Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Playdates there always one sided

158 replies

Douse · 05/02/2023 15:05

Playdates always seem one sided for us . My children have friends over for tea and a play but the offer is never received back to the friends house . Its something that really bothers and makes me not want to carry on having playdates

OP posts:
TokyoSushi · 05/02/2023 19:27

I find play dates really stressful, I think it's the responsibility of looking after other people's children so I do try to avoid them although I don't really ever explain why.

I do try to make up for it though with things like doing more than my fair share of driving children about to clubs etc, buying you a really nice birthday present, organising lots of things like meals and nights out and just generally being one of those helpful people in the hope that you don't notice my play date fear!

Bijou23 · 05/02/2023 19:25

NuffSaidSam · 05/02/2023 15:52

Personally, I don't think that's fair, the load should be shared. So, I don't have those children back; I choose other friends of dds who do reciprocate. Not fair on their child of course, but that isn't my responsibility.

How deeply unpleasant.

I don't like it when people say this about not inviting them back, maybe they don't have a nice house or live in a flat or some other reason why they haven't reciprocated, it's awkward enough having to explain your situation to another parent whom you probably don't know very well either,
People on here are very split over play dates being reciprocated vs not. Id prefer not too do them but feel bad on my child's part if we didn't and no I don't reciprocate because I can't and hope to one day be able to offer the other children round

MoomiMama · 05/02/2023 19:24

Also someone inviting my DC for a play date at a time of their choosing isn’t a favour for me. It may well be an inconvenience based on work and other plans, but I will try my best to accommodate for the sake of DC. It’s only a favour if it’s at a time when I needed the childcare (and asked for it).

UsingChangeofName · 05/02/2023 19:21

It is not healthy to model a non reciprocal relationship/friendship to children by continually inviting children that have no intention of ever returning the favour.

Grin

Are you actually stating "it's not healthy" to demonstrate to your dc that it is nice to be kind ?
That it is nice to offer when you can - be that food, space, a listening ear, friendship or whatever ?

I think it is excellent parenting to demonstrate kindness.
To demonstrate how lovely it is to have a welcoming environment in your home. To demonstrate the fun you can have by having friends round.
To demonstrate how nice it is to share a meal.
To demonstrate that it is often more fun to do something with a friend.

MoomiMama · 05/02/2023 19:20

For me, play dates are for my DC. So I invite their friends - whoever they want, not whose parents I get on with or who will reciprocate. Some do, some don’t. I would be lying if I said I don’t notice who doesn’t reciprocate but that doesn’t stop me inviting them if DC ask. It’s an unpopular opinion on MN but I don’t find play dates particularly hard work. I expect DC to get on with it and amuse themselves and they pretty much always do. The only reason I might stop repeat invites is for consistently bad behaviour but luckily that’s not happened yet.
Separately, some of the parents I am good enough friends with to ask for the occasional childcare favour and vice versa. I see this is a separate thing to child-initiated play dates, and this is something that is reciprocated in various ways.

NuffSaidSam · 05/02/2023 19:19

Blessedwithsunshine · 05/02/2023 19:15

It is not healthy to model a non reciprocal relationship/friendship to children by continually inviting children that have no intention of ever returning the favour.

Children should grow up understanding that friendships are give and take. Most children enjoy being invited to friends houses, playing with new toys and enjoying the experience and learning to enjoy dinner at different houses. It is good for their social development, if that isn’t happening over a long period of time, then a child will be disadvantaged socially.

Most parents can easily host, but choose not to. Unless it’s been explained to other parents that there are some extremely good reasons why it’s unbalanced, then they shouldn’t continue to accept invitations - it is CF behaviour, and taking advantage.

If you can’t host at home there is nothing wrong with hosting in parks, cafes and other public places. We wouldn’t dream of continually inviting children that don’t reciprocate. I have no intention of turning my children in to adult people pleasers.

Children should grow up understanding that not everyone is as lucky as they or has access to the same opportunities. Children should grow up judging people on the content of their character and not what their parents/wider family have/can do/are like.

A child will be far more socially disadvantaged being brought up devoid of empathy and thinking all relationships operate on a simple transactional basis than they will be not being invited to a couple of friends houses.

