Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Old age money, help!

70 replies

Salsi · 05/02/2023 10:30

I’m 50, just started a new job. Finally, we have some financial security. But I’m anxious about the future and old age poverty. AIBU?

For context, have spent past 15 years of freelancing, while the kids were little. Over this time, almost no spare cash, but I am a careful saver, so I tucked some away in isas, over the past 25 years. My former boss (25-15 years ago, when I was last in non self-employed employment) explicitly told me not to bother with a pension, but to to save in isas, which I did. Saved about £50k.

But I’ve had to draw down those isas during covid, and up to now (husbands business not recovered yet) so I only have about 10k saved now. (Btw, Am now wondering if former boss was simply fobbing me off - he’s a small business owner who wasn’t liable to support employees pensions…)

Anyway, long and short: I have no pension provision, and nor does my 53 yo self-employed husband. Our combined income has been very low, esp during covid (£18k joint during past couple of years) but now I’m getting roughly 45k/ year. He’s maybe on £40k/year, but it’s hard to tell, it goes up and down, depending on the jobs he secures.

obvs I’ve signed up to the work pension. But I’m so confused.

my husband has his head in the sand. He hates communicating about money, like it’s a slur on his soul (his work is a vocation). He thinks he’ll work until 70 (quite likes his work!) but what the heck do we do?

It was grim living on £18k (ie our joint earning in covid, which is equivalent two state pensions), hence we drew down my isas by about £20k per year during that period. We are in London. We have a house, with £250 k left on mortgage. But no assets otherwise. AIBU to be very worried? Any advice? Where do we start? What have you done? How do I learn more about investing? I’ve maxed out the work pension, but can I put even more away? If so, how? I can do some extra work on the side, c. £5-10k per year, which I’m thinking I should invest!

OP posts:
Bucks67 · 05/02/2023 16:14

Cash ISAs are a waste of time.
Husband needs to open a Sipp and pay into it every month.
I would say you need to be quite aggressive with your investments inorder to make up lost ground.
But first you need to do your homework
Checkout Meaningfully Money podcast,Pension craft and Money to the Masses all good sources.

Toooldtoworry · 05/02/2023 16:04

Salsi · 05/02/2023 14:51

IFA - your advice is unanimous. I’ll do so. I did have one. I could go back to him (or rather, his son now). Or any recommendations for advisors in London. Mine was from my old home town.

My Mum uses Lawrence from Throgmortons. I think he is based in Essex but he does visit my parents who live in Lincolnshire, so I wouldn't rule him out.

He has made them a LOT of money over the years. He was recommended to them by my Uncle so been advising my family for a long time.

Orangesandlemons77 · 05/02/2023 15:40

You could downsize to a flat maybe

Slowsteps · 05/02/2023 15:40

There are really useful podcasts that walk you through all the above issues, such as the Meaningful Money Podcast and Money to the Masses.

Some Meaningful Money episodes deal in detail with self employed pensions etc.

The fact that you’re worried about this and making plans puts you in a better position than lots of people.

Schoolchoicesucks · 05/02/2023 15:30

Start paying into a SIPP now. You'll immediately get 20% tax relief added to what you pay in. You won't get that from an ISA. If you had no other savings and were younger, ISAs make some sense as you can access them if you need to (as you did) but assuming you have something to draw on in an emergency stick all you can in a pension.

With £600k equity in the house, if you're open to relocating somewhere cheaper either once the kids finish school or when the mortgage term ends, I'd probably plan on that rather than trying to pay off a £250k mortgage in 12 years and start a pension.

I'd track down my other pension and as long as it's not a final salary one transfer that into the SIPP.

If your mortgage is only £450 a month you should be able to save a fair old amount on 2 £40k+ salaries.

The old rule of thumb used to be half your age as a % when you start paying in. So would be 25% for you. If you and your employer are already paying in that's probably around 10% - so another 15% would be good.

It should be possible for you to build up a pot to pay another £9-10k pa by retirement age, so combined with state pension £18-£20k pa. So joint £36-£40k pa. But you need to start saving now.

Your husband needs to take some responsibility too. You should both see the IFA and not let him leave it to you to plan for both of you.

