Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off about paying back child benefit

560 replies

pinotnow · 05/02/2023 16:56

I am in a sector that was awarded a pay rise this year - though our union is fighting for a higher one. The rise was from September but our school (yes, it's teaching) didn't pay it until November when we got months at once. HR always send us a pay statement at this time of year and I have just opened mine and seen I am now on approx £52k (been teaching 18 years and am head of a core subject in a large secondary school). I understand I now have to pay back some of my child benefit. This is a pisser as things are pretty tight and I'm a lone parent who gets no CM (ex is a total waste of space - I've gone through CMS). Also, I wasn't expecting it this year (I was on £49k last year and now I'm worried I've missed some sort of deadline for paying it back as technically I've been on this for 5-6 months, but only just realised.

I really haven't got the head space for this now and a quick Google has just brought confusion. As soon as you move forwards a bit in this shithole country you move backwards it seems. Any advice would be great!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EasterIssland · 01/03/2023 14:03

Just seen Michael gove has said child benefit should be cancelled. And thought about @Zax ! Have you had your chat with your mp? Looks like it’s had an effect!
tho it’s seems it’s mainly for those parents that don’t provide an education to their children rather than to the rich ones

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-64803947.amp

TheLostGiraffe · 18/02/2023 11:36

I'm longing for a place where 'your' and 'you're' are used where they should be. That would make more sense in my natural homeland.

"Your longing for a place..." makes perfect sense.

Nothing more embarrassing than a vocal pedant who tries to point out a grammar error but is in fact wrong themselves. Oh dear.

usernamealreadytaken · 18/02/2023 10:35

@Zax the "your" was correct, but possibly could have been clearer with a comma, or brackets - the reference was to "your longing" making sense, not "you are longing".

I guess people are always mosf comfortable with what they are familiar with, so your longing (for a place where nothing makes sense,) makes sense. A natural homeland.

Zax · 17/02/2023 08:33

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 20:57

I guess people are always mosf comfortable with what they are familiar with, so your longing for a place where nothing makes sense makes sense. A natural homeland.

I'm longing for a place where 'your' and 'you're' are used where they should be. That would make more sense in my natural homeland.

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 20:57

I guess people are always mosf comfortable with what they are familiar with, so your longing for a place where nothing makes sense makes sense. A natural homeland.

Zax · 16/02/2023 17:09

This thread has now drifted right off course, hopefully towards The Bermuda Triangle.

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 16:14

I don't often swear but WTF?? Why should we be grateful for having overqualified migrant workers working below their skill level and claiming benefits? How, exactly, does that benefit us?

What are you talking about? The entire point I was making is that it's been proved multiple times by large scale research that EU migrants were net contributors to the economy. I.e. they used less in services/ benefits than they paid in, consistently. Most were not claiming benefits at all. They were a net benefit to the economy, unlike the average UK citizen (only 10% of those born here are net contributors).

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 16:12

If the UK is suddenly an unattractive place to work, why do we have more migrant workers living and working here than ever?

🙄😆

Obviously it isn't unattractive to most of the world population. It's unattractive now to our historical comparator countries: Germany, the Netherlands, Australia, Canada, France. Have a look at the migration stats and economic comparisons over time.

Dobby123456 · 16/02/2023 15:57

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 13:58

I didn't vote Brexit, but I do have a question in my mind on this topic that goes something like 'Why are taking skilled people from other countries, rather than training people here?' and 'Why don't British people want to do jobs like midwifery that should be a very fulfilling and well-respected occupation?'

So what is the complaint? First it was that most migrants are not skilled enough but now apparently it is that we shouldn't have been taking the skilled one?

It benefits everyone to have people with different skills and backgrounds moving around. Avoids groupthink. Helps economies, fills specific skills gaps at any given time that occur due to a wide range of reasons: structural changes or demographic changes or sector-specific changes happening at different paces at different times in different countries, etc. Worth noting also that there were a higher number of British people migrating for work to other countries than from any other country in the EU, before Brexit. So the hypocrisy of such arguments is staggering and ill-informed.

Haven't we got rather off topic?

I simply responded to the content of your previous post.