And you know it.

Blessedwithsunshine · 05/02/2023 19:15

NuffSaidSam · 05/02/2023 16:10

Of course you punished them. You stopped inviting them over, banned them from playdates. Not because of their behaviour or because they were no longer friends with your DC but because their parents couldn't or wouldn't invite your DC over.

I understand you're not going to apologise for it, but you should feel bad about it because it's a horrible thing to do isn't it?

It is not healthy to model a non reciprocal relationship/friendship to children by continually inviting children that have no intention of ever returning the favour.

Children should grow up understanding that friendships are give and take. Most children enjoy being invited to friends houses, playing with new toys and enjoying the experience and learning to enjoy dinner at different houses. It is good for their social development, if that isn’t happening over a long period of time, then a child will be disadvantaged socially.

Most parents can easily host, but choose not to. Unless it’s been explained to other parents that there are some extremely good reasons why it’s unbalanced, then they shouldn’t continue to accept invitations - it is CF behaviour, and taking advantage.

If you can’t host at home there is nothing wrong with hosting in parks, cafes and other public places. We wouldn’t dream of continually inviting children that don’t reciprocate. I have no intention of turning my children in to adult people pleasers.

Howmanysleepsnow · 05/02/2023 19:04

I haven’t returned a play date for over a year. It’s not that I don’t want to.

  1. Dh has had depression and wouldn’t have coped with the noise
  2. DH then had a physical illness that meant he couldn’t walk more than a couple of steps
  3. DH has now returned to work very part time, but between helping him run his business, working 45h a week in my own job and looking after 4DC and 2 dogs I’m embarrassingly behind on housework… plus due to reason 1 I only have 2 two hour windows a week I could offer in atm, which for seem long enough.
I feel really bad about it, but I/ we just couldn’t manage a play date yet.
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 05/02/2023 18:58

Snap and I understand in some instances why not- a sibling of a child having SEN, too many other siblings etc- but it’s hard when your child says “can I go to so and sos house”- I explain you can’t invite yourself but then we’re always hosting, always spending money, always giving other adults a break, always cleaning up.
Its annoying my tbh!

UsingChangeofName · 05/02/2023 18:56

NuffSaidSam · 05/02/2023 15:21

There are many reasons playdates don't get returned, you need to change your mindset.

Playdates are not something you do for the other parent or the other child. They're something you do for the benefit of YOUR child. Whether another parent hosts a playdate for their child is neither here nor there. If your child enjoys playdates and you have the ability to host them then carry on. If they don't enjoy them or they're difficult for you, then stop. It's that's simple. Absolutely irrelevant what other people do.

Totally agree with this

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/02/2023 18:56

Its he same for us. There are a couple of friends who we take turns with but some only ever come over.

I feel bad for my kids as they are desperate to go to some of their friends houses and aren't sure why they arent invited. However I'll keep doing it for a few reasons. If I stopped hosying I feel like I'd be denying my kids. And they really enjoy it, and I feel like I get a bit of a break if they have kids to play with. And actually I think some people have really good reasons for not having people over. Some parents told me they run a business from home so are short of space and it's a bit tricky for them, which is fair enough

UsingChangeofName · 05/02/2023 18:55

Snoken · 05/02/2023 17:24

I think this is the problem. Just calling it playdate rather than just having a friend over makes it sound like such a big thing. Me and my friends were constantly in and out of each others houses growing up. Nobody kept a score, none of the parents cared they just carried on with their day as planned. I had the same attitude with my kids, they could always have friends over, I didn't care if they were also going to their friends houses or not. Some of their friends had horribly strict and boring parents so I always understood why they'd rather be at our house and had no problem with it. My kids are now adult/late teens and I miss the days of having a fuller house.

I agree with both of these.

If your dc wants someone round to play, and you can facilitate it, then why wouldn't you ?

I've never understood this MN thing of keeping score - be that having dc round to your house, giving lifts, or something else.

dottymac · 05/02/2023 18:49

I'm always the host. Invitations are rarely reciprocated. The mums have made it clear that they don't want the extra mess/noise etc in their houses. D#cks.