Aprilx · 05/02/2023 15:21

Salsi · 05/02/2023 11:52

hi @WoolyMammoth55 . We (I)have to renew the interest-only mortgage every two years, so we have another year on this rate. But it’s been like that from the start (costs about 1k to renew each time; but it makes it affordable - only about £450 / month). I’m always in charge of the renewals and have got good rates up to now. Husband has zero financial planning.

However, the whole £240 k (remaining) needs to be paid off over the next 12 years (the remaining life of the mortgage).

I honestly think my husband’s only old-age planning is selling the house (which I bought with my own funds, and with inheritance from my parents, but we are both on the mortgage, and happily married, no plans to divorce!).

At this rate, I think selling is the only option, and we will have to move out of London! House is now worth maybe £850k. It’s nothing madly fancy, it’s a terraced 2-bed house, an average road, but it’s just that it’s in London. This was all very abstract previously, and I had no capacity to pay anything further (wfh mum), but now I’m in work, I want things to be better, but the reality is hitting me that I’ll have to move out of our home, leave London and all our friends, if we don’t sort things out. i know we are so lucky to even have a house, we’d be completely stuffed without!

relocating atm doesn’t seem like a good idea? given our monthly interest only rates are so very low… I doubt we’d get another interest only mortgage. Even with higher internet rates, I expect we can keep the internet only mortgage costs to under £800 per month. Plus, would like to stay while kids finish their secondary school careers (six more years).

All that and then you announce you have £600k equity. You aren’t going to starve, you will be fine.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 05/02/2023 15:17

Salsi · 05/02/2023 14:48

@BanjoKnickers I was told (by my old boss), 25-15 years ago, not to bother with a pension. He owned the company that I worked for. I’ve changed the details in my previous post so not to be outing. But it was a small company, with us, a team of very dedicated, but low paid specialists, in a poorly paid industry.

He said he didn’t have a pension. However he has a business background, and invested in property, as inherited the business he ran. He advised me to focus on isas. He was adamant that pensions were not a good idea, that isas worked better. But my Isas were nothing more than a savings account, of sorts. It was good to be able to access it during covid, when most of our combined work dried up.

Anyway, I have also put my head in the sand where all this is concerned. I have read books on investing, but I still need to get my head around pensions. I need to work out what I’d need to save in a pension to generate an income of say 20k a year. Whether that would even be possible at this stage.

but then, I also need to spend about £20k a year on paying off the mortgage! And we need a bit of the money to live off, especially since my husband’s income changes month on month. So yes, it has all gone a bit wrong, the maths are out.

Your husband needs to get a job.

Decorhate · 05/02/2023 15:13

What was the original reason for going for an interest only mortgage rather than a repayment one? So that the monthly outgoings would be less?

I only know one person in RL who has one & it was so they could afford a larger house when there kids were small with the idea that they would sell to downsize later & would gain a lump some due to rising house prices.

Realistically I can’t see how you can avoid selling and buying somewhere cheaper in a few years. It sounds very unlikely you can save £250k in that time. If your children go to uni that is potentially an expensive period of time.

If it’s any consolation, we (mid 50s) have paid off our mortgage & will have work as well as state pensions but the amounts are ridiculously low considering how much we and employers are paying in each month.

NoSquirrels · 05/02/2023 15:12

I would start trying to get your working incomes and your retirement incomes to converge. In other words, if realistically you're going to have about £25k pa in retirement (including state pension) then start adjusting towards that level now. That means you won't have a sudden cliff edge to dread, you'll be putting more into your pension (because you're spending less of it now) and you'll smooth out your income over your remaining life times.

Start here.

2x state pensions = £18,000, as you know.

You need to pay off your mortgage. That’s the next thing. Make a plan for that, either paying it all off in 12 years or extending the term by at least 5 years more - or make a plan not to do either and accept you’ll need to sell up and move out of London when the mortgage term ends.

Then you need another £6-8,000 per year in retirement between you to be just about comfortable. You need to figure out how to live on £24-26K a year. What will you cut to achieve this?

(Btw you didn’t ‘live on £18K’ during Covid, you lived on more like £38K if you spent £20K of saving per year to top up).

HappyHolidai · 05/02/2023 15:00

What was your original plan for paying off the mortgage?
Examine why that hasn't happened and whether you can make changes. Clearly you need to be rid of the mortgage before you retire, either by repaying it or (maybe more achievable) downsizing/relocating.

