Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it too expensive?

257 replies

miniandmestudios · 04/02/2023 19:40

Not sure if it is entirely the right thread but I’ve started making hats by hand to try make some money - I’m a stay at home mum of 2, can’t afford childcare to go to work but can’t afford to not work. So I’m a bit stuck (DP works) and there is no one else I have to watch the kids.

My friend told me she would never pay £15 for a hat but it costs me £5 in materials and 3 hours roughly to make so it’s £3.33 ish an hour. I really don’t want less than that as working for £2 an hour is stupidly low.

I’ve attatched images of the hats so if I could get everyone’s opinions I’ll lower the price or keep as they are!

YANBU - the prices are okay
YABU - the prices are too expensive

Post edited by MNHQ

Is it too expensive?
Is it too expensive?
OP posts:
margueritedaisy · 04/02/2023 22:31

I'd switch to baby blankets in the softest merino as people love buying something special for a newborn. Add a little embroidered flourish somewhere to highlight that they are handmade. A little logo .

bridgetreilly · 04/02/2023 22:31

I had a look at JojoMamanBebe. Theirs are £14, but they are more stylish and fleece lined. I don’t think the price is crazy OP, but you need to look at how you attract customers who would pay that price. It won’t be people who would normally shop at Primark.

Can you package them in a way that makes them into a special gift, for example?

bridgetreilly · 04/02/2023 22:26

You either need a more upmarket product, e.g. using organic yarn or cashmere or whatever, and then knitted and finished very professionally. I think you could do a better job of blocking and also photographing your work.

Or you need to be sourcing cheaper materials. You should be able to knit a hat in less than £5 worth of (nice) acrylic yarn. Check out Stylecraft Special or Scheepjes Colour Crafter.

But honestly, if you really want to make money from, you need to be at the super-high end of the market.

cowsaysmoo · 04/02/2023 22:20

Tinkywinkydinkydoo · 04/02/2023 22:17

What will you do next month when it’s spring and people won’t be buying hats? If you have a sewing machine could you try making memory blankets or somethings similar? They always seem to sell really well.

Ooohhhh! Newborn blankets! That's a wonderful idea!

Petronus · 04/02/2023 22:18

Could you do baby blankets? I paid quite a bit for a close knitted pure merino baby blanket for my dc who wouldn’t sleep in sleeping bags. Loads of crochet type jobs where fingers etc could get caught, or wool blends (I guess a bit like alpaca merino) that were too fluffy. By the time you’re talking about babies there’s a market from people who will want natural fibres for dc. Also merino wool has marketable properties particularly suited to small babies, anti-itch, anti static, draws moisture away from skin, good for summer/risk of overheating etc.

cowsaysmoo · 04/02/2023 22:18

Also, hats off to you (no pun intended) for making these with 4 and 21 months old kiddos!

Tinkywinkydinkydoo · 04/02/2023 22:17

What will you do next month when it’s spring and people won’t be buying hats? If you have a sewing machine could you try making memory blankets or somethings similar? They always seem to sell really well.

ritarita · 04/02/2023 22:13

the hats are stunning ... you are a queen

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 04/02/2023 22:12

Thatiswild · 04/02/2023 19:48

They’re hand knitted so people comparing them to Primark or other chains are not your market (no offence to the pp I just mean don’t be disheartened as I would pay £15 for a hand kitted hat) they’re very pretty - and it’s a great idea but you’re not paying yourself enough as with most crafters of course!

Exactly this! Not everyone wants something from Primark. 🙄

I would pay £15 for a hat but I would want something a bit unusual. What are you knitting with - acrylic isn't going to get as premium a price as merino or alpaca, or even cotton. You could look at doing stripes or patterns or similar - or allowing people to commission you to make a particular colour combination. There is a market for good quality hand made but think about how to stand out from the competition.

cowsaysmoo · 04/02/2023 22:11

miniandmestudios · 04/02/2023 20:06

It’s an alpaca merino wool blend so 100% wool!
I’ve done them more minimalistic as that’s my style and will expand to do more decorative ones as time goes on, they’re the easiest to knit with my kids around me as they take little to no concentration!

I'd definitely pay 15quid for 100% merino/alpaca hat if it was well made. In fact, I think it'd be quite a bargain for a quality made wool item.
I think you should be making scarfs to go with the hat too.
Where do you sell them?

Fifthtimelucky · 04/02/2023 22:07

I like your hats OP, especially the blue one and the blue and white one, and would definitely be prepared to pay £15.

I have a large head though and often have trouble finding hats big enough, so I wouldn't want to buy one without being able to try it on.

Notjustabrunette · 04/02/2023 22:06

yes I would pay £15. I know someone who makes adult size ones and sells for £45.
I think craft markets and the like would be a good place to sell them. Having said that you aren’t going to sell loads so you may need to look into an alternative source of income. Have you thought about giving knitting lessons?