NuffSaidSam · 05/02/2023 18:39

RealBecca · 05/02/2023 17:47

I'm.just gonna put out there that there arent many situations where a playdate cant be accommodated...
Living with wider family, understandable.
A house with work going on, same.
Special needs layout or sibling, ditto.

Living miles away - ok, but it would be possible to invite at the weekend.
Living in a small home - most people can accommodate one child and adult for an hour.
A working from home parent - well, if it's full time then they probably need to look at an office or noise cancelling headphones or a coffee shop or putting up with some noise for an hour now and again or at the weekend.

Interested to hear about other situations which mean an hour's play and a coffee cant be hosted by most people.

There are lots of reasons in addition to the ones you've given. Perhaps there is domestic violence, perhaps they have a dog that's isn't friendly with strange children, perhaps one of the parents is physically or mentally unwell, perhaps there is a sibling with commitments which make playdates difficult, perhaps there are loads of siblings, perhaps they're really struggling to heat their home and don't want to invite someone back when it's freezing etc. Etc. Etc.

But that isn't even the point.

The point is that you shouldn't visit the sins of the parent on the child. Maybe there is no reason and the parents are just cheeky fuckers. Maybe they're awful, lazy, nasty people rubbing their hands together with glee about what a mug you are to always host their child when they never return the favour. But that's not the child's fault is it? And the child should not suffer as a result.

Mangogogogo · 05/02/2023 18:31

I’m guessing it’s just me who doesn’t see my children going for play dates as a favour? It’s actually a bit of a fuck on for me!
if I’m at work it’s a fuck on getting them picked up after play date by someone, instead of the usual they go straight to my mums from school. If I’m off it’s also annoying to have to go back out after I’ve got in and try to work dinner around picking them back up!

so as much as I love the fact that my kids have fun at others’ houses I really, really don’t see it as a favour so I wouldn’t be too bothered if someone didn’t reciprocate.

i reciprocate though!

aloris · 05/02/2023 18:26

There are advantages to being the one who hosts the playdate. My kids actually prefer if the playdate is at our house as I can tolerate quite a lot of noise and running around, whereas some other mums have more strict rules and get upset if there is noise. Having the playdate at our own house also allows me to observe how the children are treating each other and step in if there is bullying or bad behavior, whereas I don't know how the other parent is handling this if it's at a different house. It also allows me to teach social rules that I like - how to share, etc. Many children have told me they like that they feel welcome at our home. So I don't always mind if parents do not reciprocate.

However if I sense I'm being used as free babysitting, or the other parents are taking advantage (e.g. not picking up the child at the agreed time, being unreachable in case of emergency), or the other parents are unable/unwilling to work with me so that my family is not overly inconvenienced by being the only hosts (e.g. sending their child to a playdate sick), then I stop having playdates with those children. I host when it works for me but I'm under no obligation to be someone else's doormat. It's a judgement call.

As my kids have grown older, the balance of locations of playdates and "get togethers" has shifted, so I've had a lot fewer at my house and there are other parents who have "taken over" the bulk of the get togethers, because their house is more central, an easier drive for new driver kids, etc. Those mums might feel that they are getting too much burden now, I don't know. At the same time, older kids are more independent and it's a matter of reminding them all to chip in some cash if they are going to get a pizza, not so much about making sure 5 or 6 unruly toddlers aren't wandering into the street or choking to death on Legos. Personally I found the toddlers MUCH more exhausting. Teenagers can be loud and opinionated but generally know how to cross the street.

minipie · 05/02/2023 17:54

I don’t keep score. My DD does.

She notices that she’s not been invited back and gets upset by it. This puts me off inviting the other child back again because DD will inevitably ask “but why is it at our house again”.

And it’s not because the other child’s parents can’t do playdates. They do. They just haven’t invited DD 😕 She is unfortunately just not at the top of people’s lists.

RealBecca · 05/02/2023 17:47

I'm.just gonna put out there that there arent many situations where a playdate cant be accommodated...
Living with wider family, understandable.
A house with work going on, same.
Special needs layout or sibling, ditto.