Then think about how much money you will actually need in retirement. Again make a plan as to how to achieve that.

With a household income approaching £100k a year you are a whole lot better off than many others, so make your money work for you!

BanjoKnickers · 05/02/2023 14:59

I need to work out what I’d need to save in a pension to generate an income of say 20k a year. Whether that would even be possible at this stage.

Astronomical!

To simplify everything a little bit, pensions involve building up a lump sum which you use at retirement age to buy an annuity. An annuity is a financial product which turns your lump sum into an annual income. How much annual income you get from a given lump sum is determined by the annuity rate. For a fixed income for life, in other words one which does not go up as inflation rises, the rate is currently around 3 or 4 percent. In other words a lump sum of £100,000 would buy you an income of £3,500 pa. To generate an income of £20,000 per annum you would need to save around £600,000.

In fact it would be much more sensible to buy an index-linked annuity where the income paid does go up with something approximating to inflation each year. But the the annuity rate for those products is much worse, I think around 2%. In other words to buy an income of £20,000 per year which would go up with inflation over the course of your retirement rather than leaving you worse off each year you would need a lump sum of around £1,000,000!

There are alternative ways of arranging your pension, in particular something called drawdown, which might be more efficient but more risky. But unfortunately those fag-packet calculations do give you some idea of how expensive pension planning is.

Mediumred · 05/02/2023 14:53

It’s great you have such a lot of equity in the house but you will struggle to pay off 240k in 12 years on your salary unless your husband also significantly increases his earnings. That is 20k a year without any interest payments!

they might let you extend the term to 20 years, when you are 70, and you could try to overpay if your freelance work allows.

I get why you don’t want to move out of London at the moment but maybe in actual retirement it is an option and depending on where you go could potentially give you several 100k to live off in retirement. The more you pay off now then the bigger the pot would be obv.

good luck!

balconylife · 05/02/2023 14:53

Just realised you are now employed, not self-employed. Take whatever employer contributions are being offered. It doesn't matter if it is a new pension scheme - no need to merge with existing ones.

balconylife · 05/02/2023 14:51

First thing to do is check your state pension forecasts - both of you. Here is the link:

www.gov.uk/check-state-pension

It's not clear to me if you have both paid class 2 national insurance while being self employed. Check the link above to find out how many more years, or missing years, you have to gain your full state pensions. Being self employed means your NI contributions cost a lot less than if you were employed, so it is very cost-effective to make up any missing years. Or as you have 16+ years to go you may not need to make up for lost years, just make sure you pay (via your tax returns) in the coming years enough to qualify for the full state pension.

I would prioritise paying off your mortgage. You said it is interest only. That means at the end of the approx 12 year term you will still owe the full outstanding amount that you owe today. Can you convert your interest-only mortgage to a repayment one? If so, I would do that.

Re your private pension. Yes, pay what you can into that and the government will top it up by adding 25% to whatever you pay in. This means that for basic rate taxpayers, the government adds £25 for every £100 you pay in, so you only need to make a £100 contribution to add £125 to your pension pot. Being self-employed you don't benefit from an employer's contribution but it is still well worth it for the government top-up alone.

I would plan to downsize outside of London before retirement, and make sure it is mortgage-free. Perhaps when you are around 60. Somewhere like Reading will get you a decent house for £500,000 at today's money and excellent train links to London.

Salsi · 05/02/2023 14:51

IFA - your advice is unanimous. I’ll do so. I did have one. I could go back to him (or rather, his son now). Or any recommendations for advisors in London. Mine was from my old home town.

OP posts:
Salsi · 05/02/2023 14:48

@BanjoKnickers I was told (by my old boss), 25-15 years ago, not to bother with a pension. He owned the company that I worked for. I’ve changed the details in my previous post so not to be outing. But it was a small company, with us, a team of very dedicated, but low paid specialists, in a poorly paid industry.

He said he didn’t have a pension. However he has a business background, and invested in property, as inherited the business he ran. He advised me to focus on isas. He was adamant that pensions were not a good idea, that isas worked better. But my Isas were nothing more than a savings account, of sorts. It was good to be able to access it during covid, when most of our combined work dried up.