What previous post?🤔

usernamealreadytaken · 16/02/2023 15:14

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 14:01

@usernamealreadytaken and your problem with having overqualified people is what exactly? Again surely we should have been grateful for that!! Even if working below their skill level they managed to be on average net contributors to the economy, which the average British person is not.

I don't often swear but WTF?? Why should we be grateful for having overqualified migrant workers working below their skill level and claiming benefits? How, exactly, does that benefit us?

You know how averages work? There will be a few highly skilled highly paid workers who are net contributors, but then hundreds of net recipients are "averaged" to magically appear to be net contributors. If we just had the actual net contributors then this country would be in a far better financial position.

This thread has been an absolute eye-opener. Highly paid professionals encouraging other highly paid professionals to minimise their tax in order to continue to receive state assistance, and simultaneously vilifying the government for not providing more state assistance to more people, which they can't afford to do because so many people avoid paying their full taxes. You couldn't make it up!

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 14:01

@usernamealreadytaken and your problem with having overqualified people is what exactly? Again surely we should have been grateful for that!! Even if working below their skill level they managed to be on average net contributors to the economy, which the average British person is not.

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 13:58

I didn't vote Brexit, but I do have a question in my mind on this topic that goes something like 'Why are taking skilled people from other countries, rather than training people here?' and 'Why don't British people want to do jobs like midwifery that should be a very fulfilling and well-respected occupation?'

So what is the complaint? First it was that most migrants are not skilled enough but now apparently it is that we shouldn't have been taking the skilled one?

It benefits everyone to have people with different skills and backgrounds moving around. Avoids groupthink. Helps economies, fills specific skills gaps at any given time that occur due to a wide range of reasons: structural changes or demographic changes or sector-specific changes happening at different paces at different times in different countries, etc. Worth noting also that there were a higher number of British people migrating for work to other countries than from any other country in the EU, before Brexit. So the hypocrisy of such arguments is staggering and ill-informed.

Haven't we got rather off topic?

I simply responded to the content of your previous post.

usernamealreadytaken · 16/02/2023 13:23

Dobby123456 · 16/02/2023 12:39

I didn't vote Brexit, but I do have a question in my mind on this topic that goes something like 'Why are taking skilled people from other countries, rather than training people here?' and 'Why don't British people want to do jobs like midwifery that should be a very fulfilling and well-respected occupation?'

Haven't we got rather off topic?

I completely agree with your questioning why we import skills rather than training our own, and it's in part because successive governments of all colours have found it cheaper to import rather than properly train.

I'd add to your observation my own; why are we creating so many low paid/low skill jobs with wages topped up by taxpayers which seemingly can only be filled by importing migrants willing to do low paid/low skill jobs with wages topped up by taxpayers? Why are businesses allowed to operate on the basis that their staff have to claim benefits to be able to live? Make it illegal to pay lower than the amount needed to live on; if your business cannot do that because people won't pay your prices, then you don't have a business, you have a scam benefits claim.

usernamealreadytaken · 16/02/2023 13:18

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 12:08

The majority of migrant workers are in lower skilled and paid jobs. We do have skilled migration, as every other country does, but we bring in far, far more lower skilled workers which has been proven to not only suppress wages for the lower paid, but also leads to resentment for so many reasons; lack of infrastructure to support significant migration, lack of social integration, perception of migrants getting things paid for which drains already stretched funding.

This was not the case with the EU migrants who came here when we had free movement. Multiple studies showed that they were on average more educated and skilled than the average UK worker, paid more in taxes and used less in services than the average UK worker. Plus the majority tended to then move back to their home countries before retirement therefore less of a burden to the state. They were net contributors and we should have been extremely grateful to them. But in their infinite wisdom the UK public decided this was a bad thing and we should make the UK a very unattrractive place to come and work.

If the UK is suddenly an unattractive place to work, why do we have more migrant workers living and working here than ever? Why do you think it's a good thing that so many people come here when we just don't have the infrastructure to cope with the huge influx we have seen in recent years? Where would you like to build 500,000 houses every year to accommodate those coming here?