Living miles away - ok, but it would be possible to invite at the weekend.
Living in a small home - most people can accommodate one child and adult for an hour.
A working from home parent - well, if it's full time then they probably need to look at an office or noise cancelling headphones or a coffee shop or putting up with some noise for an hour now and again or at the weekend.

Interested to hear about other situations which mean an hour's play and a coffee cant be hosted by most people.

PAFMO · 05/02/2023 17:37

UpendedPineapple · 05/02/2023 17:32

You just know all those arguing it's completely fine and reasonable for their child to have the fun of play dates and being at someone else's house while yours doesn't cannot be arsed to return a favour.

Because play dates are a favour for the parent and hopefully a treat for the child.

As with everything some people put themselves out and some don't. And yes, I've got stuck with siblings too 🙄

Except lots of us have said that isn't the case. We're just more understanding that some kids, for whatever reasons, don't have their friends round to play.

UpendedPineapple · 05/02/2023 17:32

You just know all those arguing it's completely fine and reasonable for their child to have the fun of play dates and being at someone else's house while yours doesn't cannot be arsed to return a favour.

Because play dates are a favour for the parent and hopefully a treat for the child.

As with everything some people put themselves out and some don't. And yes, I've got stuck with siblings too 🙄

Snoken · 05/02/2023 17:24

PAFMO · 05/02/2023 16:52

It's all a lot less fucking stressful and doesn't take up nearly as much space on your tit for tat spreadsheet of pluses and minuses if you think of it as "kids playing in each other's houses" rather than some military obligatory "now we shall have fun and craft with an organic fruit juice" set up.
(I was a hoster rather than a hostee- win win. Chuck a biscuit in the bedroom every so often, let them get on with the Lego while you do something not dominated by a 5 year old)

I think this is the problem. Just calling it playdate rather than just having a friend over makes it sound like such a big thing. Me and my friends were constantly in and out of each others houses growing up. Nobody kept a score, none of the parents cared they just carried on with their day as planned. I had the same attitude with my kids, they could always have friends over, I didn't care if they were also going to their friends houses or not. Some of their friends had horribly strict and boring parents so I always understood why they'd rather be at our house and had no problem with it. My kids are now adult/late teens and I miss the days of having a fuller house.

MintJulia · 05/02/2023 16:55

I've always regarded a play date as being about the DCs having company, socialising and enjoying themselves. It isn't about shared child care or a free meal. I didn't mind if we didn't get invited back, as long as DS had a good time.

Now he's older, he has a nice group of mates so they are usually welcome. A couple of extras for home made lunch doesn't cost much.

Lots of parents don't have time after school or at the weekends because they don't work office hours. Or they have home lives that are difficult. I grew up in a house where my df wouldn't tolerate visitors. Good thing my friends' parents didn't mind.

PAFMO · 05/02/2023 16:52

It's all a lot less fucking stressful and doesn't take up nearly as much space on your tit for tat spreadsheet of pluses and minuses if you think of it as "kids playing in each other's houses" rather than some military obligatory "now we shall have fun and craft with an organic fruit juice" set up.
(I was a hoster rather than a hostee- win win. Chuck a biscuit in the bedroom every so often, let them get on with the Lego while you do something not dominated by a 5 year old)

Tempone · 05/02/2023 16:44

Op you don't know what's going on in other people's houses that they can't reciprocate. If your child enjoys having friends over what's the big deal.

ForestofD · 05/02/2023 16:44

What's your child's behaviour like when they are on a playdate?

There is one child who usually asks my child for a playdate- her Mum is very busy and she wants someone to keep her occupied. That's fair enough. There's plenty of space and they usually end up running around the garden. Sometimes my child says yes and sometimes no as she can't be bothered to put up with the child's behaviour.

The others child behaviour when they come to our house is poor. She has been caught taking something from my daughters jewellery box, she's rude and not well behaved. So we don't invite her back but we will help if Mum needs help with pick-ups etc. We did have an elderly rescue cat, who while very placid, didn't like being picked up. She insisted she was going to pick him up/pulling at him- until I told her she would be packed into the car and taken home that minute if she bothered the poor cat anymore. That resulted in a huge huff, so we ended up taking her home anyway.