Anyway, I have also put my head in the sand where all this is concerned. I have read books on investing, but I still need to get my head around pensions. I need to work out what I’d need to save in a pension to generate an income of say 20k a year. Whether that would even be possible at this stage.

but then, I also need to spend about £20k a year on paying off the mortgage! And we need a bit of the money to live off, especially since my husband’s income changes month on month. So yes, it has all gone a bit wrong, the maths are out.

OP posts:
thetrees · 05/02/2023 14:43

You're not in that bad a position with the equity you have but you must check you've got your NI contributions lined up. An IFA is a good idea.

Toooldtoworry · 05/02/2023 14:41

Can I please urge you to see an IFA. Its all very well getting peoples opinions on the Internet, and although well meaning many are not financial advisers and qualified to advise you.

Not only will seeing an IFA be beneficial to give you a clear path moving forwards if you go with your husband it may well pull his head out of the sand too.

JudgeRudy · 05/02/2023 14:38

Start off by getting independent advice but I'd say the obvious answer would be to relocate and make use of the housing differential. Maybe you could even purchase 2 smaller homes and rent one out.

Whatever you do though you really need to do it as a couple. Start off with the appointment. If he show disinterest give him 2 options...either he's on board with you and gets involved in the planning or he hands over total responsibility to you. Doing nothing is not an option.

BanjoKnickers · 05/02/2023 14:32

Don't throw up your hands and give up on pension saving. But the truth is that starting relatively late you're unlikely to get together enough to generate more than a few thousand a year. Check on a website calculator. Still tax efficient and well worth having.

I would start trying to get your working incomes and your retirement incomes to converge. In other words, if realistically you're going to have about £25k pa in retirement (including state pension) then start adjusting towards that level now. That means you won't have a sudden cliff edge to dread, you'll be putting more into your pension (because you're spending less of it now) and you'll smooth out your income over your remaining life times.

Another possibility is releasing equity in your house by downsizing.

DroppedIt · 05/02/2023 14:27

@Salsi - I would then also check out the carry forward rules to see if that's something you can make use of. There is one link here Carry Forward

Salsi · 05/02/2023 14:19

@DroppedIt i do have a pre-existing pension. Not added to it for about 13 years.

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune I hear you. Though we haven’t lived beyond our means, or at least I haven’t. I’ve always cut my cloth acc to my income. I am highly qualified in a low paid area. I thinks that’s where things have gone wrong. E.g. (changing role so not outing) started as a music lecturer; then had kids so freelanced as a music teacher, working all hours I could; now full time employed in an allied role (but not a vocation) e.g. think specialist musician lead in an academy where I look after all the musicians, their contracts etc. I tried so hard to find lots of other jobs, but with my weird background, no one would take me. I’m hoping the skills I learn in this job will let me pivot into other roles.

maybe I should never have gone into music, that’s absolutely true. Now we are stuffed. But I’m trying to correct that.

OP posts:
DroppedIt · 05/02/2023 13:51

Savings wise I would definitely start by exploring what you can do in your pension(s) as that is the most tax efficient way to save because of the tax relief you get.
It sounds as though you were not in a registered pension scheme for the last three years before taking this new job (?), in which case you can't make use of the carry forward rules, but you can still make sure you make the maximum contribution possible from now on.
On your current earnings you can put up to £40k a year into your pension and still get the tax relief.
So I would work out how much will be contributed via your company scheme in total over the year and assuming this does not add up to £40k then decide how much extra you would be able to put away, whether this is as additional contributions to your company scheme or into a separate pension.

TuxedoJunction · 05/02/2023 13:48

Do you need to be in London daily for work? If not, I’d seriously consider moving outside of the M25 - somewhere accessible by train, so you can commute into London when needed. As others have said, you could buy a house outright for £500-550k, and potentially have £100k in spare change, once you’ve moved. I’d invest this into a private pension, will give your fund a boost.
How old are your DC? Could they realistically move schools and it not impact their education? Assuming they’re not at gcse/alevel exam age…

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 05/02/2023 13:36

Paq · 05/02/2023 13:20

Your husband is a massive problem and has the potential to drag you into poverty!

What is his problem with acting like an adult over money?

This.

And frankly both freelancing and living well above your means for years on end was quite self-indulgent.

You both need to take any work you can get now, weekends included, to make up for lost time. The hobbies will have to wait.

Swipe left for the next trending thread