EU migrants may well have been more highly skilled, but they were not working in jobs which corresponded with those skills or qualifications.

"Around half of highly educated workers born in new EU member states were in low and medium-low skilled jobs in 2020
Compared to the UK born, migrants are more likely to work in jobs for which they are overqualified, especially if they have foreign qualifications (Chiswick and Miller, 2008). In general, workers are considered overqualified for their jobs if their educational level is above that required for their jobs.
Some of the factors explaining migrants’ high over-qualification rates include the lack of UK-specific skills, employers’ mistrust of or unfamiliarity with foreign qualifications, or migrants’ lack of information about the job searching process in the UK.
The indicator of over-qualification used here shows the share of highly educated workers (those with university degrees or with higher education qualifications below degree level, such as nursing) in low and medium-low skilled jobs (Figure 11). In 2020, the share of over-qualified workers was higher among people born in EU-8 countries (47%), Romania and Bulgaria (41%) and in Pakistan and other South Asian countries (35%), than among the UK born (22%) or the EU-14 born (16%) (Figure 11). Importantly, the migrant groups with the lowest earnings (see Figure 10) were also the ones most likely to be over-qualified for their jobs."

public.tableau.com/views/Labourmarketbriefing2021/FIG10?:language=en-GB&:embed=y&:embed_code_version=3&:loadOrderID=9&:display_count=y&publish=yes&:origin=viz_share_link

public.tableau.com/views/Labourmarketbriefing2021/FIG11?:language=en-GB&:embed=y&:embed_code_version=3&:loadOrderID=10&:display_count=y&publish=yes&:origin=viz_share_link

Dobby123456 · 16/02/2023 12:39

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 12:08

The majority of migrant workers are in lower skilled and paid jobs. We do have skilled migration, as every other country does, but we bring in far, far more lower skilled workers which has been proven to not only suppress wages for the lower paid, but also leads to resentment for so many reasons; lack of infrastructure to support significant migration, lack of social integration, perception of migrants getting things paid for which drains already stretched funding.

This was not the case with the EU migrants who came here when we had free movement. Multiple studies showed that they were on average more educated and skilled than the average UK worker, paid more in taxes and used less in services than the average UK worker. Plus the majority tended to then move back to their home countries before retirement therefore less of a burden to the state. They were net contributors and we should have been extremely grateful to them. But in their infinite wisdom the UK public decided this was a bad thing and we should make the UK a very unattrractive place to come and work.

I didn't vote Brexit, but I do have a question in my mind on this topic that goes something like 'Why are taking skilled people from other countries, rather than training people here?' and 'Why don't British people want to do jobs like midwifery that should be a very fulfilling and well-respected occupation?'

Haven't we got rather off topic?

TheLostGiraffe · 16/02/2023 12:08

The majority of migrant workers are in lower skilled and paid jobs. We do have skilled migration, as every other country does, but we bring in far, far more lower skilled workers which has been proven to not only suppress wages for the lower paid, but also leads to resentment for so many reasons; lack of infrastructure to support significant migration, lack of social integration, perception of migrants getting things paid for which drains already stretched funding.

This was not the case with the EU migrants who came here when we had free movement. Multiple studies showed that they were on average more educated and skilled than the average UK worker, paid more in taxes and used less in services than the average UK worker. Plus the majority tended to then move back to their home countries before retirement therefore less of a burden to the state. They were net contributors and we should have been extremely grateful to them. But in their infinite wisdom the UK public decided this was a bad thing and we should make the UK a very unattrractive place to come and work.

fairypeasant · 16/02/2023 10:00

@usernamealreadytaken The BMA is a trade union. You don't know what you're talking about.

The GMC regulate doctors and medical schools.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 15/02/2023 22:00

Has this been overturned then? www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748

It's utterly irrelevant. The BMA doesn't control the numbers of medical students. You may also notice that the motion (passed 15 years ago) "agreed on a complete ban on opening new medical schools". By my reckoning, at least six new medical schools have opened since then, not counting private ones, joint ventures between existing ones, offshoots of existing ones, and the international-only ones. And medical student numbers did increase significantly in 2017.

usernamealreadytaken · 15/02/2023 20:23

messybutfun · 15/02/2023 13:09

It‘s the Three Counties Medical School at University if Worcester.