Knoblauch · 04/02/2023 22:06

I'd pay £15 for an alpaca/merino/cashmere hat like these. I just wouldn't buy these as the colours aren't my taste. The blue and brown doesn't go well together in my opinion. You could do with getting some better photography done to show off the hats better. They do look misshapen in the image of the 3 block coloured ones but that might be the way they are laying.

I make handmade jewellery myself so I really do appreciate the time/cost that goes into handmade items. I have first hand experience how others don't though and it can be disheartening.

RobertsRadio · 04/02/2023 22:06

CeeceeBloomingdale · 04/02/2023 20:50

You're undercharging. They are handmade items made from premium yarns. If you aren't charging what is cost plus fair labour they don't appear special enough on Etsy to attract attention. I buy premium handmade items on Etsy regularly, you have a niche target audience rather than mass appeal, you need to market to those people.

I agree with this post. I would consider £15.00 an absolute bargain for a handmade alpaca wool hat. I think they are worth more. Also, someone mentioned adding a fur Pom Pom, I wouldn't use real fur for obvious reasons and cheap nylon fur does not belong on a premium alpaca wool hat. If you decide to add pom-poms make them from wool, either same colour or mixed colours. Good luck Op, the hats look beautiful.

PinkSyCo · 04/02/2023 22:05

I’m sorry but I wouldn’t pay more than a fiver for a basic beanie hat. I’m surprised they cost you so much to make!

mondaytosunday · 04/02/2023 22:04

Do you have an Etsy shop? How are you planning on selling them? The photographs are not showing them off that well - the second photo they do look stretched out. You should either put them on a person or a mannequin.
But you are underselling yourself. You should price items : cost plus hourly wage (and I wouldn't pay myself less than £10/hour) plus business expenses (say £2/item). These hats should take you an hour or so to make - if they take you three hours then that's £37 and they are not good enough to charge that.
If you can't sell an item at a reasonable price for the effort it takes to make them, then make something else.
And people who shop at Primark are not your target. You need to identify who your target customer is. For example 'sahm who appreciates handmade items, natural materials and enjoys buying for their children' (if these are kids item). Then you put words in that would attract that audience. #handmade #wool, #allnatural #childrenhats etc. And pay for advertising on Etsy.
If you do go down the craft market route, then choose a market that these customers would shop at. So not flea markets or primarily food markets for example, but a craft fair featuring handmade items.
There is a market for handmade items, but they need to be very well made. And Etsy doesn't work for you - you need to drive traffic to your shop through social media etc. you can't just open a shop and expect to sell - you need to treat this as a job if you are to make any real money doing it. That means investing time in setting up an instagram account, posting regularly and pushing potential customers to your shop.

Cordeliathecat · 04/02/2023 22:04

Are they baby size or adult size? I’d buy an adult size one for sure. For a lot more than £15 too.

plumduck · 04/02/2023 22:01

Scalessayeek · 04/02/2023 21:28

These were £16 for the two. The smaller bag will fit my kid until she is about 4/5 and the larger one until she is nine so we’re getting 3/4 years out of them. They are crocheted but it’s similar product.

That's good. I like these.

Eloisalily · 04/02/2023 22:01

Scalessayeek · 04/02/2023 21:35

She’s called Little Foot Bootique on Instagram and she ships :) I got my firstborn a gorgeous bee jumper. Love her bits!

Omg… thank you. Yes, I will be coming back to blame you when I’m skint 😅

ireallycantthinkofaname · 04/02/2023 21:58

too expensive and nothing about them really stands out to justify the price to me to be honest.

Branleuse · 04/02/2023 21:55

I love hand knitted and hand crocheted things. I dont think £15 is too much at all

Unikeko · 04/02/2023 21:54

You'll be competing with mass manufactured goods that will be marketed as hand made. Unless you know a niche place to sell these it's unlikely you'll get close to what they cost to make. Most people don't value the time or skill that it takes to make good by hand when they can get something similar online for far less.

MysteryBelle · 04/02/2023 21:50

I think the hats are beautiful, I’d rather have a hand knitted hat. Good for you doing this, I hope you’re able to be compensated for time and materials.

Humptydumptyfellapart · 04/02/2023 21:49

IMO, way too expensive.

But, If you have a market for them, charge what you like.

If you don't, it's irrelevant what you charge.

BTW, your DH is perfectly capable of working during the day and looking after the DC at night.

Ask any single parent, or couples where both parents work...

FancyFanny · 04/02/2023 21:49

I've paid more than that for a pom pom hat. Not everyone compares prices to Primark and refuses to pay more than they sell them for. They would have to be made of lovely, soft yearn for me to buy though. Not itchy!