can see from this thread, people are having to find ways to reduce their income to keep getting it. The whole thing is so messed up!

Also some women (and men!) stay at home to look after their children because they couldn't earn enough to pay for the childcare. Especially if they've got a few children. Basically, the government doesn't want people to have more than one or two children or stay out of work too long (not paying taxes), so they've come up with a system to make that kind of family life impossible for most.

Dobby123456 · 06/02/2023 23:58

Zax · 06/02/2023 18:39

Nice little scam you've got going there.

It might be working the system, but as long as it's legal, it's not technically a scam.

Silentmama · 06/02/2023 23:41

You can put the excess into a pension and still get CB.

Hellybelly84 · 06/02/2023 23:27

MissTrip82 · 06/02/2023 22:01

Why do you think working parents aren't raising their children? You really think that your husband wasn't raising yours? Have you told him?

Being a parent involves the dual responsibilities of child care and financial support. Working to pay for the food your child eats, the shelter they live in, the clothes on their back..... that's all raising a child. I'm not being punished because I work to provide the food the child I chose to have needs.

I work too and plan to for at least 40+ years of my life. Other than the first few years of my kids lives, ive never been out of work. My Husband loved that I stayed at home (ofcourse had to accept a massive income hit for this but worth it). My point was shouldn’t the government be at least giving parents (and usually it is the Mum who wants to stay at home abit more in the first few years but ofcourse some Dads do aswell) the chance to spend more time with their kids whilst they are young? Why take child benefit away from a family where a parent stays at home in the early years, yet give it to a household earning nearly £100k for 18 years of their kids lives. Thats what everyone should be questioning!

As ive said before, just basing it on total household income would make it a much fairer system. You can see from this thread, people are having to find ways to reduce their income to keep getting it. The whole thing is so messed up!