Places are funded by the Department of Health and Social Care - or not in this case.

This country has been importing skills in health care, IT, accounting, engineering - really anything that needs a qualification - for years - it‘s not just low skilled jobs that the British don‘t want/can‘t do.

There will be UK students as alternative funding has been secured, partly from a charity and partly from the NHS - where do you think NHS money comes from...?

usernamealreadytaken · 15/02/2023 20:19

messybutfun · 15/02/2023 13:09

It‘s the Three Counties Medical School at University if Worcester.

Places are funded by the Department of Health and Social Care - or not in this case.

This country has been importing skills in health care, IT, accounting, engineering - really anything that needs a qualification - for years - it‘s not just low skilled jobs that the British don‘t want/can‘t do.

The majority of migrant workers are in lower skilled and paid jobs. We do have skilled migration, as every other country does, but we bring in far, far more lower skilled workers which has been proven to not only suppress wages for the lower paid, but also leads to resentment for so many reasons; lack of infrastructure to support significant migration, lack of social integration, perception of migrants getting things paid for which drains already stretched funding.

usernamealreadytaken · 15/02/2023 20:16

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 15/02/2023 16:26

It's the BMA which restricts the number of training places available to UK students

No it isn't! I do wish people would stop repeating this nonsense.

Has this been overturned then? www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 15/02/2023 16:26

It's the BMA which restricts the number of training places available to UK students

No it isn't! I do wish people would stop repeating this nonsense.

messybutfun · 15/02/2023 13:09

It‘s the Three Counties Medical School at University if Worcester.

Places are funded by the Department of Health and Social Care - or not in this case.

This country has been importing skills in health care, IT, accounting, engineering - really anything that needs a qualification - for years - it‘s not just low skilled jobs that the British don‘t want/can‘t do.

usernamealreadytaken · 15/02/2023 12:54

messybutfun · 14/02/2023 08:11

@usernamealreadytaken Specifically, I was talking about nurses. Pay them to study. It‘s a nonsense that we have 150,000 vacancies yet we are not training enough. And about 30% of those that start training drop out. Why is that? It needs addressing now.

Secondly, we have a recently opened training facility for new doctors which has placements only for overseas students. Not a single place has been funded for domestic students. All the while we are short of doctors.

This is just the tip of the iceberg - it goes for pretty much any industry with a skill shortage. It’s really not about jobs the British don‘t want to do - the British need to be skilled up to do them. And they can‘t be expected to pay for it.

@messybutfun no, you weren't specifically referring to nurses; you mentioned that we "now need to import these skills at a rate of half a million a year without getting anywhere near sufficient levels." There are only around 700,000 clinical staff within the NHS in E&W, excl Primary Care. You are confusing migrant workers with NHS staff; the half a million migrant workers coming here each year are, in the majority, employed in lower paid/lower regarded sectors and jobs such as retail, hospitality or transport and manufacturing.

Which new medical training facility are you referring to? It's the BMA which restricts the number of training places available to UK students, partly because students need qualified mentors and if the qualified doctors spent all their time mentoring lots of new doctors, there'd be nobody to actually do the doctoring.

It's absolutely about jobs that British people don't want to do; we spend an absolute fortune on importing low paid workers and topping their wages up with benefits which then leave the country. It's a house of cards, enabled by FoM, and it's going to fall. We've created whole industries of low paid jobs just to be able to import people to do them. Madness.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 12:28

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 12:23

But essentially you aren't actually disagreeing, I feel like you are generalising more than me, i have said that situations vary and you have made similar points to me, but are also insisting that the stepped loss of CB makes you worse off if you earn more, which frankly isn't true in all cases. That is what i am referring to.

I'm really not. I'm saying we clearly aren't talking solely about the CB when discussing if we're financially better off, that it would be stupid and pointless to do so. And that the tapered loss of CB means even with no extra financial costs of working, a person's effective marginal rate will be higher than it is below the threshold, which is liable to be the point at which some people decide it's not worth extra effort.

Swipe left for the next trending thread